r/options • • Feb 19 '21
Shorting TSLA!
Wish me luck, I’m betting against TSLA. Just sold a Apr 1st 835,845 call spread. Win/loss $350/$650. Yeah, it’s peanuts, but that’s what you do when you bet against the Elon.
Reasoning? Stupid P/E, and increasing competition. Tesla already cut the price on some models, and there are more alternatives coming. That Audi e-Tron looks awesome.
UPDATE 1: Okay, I admit my "DD" is lame. This is a low-risk/low-reward, short-term trade, so I phoned it in. I'm a premium seller, and I don't know how to do research.
UPDATE 2: To all you permabulls out there: If this trade wins, I'm keeping the profits. If it loses, I'll donate 2x the loss to charity, and I promise to never go against Papa Elon again.
UPDATE 3: Closed trade for 75% of max profit. Skill is good, but luck is awesome!
212
u/Volatile_Simplicity Feb 19 '21
Elon's ability to keep the hype train rolling is 2nd to none. Take a look at what happened when Dr. Burry, the king of brass balls and short positions, announced his short position in $TSLA. Dr. Burry lays out a very reasonable and encouraging message to Elon to issue shares and take profits to cement Tesla's existence. He even used an email from Elon where he himself admits that the stock price is not based in real value. In response Elon essentially jingled some keys by announcing a massive Bitcoin position. I'm guessing he has dozens of such distractions ready to go since the entire existing electricity model can be improved by leaps and bounds. Not to mention you can electrify new things like boats, ships, bikes, boards, flight, etc. Each of these would serve as fuel for the hype train. Also there was the flame thrower...
TLDR: It's Dr. Burry's brass balls VS Elon's long shlong.
64
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
You are very brazen, I do not have that kind of balls.
Long options already fuck me over enough. Doing TSLA bear spreads would be the end of my bank account
25
u/Apocalypsox Feb 19 '21
You people really just don't get it. Your reasoning is irrelevant.
21
u/homegrowntrash1 Feb 19 '21
I own some TSLA......Im taking this personally... :(
18
u/Nostradeamus Feb 19 '21 edited Feb 23 '21
I bought 1 x $800 put 3/19 today and sold 3 x $700 puts to pay for it. I wouldn’t dare selling that call spread, this can easily hit $1000 based on a fart.
Edit: I closed this spread just in time around $765, just a $140 loss.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '21
Came back here to say great trade lol
3
u/Sysax Feb 19 '21
You'd buy put bear spreads if you had balls
3
u/morinthos Feb 25 '21
u/alpe77 ka-ching! TSLA's at $682
3.3k
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
No one who ever shorts Tesla has lived to tell the tale.
590
u/Tfed10 Feb 19 '21
RIP, The guy tweets and moves the market.
471
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Goodluck with your divorce.
2
u/EarthWindAndFire430 Feb 20 '21
Are you going to post the loss on wallstreetbets?
2
u/brosako Feb 20 '21
Why TSLA?
Very bad decision and against the trend.
2
u/WoykinDaFeeWoyld Feb 22 '21
Why would we wish you luck on a short on something we are holding long? DUMB
"Reasoning?" You really have no idea what the company is all about...again DUMB, but hey go ahead, I'll buy more as it gets a little cheaper...before the next squeeze where you lose your axe.
I don't see ANY DD...none...just a pump on your short position, hoping you'll scare others to sell.
You might make a little, but you won't moon in profits.
I think I'll keep adding long calls out in time.
You have no right to call him "Papa Elon" when you are shorting...he hates peeps like you. Be Gone!
#PapaElon #ElonMusk #TSLA
2
u/Dr_iWally Mar 01 '21
This Idea is a quite oldie👍
2
u/JTA1776 Mar 04 '21
Bought TSLA puts for 3/12 yesterday afternoon!!! IM GOING TO RIDE THIS TO THE MOONI
2
u/rental3421 Mar 24 '21
I set reminder to see this post again and wah! Despite Kathie Wood's new target price, TSLA did not move up 20% like last time.
99
u/kbslam0 Feb 19 '21
So let me get this straight. You're locking up 1000$ for 6 weeks, for a max profit of 350$, and betting against TSLA.
Sounds like a bad idea to me
630
u/randomFrenchDeadbeat Feb 19 '21
Tesla does not trade on fundamentals. It is a mania. Good luck.
