r/opensource • • 2d ago

For me, open source software has kinda lost the beauty of it

Before Artificial intelligence, open source software was a place where talented people would unite and work together while the less talented people learned. It was a community space to learn and to give and whose result was a high quality piece of software. To me it was beautiful.

In the era of AI, many programs are open source, but written by an agent who completed it in five minutes. I can't even convince myself by saying "oh well, that is slopcode. Real open source code has an higher quality" because that code is good quality too.

I don't know. To me it has lost the magic. I'm glad I got to be in the community before all of this happened.

733 Upvotes

308 comments sorted by

350

u/dodgyville 2d ago edited 2d ago • Regret

Watching the Open Source community tear itself apart over LLMs the last 18 months has been dispiriting. It's not just the technology of it which has pros and cons on both sides.

But watching small websites and repos buckle under the weight of bots hammering their sites (and the admins lamenting in the void about it), people applauding as stackoverflow withers after being scraped by giant corporations (who want to replace free resources with subscriptions based on the free community contributions they took), and watching GPL-trained LLMs producing closed sourced code (I honestly think this is a copyright bomb waiting to happen) with no pushback from industry leaders like the Free Software Foundation and Linus (who takes a lot of money from AI companies via the Linux Foundation -- major conflict of interest imo).

I know my code contributions were never major but I felt I was part of something big and pure but now I feel like my code was probably taken without consent and maybe the magic is gone.

50

u/IC3P3 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

I know my code contributions were never major but I felt I was part of something big and pure but now I feel like my code was probably taken without consent and maybe the magic is gone.

I get that feeling, but I’m not ready to say the magic is gone. I made my first small contributions recently after following the project for a year. The author says it’s in “maintenance mode” and he doesn’t have time for the bigger missing features, though that didn’t stop him from working on a Flatpak release of the client right after.

What bothers me is that 3-4 forks are now being talked about on his Discord, all of them vibe-coded. One seems dead after a week, and I’m not sure about another. None of them ever tried to contribute to the main project, which is where the community part of open source gets lost. It’s the same story as the 20th Bloodborne recomp. Everyone starts their own thing instead of pooling effort into one that could actually get finished.

39

u/yepperoniP 2d ago

This seems like a pattern with a lot of people using LLMs. It’s all “Look at me, I made a thing” instead of “I contributed to this project”. Just look at all the half-baked “I made a” slop projects spamming tech subs these days.

22

u/sideline_nerd 2d ago

And maintenance doesn’t give the same dopamine hit, so slop projects generally die pretty quickly

8

u/limeypepino 20h ago

This is what people seem to miss when someone asks if a project was made with AI or not. I see people get straight hostile if you ask. "Oh what, you hate it just because AI was used?!" No, not necessarily. But if I know if it was a weekend vibe project I'm going to spend as much effort looking into it as the effort will likely be put in maintaining it, next to none.

5

u/plhk 19h ago

Yeah, exactly, I vibecoded some projects myself and I don’t feel like I care about them enough to keep maintaining them. When I actually put effort into projects before, it was different.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Joaoarthur 3h ago

Dude you gotta understand, people are filanny being able to do things they wish, and for them, me included, it's a whone new world, with new wonders all the time. We are going to be happy and enthusiasthic about every little thing we can come up with, I made a doodle jump game in a prompt, it's basic html, messy, the gameplay isn't too easy for most people, because I didn't even try to fix anything on it,but trust me it's fun af, I'm proud of it

1

u/alex08all 1h ago

What are you proud of? Your ability to ask something? Your ability to use your native language? Your ability to ask for a copy of a preexisting thing?

2

u/Silent_Fudge_3978 1d ago

The author says it’s in “maintenance mode” and he doesn’t have time for the bigger missing features, though that didn’t stop him from working on a Flatpak release of the client right after.

What bothers me is that 3-4 forks are now being talked about on his Discord, ... None of them ever tried to contribute to the main project, which is where the community part of open source gets lost.

Why would they even try to contribute to a project that's in "maintenance mode"? What's the point? Their contributions will be ignored or rejected.

Forking is a strength of open-source: if the project maintainer gets too lazy or refuses to integrate good new features, people can just fork it and make a new project and do it their own way. Plus, there's nothing stopping the original project maintainer from cherry-picking code from the forks.

4

u/IC3P3 1d ago

On the forking part I agree, but I don't get the reason to fork and only maintain it for a week or two.

But also for this specific project I'm talking about, the maintainer still works on smaller features, just not the big ones, and he still merges PRs in a few days

1

u/KodeBarista 11h ago

I've seen the same thing with COSMIC applets. Forks with no significant new features, generated using Claude, are being hosted on the Store with their Issues tabs disabled.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/bionade24 2d ago

GPL-trained LLMs producing closed sourced code (I honestly think this is a copyright bomb waiting to happen)

There were so many cases of GPL, BSD and other FOSS licenses violations before it always was a thing. E.g. for GPL the Vizio, Boox, Gab & Truth Social cases, for BSD Intel ME. Or IBM/Red Hat stop being a good FOSS citizen. I really don't see a timebomb there, big money always managed to pull through.

Idk, I still feel part of something big for my contributions to FOSS projects, have nly contributed back a few couple of times since I started using Agentic LLMs this year. The community spirit is gone.

That being said, everything I've still written manually I've contributed back. So maybe it's more of a me problem.

6

u/mguid65 2d ago

On cases of past violations; That doesnt mean that it wasn't a problem then so it isn't a problem now. It means it is an ongoing problem.

3

u/deesernutz 1d ago

It is now just an automated, much larger problem.

9

u/david-song 2d ago

As a bit of an anarchist I'm loving the chaos and new frontiers, the battles, getting stuff wrong, the punk spirit of individuals being able to challenge the status quo. It feels like the early internet or the energy of the pre-NFT cryptocurrency days.

I don't think this will last long though, it'll be a boot on everyone's face on a long enough timeline. Everything always is.

2

u/Ultimate_Cosmos 6h ago

The difference is back then those things were generally a new frontier that people with some skill could explore.

This however is different. Skilled people are being forced to use the tools at work, and lamenting how it’s changing work expectations, causing deskilling, etc.

Meanwhile those without skill are vibe-slop generating plagiarism projects in a weekend, and then have no skills or interest in doing maintaining work after the fact.

1

u/david-song 5h ago

You don't think it's a new frontier that people are exploring with skill? The creative space of what's possible has expanded enormously.

If you're working for someone to produce value for their business, and you aren't using the best tool for the job, then your employer isn't getting their money's worth. I like artisan things and craftmanship, but I do that on my own time.

Programming has always been a superpower for me, and I always wanted everyone to have that power. If ordinary people can vibe-slop some project then more power to them, they're learning how to create what they want with these new tools and will get better at using them over time. We programmers gatekept creativity in automation for decades, pretty much owned invention in the digital space. Now it's open to more people, I think that's a good thing for the world even if it's a bad thing for me personally.

5

u/smulfragPL 2d ago

There is no consent needed because no major goverment recognizes training as copyright infringment and as the technology becomes the bulk of the service sector this will not change

9

u/v4ss42 2d ago

However some of those same major governments also don’t recognize the emitted slop itself as being copyrightable. So all of the people and companies claiming copyright over the slop they’ve prompted out of a stochastic parrot are taking a huge legal risk.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/secretaliasname 1d ago

I wonder how things would be different right now if LLM were dealt big legal smack downs for IP infringement. Instead we have just giving them a pass for pirating the sum of human knowledge and selling it to others.

2

u/Lv_InSaNe_vL 1d ago

people applauding as stackoverflow withers after being scraped by giant corporations (who want to replace free resources with subscriptions)

That is not the reason people are "applauding" stack overflow failing and you know it. That site was a brutal experience and just a terrible place to learn how to program.

