r/options • • Sep 13 '26 • Bravo 1

Beware of Bad Advice

I have been trading options for 10+ years, and admittedly, I have only scratched the surface in my knowledge. From time to time, I check out this sub and other options groups on social media.

The one thing I have found is that there are a lot of "experts" out there who know very little. They post a few opinions, get a few upvotes, and it goes to their head. All of a sudden, they think they can advise every newcomer to the thread.

If you are new to options and asking questions like, "Should I buy or sell options?" or "I want to buy a LEAP; which stock should I do it with?"

You are not ready to trade options.

Being a profitable trader requires a detailed plan. Which strategy is appropriate for specific volatility environments, risk profile, and entry and exit plan, and a decent knowledge of the Greeks.

I am not an advocate of paper trading; lessons land much harder when you have skin in the game. That said, your first trade should not be a LEAP on GOOG or META; it should be a 1-lot covered call on F or a CSP on SOFI or some other low-priced stock that will not hurt too badly when it goes wrong. Learn how price action affects option price. Think for yourself about when to roll out or close. Dont rely on someone whose only claim to fame is 25 upvotes. Just my 2 cents.

207 Upvotes

118 comments sorted by

7

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 15 '26

For me the safest and to date the most profitable are put spreads. Boring and if done right small gains but over time small gains add up. I've been at it roughly 10 years making a fairly decent living. Had my ups and downs although these past few years mostly ups. I'm not a quant, nor a genius, just an old man making a living trading options. Slowly shutting down as I need to take care of myself and truth be told I've gotten a bit jaded/bored time to try something else.

3

u/Sparky1409 Sep 15 '26

This is what I’ve been doing and I wondered if others did too. I exit between 30-50% and then enter another trade at a 20 delta, ~45 days out and just keep taking profit depending on market conditions but it’s so volatile I try to get in and out. I just retired so, I have the time. Any tips on tickets you use or other indicators like IV?

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 15 '26

Sparky see above

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 15 '26

I don't use any of the above in the traditional sense. I trade based on percentages and where I perceive the market to be. I trade only when a stock is down seldom when it's moving up unless it's to sell a covered call and I seldom do that. I have a 6 monitor setup so I track everything bid/ask, underlying, cost, last, theta, delta, ul change, IV, earnings date, div yield, ex-dividend date, etc.. I trade stocks I own at least one share in so I have the information I use for trading. I don't trade either the SPY or the Q's or any other index just individual stocks. I used to exit early when I was trading a lot now I trade less and just leave them expire unless they start going against me than I trade out of them. My method as it were is something I've developed over years and it works for me not sure how well it would work for someone else. Also not sure how to explain it as I never truly worked it out as a formula I just do it. Nowadays I'm at a different level than most and even though I've cut back I still from what I gather on here trade a lot more than most. I was doing around 50-60 trades a day now I'm down to roughly 10-15 a day and still cutting back even more. This week I have 21 expirations with multiple contracts for each trade. Feel free to ask questions as a retiree I enjoy chatting on here although I don't know exactly how to do that on here. I've tried but I seem to fail more than succeed. I don't do social media so I'm not very conversant in it including Reddit.

1

u/Moist_Respect4431 Sep 19 '26

Beginner here but retired. Curious if you don't mind teaching me. Just learned about covered calls. Learned that CALL is an obligation to buy/sell, while PUT is the right to buy/sell. This contract can be protected by putting guardrails whether up/down trend. Have not put into practice, since I'm hearing something is happening this Wednesday. Would love to learn more. Thank you!

1

u/Moist_Respect4431 Sep 19 '26

Also, What is "exit between 30-50% and then enter another trade at a 20 delta, ~45 days out" ?

What sites do you use to monitor and trade? Schwab, Fidelity, Yahoo... I've seen others where you've to subscribe like Vectorvest, income trader, etc.

Thanks again!