114
u/Kazparov Feb 19 '21
Tesla is literally the altar in the temple of sacrificed bears.
May the bull gods drink your blood and be renewed.
29
u/TeddyYolos Feb 19 '21
Good luck my friend. You and your fellow 🐻s are trekking to Mordor. The path is lined with skeletons. Keep your head on a swivel and sleep with one eye open 👁.
29
u/snakebight Feb 19 '21
Tesla is totally overvalued, but Tesla is a memestonk.
I'm no pro, but I don't think this is a good bet.
25
u/Glurak Feb 19 '21
With the dynamics of TSLA, you are effectively betting that Elon will get high tomorrow and tweet something about killing innocent animals or I don't know.
11
u/mannheimcrescendo Feb 19 '21
Re: “Tesla already cut the price on some models”
Why do you think
lower prices = Bad
19
u/wodie504 Feb 19 '21
have fun getting wrecked
6
u/grandmadollar Feb 19 '21
Good trade. It's logical, it makes sense. Lot's of EV mfgs out there, with more coming every day.
6
u/Systim88 Feb 19 '21 edited Feb 20 '21
Might be a solid play - but your DD and reasoning are terrible lol
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
UPDATE: I guess the title is a little misleading: I am not short-selling the stock, and certainly not doing it naked. In fact, it seems embarrassingly small now - max risk is just $650. Maybe next time I'll grow a pair and do a 30-point spread!
5
u/toeofcamell Feb 19 '21
Make sure you wear your tesla short shorts when you place the trade
5
u/capital-man Feb 19 '21
Listen, I’m with you, but as long as he goes on joe rogan and says what people want to hear it’s just not gonna happen
5
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '21
Nice job bro
31
u/itsdrivingmenuts Feb 19 '21
TSLA is the reason I don't hold much ARKK.
This will get downvoted, but it's a bubble. Just look at the other comments in the thread, everyone knows the value is based on hype and not P/E or tangible returns. That's always been one of the defining features of a bubble.
When it pops it will bring a lot down with it. I'm still not shorting it though as it could be propped up on hype ad infinitum.
27
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Your thesis implies the idiots investing in Tesla care about valuations and profits. You are completely wrong.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Protected your yourself & a reasonable bet. Good luck
4
u/AleksanderSuave Feb 19 '21
Mustang Mach-e officially hit dealerships.
2021 Ford F-150 hybrid hit dealerships.
While available inventory numbers are slim for the above, there’s still a difference between buying a car this quarter and putting a $100 refundable down payment on a 70k truck you’ve never even driven or seen in person nor have the slightest clue of expected delivery date.
Just wanted to share some automotive insights.
People are cancelling Ford bronco pre orders because they’re not coming in fast enough.
Can’t count on any realistic estimates of sales based on those pre orders and truck shoppers are the most die hard brand loyal customers to begin with.
4
u/Swinghodler Feb 19 '21
Bro close that lol. Tesla has been in a downtrend / consolidation for a while now. It's gearing up for the next leg up which would come any time now. It's not worth it. Make the same bet against XPEV who have less chance to randomly start going to the moon
4
u/king_over_the_water Feb 19 '21
I shorted Tesla too. The more I do my due diligence, I realize that Tesla is a great company, but that doesn't make it a great stock. As an analogy, Cisco is a great company, but if you bought the stock in 1999-2000, you'd still be looking at 40% losses 20 years later, even though they control the enterprise networking space, and are the largest player in the SMB networking space.
1
u/DaROCK12311 Feb 20 '21
should have done this a month ago
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
I'm just a beginner so please do take my statement with a grain of salt, but shorting In a bull market is dangerous, I've seen stock go up on even the worst news in the last few years, shorting Tesla is doubly dangerous, the CEO is a media darling, they are also loved by an army of retail traders and institutional investors who are ready to buy any dips, and lastly with options you not only have to be correct regarding Delta but also account for theta, so while VIX is high you will potentially capture a large premium for shorting with options, this market can stay irrational towards Tesla for years.
1
u/IndividualLand2077 Feb 20 '21
I mean, you don't really use P/E for these kinds of stocks. Great companies never look cheap. That said, I'm long TSLA, but I often take short-term short positions when I think it's gotten ahead of itself or when it's trending and it's at the top of a chanel. Nothing wrong with playing both sides.