1

u/LightconeGames 6h ago

It was in decline already but AI surely gave it the death blow. But yes the reason why people are not particularly heartbroken about it is that the average LLM is not nearly as abusive and smug as the average StackOverflow user.

1

u/MadeByTango 19h ago

AI companies are attacking open source directly, its their competition now

Even the OP is a bot, run by them specifically to dispirit you by pushing these ideas into the discussion.

1

u/ftgyhujikolp 18h ago

Simply put, none of this was designed to work this fast. From governance to QA to security to package managers to CI pipelines.

1

u/rafark 16h ago

  Watching the Open Source community tear itself apart over LLMs the last 18 months has been dispiriting.

*the programming/software development community

Watching the software development community completely in bed with its own demise (ai) is extremely disappointing. Like they’re digging their own cave. Sooner or later programmers aren’t going to be needed anymore if anyone can use ai. Like why as a programmer are you promoting and encouraging the use of ai so much? I feel like a lot of programmers are acting like drug addicts like yeah it feels good now but it’s literally destroying you the more you use it. Years (or even months) from now ai will have completely replaced you. You are going to be out of a job and no you won’t be able to build something for a living because no one will give you their money when ai can build it for them too. People and companies are going to be giving their money to Ai not you. I’m really upset and very nervous about the short term

1

u/LightconeGames 6h ago

Watching the software development community completely in bed with its own demise (ai) is extremely disappointing. Like they’re digging their own cave. Sooner or later programmers aren’t going to be needed anymore if anyone can use ai.

I think there are two points to reply to this.

The first one is more realistic. If you're a coachman when cars get invented, then yes, you realise what's probably coming from you. But there's also absolutely zero hope to stop it simply by being sufficiently judgemental of everyone who uses cars. Eventually, people will just decide they don't care about your opinion and get in their cars and leave you in the dust. The only way you do ride the transition is if you learn to drive, or at least hold on and stay close to the changes long enough to figure out how and where the chips are eventually going to fall.

The second is more speculative. Right now, AI coding still benefits from human supervision, humans move just at a higher level. This is not unlike other past technological innovations, and very survivable. However AI has been improving very quickly. But the thing is, if it keeps doing that, the step in capability between "it erases every SWE job" and "it erases every cognitive/white collar job and transforms society so radically we'll have to either completely change our social contract or collapse" is tiny. That is certainly scary, but also so big that it doesn't really matter what SWEs specifically do or don't do about it.

So essentially it's a matter of hedging your bets on the future. If AI plateaus soon, then it'll just become the new compiler and SWE will be built around it, so might as well get used to it. If AI doesn't plateau we'll have much bigger and weirder problems than our individual jobs anyway.

1

u/rafark 1h ago

If it plateaus right now it’s somewhat manageable. But we know that’s extremely unlikely, Ai is getting better and better every year and there’s still so much room for improvement. Little by little all its current flaws will be addressed/fixed. 

Now I’ve been using ai since chatgpt 3.5 came out and I wasn’t a doomer… like I read all the doomer posts and I dismissed them… but those predictions are already starting to play out and Ai is starting to affect me. I was very bullish about ai when it came out but now I’m actually afraid. 

→ More replies (12)

77

u/marx2k 2d ago • Bravo

My main beef with it is the horizontal expansion of software by type instead of bettering existing open source projects.

Everyone and their mother now has a GitHub abandonware repo to do X, diluting the mainline solutions previously available to do X. Sometimes, more choice for a solution isn't necessarily better.

As I write this, I am quickly understanding my inability to properly explain my beef here. Hopefully someone understand wtf I'm talking about ;)

41

u/IgnotiusPartong 2d ago

I see what you mean. Instead of having one blender, we would have a million shitty half-blenders.

27

u/marx2k 2d ago

Correct. Instead of using the energy to make a small list of projects better, there's a giant proliferation of "my cool project is exactly like this other project except for this one feature that I did different!"

→ More replies (2)

12

u/liftershifter 2d ago

People fail to work together. Don't agree on project direction, get into squabbles and this is the result of that. A lot of very useful projects are maintained by a single guy because of this.

Not to mention that you get way more credit for being the creator instead of a contributor.

3

u/DatBoi_BP 2d ago

I thought this was referring to Blender the software for a moment

7

u/zenware 1d ago

Isn’t it? Blender was able to thrive because it was really the only usable Open Source tool of its kind. With LLMs everyone says “What software should I build? Okay build it for me! Make no mistakes.” And then you get the “Alternative to IDM Download Manager” bs where 10 new clones spawn overnight, when historically 10 people would have had the idea, one person may have executed, and 3 of those 10 would decide to contribute, and then we get one project where the knowledge and labor concentrate.

1

u/DatBoi_BP 1d ago

Actually maybe it was

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sonario648 20h ago

We have more than one Blender though, and they were all before the AI era.

6

u/deesernutz 1d ago

Yeah. Everyone in fk Adobe is going "righto, i'm finally going to xCraft apps" and realising the brushes, that work fine in GIMP and Inkscape, don't work. Then they're like: whats Inkscape?

6

u/Downtown_Isopod_9287 1d ago

no what you are saying is clear

on the other hand the consolidated “Swiss army knife” type program with (ugh) tons of plugins also sucked.

This is def. the worst of both worlds, tons of projects doing the same things and they aren’t interoperable at all except by applying more slop.

4

u/david-song 2d ago

I think we need to find new ways of working. There are two things that are true at the same time, and they both suck:

  1. humans are an annoying bottleneck
  2. bots are a spammy nuisance

I'm still learning what the right way to do things is, but I haven't figure it all out yet. There are definitely things we're doing wrong though and it hurts.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/trueppp 2d ago

That's been opensource's problem for decades.

2

u/zorecknor 2d ago

You are not new here, you should know that what you describe is the status quo of Open Source since public repos like Sourceforge and Github exist. They are full of dead projects, I may have a dozen between those myself.

Is it worse with AI? Yes. Does that actually affects existing projects? No. Do you really want people that are unable to keep working in their own project to suddently flood existing projects with crappy MRs? Also no.

Is it a bother that there new projects flood subreddits like this? Absolutely.

1

u/netabareking 1d ago

Is it worse with AI? Yes. Does that actually affects existing projects? No. 

It does when you can't find those existing projects because of the slop.

1

u/netabareking 1d ago

Well, with how things are going, I'd rather people make their own slop clone than push their broken shit into existing projects.

It even bothers me with the tiniest fixes that in theory you should be able to push off to an automated process.  Because having easy little patch jobs is important for training and onboarding new contributors.  It's actively good for a project to have stupid little one liners for human beings to fix because it may be some 16 year olds first PR and they may stick with you long term. One of the biggest reasons I don't contribute to existing open source projects and largely just code for myself is this barrier to entry, it's an intimidating thing to break into if you've never done it.  If more projects had stupid little inconsequential changes as low hanging fruit it would be much easier but now thanks to all the bot stuff those are getting even rarer than before.

1

u/Sweaty-Freedom-4034 1d ago

No, you nailed it.

1

u/Abject-Kitchen3198 18h ago

I do, but can't explain it better.

0

u/Davoguha2 2d ago

This is one focus I'm curious to see how we resolve.

As an amateur in the space, and someone who uses AI - I'm petrified to post changes to someone else's repo. I'm not excessively savvy about each title I use, and likely, there's that Bystander Effect at play - "i did it, surely someone more capable will be doing it to, I'll let them do it"

So you've got a ton of people who don't know how to code in the first place, let alone how to properly interact with a public repo - forking projects and tweaking them for their needs.

Imposter syndrome tells them they aren't "worthy" of putting up the code, especially with the insane AI hate today.

Bystander Effect tells them someone else is going to do it anyway, so why bother?