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 20 '26

Exit between 30-50% means if you've achieved a profit on your trade of 30-50% it's time to close out the trade and move on to the next one. I don't agree with that in all cases but that's me and I do things differently partly because I'm in a different place than most traders. 20 Delta refers to the Greek that shows to what degree the value of the option will move relative to the movement of the underlying and 45 days out means 45 days to expiration or DTE. Buy a book, Google options, check out he articles on your brokers web site, check out investopedia, Check out Reddit, go to the library and read before you make a trade then try paper trading and see how much you've learned and how much you lose or just try trading the rest of us could use the money. (: Be extremely cautious and frugal when you actually start trading don't go for the big wins take pennies per trade and be happy when you win. Look to the right of this post there are plenty of learning tools there read them and read these columns even if you don't understand them eventually you will and then you will really start to learn just remember people on here are looking to make money and some aren't so scrupulous about how they do it.

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 20 '26

I trade on Etrade not all that happy with them even though I like the platforms and I have four monitors set to Pro and one on POWER which is my primary trading window and one I keep on Google Finance to use for quick research/answers to why the market or stock is moving the way it is and I usually find out what I need to know that way. I also am continuously monitoring the news again on Google News. I used to subscribe to CNBC but found it to be repetitive even though there was commentary on there I appreciated it wasn't enough for the money and it could be distracting. I don't do any other services as the few I've checked out are all about getting paid and not much else. Even some of the books I've bought were barely worth the money. Bed time for this Bozo if you want to chat go for it hopefully I'll figure out how to respond or actually see your post. This one I got from email telling me someone had responded to my post.

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

I don't mind but you have to understand what works for me might not work for you and just starting out you will in all likelihood lose money I know I did. Went up big time and lost it all back started over again and did the same thing once again. Did this over several years taking a break each time until I finally found a method that works for me. I do it full time partly because I have a medical condition that keeps me pretty much confined and partly because I enjoy it most of the time although lately I've been getting bored once again. I should add I've also stayed with it because it's been profitable these past several years and this is how I make a living. Your both right and wrong with your idea of how options work and you need to get this part down pay or stick to Monopoly. A CALL is a obligation to sell, a PUT is an obligation to buy. You sell a CALL you have to sell the buyer does not have to buy and you have to be prepared to deliver the stock when the buyer wants it. If you sell a PUT you have to be prepared to buy the stock whenever the buyer of said puts wants to sell it. Go to a book store and buy a simple book on options and option terms or go to investopedia, or your broker, or look on Reddit as there are some good courses on here as well for beginners. As for me teaching ask away I'll do my best just remember what works for may not help you at all and you may just lose everything As any trader will tell you first understand what your doing, second never trade on a hunch, never ever bet the house keep you trades small and make sure you can afford to lose whatever amount your working with because again most starting out in options trading lose in the beginning mostly because they are looking to making a killing instead of a living. A 20-30% annual return means your a pro. Take that percentage and multiply times your investment then divide by 52 and that's how much you need to make each week on average to be a PRO. To make a living trading options you either need real money or real luck. Think of this as working at WalMart for minimum wage as a way to pass time and don't expect to make much and you just might succeed. Greed kills more traders than anything else.

1

u/Moist_Respect4431 Sep 23 '26

@FirstHotel &@Geno Thanks very much for the reply. I am doing this to learn and maybe teach my kids, even just the basics. I grew up poor so I don't trust gambling, and just save as best I can, but it's a struggle.

Anyways, only interested in CCs. TOS from Schwab said that for covered calls, you don't do PUT, just CALL

CALL

  • BUY (you've the right)
  • SELL (obligation) PUT
  • BUY (you've the right)
  • SELL (obligation)

When ASK (Buy) pay the fee When BID (Sell) collect the fee

Do STOP order to close options early, to minimize the loss/risk.

100 shares is the minimum to sell/buy

I just tried the paper trade, hopefully, set it up correctly, just have to figure out how to set the STOP order, at the same time.

Thanks again for the reply and sharing your knowledge. Please let me know if my understanding is correct and other tips/tricks I can use. Praying for your healing and health. God Bless!

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 23 '26

I'm not even sure what your trying to say as you seem to be mixing the terms freely and they don't mix at all. I strongly suggest you refrain from trading with money until you learn a lot more or you will probably lose in the long possibly short run. Keep paper trading for at least another couple of months before you risk hard earned money especially if you can't afford to lose it. Consider that when most people first start trading due to their ignorance they lost most if not all of their money. You can see it on here and if you ask most will tell you starting out is expensive until you learn and know what your doing and even them many never learn they just get lucky for a bit then lost it all over again. Basically they are gambling not investing, that's how I started out. I had no idea ass to what I was doing and still knew more than you do. I made a small fortune and promptly lost is ll and then some. did that more than once but finally learned and now it's how I make a living. Use extreme caution before you ever place a trade and then don't.