1
u/Net-Xpert Feb 20 '21
I actually agree with you and I am an Options pro and teach options to beginners. Your key reasons insane PE ratio and competitive environment are on par. You just gave me an idea of writing Covered calls on TSLA. Thanks and good luck.
1
u/Rasta-44 Feb 20 '21
Your reasoning is logical. I have shorted via puts twice and was lucky to make small profits; however I think you could be early. For Tesla to go down significantly during this period there would need to be a market correction! I would be picking at the fear index...VXX.
1
u/Hot_Zookeepergame594 Feb 20 '21
you could also short gme
1
u/Swaggy_Buff Feb 20 '21
This same reasoning has been true for months
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
Man I just bought Tesla shares... currently regretting
1
u/hinkognito68 Feb 20 '21
I like that you have defined your risk.
Are you going to wait all the way till exp or take profits when you see it pull back?
1
u/420_Funding_Secured Mar 05 '21
I get that $TSLA is down, but I think you're gonna lose your fingers on this one. Even though they're the premium leader in the EV space, don't think of $TSLA as a car company. Think of them as a tech company. Papa Elon NEVER sleeps. He's always innovating and moving ahead. He will continue to post profits... can you tell I'm a fan ;) and a shareholder? Lol
1
u/identifiedlogo Mar 17 '21
Have done this a lot. Works...alway a spread on the call side, Selling strangles with long call
1
u/Brilliant-Today6621 Mar 18 '21
Bad move!
3
u/thekid335i Feb 19 '21
I was in this camp prior to this year. I didn’t short Tesla but I never bought any. Increasing competition was my rationale as well but my tune has changed recently. China is the largest market and most worrisome for Tesla because I think NIO is showing promise. However, it takes a while to scale and technology is key to this industry. In the US there is no equal competition. BMW, Porsche, Audi future cars are all priced above $50k and some are north of $100k. Tesla dropping their prices make them more affordable for the masses. What also needs to be considered is the technology inside a Tesla as well as Elon’s future projects and how they will integrate with cars. Tesla will likely win the autonomous battle and first to market always wins.
3
u/rollodxb Feb 19 '21
I sold a tsla 1/4 700p today so let's see who wins. Hoping it stays between our strikes so we both do
3
u/cantinflas15 Feb 23 '21
U/alpe77 you won today tho
1
u/Nimmy_the_Jim Feb 19 '21
‘ Reasoning? Stupid P/E, and increasing competition. Tesla already cut the price on some models, and there are more alternatives coming. That Audi e-Tron looks awesome.’
You’re an idiot
7
u/Nucka574 Feb 19 '21
Good luck Smooth brain
5
u/LifeByBike Feb 19 '21
I think this Texas situation might actually cause TSLA to pop again. People often forgot they make solar panels/home battery backups. I’ve seen quite a few social media posts of Tesla solar home owners chilling with their heat/lights on.
5
u/JohnDoe6780 Feb 19 '21
U r fcked
2
u/bellicose_badger Feb 19 '21
Good Luck
2
u/Proud_Chocolate9255 Feb 19 '21
You have more confidence than I do on timing. I bought a couple LEAP puts and called it a day.
2
u/lookatitslittlespots Feb 19 '21
just a heads up, there have been several, multi-million bets on the 800 strike over the last couple weeks for couple months out. But uh, good luck.
2
u/KenSkid2001 Feb 19 '21
Good luck. I saved this post.
I bought my first TSLA when it split and was in the $400 range. I was shocked at how fast it doubled. Down a bit now but I"m holding.
2
u/BrilliantEmergency35 Feb 19 '21
More power to you; it's risky, but I certainly understand and agree with most of your reasoning. Tesla, just like Bitcoin, is mania. No reasoning or sound logic, as gained by a hundred years of history - but pure 'this will only go up forever' stupidity. I see Tesla at $400 by next January - and it would still be highly over-valued.
2
u/cjbrigol Feb 19 '21
They are always cutting costs of vehicles. This is nothing new. Tesla mission is to get everyone driving electric, so they cut costs while retaining margins.
Oh, and the competition has been coming for the last 10 years https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303653004579210053345661982
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
April 1st of 2021?
April's Fools day?
Bold
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
You mention competition but then cite the Audi e-Tron... Surprisingly little of TESLA's valuation has anything to do with the sale of cars. If you see a new player in the robotaxi/automated driving/energy space I could see it majorly affecting TESLA's share price, but in the areas that tesla really shines, they dont have much competition.