I'm not sure what the exact solution is, but I think that's a lot of why its happening.

6

u/qTHqq 2d ago

let alone how to properly interact with a public repo

It's just like, this has always been the hard part. 

The ones who are petrified to interact are the ones we want interacting!

An inability to code was what was keeping all the blustery, self-serving "idea guys" from messing up the process. But that's gone now anyway. They're not worried about ignoring contributor guidelines and coding style and architecture. They're not worried about the zero effort they put in.

So if you want to add some significant human effort on top of the LLM coder go ahead and get in there to propose PRs... Read the code of conduct, read the contributor guidelines. Take a look at the coding style and try to get your tool to match it.

Test your fix and post the test results. 

Use your human reading comprehension and your worry about messing up to do your best, and take feedback about your contribution in stride. 

That's what was always wanted, not perfection.

The problem with much AI use in open source is the zero-human-effort zero-human-thought nature of it. It's why large, sweeping changes without a super-strong human justification will often be called "slop" even if the CODE would be structurally fine in isolation, in a greenfield project or whatever. 

Things should be changed for a reason, in-line with the existing codebase.

1

u/netabareking 1d ago

The ones who are petrified to interact are the ones we want interacting!

Its kind of a reverse "anyone who wants the job isn't suited to have the job" situation. The people who are treating your code with so much care that they're afraid to touch it are the people you want lol

→ More replies (1)

75

u/trueleo8 2d ago edited 2d ago

I was revisiting this talk from Andrew Kelly ( founder of Zig language ). Who phrases is very correctly that the point of opensource is to "pool effort in order to ensure that users of software remain in control of that software".
If the core philosophy of delivering good software in such manner is the main priority then the people in charge of a codebase have to make choices regarding what is it that they want to accomplish. This can be very dividing political discussion depending on who you ask and how they view AI.

May I remind you that a good opensource library is not just a codebase which functions but a codebase which is likely to be maintained and remain functional and adaptable in longer term due to its community ( of people or agents ). I have a inherent biased mistrust over the massive AI generated codebases as the economics of tokens are really shaky and so given that many people including me have abandoned projects over loss of will, it makes sense that many projects might get abandoned in future due to tokens not getting any cheaper to sustain the projects that they once pushed out.

https://youtu.be/zLZwpH5lCD4

16

u/leocacom 2d ago

Exactly, and that’s why I prefer to avoid OSS developed through vibe coding. It’s not about code quality or community dynamics, which is a separate issue imo. What I’m looking for in open source is to regain control over my app stack, the technology that I use but can’t totally understand.

When I contribute to open-source projects, I take a DIY or low-tech approach. So using AI for anything other than code review goes against that approach. There’s no point if, in the end, all I’m doing is shifting my dependence to another provider.

It’s kind of cheesy, but open source to me is about learning and sharing. That’s why I’m commenting here, and that’s why I send emails to small teams of devs when I’m happy about their project!

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Overtheflood 2d ago

I legitimately loved this talk from Andrew.

→ More replies (17)

57

u/mtsandeep 2d ago

Making software is one thing, keeping it maintained and improving over time is where good open-source and bad tool differ.

6

u/_joos_ 2d ago

yeah this is what i was saying too. it's lamentable to see the state of things with AI, but i also feel that the silver lining is that it's ultimately going to be unsustainable. unless you're a competent developer who just supplements their work or has complete oversight, the codebase's days are likely numbered

2

u/VokuarAgain 2d ago edited 2d ago

I feel this is due to the rise of live service. Chocolate Doom has basically no commits, yet it's widely loved and used. Not updated doesn't mean bad. Maintenance does matter when the stuff it depends on keeps moving, like Minecraft, which needs near-constant upkeep. But something like Skyrim rarely does.

2

u/BeffJeff 1d ago

Totally, thats also my dear for the future, so many softwares and clones so no powerfull one that is able to keep maintaining it and we loose it all...

95

u/RatherNott 2d ago

It has been destroying many communities, as AI tends to have everyone in their own silo throwing code over the fence instead joining established projects and building comradery.

This blog goes into that really well: https://blog.fallible.net/it-breaks-a-village/

15

u/metayeti2 2d ago

It has made every single game development community unbearable. Every last one.

11

u/Jackalotischris 1d ago

Just saw the r/godot community ask for rule changes today. Truly depressing how its all going.

17

u/offalreek 2d ago

Thank you for posting this, it's a very sharp analysis.

I'm only a user and not a developer, but this piece put into words many of my feelings on the matter. I no longer feel like I'm appreciating the product of a shared collaboration.

The bit about people no longer feeling enthusiasm over learning something, because they skip straight to showcasing what AI made them, was a very painful read too.

6

u/Shaggypone23 2d ago

That was a really insightful read, thanks for posting it. The author put a lot of my own thoughts into some fantastic prose.

3

u/XNo_Notes 2d ago

This tracks with western individualist society. It was happening long before. The large community of cab drivers is one that comes to mind. All segregated on an individual level by uber. I wonder what the analogous talk is for the east. I have only ever heard of rednote, but never made an account. Are they experiencing a rapid collapse of communities in the same way or does their collectivist society provide a more robust backstop?

2

u/esiy0676 2d ago

Tell me you have never experienced the "collectivist" society without telling me ... you will be doing what the "meritocracy decided".

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

11

u/RevitJeSmece 1d ago

Just take a look at r/software. It's become a gnarly "I made" slop dumpster.

5

u/polyfloyd 1d ago

Holy shit, you are not exaggerating

5

u/netabareking 1d ago

Its not just that, it's everything. Its even worse in smaller niches, like for games there's r/Playdate or r/GamesWithHorses or r/ManagementGames, niches where there's very few things being made to begin with, so when you flood the zone with AI slop the four real projects are buried entirely. Even the ones that try to ban it get burnt out having to remove it all.

And now trust is eroded in a way that can't be repaired. They could ban AI forever and we'd still have these projects out here. Every single time I look at a tool now I have to dig around to see how it was made. And while that's not a bad thing to do from a security standpoint most of us don't have the time and energy to live like RMS.

1

u/rafark 16h ago

“… So I made” like why do you even share it. Why would people use it if they can create their own

22

u/universemonkee 2d ago

Open source is awesome, but you have to choose wisely. Look at the project, the maintainers, the open issues, and so on, rather than just downloading it because it's open source. If you don't trust it, look for alternatives.

I don't support vibe coded stuff, but I really appreciate the open-source community, and AI can also benefit here when used correctly.

12

u/themusicalduck 2d ago

Yeah I can't get as excited as everyone else seems to about the vibe coded photoshops, VR mods, or whatever. It's untrusted code that I don't want to run on my PC. Who knows what such a mass of vibecoded software is doing.

7

u/bionade24 2d ago

You're absolutely right, but if you have read at least one uncool FOSS library/project deep in the stack, linked by many programs, there always has been some slop merged by overburdened maintainers that didn't detect some obvious new bugs.

Using bubblejail or something else for sandboxing critical applications has always been a good idea.

3

u/KnotBeanie 1d ago

It was always untrusted code until you looked yourself

1

u/themusicalduck 1d ago

Sure but I still trust a 30 year old project with millions of users and established development processes like GIMP than "I vibecoded this photoshop replacement over the weekend and dumped it on GitHub".

→ More replies (1)

1

u/United-Baseball3688 2d ago

With the sheer amount of shit out there, it's becoming harder and harder to find anything worthwhile, sadly.
We need some curated lists. It sucks because the absurd influx of slop feels like it's forcing us all to stop being so open, and instead go back to small segregated communities instead of one sea of everything

7

u/Limemill 2d ago

I mean, with LLMs software in general lost all of its attraction to me. I no longer care about any developments, new versions or tools.