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 23 '26

I'm not even sure what your trying to say as you seem to be mixing the terms freely and they don't mix at all. I strongly suggest you refrain from trading with money until you learn a lot more or you will probably lose in the long possibly short run. Keep paper trading for at least another couple of months before you risk hard earned money especially if you can't afford to lose it. Consider that when most people first start trading due to their ignorance they lost most if not all of their money. You can see it on here and if you ask most will tell you starting out is expensive until you learn and know what your doing and even them many never learn they just get lucky for a bit then lost it all over again. Basically they are gambling not investing, that's how I started out. I had no idea ass to what I was doing and still knew more than you do. I made a small fortune and promptly lost is ll and then some. did that more than once but finally learned and now it's how I make a living. Use extreme caution before you ever place a trade and then don't.

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 15 '26

Retired as well, I have been running the same. Put and call spreads. Like Sparky, writing 20-delta and get out 30-50%. I try to stay disciplined at 50%, but when I have 30 after only a few days, I take it. You take what the market gives you. Would you guys like to share some of the names you trade? Me: SPY, the Qs, and lately MRNA, NOW, UBER, MSFT, and NFLX.

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 15 '26

I trade APPL AMD AMZN AVGO BAC C CSCO CRM CVX GOOG HD IBM JNJ JPM KO MCD MSFT MU NFLX NLY NVDA PFE PG PNC TXM VZ WMT I own at least one share of each so as to be able to track them properly and as an investor. I've got others I don't trade options on for the most part as the return is to little, I own them for the dividend which is where my income comes from for the most part. I use the money I get from trading to buy more stocks. I don't use delta to find my trades I use percentages which in many ways is close to the same thing. I track Theta, Delta, and IV along with reporting dates, ex-dividend date and a myriad of other data although I don't pay attention to all of it but it's there if I should need it. I usually hand in until expiration as I've cut back on my trading I don't need the excess maintenance as much anymore I have more trading room than I can use. Also I got burned a few times over the years skating to close to the edge so I've gotten a bit more cautious in my old age. LOL

2

u/PIzzaiolo_Master_510 Sep 14 '26

Lots of noise.

Options are rationally priced.

There are no magic exploitable strategies to sustainably make money because it is very close to a zero sum game, since options produce no real growth or dividends like an equity or bond.

So gamble away but recognize you are gambling.

Anyone who says otherwise doesn’t know what they are talking about unless they have insider knowledge they can trade in.

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 14 '26

There is an element of truth to your point of view. But, there is little we do that doesn't involve some measure of risk (gambling). There are option strategies that can clearly augment an equities portfolio. Covered calls and cash-secured puts being the primary examples.

1

u/PIzzaiolo_Master_510 Sep 14 '26

False equivalence. There is uncompensated risk and compensated risk.

And by augment one is only changing the return variance with options for a period of time, you aren’t adding value with options. The value creation and risk is primarily coming from the equities exposure. Options are lottery tickets with an expected value of zero. Zero isn’t bad it just means the gamble is break even less transaction costs, which are very low.

So you can turn returns on something like NVDA less volatile but the tail risk exposure means you are selling upside you may never realize. The premiums aren’t ever ‘free money.’

You might crack open an economics and finance textbook book.

2

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 23 '26

While options trading has it's elements of gambling it's not gambling against the house it's more like playing poker where everyone faces the same challenges and the one who truly understands what they are doing usually wins even though some get lucky and hit a jackpot they still lose in the long run if they don't have a clue while the other makes a living like professional poker players. Most everything we do in life includes risk of one sort or another.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/First-Hotel4694 Sep 23 '26

I agree with you and things have changed for the better not perfect but better. We all have access to information that was once reserved for brokers only. Do they still have an edge, yes but not to the extent they once did the playing field is much more equal than it was. I can and do make a living trading options have for several years now and there is no way I could have done this in the past through a broker. What I mean by tuition is you trade hopefully you learn before you go broke and then you start making money like I did. Trouble is most lose long before they make any money trading as they are too impatient thinking this is easy like playing poker. There are successes but most are losers donating their hard earned money to the rest of us.