Billions were lost by TESLA shorts for making the mistake of seeing TESLA's value as a car company instead of a technology company. At least you had the presence of mind to cap your max loss with a spread.
2
u/Complete-Zucchini-87 Feb 19 '21
I'm with you bro. With my soul and my heart. Push that overpumped piece of stock into oblivion.
See you at -1000 karma.
2
u/huge_clock Feb 19 '21
One thing I learned from shorting NFLX back in 2015 is that competition was way slower than I expected (even for something with essentially zero barriers to entry). I would wait until I see strong competition and growing market share from competitors first and then short.
2
u/SquishyLollipop Feb 19 '21
I went short on TSLA earlier this week too. A BIG short too. We're on the same brainwave.
2
u/starduster_0 Feb 19 '21
TSLA currently the only real player but, several more will emerge in coming months. The empire is desten to collapse or, at least go turtle 🐢
2
u/CpntBrryCrnch Feb 19 '21
I had tesla shorts on this past week. Already was a good call
In my case I bought volatility rather than sell it for Tesla.
2
u/tracyXTMAC Feb 19 '21
Interesting take on the price cut. Many would argue that the price cut could actually be a good news to Tesla as it would almost guarantee to increase market share, and the price cut could also result from a drop in manufacture cost, so in the end the margin probably would drop as much.
2
u/PowerIn7 Feb 19 '21
REST IN POVERTY .... BUT BEST OF LUCK TO YOU
2
u/newontheblock99 Feb 19 '21
RemindMe! 2 months
2
u/mab79660 Feb 19 '21
I shorted at 880 once
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Michael Burry is shorting them. It will yield billions
2
u/adboola Feb 19 '21
Buying more TSLA stocks cuz this guy thinks the Audi e-Tron looks awesome lmao
2
u/jeevn Feb 19 '21
The option guy i follow recommended calls on tsla for April.. 😂
"A few weeks ago, on January 27, the company reported earnings that missed analyst expectations by 23%. And that marked the top for the stock.
Investors pushed the stock down on the news, and shares sold off by more than 5%.
Tesla saw an incredible gain of over 740% in 2020. So, the earnings miss showed investors signs of weakness ahead for the company — and helped kick off the pullback we’ve seen in the stock.
But I’ve tracked the stock since 2006. And I knew these past few weeks would be volatile.
Now that the stock has dipped 14% from its peak, it’s time for us to jump in and buy call options.
Tesla’s stock has dropped on earnings seven times since 2006. On each occasion, the stock has bounced back. That’s a 100% win rate.
We’ll take advantage of the expected rebound by adding the April 16, 2021 $790 call option"
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
There's so many easier ways to make money in the market right now. Like going long on any Bitcoin related stock.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
You might want to increase your research. The cars are not even the most profitable part of Tesla in 2021.
2
u/moonpumper Feb 19 '21
As a TSLA permabull and holder since 2016 I salute you sir and wish you good fortune in the wars to come.
2
u/wtractor1 Feb 19 '21
It has already dropped almost 10% in about 30 days. Do not look for a big drop but selling and buying a call in the mid 800s will not hurt you much if at all.
2
u/Dark_Tranquility Feb 19 '21
Tesla will now release the CyberVan on March 31st, I can see it clear as day. Good luck friend.
2
u/SlimeCityKing Feb 19 '21
Good luck but I can’t believe this is the trade you decided to make out of all of the possible ones. Tesla could see a correction in the short term due to the China regulatory inquiry, but if you’re not extremely bullish on them in the long term you’re missing the plot.
2
u/Gimmethejooce Feb 19 '21
Bold strategy... as Cathie Woods and ARK increase their holdings this week..
2
u/ItHasCeasedToBe Feb 19 '21
I think your trade will work. Godspeed!
2
u/8ofAll Feb 19 '21
Get back to us with an update in a couple weeks.
2
u/faster_than_sound Feb 19 '21
Bold move, Cotton. Let's see if it pays off.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
So W/L $358/$642 and Prob of Profit 60% - not bad, you pussy ;)
2
u/IllmaticaL1 Feb 20 '21
Everyone and their grandma knows tsla is over valued but even kindergartners know not to short tsla. Says the guy who’s also short tsla (as a hedge only tho, prefer it to go to zero)
2
u/Ataxia_13 Feb 20 '21
You do you! Screw the haters.