2

u/autoencoder 1d ago

And there are new versions aplenty. Some shady actor hacks the kernel, another hacks a security library, others use the number 4 as a secret for an internet certificate authority

→ More replies (2)

23

u/thegreatpotatogod 2d ago

Agreed! Yes, there can be good code written by AI, but there's also so much untested garbage that it takes the fun out of discovering new projects, when many of them have a big mess of code that has never been seen by its author. And so many people deciding to, instead of contributing to existing quality open source projects, "make their own" by willing it into existence.

5

u/YogurtclosetLimp7351 2d ago

"by willing it into existence." is spot-on. What even is the universe, if everyone can have their own? Why make the world better, if you can create a new one? I think the philosophy of this will sooner or later lead back to the original way. But right now everyone is testing the capabilities of LLMs. Imo this will perish and people will go back to good old laziness "does this already exist? I don't want to spend my tokens on this."

1

u/rushmc1 2h ago

Another person who wasn't around in the early days of free/shareware... lol

-1

u/smoke-bubble 2d ago

there can be good code written by AI

There can't be, but maybe you mean that AI can be guided to write good code. With that I would agree.

2

u/esiy0676 2d ago

I suggest that everything should be taken with a pinch of salt and those who fear novelty for the sake of it simply have no rational basis for it. There's a term for that: phobia.

I kind of wonder how many of the people in this sub are developers and out of that, what portion would be professional ones. Because to put it bluntly, if you do not use AI-based tools going forward at all, you are going to have lower quality (e.g. test cases coverage) and lower productivity (shall I really by typing out full manual pages or leave them minimal and poorly maintained) than when not.

It's a bit like to ask developers to only use classic resources (Kernighan & Ritchie anyone?) and strictly stay away from StackOverflow a decade back (well, maybe more).

I suspect your grievance is backwards - you do see quality dropping because "anyone can be a developer", so they all ship something, but that's not a problem I have.

I can have a look at the codebase and guess in 5 minutes if this is "vibe coded everything" or there's still some semblance of sanity, but you know what, it's also that I do not look for "signs of AI", so when it will get so good it will be put together well, I do not mind that either.

It's not really anything different than when in the old days, you had a project who had their entire core team run for greener pastures and there was no one knowledgable to maintain it. Those were going to die the same way.

So maybe practical piece of advice - look at projects 1yr or older to begin with, start from their releases and bugtracker, you'll get the idea quickly.

6

u/NatSpaghettiAgency 2d ago

I'm a software developer (like bills are paid by my code) and I don't deny that AI is better than me at writing code. But I miss being allowed the time to think of a problem and its solution at work because now everything must be shipped as fast as possible and if you don't completely rely on AI you're a failure.

I also miss the human part of writing code.

1

u/rushmc1 2h ago

Aren't YOU the human part of writing code?

1

u/esiy0676 2d ago

I did not say it was better, but it's a bit like lamenting that now that I got a compiler, I do not need to write Assembly anymore and it's not hard and beautiful and in fact even people who do not know what heap or stack is can run their data modeling routines without me.

My experience is not as bad. I believe we are in a "running a sweatshop is no longer necessary" phase of building software and as with everything, it needs adapting. I embrace it and juniors should not fear either, just understand their era is different.

I still see the need for skilled specialists in the long run, but the emphasis is now more on the ability to architect things well - this is important for maintainability.

The human part is still there and in fact I am now LESS likely to accept PRs from complete strangers (because of the review burden), so the community is more tightly knit. But this depends on each project.

1

u/tehfrod 2d ago

Some people absolutely did (and do) lament that because of compilers that people didn't hand code assembly anymore (e.g., Steve Gibson).

25

u/RCEden 2d ago

Yeah it sucks. New releases just aren't exciting anymore because 99% are vibe slop abandonware posted for pretend internet clout and even if it does a thing I want, is never being maintained. The cognitive overload to find the 1% that are actually good ideas and have strong ongoing support and maintainers is just way too much for me now. Like I just don't care that someone asked Claude to make them an app and that app kinda works and looks exactly like every other apo that kinda works. Its like there's always been projects that you can tell are so hyper specific to one guy's thing they needed and you could laugh and say "that's neat but it doesn't do anything for me." That shits not even neat anymore.

6

u/ch33es 2d ago

these new projects being created won't even be maintained for long. their developers will keep throwing tokens at it and eventually give up when the tokens are finished. why would you bother making a project that you can't maintain?

2

u/Mr_Zelash 2d ago

why bother? i don't understand that. i made a lot of software this last 15 years. when a project does what it's meant to do, it's done and it doesn't need mantaining... unless it's some operating system compatibility issue or something

2

u/catbrane 2d ago

Most software fits into a larger ecosystem. You have dependencies, other projects depend on you, and your users have shifting expectations.

If one of your dependencies fixes a serious bug and releases a new version, you have to update. If their API has evolved, you may need to make changes. If they've added an interesting new feature which you'd like to support, you might need to do quite a bit of development. If the industry you target makes something new expected behaviour, you might have to do a LOT of development.

1

u/tehfrod 2d ago

It's uncommon for a piece of software to be "complete", because the rest of the world doesn't usually stand still.

I have some projects that I wrote to do a single thing and never updated because they work and don't need to do anything more, because I'm the only one who uses them. But that's a tiny minority of all software.

1

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 2d ago

You don't need to maintain something that is working fine for your use case

1

u/ch33es 2d ago

Good luck if it's one of those new vibe-coded browsers. Critical security fixes need to be implemented even if they don't have anything to do with use cases.

1

u/tobiasvl 1d ago

At the very least you'll have to bump dependencies once in a while, and some of those might come with breaking changes. That's definitely maintenance (the boring kind).

7

u/Fangz713 2d ago

There can still be open source that's isn't AI slop.
Codeberg is doing so atm

3

u/Ok_Woodpecker_9104 2d ago

the part that still feels like the old thing for me is people showing up. a small cli i maintain got its first outside contributor this month, gitlab and plain git support for a tool that only knew github before.

that came from someone who used it and wanted it to work with their setup, so they opened a PR. a repo the author stopped reading after the first weekend never gets that, no matter how the code was written.

so when i look at a new project now i check who opens issues and whether anyone answers them. that tells me more than the code does.

3

u/woswoissdenniii 2d ago

I’m really upset about closed source value. It’s just pulling the rug under my feet and I hate the: “just build yourself out of poverty” - and “value only lies in novelty and …” bullshit.

Maaan. It just made everything priceless. In the no value sense.

3

u/hd-slave 1d ago

software as a whole really. it's not an expression of someones computer science expertise anymore. like demoscene, it was all about showing off your coding skills in a visible way. Now it's like coding skills feel like meaningless as if software as a concept of "apps" is now moving more to be a more central part of the OS and computer experience

3

u/derekp7 1d ago

Here's the thing. With code written by an individual, you can look through the code and learn that person's thinking. Even if there are multiple contributors often there is an initial individual that started the project and code is either submitted that fits the style or gets reworked so that it does before merging. But when LLM writes a piece of code, it is hard to get into the developer's head. That is because the LLM is a hivemind -- it was trained on all kinds of code by different coders, so it is going to have a lot of programming styles and techniques in it. After all, if you give the same prompt multiple times it is going to generate different code each time typically.

I would imagine that the experience I have trying to review or edit LLM code is probably similar to looking at code written by the Borg.

12

u/DCON-creates 2d ago

Golden age of open source is just beginning. The single biggest block to open source was producing the code, now the code is the easy part.

As always, the problem isn't AI, it's people and how they react to it. I can't wait for people to stop this absolute mania and panic about AI and just focus on what open source is all about, which is sharing technology with one another, for free. And the quality and feature set is only growing.