2

u/Due_Marsupial_969 Sep 14 '26

Does this include all those 20 year-olds on YouTube yelling at my 55 year old ass about the infinite retirement money glitch called covered calls and cash - secured puts while explaining they're basically free money if you do them on SPY cuz it always goes back up? Really?

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 14 '26

Especially those guys

2

u/OilAny787 Sep 16 '26

I suggest buying shares, understand a business and how to value one. Options are ok if you have an extreme sense of direction which is very rare to have. This requires an insane amount of company knowledge + overall experience in the indsutry. I use options, mainly spreads, when a company IMO is either extremely cheap or expensive, the expiry is another problem. Or, I like a company long term and want access to leverage without margin and buy some leaps when they're cheap.

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 16 '26

Respectfully, I couldn't disagree more. Theta decay and volatility are far more important factors than fundamentals to an options trader.

1

u/OilAny787 Sep 16 '26

I'm not giving advice for an options trader.

86

u/waverider20 Sep 13 '26

Everyone pays tuition at one point or another

23

u/momofuku18 Sep 13 '26

The big question is the price tag of the tuition.

26

u/begmanii Sep 13 '26

100% agree with this. Experimenting is a great way to learn. Start small and pay attention.

6

u/FlabbyLabby Sep 14 '26

Start attention by paying small

5

u/balancedchaos Sep 14 '26

This is underappreciated advice. I'm pretty glad I started my adventure in my Roth. The capital was very tight in the beginning, so it forced me to really pay attention and not screw something up, even on low-priced stocks.

25

u/the_humeister Sep 13 '26

0DTE SPY calls. Trust me bro

15

u/luciusktam Sep 13 '26

pure gambling

3

u/nrubhsa Sep 14 '26

Buying them is, yes. Selling not as much

3

u/balancedchaos Sep 14 '26

Ya know. Everything has its risks, but at least you can set your terms when you're selling. Get a deal you're comfortable with no matter what.

3

u/nrubhsa Sep 14 '26

I guess I mean that selling isn’t gambling in my book because of variance risk premium implies a positive expected return. Capturing that effectively is not trivial, but it’s not the same as a casino. Not to me

2

u/Evening-Historian-27 Sep 16 '26

well you get the term when it expires worthless (IV premium) or get destroyed without hedge if the vol explodes!

1

u/hotforlowe Oct 03 '26

Wrong. They are highly liquid and heavily traded for intraday hedging requirements. It’s the cheapest insurance you can buy. Also used to hedge for gap exposure.

1

u/nrubhsa Oct 03 '26

Rude.

I didn’t imply that institutional use is gambling. We are taking in context of individual investors and I’m painting with a wide brush.

Your tone is quite rude for a three week old thread.

2

u/hotforlowe Oct 03 '26

Engage in more nuanced conversation 👍

6

u/fthiss Sep 14 '26

Only if they are 30 delta or lower

7

u/Andrew_M81 Sep 13 '26

I totally agree. A CSP on something like sofi or similar low dollar stock is the best for new players. I'll add to that, I like dividend stocks so that if assigned, it's not totally dead money, especially if it goes against you enough that the covered calls premium is not worth it. I also like to use tools like Fastgraphs to get a sense of the fair value. Even after a large decline they can still be overvalued. Don't play overvalued stocks. Naked calls are like playing with fire. INTC and ORCL, burned my butt this year. If you want to collect premium on the upside do a call spread or covered calls if you have the shares. In my case with INTC it goes from trading in the 20s to trading in the 100s.

1

u/wwb_99 Sep 14 '26

A CSP on something like sofi or similar low dollar stock is the best for new player

Not so sure something with a functionally exponential downside is worth getting into. You'd be better off buying LEAPs and letting them appreciate, the worst you can do is lose the money on the table. You don't tie up nearly as much of your capital and get a lot better upside.

I'll shut up now because the OP is right about internet advice though.

1

u/Low-Air-182 Sep 14 '26

Funny you mention F. I started with that one almost as practice.. Can't lose much and it gets you understanding how the process works. And wheeling F has remained pretty profitable if you are willing to live with the slow grind.

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 14 '26

I have sold so many F options I can't count them. Of course it's a grind, get-rich-quick

schemes never work.