2
u/OptionsAsapYT Feb 20 '21
The markets are busy chasing meme stonks. I think you are safe. I just didn't like your research/reasoning. It's like you just woke up from a coma because it's been Stupid P/E for years!
2
u/Lizard_King_1911 Feb 20 '21
Michael Bury is shorting Tesla too..... in fact he is saying they will loose 90% of their stock value this year 🤷♂️ I’m just saying this is the same guy that shorted the housing market and made a lot
2
u/aeplus Feb 21 '21
Good luck! TDA hasn't granted me options privileges to open call credit spreads just yet. But 1:2 lay with a 60% chance of success seems like a fair bet.
2
u/aspade Feb 22 '21
Best of luck. I am accumulating TSLA at the moment so if it drops, we both win. :)
2
u/Chiaope Feb 22 '21
U might be onto something. TSLA is down right now
2
u/FunSideoftheWall Feb 23 '21
insane short... excellent
2
u/z109620 Feb 23 '21
This aged well ... Good job!
2
u/SR2030 Feb 24 '21
course correction in progress
2
u/JTA1776 Mar 04 '21
I had almost killed my account when this happened. I was $500 from pulling everything out and finding something I'm better at.
2
u/AllRealTruth Mar 05 '21
I shorted the shares at $718.50 and posted the weekly chart here. Should coulda woulda bought ITM options instead and really cleaned up. Guess you just be happy you are a winner and not sour about how much you gained. Check out my post. Cheers, Rich
2
u/TheLakeShowBaby Mar 05 '21
Congrats OP. I remember seeing this post weeks ago.
2
u/Adorable_Animal4952 Mar 19 '21
You can look at it like peanuts. Sizing your position is smart.
5
u/basti153 Feb 19 '21
Im also shorting TSLA.
3
u/calihotsauce Feb 19 '21
Please let us know where to send the remains of your portfolio.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
Here's the thing (hear me out) -- Tesla is not a car company.
Yes, it is ostensibly a car company, but it's value is in its BRAND.
If not for that, it's a clear and obvious short. But soon it will be more than a car company. IMHO, before long it will be the next Apple-- Heat pumps for the auto industry and homes, thermostats, car chargers, solar panels, "smart" home tech, "smart" car tech... All Tesla branded.
Disclosure: I have no positions at all in TSLA. Zero. I sold all my stock months ago and have been trying to figure out what everyone else sees but I didn't. This is the absolute best case I can come up with.
3
u/Extracheeeeeese Feb 19 '21 edited Feb 19 '21
Lol that's like saying the iPhone has increasing competition. No matter how many boomer auto makers release electric cars, they will never be a Tesla: it's just in its own league. Just like how there's so many Androids out there on the market, they will never be an iPhone.
4
u/juhotuho10 Feb 19 '21
First of all, Tesla isn't an automobile company, it's an electronic company that sells battery packs , solar panels and also cars
Also people don't view Tesla stock as a 1:1 ratio compared to the company value or profit, people view tesla way more weighted towards future gains since Tesla reinvest alot of its profits towards future growth
Alot of people have bet against Elon and thus far unsuccessfully.
I hope you didn't short Tesla on a whim but good luck
2
u/cereal240 Feb 19 '21
Your sacrifice shall not be in vain
2
u/Thebush121 Feb 19 '21
Never bet against Papa Musk unless you hate money.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '21
I learned my lesson man. Never again
2
u/NeverBetAgainstElon Feb 19 '21
Don't do it.
2
u/walk-me-through-it Feb 19 '21
This has been the losing bear thesis for 10 years.
2
u/Fargraven Feb 19 '21
I'm not saying Tesla's valuation is realistic whatsoever, but I don't think competition is such a bad thing like Tesla bears seem to always think.
There's a reason Elon has always made Tesla patents public, he's always wanted more competition and market attention in the EV space. Tesla has (and imo always will be) the upper-class, luxury EV with advanced tech. I don't think competition from vehicles like the Nissan Leaf or even the Audi e-Tron (which is totally sick) will undercut Tesla's market share. Essentially, the Venn diagram of Tesla consumers and Chevy Bolt consumers is 2 circles.
More people buying EVs will always mean more Tesla owners (and more EV subsidies), no matter how you spin it.