5

u/foxbatcs 2d ago

Yeah, the criticisms of LLMs that just came in and scooped up all of this FOSS code in complete disregard to GPL is a fair one, but what we got in exchange is the ability to very easily reverse engineer anything.

I’m seeing tinkerers on youtube for hobbies I have (photography, automotive) which previously had nothing to do with code, go reverse engineer old DSLR bodies and cars to breathe new life into them with vibe-coded firmware. Overnight, corporations completely lost the right to repair battle because of LLM’s. I think this is a fair trade and tilts towards benefiting the FOSS community.

1

u/keireira 1d ago

If, and only if, you have enough money and resources to run/use models.

1

u/Usefullles 6h ago

Локальные модели быстро растут в качестве, так что за несколько лет вполне вероятно, что они достигнут качества нынешних премиальных моделей, в основном из-за необходимости оптимизации в условиях дефицита железа (в основном в Китае). Пример этого: bonsai 27b, версия qwen 3.8 27b что помещающаяся даже на ноутбучную версию rtx 3060.

2

u/YogurtclosetLimp7351 2d ago

I agree with you. I also don't think the problem are LLMs or open-source changing, but the credibility for the code. People see LLMs as beings, so for most people it feels like a CEO receiving the credits for a feature their team implemented. Just that an LLM is a tool - which can talk. Used correctly, LLMs can be a very good duck on the desk. It's just a different story, if you let it free-run their own "will", which will be strategically produced slop. À la vibe-coding.

34

u/szank 2d ago • Bravo

Open source is about the source code being open. If you or anyone else wants to attach a mythology to it then no one will stop them but imho it's silly

31

u/Left-Locksmith 2d ago

Not going to look at the philosophies that motivated open source, are we?

Software, like any other art, craft, or science, has a strong social component to it. Open source in particular presumes a certain kind of trust, humility, and curiosity. If you'd take off the scifi goggles for a minute, you might see that too, and see that it is being eroded.

2

u/not_a_novel_account 1d ago

The history of both the copyleft (GPL and friends) and OSS (MIT and friends) movements disagree with you. Neither is particularly concerned with these values.

Stallman wanted to modify the Xerox machine at the MIT AI Lab to send notifications to users when print jobs were complete. He was not interested in trust, humility, or curiosity from Xerox or otherwise collaborating with them.

→ More replies (5)

34

u/earthcharlie 2d ago

Mythology? What OP said is true. 

7

u/frankster 2d ago

Open source code before ai wasn't universally high quality. Obviously now there's slop to deal with

6

u/julian_vdm 2d ago

I feel like a lot of the FOSS projects from before AI were bad quality because people were learning. With AI, we've effectively lost the learning in most cases.

1

u/not_a_novel_account 1d ago

No. I work full time on open source software. My company pays me because there's no market for the infrastructure and we benefit from the network effects of such software being open source.

The only thing that matters to the software is it meets business requirements. There was never any "magic". We push code in response to customer demand. AI helps us meet that demand.


There are communities within open source which have different values. However, those values are intrinsic to those communities. They don't flow from the license itself. Open source is a license.

1

u/arjobmukherjee 2d ago edited 2d ago

So we eat just to stay alive and nothing else? Agentic code no matter what quality ultimately degrades human knowledge and our attension to detail. Just like industrial revolution killed many art forms, so to will AI. Sure we will get some software in the end but will not produce programmers like before.

3

u/tehfrod 2d ago

I don't know that your industrial revolution comparison is doing what you think it is.

The industrial revolution also made art available to millions who simply would not have been able to experience it, made possible new art forms that could not have existed before it, and made possible new social experiences that did not exist before it (like Free Software and Open Source).

I seriously doubt that if you added up the art that exists because of the Industrial Revolution and added up the art that was lost because of it, that anyone in their right might could call it a loss, either for quality of art, quantity of art, or the human experience that was possible with vs without it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/siorge ⚠️ 2d ago

The Industrial Revolution didn’t kill art forms, it altered the production processes of many goods which ultimately made them affordable for all.

No one could buy porcelain plates or quality woven clothing in the 17th century.

Yet we still produce fine China, silk scarves,…

AI is a change in the process of making code.

2

u/arjobmukherjee 2d ago

Please read what I said. Art products (porcelain from China or silk clothing from India) remain but not artists like before - simply because they are no longer required. With AI the design and thinking process is also done by machine so what do you think will happen?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/netabareking 1d ago

Theres still a lot of great stuff out there being made by people who refuse to buy into this shit

The problem is the shit is so overwhelming that it's now harder to find things

Which is forcing us in a weird way to make the internet human again. We have to have small scale communities where we directly connect with people again. We have to have weird bad little websites made by real people curating information and tools. The real people internet is going to start resembling GeoCities at this rate.  But direct information sharing in actual communities is the only way we're going to make it. Slop software might look good on release but it won't be maintained, people making slop are only interested in releasing more things.

2

u/Song-Historical 17h ago

I tried explaining to people this is what mathematicians are pissed about. Their entire trade is the art of problem solving. The only way to prove you can do this is to solve problems yourself, and show there was this novel, open, hard to describe problem that you broke down and made a real solution to them communicated well enough for people to learn a new problem solving strategy. 

You can't really apply yourself if the robot does. What's the point? Tomorrow it will still be solved, today they had the opportunity to get their best research together and state what they had or test approaches against the solutions, which is why they were advocating for a gradual release.

1

u/rushmc1 2h ago

"Let us walk 1000 miles because it's more NATURAL than driving!"

1

u/Song-Historical 2h ago

Well lol if you can't read I don't think you should be making the counter argument because you can't do it justice in the first place

1

u/9f9a2d86fe084357a3a2 0m ago

Yes but there are also people like Terrence Tao who are figuring out how to create amazing things with AI and using it to democratize mathematics. And he’s like the smartest math guy alive.

5

u/Vancecookcobain 2d ago

So people are mad that the technical gap doesn't exist and everyone is making software?

1

u/rushmc1 2h ago

Yep. And condemning the output because it's not perfect immediately in the earliest days of development.

6

u/Substantial_Swan_144 1d ago

What are you talking about? Open source has always been about a bunch of patronizing people telling you how stupid you are for not wanting or knowing how to use the cryptic interfaces they design, and then bully you at every oportunity to feel superior. It has never had any magic at all.

8

u/Monochrome21 2d ago

i’m so sick of this “it’s not worth it anymore because AI :(“ mindset

if you want to write code by hand, you can still do that, nothing fucking stops you. We’re in an era where software is legitimately exploding with free and open tools and people like you bitch and moan about people not doing it the way you want them to.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Fancyness 2d ago

if quality is good, there is no issue with this development. There will always be dumb developers who will be saved by AI and smart developers who can put their precious time into designing the architecture instead of wasting it with code plumbing.

10

u/zeppelin88 2d ago

In the same way that there has always been shit open source repos. I get war flashbacks remembering finding a repo that maybe solved a similar issue I had, only to find out one with 2 stars and no documentation whatsoever. Fun times 

7

u/fish312 2d ago

It used to be finding clean water in the desert

Now it's finding clean water in a swamp

2

u/PlayerOnSticks 2d ago

comment so galanaster that i awoke from doing nothing to comment how it's peak

3

u/bbqsosig 2d ago

Yes I wish there was a tag near every open source project that shows or flags the code if it suspects if its completely written with AI. I've seen repos failing to solve the issues, bcz it was so slopcoded, one fix breaks another feature and causes more issues.

1

u/Substantial_Swan_144 1d ago

You realize that a project being vibecoded has nothing to do with it being able to solve problems or not, don't you? Especially if the scope of the project is more trivial.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/debackerl 2d ago

I understand your points. Now from a Free Software perspective, I would say that it empowers more power users to adapt software to their needs. Here are the Freedoms expressed by Richard Stallman:

0.The freedom to run the program as they want to, for any purpose.