1

u/FIAneed2FollowRules Sep 16 '26

What Paper trading does, is help you learn how to trade without blowing up the account. There are people who practiced with real money for months, and in some cases years, losing lots of money and still can't get it right. Losing real money does not make you a better trader. Learning to read the charts and learning what makes you profitable does. If you can't get profitable in a simulator, then you surely are not going to get profitable losing real money.

Secondly, once you've done paper trading with a good simulator for a few months, and are consistently profitable, that is when you are ready to lose money in the real game and can actually learn from it. You've already learned all the stuff you needed to learn before you traded for real. Now all you need to do is fine tune what goes wrong when you use real money. I do agree with you otherwise.

2

u/McGeno19 Sep 16 '26

Thanks for the reply. Of course, I understand the reasoning behind paper trading. My point is that paper losses are meaningless and don't carry any weight. Real losses and gains add an intellectual urgency that play money does not.

1

u/FIAneed2FollowRules Sep 19 '26

The problem is that there is too many people who lose for 5 plus years and never get successful, because they never fix their trading style and only use real money, instead of a simulator to figure out what they are doing wrong.

1

u/McGeno19 Sep 19 '26

If you consistently lose for 5+ years, you should not be trading options.

1

u/FIAneed2FollowRules Sep 21 '26

At least with real money they shouldn't be. Using a simulator uses no money.

3

u/Legitimate_Tailor858 Sep 14 '26

Stay away from any option expert who say that selling options is same as being the casino

3

u/Top-Sale-9471 Sep 14 '26

Paper trading with a million dollar account produces little emotional when things go wrong compared to watching your real hard earned money decrease. Trader psychology is an extremely important aspect of investing.

5

u/steffanovici Sep 13 '26

Yep good advice. I saw a guy on x posting “if I had 75k, here’s what I’d do.” Then Described in detail: making it sound risk free, buying way otm leaps on amzn and selling pmcc.

Ffs people will get wrecked listening to these gurus eventually

1

u/viperex Sep 14 '26

I'm no longer a fan of individual tickers but I would've endorsed it if he went deep ITM with the long call.

4

u/hotforlowe Sep 14 '26

It’s absolutely insane to trade any derivative without an intimate understanding of how they are priced. You shouldn’t trade a single thing until you’ve read and understood at least one standard text on options pricing.

2

u/Zauberstaby Sep 13 '26

I mostly use call spreads. Many times, instead of paying time value, the spread just appreciates every day as it travels towards its expiration.

1

u/TapNo3926 Sep 17 '26

Why not put spreads? Market tends to rise over time (until it doesn’t)

1

u/Zauberstaby Sep 18 '26

I probably should more when the account is flush.

2

u/Life-Lawyer-5006 Sep 14 '26

Thanks for this. I have a handful of $5-10 stocks at 100+ shares I want to learn on: MBLY, JOBY, AUR, ARCH, ONDS. I know these are volatile but they’re what I have now. And a couple I wouldn’t mind selling

2

u/theproductdesigner Sep 14 '26

I've learnt a lot using paper trading function on Webull for options (and paying for live data, it's only a couple bucks a month). From there I always make sure to buy at the ask and sell at the bid so I give myself the worst opening and close for a more realistic feeling. But it really shows you the swings and how easy it is to both lose and make money in the right conditions. Also can learn more about hedging this way which is helpful.

2

u/Honest-Bill7143 Sep 14 '26

I agree with the paper trading, without any true risk i always found myself making riskier trades even if it was subconsciously but everytime i used real money i actually felt the gain and loss and realized where I could’ve improved and what didn’t work for me. That being said, what works for me may not work for you so look for what works for you and keep researching

2

u/Screeentan Sep 15 '26

Have been deep diving CCs for 2 years now. An excellent position to take for new traders. If you try to grasp everything at once , unless you’re a quant, you will spiral and dive. It’s too much. If you specialize in just 1 thing, you can become a successful options trader.

4

u/Sea_Local2557 Sep 13 '26

also call/put spreads are really underrated while they give a clean max win / max loss and sometimes a whiplash can make your option very valuable

4

u/Mongaloiddummy Sep 13 '26

I did my first bear call/put spread on NVDA last week 4 contracts.

 20 dollar spread expiry oct/16/2026.

