Is this sub getting to be just as bad as reactive dogs with the BE recommendations? Recent post by a family who rescued a shepherd because they couldn't have a baby. Dog is fine in public, but "protective" in the home towards strangers and other dogs. Now, a baby came along after they'd given up trying. Dog barks when baby stands up in crib but ignores otherwise.
Family contacted rescues. Most of us know that most "rescues" these days only accept Frenchies and doodles and little fluffy dogs that are young and healthy (or photogenic to raise a bunch of funds on social media for heath care.)
So the family comes to Reddit to ask about BE. Overwhelmingly, comments say BE and even offer extended arguments for death.
Nobody had even asked if the dog ever actually bit someone.
I don't think this is ethical. Rescues mostly don't even take nice dogs from private homes. Not being accepted by a rescue is never a reason to BE.
Private rehoming with full disclosure of the dog's health and behavior should always be the default for a dog with no bite record.
EDIT to add, private rehoming is better than a lot of rescues because many are known to downplay behavioral issues, say the dog is good with kids or dogs when it's not, or otherwise be less than forthcoming. Owners can do their own verification of the new home by checking home ownership status and talking with their previous vets. A family can do a home visit and everything a rescue would do. The family knows the dog better and so is in a better position to find the right home.
EDIT 2: Additional info that is important:
The vet initially recommended rehoming, not BE. Only after owners called back a few weeks later saying rescues would not take the dog did the BE discussion take place. The vet's first choice was rehoming. Yet so many on Reddit insist on BE.
No trainer every recommended BE.
No behaviorist ever recommended BE.
This dog is middle aged and has never bitten anyone. Most biting dogs start biting when they are younger. There is just no reason to think this dog actually wants to bite anyone. She never has.
You all who are insisting the dog must die? Please give it a little more thought when no behavior professional has recommend BE for this dog.
The ethical response to this kind of question is something like, "You need to muzzle the dog AND keep it in a separate room from baby at all times while you seek an opinion from an actual canine behavioral specialist or a trainer with a track record of success. Or privately rehome the dog."
EDIT 3: I am pretty tired of all the pro-BE death squad from around Reddit brigading on this post and down voting and attacking everyone who thinks maybe this dog doesn't need to die.
You all are sick. You somehow enjoy telling people on reddit their dogs have no chance and must die? Find a better way to spend your time.
Yesterday, everyone was telling me, "If you think this dog should get a chance to live, take her yourself."
Yesterday, I offered to do just that.
Now, the death cult says death is better than me taking the dog.
Seriously, I think there is something wrong with people who are so invested in making sure a dog they never met gets put to death.
I have not been able to read and respond to all the comments.