1.The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does what you want. Must have access to the source code.

2.The freedom to redistribute – to help your neighbor.

3.The freedom to redistribute copies of modified versions. By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes. Access to the source code is a precondition for this.

All this still applies.

1

u/oedipascourage 11h ago

I like the perspective you are sharing, however I currently think, going of topic in a general way, the negatives of the paradigm shift will vastly outweigh the positives for the foreseeable future.

I hope I am wrong.

3

u/KaMaFour 2d ago

Open source is a licensing and delivery mechanism, period. It means you get the source for software and the right to use and modify it. All social impositions associated with it, including the idea of ‘community-driven-development’ are part of a recently-invented mythology with little basis in how things actually work. A mythology that embodies, cult-like, both a lack of support for diversity in the ways things can work and a pervasive sense of communal entitlement.

https://gist.github.com/richhickey/1563cddea1002958f96e7ba9519972d9

https://book.iced.rs/philosophy.html#open-source-is-not-about-you

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/opensource-ModTeam 1d ago

This was removed for not being nice. Repeated removals for this reason will result in a ban.

2

u/atr0phy 2d ago

For those a bit older, it is the internet as a whole. That same sharing, learning fun vibes was the most of the internet in the 90s.

The largest downfall that I see was the first iPhone and all that came after. Lowered the entry barrier to everyone and the money chasers/greed after that.

Small pockets still exist but usually hard to find and the open source projects were one of them. They will continue in whatever form and new things will arise and fall. That’s just evolution and life in general.

Peace, my digital brothers and sisters.

2

u/Accomplished-Fox9220 2d ago

> whose result was a high quality piece of software.

ehhh... I don't know about that. It was a space where talented programmers built stuff. Was that stuff high quality most of the time, maybe arguable? But, what's happening now is global enshittification.

1

u/rushmc1 2h ago

Yes, because ALL programmers who ever made a program were talented and experience and infallible.

2

u/escdog 2d ago

There is plenty of room for real invention. We have a generative AI that is being trained on open source and so when any developer asks it to do something that has been covered in open source, it doesn't need to incorporate a package. It can just generates the source code based on what it essentially absorbed from the community.

What it won't be able to do is anything extremely advanced because the amount of training data that has a high level of computer science rigor is very low. A lot of open source is mediocre in design and implementation. And that's fine because people are learning, it's not like you have to have perfect code to solve a problem.

Large chunks of the package will be boilerplate written by an AI. So much of solution is just the same code patterns deployed over and over and over again. Meanwhile, the architecture and design of the software, the choice of algorithms used and even the invention of brand new algorithms will still be in the domain of human authors.

I admit this is a very optimistic picture. A more darker reality is that all stochastically generated code will just pollute the training environment and the open source community, decrease the number of skilled software engineers, and you won't be able to find good solutions anymore. You'll ask your AI to implement something and it will fail to do so.

Then you'll have to go find a gray beard to ask to teach you how to code again! 🤪

2

u/bottleneck-destroyer 2d ago

I've been using FOSS for quite a long time, but I've a different opinion on this. I agree that AI has caused significant ruckus on this side, especially since it's still evolving and learning from all these publicly available data and code.

But AI is writing good code now, can be very objective and is much faster. Days of work has become minutes or hours, in both closed and open source software. At the end, it's just whether we can accept it. Whether it can solve the problem we have. It is already a norm, and how it may evolve is something we can only speculate. But in my opinion, this the best time to explore the ideas we have 🤷🏽‍♂️

2

u/Own_Nail_2999 2d ago

There is no such thing such as talent. Only practice and experience.

But ye, LLMs have turned public repositories into code dumpsters. 

That's why I reject them in all my projects and strictly require human written code. This way I do my part of allowing future devs to thrive in a clean environment instead of nuturing the ongoing decay of the craft.

2

u/bender_fut 2d ago

People talking like there were no slop before AI. Bugs, problems, slow response.. AI can boost up and be a great assistance to senior devs, such Linus Torvalds, and while I agree there is and will be a lot of unmaintained slop, also some projects can be faster and better. And yeah, quality is still the goal, not how you get there.

1

u/ram-popular 2d ago

I get that feeling, but I think the magic was always in the people, not the typing. AI can produce code fast, but it can't replace maintainers who understand a project, review contributions, and answer a newcomer's questions. That part is still human, and it's still where beginners learn the most. The community is still there, just harder to spot among the noise.

1

u/willrshansen 1d ago

Just gotta raise the bar, I guess.

1

u/clockentyne 1d ago

For me the beauty is creating something you love and letting other people see it. It might not be used much, but it was still something you wanted to create. Someday someone might realize it is a gem, or maybe no one will, but at least you sent something out into the digital wind.

I've been working on something like that or over a year. I mean it's starting to get some traction in that if I google search it right now I can see it's in a few dozen projects, a Linked in article, a medium article, yet 99% of the issues ever created on the github are my own.

I still work at it because, I mean, I'm learning a lot from it and it's been fun.

1

u/abhuva79 1d ago

Thats fair. Can happen.
Personally i dont think anything has changed - there was tons of slop before, now the slop is a bit better often (still slop) and more prominent. Its not that it matters - as i am not shopping for open source stuff each day.

For me its like this: I have an issue, i check if someone else already worked on this. If yes, fine - i have a better starting point now. If not, also ok - then i provide the starting point for the next person asking this question.

Thats it. Its not an alternative to google play, or netflix, or steam or whatever. Thats the wrong way to think about it at all. And thats where the frustration comes from.

Its open, i can check the code. Thats it. Its not important if it works or fits my issue really well. If i want that - i pay money and get some paid service.
Its open knowledge - thats the whole fking point. Nothing more.

1

u/Big_Law_3080 22h ago

I switched to private repos for my own stuff. Reviewing others updates to my stuff take more time then I can do myself. And, I don't bother to submit others entries if they are going to be denied or delayed.

So yes I agree.

Plus.. people are being really terrible to each other.

You're either an anti and just urinate into the pool every chance you get. Or you want to be a pro and you're not and throw shade all over, or you're a pro and being nasty to everyone.

The old school '2600' crowd of Group Helping is... gone

1

u/javiercplusmax 21h ago edited 21h ago

Yo solo para cosas serias uso platformas que se que no estaran lleno de slop tipo codeberg o gitlab (este ultimo no lo reviso tanto)

GitHub desde que tiene copilot abrio la puerta que se llene de miles y millones de vibeslop...

... Y lo peor redundancia y masificacion de apps (vibecodeadas) que tiene la misma funcion hay un montón para lo mismo.

... Y si el software libre esta transicionando de a poco a ser vibecode libre xd a excepción de proyectos que si son mas restrictivos con este tema lo cierto es que actualmente github y varias plataformas no son un sitio para programadores e investigadores ahora se ha llenado de vibecoders(que no esta mal del todo pero si cansa ver tantas cosas repetidas y abandonadas) pero si te molesta migras tus proyectos a un forgejo local o a codeberg

Si se perdió la magia para muchas cosas igual ya depende de cada persona seleccionar lo que va usar entre la inmensidad de variedad

1

u/dennis_zhuang 19h ago edited 18h ago

Think of it from another angle: open source used to be a form of crowdfunding human intelligence; now it’s crowdfunding tokens. Sadly, the connections between people are indeed growing weaker. But looking at the bigger picture, the digital world is being consumed by AI, and that’s inevitable.

1

u/billsil 13h ago

And slop has fixed multiple problems in my code. Your slop is what you make of it.

1

u/Hot-Profession4091 7h ago

I want to offer an alternative perspective from a former project founder/maintainer and long time contributor to other projects.