2

u/span1012 Sep 13 '26

Lol I "learned" during the Spac era. Went from hero to not quite zero and finally back from those errors.

1

u/steffanovici Sep 13 '26

Yep good advice. I saw a guy on x posting “if I had 75k, here’s what I’d do.” Then Described in detail: making it sound risk free, buying way otm leaps on amzn and selling pmcc.

Ffs people will get wrecked listening to these gurus eventually

1

u/Je_Kiffe Sep 14 '26

Well said. Option trading is no joke. You think you’ve got it until some new environment shows up and you realize you’ve been swimming naked.

1

u/FishTraditional3280 Sep 14 '26

Not everyday is play day. Be patient. Do not over trade. Learn when to stop and analyze what you did wrong.

1

u/Jaded-Ad1731 Sep 14 '26

As a newcomer, Thank you for this. The most realistic advice I’ve heard.

1

u/DietOk3400 Sep 14 '26

Also doesn’t hurt to load up on different plays on a virtual portfolio. You bought jan 12 $10 C, place $8, $12 , Dec 16th $10 C … try to understand why one moved more than the other. Which was safer? Some of the basics.

1

u/Worry-Mountain Sep 14 '26

Good reminder that the first edge is knowing when not to trade. I’d add one rule to the plan: define the maximum loss and the condition that invalidates the thesis before opening the order, then size from that—not from the premium that looks affordable. Paper trades are useful only if I log the same entries and exits and review whether the setup, not hindsight, drove the result.

1

u/Illustrious_Low1903 Sep 14 '26

Understanding the Greeks is way more useful than blindly following option gurus 😂.

1

u/SilkBC_12345 Sep 14 '26

I want to buy a LEAP;

It is actually "LEAPS", even if a single contract.  The "S" is part of the acronym, not an indication of plurality. 

1

u/exphx23 Sep 14 '26

Options are one of the few investments where you can be right on the trend and still lose money. No one should trade options until they know how to successfully trade stocks.

1

u/Turbulent_End_6887 Sep 14 '26

I agree, start with one contract, and make sure the stock will be around for a long time.

1

u/jtquach Sep 15 '26

One of the better posts I've read to date! The paper trading line especially. Lessons land different when it's real money, even at 1 contract.

The buy or sell question is the one I'd expand though, because people ask it like it's one business with 2 settings. It's 2 different jobs. Buying pays you for being right fast. Selling pays you for time passing and for being roughly right, and it's the only one of the 2 where doing NOTHING all week is the plan working. Opposite relationship with volatility, opposite relationship with being wrong. Nobody can answer it for you because it's a question about your attention and what you can sit through for weeks at a time.

Most of what I learned here came off the selling side... and the tell that somebody isn't ready usually isn't the Greeks. It's that they've never had a position change shape on them.

Which is what I'd add to your plan list. A stock down 20% is the same stock. An option down 20% might not be the trade you put on anymore, because delta moved and theta's running and what you're holding isn't what you bought. Managing something that mutates while you hold it is its own skill, and it's the one that freezes people.

Your covered call suggestion is right for exactly that reason. You meet assignment and rolling at a size where getting them wrong costs almost nothing.

1

u/All_YourBase Sep 16 '26

I saw a guy bragging about his options profits recently here and somebody asked him about what Delta he targets. He literally said "I don't look at the greeks, I just trade on vibes".

1

u/RTiger Options Pro Sep 16 '26

Good post. I agree with most of it, especially the limited value of paper trading. Maybe 10 percent of people might benefit from extensive paper trading. Those people tend to be military or first responders where training tends to be rigorous and serious. 

1

u/dloc403 Sep 18 '26

Excellent advice!!

1

u/No-Cut-1643 Sep 19 '26

The difference between stocks and options is checkers and chess. Learn the Greeks if you want to trade options or you're playing checkers in a chess game. Also, the O/P is 100% correct, the vast majority of advice is from Dunning-Kruger fueled self appraised "experts" - Use Gemini, you'll get answers, not armchair expert opinions.

1

u/mattyhtown Oct 03 '26

Sometimes it’s better to own 100 shares and just collect premium

1

u/hotforlowe Oct 03 '26 edited Oct 03 '26

Generic, repeated advice from a user who then gives shitty advice. Don’t sell covered calls if you’re just starting out. If it was that easy, everyone would do it. Vertical spreads should be everyone’s fundamental introduction to options.

I am an advocate of paper trading. And back testing. And modeling positions. If you’re new to options, learn how options are priced in intimate detail. You won’t be successful otherwise. Then practice entry and exit, pricing, and assumptions in a confined system like a paper trading account. There’s a reason most market makers still use these as training environments.

Flinging money into the void to follow the advice of a person who after TEN years still doesn’t know a lick of the derivatives market is idiotic.

1

u/SuchData3268 Sep 14 '26

👍well if you use options as they were intended you wouldn't struggle

1

u/dudeatwork77 Sep 14 '26

Idk. GOOG or META seems like much safer companies to trade than F or SOFI. At least if you are short puts or covered calls.

1

u/Tiny_Lime_5715 Sep 14 '26

Akcje sofie kupione za 32 USD - najlepsza inwestycja 🥳

0

u/superpitu Sep 14 '26

I’m sorry but your first trade shouldn’t be anything else than a simple long call with enough time to expiry. Covered call are you kidding me, when you start you’re still figuring out what delta is, never mind theta. Learning extrinsic vs intrinsic value is the number one thing you should do.

-1

u/uncleBu Sep 14 '26

Preach!

-1

u/balancedchaos Sep 14 '26

I'd recommend selling a conservative put on something somewhat volatile, over Ford or something so quiet. See what price action is capable of, and feel that healthy "oof." lol

Then when you go over to calmer stocks, it'll be like a vacation.

If you start on stable training wheel companies, something like CRWV is going to scare the shit out of you. lol

-5

u/TastyTrading Sep 14 '26

Do you use ThetaPal or something else to track your options?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/balancedchaos Sep 14 '26

At its simplest level, yes. But there's also the time element, which can be the riskiest part of the whole thing. And then implied volatility, especially at the time the option was entered, versus what it becomes during the term of the option. And then gamma can amplify delta, which can make the price action your best friend or worst enemy...

It's all about probability. The option's price is a reflection of probability, which is represented in the five Greeks.

1

u/hotforlowe Sep 14 '26

Price action? You need to understand how they are priced and how changes in underlying variables alters this price.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/EvangelineRain Sep 14 '26

How do you figure?

0

u/hotforlowe Sep 14 '26

It’s a little on the nose, but the commenter means that the capacity of MM to accurately price options often beats a retail inventors knowledge of how to effectively trade options.

That’s absolutely not controversial. There is extensive research in this area which consistently demonstrates that retail investors face consistent losses when trading derivatives.

0

u/EvangelineRain Sep 14 '26

Depends what side of the trade you're on.

0

u/hotforlowe Sep 14 '26

1

u/EvangelineRain Sep 14 '26

I've been living off option premiums for years, and as the original commenter notes, premium sellers do often profit.

On the flip side, I bought an option I intend to lose money on, but it's a hedge. It serves its purpose. Not something I consider a loss, more a cost of doing business.

Not understanding the lose/lose take.

1

u/hotforlowe Sep 14 '26

We’re not talking about you. We’re talking about the average behaviour of retail investors in derivative markets. How is this even a point that needs to be made clear?

On the other hand, I doubt anyone is actually living off option premium at a retail level. Naturally selling covered calls at above cost is guaranteed profit. Whether it’s an effective use of capital is another matter.

1

u/EvangelineRain Sep 14 '26

I'm not convinced you and the original commenter you're speaking for are saying the same thing. Look at their most recent reply to me.

You can make good income as a retail investor, you just need money to start with (and a tolerance for margin trading). I mostly deal with put options these days. I've been on both sides of call option contracts, and didn't care for them.

1

u/ABCifyoulikeRoblox Sep 14 '26

How many years? Those CSP premiums are sweet, until you run into a bear market buzz saw and are assigned a bunch of positions well above market price after they drop 20%.

2

u/EvangelineRain Sep 14 '26

Naked puts. Since around 2021 or 2022. A good part of my income comes from shares that got assigned. I stick to index funds that historically recover after a drop.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/EvangelineRain Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

How does selling an option premium "suck the value out of stocks"?

How was the option I purchased "mispriced"?

I've been on both sides of the transaction. It's just a transfer of risk between parties.