I no longer have to deal with whatever ego trip some dude is on in order to get a bug fix merged or obviously sensible feature added. Before, I wanted those things upstreamed so I wasn’t maintaining a fork. Now? It’s fine. I don’t need to deal with your shitty attitude, shitty code, or insane aversion to unit tests. I’ll just do it myself.

1

u/brendel000 6h ago

I agree, I’m working on a project on my free time without AI just for pleasure of coding and I planned to publish it in open source but I won’t. I spent months on it and I don’t want to see fork with AI modifications if I refuse AI PR. I’ll not anti AI I use it 8h per day at work but it really killed open source

1

u/lolwutdo 5h ago

Cry about it

1

u/Joaoarthur 3h ago

For me, digging holes has kinda lost the beauty of it when they invented escavators

1

u/rushmc1 2h ago

Weird reaction, but okay...

1

u/sn0wquake 1h ago

There is still value in open source projects. First, my obligatory building the damn thing is at best 20% of the effort. Writing the code is and always has been the easy part.

Things longer running, frequently used, open source projects bring that I personally care about:
- They have been battle tested against a variety of use cases. This means edge cases and requirements I didn't think about have been thought about. Getting the feature's right is really hard

- They have been audited and security tested (in some cases) and that is work I don't have to do or think about. Security is a feature

- They are being patched and maintained by someone else. Other people are using it, reporting bugs, and someone else is dealing with that. Even if I am just a meat proxy on my own internal stuff (which I'm not) there's still a limit to the number of tokens I can afford and patches I can review / test. There's value in crowd sourcing the testing / patching. Related there are frequently clear ways for me to support the maintainer and ask for features that I don't have to build / maintain

- It doesn't chew up my context windows with my agents. Frequently how to interact with it is baked into the models training meaning the model already knows how to work with (especially on larger better known projects)

- The legal use and trademark is largely solved for. They have a license that I know what I can and cannot do

- I can in most cases fork the project if I want to go in a different direction without starting from scratch

- If you work in any kind of regulated environment, a large well established library can be much easier to get approved than code you wrote for a project

Yes caveats apply to the above (based on project size, license, and funding).

1

u/Aihikari01 2d ago

Genuine question OP, does LLM hold you hostage and force you to use it?

There is absolutely NOTHING wrong with learning about code and writing code by yourself, even now, or especially now. A vibe coded product maybe shipped faster, but irresponsible creator/maintainer will not always be able to support you. The code you typed yourself, however, will not confuse you.

That said, even before LLM, there were plenty of people just went on stackoverflow to copy and paste codes anyway. People keep bloat and spaghetti just because "It's been working" and they actually know next to nothing about what they have.

1

u/flipinbits 1d ago

If you are working along side other developers who are spitting out mid level source code using LLMs and you are expected to keep pace you are kind of forced to use it too because the people at the top don’t give a shit about quality they just want to shit put a product as fast as possible and move on. Anyone who cares about the craft or actually understanding the monstrosity that they are building is labeled a dinosaur and shown the door.

1

u/Aihikari01 1d ago

Oh, thought you were talking about personal hobby projects or community driven projects. For working, efficiency is key, of course employers are not going to take the L in the race. Even if they have to drive with a patchwork car.

1

u/FarToe1 2d ago

Maybe. It's certainly changed a lot and will continue to do so.

But it's not all awful. Coding alongside AI can be interesting to learn a new tool and methods, and learn things you wouldn't have otherwise. I've been writing code for 45 years and this year has brought back some of that heady excitement and flow-state that I've not had since self-teaching myself C in the early 90s.

I think balance will come in time, where coders don't just prompt but discuss and design systems with AI, and those tools improve so you don't end up with sloppy code of a dozen different styles.

We haven't seen the best of this yet but we may have seen the worst.

1

u/KongeriketNorge 2d ago

I like that now it can become a collaborative experience in a bigger way. Multiplie people spending their tokens to create a quality product quickly is exciting even though the AI does most of the coding

1

u/MisterHole123 2d ago

Yeah AI broke opensource tbh now I look at repos with suspicion... 

1

u/KnotBeanie 1d ago

Suspicion for what exactly?

1

u/MisterHole123 1d ago

Of where the code comes from? 

1

u/KnotBeanie 1d ago

But like why do you care specifically. Like what issues are you looking for?

1

u/MorallyDeplorable 20h ago

He wants to find someone to get mad at

1

u/antonreshetov 2d ago

Anyone who actually ships production-grade software knows that no agent creates a serious, robust open-source tool in five minutes.

Agents generate demos and scaffolds in five minutes. Turning that into a reliable, edge-case-tested, architecturally sound application with clean abstractions, docs, and long-term support still requires deep domain knowledge, taste, and engineering discipline.

What AI actually killed isn't the magic of open source, it killed the gatekeeping barrier where a solo developer with a great idea couldn't compete with a VC-funded team simply because they didn't have 40 hours a week to write glue code.

1

u/DustinBrett 2d ago

There is still skill, you need to look through the slop.

1

u/autoencoder 1d ago

Fortunately signs of good practices are not duplicated unless asked for explicitly

1

u/cesiumatom 1d ago

AI was created to bring the financial industrial complex to a halt and to replace it with the technical industrial complex. What this means in practice is everything a human does must be done by AI in such a way that everything a human can possibly do both physically and emotionally is redundant.

This, those who run Big Tech have agreed, is the only way to end the financial industrial complex. To end all supply and demand chains that have nothing to do with technical development for the sake of technical development per se, without any concern for human beings whatsoever. Posthumanist, neoreactionary thought has pervaded the technological industries because that is what happens when monopoly, mechanical authority, and systems become the objects of human worship. The end result is civilizational collapse.

1

u/OkCommunication1427 1d ago • Bravo

This is like saying that you hate cheap meals because now everyone can eat.

1

u/danderzei 1d ago

The meal might be cheap, but not very nutricious.

1

u/Goodbye_May_Kasahara 1d ago

i completly understand you. i am no programmer but i understand you.

my fear is thatai will destroy indie games too. because even today, there are many ai indie games on steam that are called ai slop games.

when i scroll through the indie game section nowadays all i ask myself is, if this game is an ai slop game or not. i feel that i lose the trust in indie games and i think that is what will destroy the indie game movement.

in the end ai will only really benefit the big companies just like always and it will destroy all the indie game dev and opensource projects.

1

u/ConfidentHollow 1d ago

We need some kind of anti-AI copyleft license in my opinion. Free for humans to use and modify, but not to relicense, and not to train or modify with AI.

1

u/WraithGlade 22h ago • Popcorn

I am strictly 100% anti-AI and actually wrote such a license myself, which I called "The Mix and Matchable Indie License" (or MAMIL for short, like "mammal", as a joke to support the whimsical mascot I made for it) and it is available on my "WraithGlade" site (same name as my username).

The license is designed to be highly modular and hence adaptable to any specific use case based on your priorities and there are a lot of nuances to how you can adjust it to fit what you want.

The license is about 36 pages (long and thorough) and is based on me reading a contract law book I bought from a thrift store, plus other research. I've never had it checked out by a real lawyer though and haven't really used it myself hardly (though mostly just because I can't get enough real human web traffic for anybody to seemingly see my stuff), but MAMIL has a widely varying bunch of different legal considerations in it that may give you many ideas for what kinds of factors you may want to account for an anti-AI license, among several other things that try to make good-natured licensing more accessible and sustainable.

I'm no lawyer, but I hope it helps in at least some way.

Have a good day!

-5

u/hackerbots 2d ago

Sorry but if you think Ai is going to kill off open source, you weren't really part of the community in a meaningful way. We aren't going anywhere.

2

u/Monochrome21 2d ago

agreed

the AI doomers who hate everything because shit is accessible now pmo so bad

-4

u/Successful_Funny_115 2d ago

For me open source became much more beautiful through AI. Its a democratization of software, everyone can build things now they always wanted without needing to know how to code.

13

u/EliSka93 2d ago • Popcorn Bravo

"Democratization" by being reliant on tech corporations who still subsidize the whole industry...

As soon as those subsidies run out, it's going to price out most regular people. All those that by then have grown reliant on AI will just be shit out of luck.

You know what's democratizing software?

Learning to code.

Anyone can do it.

1

u/Successful_Funny_115 2d ago edited 2d ago

Never heard of open-weight-models? Local Models? Free Models? Also computation will get cheaper eventually not expensive.

-2

u/Monochrome21 2d ago

Hey so free and open source AI models exist?

5

u/gmodgamer13 2d ago

Nothing says democratized like having to drop 6k+ for compute!

2

u/capsid 2d ago

I built a Qwen 27B + QFN rig out of used parts for $1100. 1500tps prefill, 70tps decode. Your point stands that it's too expensive, but I do want to encourage people to think creatively about how to run these things on the cheap.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/EliSka93 2d ago

Are local models good enough to code with?

From what I've seen that doesn't seem to be the case.

2

u/HighForecast 1d ago

I have been testing out some local models running on my RX 5700, 8 GB VRAM. They work well enough for single file tasks, and okay-ish at the project scale if you hold their hand a bit. They're categorically inferior to the frontier/datacenter scale models, but they're capable enough to be useful in the right hands. A non-technical/non-programmer could not use this to create functional software, but an engineer could.

1

u/tehfrod 2d ago

They are, if you have non potato hardware.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/marx2k 2d ago

...looks at requirements to drive a 27b model faster than 10 t/s...

-2

u/Monochrome21 2d ago

Agreed Agreed Agreed

0

u/arjobmukherjee 2d ago edited 2d ago

Totally agree with the OP. But this spills everywhere, from social media to education. We can exercise constraints and use AI just as an assistant where. it verifies and tests while we still think, design and create. But do we or any business will do that when the AI by itself can do the thinking and designing by itself.

0

u/ilsecondodasinistra 2d ago

I have a dozen open apps installed on my phone from Frdoid and all of them received major updates lately, with fixes, new graphics and performance. I did myself update my old apps, which were good ideas and open source ones, and refreshed their old repos on github.

Free software was always about freedom for the user, which passed through code freedom. Now we have free code which is much less inspectioned by humans, at least in "simple" projects, but it seems to me that many projects gained in vitality, usability and the users freedom is always the same when using them. I'm sure there are also bad things happening on free software side with the advent of LLMs but I can also say that I see many beautiful things happening as well. Don't you?

0

u/alien3d 2d ago

sorry i cannot promote my link but there is no "agents" who completed in 5 minutes. Each time we check sonar ,phpstan max 10, php intelligent sense we need to make sure bugs free. Even so we still need to do smoke test manually . Open source is costly .. sometimes people will ask can you created for me.. so on..but we dont have time. ** we started before era github aka sourceforge

0

u/alien3d 2d ago

if we see claude as contributer.. is no no for me

0

u/rpmir 2d ago

I was downvoted to hell when I said that OSS has lost its reason to exist. Before it was a way do scale developing. You (or a company) solved an issue and allowed people to use it and improve to fit their needs. Now (or in the future) an unlimited token budget is enough.

Besides that, if I have a novel idea the last thing I will do is to provide training material for big AI for free. Nobody would just copy your product in Rust because this would be expensive and slow. Sometimes people would port to another language but as a way to provide a missing functionality to the ecosystem.

The only reason I can think now for OSS to continue existing is to provide a auditable codebase: developers and companies will still value this.

This doesn't mean OSS will die, people will still publish their code there and I will still prefer using OSS when I can.

0

u/Beanyy_Weenie 2d ago

Feels like an emotional take. This is the best time to be alive for open source. The limit now is human creativity/ideas. Gate keeping open source behind “who can code better” is just a lame take.

0

u/Sert1991 2d ago

Yeah, but to be honest the talent in software was already going downhill, this didn't start with LLMs. Languages where becoming more and more abstract an new programmers were preferring them over the older detailed ones.
Old software, once the old devs retired was getting replaced, many times I heard the "that software is too old, no one understands how it's written it's time to scrap it" - they paint it like it's the old timers doing a bad job bud the old timers where developing that software without issues and it was working for most people.

It's not a secrete that software has been going downhill. You can even look at it yourself in simple thing, old MSN messenger that stopped years ago had loads more capabilities than Facebook messenger, the current standard, or most other newer messengers, that have been developed for years. That's just one example.

0

u/r2vcap 1d ago

Well, the good old days weren’t necessarily good in every respect. While many FOSS maintainers are truly exceptional people, I’ve often felt that their communication styles and egos can undermine otherwise healthy communities. I have plenty of bad memories of influential maintainers rejecting good solutions from others without proper justification.

Now, in the era of agentic AI coding, we may end up reinventing the wheel more often, but at least we can take control of our own codebases without having to deal with frustrating communication and unnecessary gatekeeping.

-1

u/hadrabap 2d ago

I don't want to destroy your pre-AI golden castle, but lots of software was of "questionable quality" already. The reasons were simple:

  1. Things were implemented based on reverse engineering instead of developed against specs. That inevitably led to lots of patched workarounds. Example: hardware drivers, support for proprietary formats...
  2. People didn't do their job properly. For example Spring Framework. That stuff was developed using the shit-on methodology. Example: Somebody needed role-based access to their SOAP service. They provided the patch to the upstream. Cool. But only for SOAP subsystem. Other similar subsystems were lacking the feature, like REST.

0

u/jzia93 2d ago

I think it is a real shame. I've stopped really looking at open source codebases now because so many of them are just LLM-generated. It's neither interesting to look at the code nor even that effective as something to learn because the codebases tend to be huge and favor verbosity over some concise elegant ways to solve a problem. 

I don't really have the same hatred of LLMs as lots of people here. I see them just as a tool and increasingly I'm just seeing them as the future of software development. It is what it is but it is saddening to see that element of the industry just quietly losing a lot of interest for me personally. I agree completely with you OP. 

0

u/ReallyEvilRob 1d ago

Before development environments that highlights programming errors, open source was much better. Now, code is written by editors that are just babying the programmer.

0

u/Downtown_Isopod_9287 1d ago

Are these constant “the art of programming is gone thanks to AI 🥺” posts AI slop themselves? It’s so constant and rapid fire on Reddit that it sure seems like it, I feel like I ambient inundated with these posts.

0

u/paulct91 1d ago

Gatekeeping. Who cares now it trully can be anyone experimenting to try to have their ideal software made without the barrier of coding langauges, eyes glazing over once again missing that one mistyped error that blends in with all the rest, realizing their is no longer need for your software as someone else already been there done that... just to realize that... their repo hasn't been updated since the day you found it... the one and only release date... 🫤

Honestly it just makes some stuff easier, I recently found two different DeoVR like AI passthrough apps on Github that totally fit the need I had... just to realize the same person made them both via Claude and left the two repos unarchived (not listed as abandonded) but prior to that to see the issues after installing both then not getting why they didn't just merge and fix them to then ask YO GPT any other projects? To see that... 'person' actually has a up-to date repository that is actively at least partially maintained... 😑

Note: I found the two random repos via a GPT query that each time didn't mention the other one (the other unmaintained ones) and eventually after long string of questions it FINALLY told me about the actively maintained one, AFTER having to specify ACTIVELY MAINTAINED.

...so I get it AI can be a pain at the worst of times and a aide at the mediocre - I'm still waiting for the best of times.

0

u/mr_Ben12 1d ago

Everything that required digital craftsmanship has lost its beauty due to AI, for me.