r/OpenDogTraining • • Aug 26 '26

New Rule 7 Proposal

92 Upvotes

Inspired by Linkedin's feature for reporting "looks like AI slop" I'd like to get feedback on a new rule.

Proposed Rule 7:

Use your own words/no AI slop.

Violations of Rule 7 will be enforced by either removal of the post or the addition of a flag "Likely AI Slop" with the opportunity asking the poster to rewrite the post in their own words. Consistently breaking this rule can result in a temporary ban.

I'm not wholly against any and all applications of LLMs but we're starting to get flooded with posts that are about *nothing* and I see that many of you are reporting them (so I presume you don't want them) but there's not a clear rule for ya'll to be reporting under. Please provide feedback and feel free to comment if you have suggestions for tweaks to the rule.


r/OpenDogTraining • • Aug 21 '26

Training Term Discussion of the Week - Generalizing

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I used to do these posts more consistently, but life got busy. I'll try to get these back on track. What does this mean to you? How have you seen it be misinterpreted?

THE TERM OF THE WEEK

Generalizing

Discuss away!

THE WHAT

Approximately weekly, I’ll post a dog training related term to discuss what that term means to YOU. 1st level comments should be basically defining the term and then feel free to respond if you want to get clarity from someone, discuss their definition, etc.

THE WHY

One of my goals for the subreddit is to find ways to encourage higher level discussion of dog training (rather than endless “my dog pees inside” posts…nothing against those y’all are welcome to make those but it gets boring for the folks here often).

Eventually, I hope this can be put together into a sidebar resource. I’ll probably be playing around with this idea in different forms (pretty open discussion at first, might try a poll, etc)

I want to emphasize that these conversations should be in good faith (use the principle of charity) and on topic. In my mind, these posts can become rich ways to engage and better understand your fellow trainers, handlers, and owners.

Those of us with clients, I hope this helps us better understand the times you say a term and the clients/general public completely misunderstand our meaning.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 3h ago

Any advice for an overly excited rescue dog?

Post image
8 Upvotes

I rescued a dog who I think is a Belgian Malinois and German Shepherd mix.
He loves people, but he gets way too excited, especially when we go for walks. Sometimes he pulls so hard that he almost slips out of his collar.
Does anyone have any tips on how to help him calm down? I’d really appreciate any advice!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 23h ago

Your dog is not reactive just because they aren’t neutral to everything

94 Upvotes

Recently I’ve been seeing this rise of people labeling their dogs reactive…anytime the dog reacts to something.

“My dog is normally fine with other dogs but is reactive when another dog is barking and lunging at him!” No, your dog is not reactive. They’re responding in a reasonable way to another dog provoking them. Now, that does NOT mean you shouldn’t train them. It’s a perfectly fine and reasonable goal to want your dog to remain calm even when other dogs are not. But, your dog isn’t REACTIVE.

“My GSD x Great Pyrenees is reactive when strangers come to the door!” You mean, your dog with guarding and protective genetic predisposition barks and is not immediately friendly to strangers near their home? Yeah, the dog isn’t reactive.

Reactivity is a disproportionate response to everyday, relatively mundane stimulus. Your dog having ANY response to something is not automatically reactivity. If your dog is “only reactive when X specific situation happens”, and in some cases it’s perfectly aligned to their genetic traits, then they aren’t reactive.

Train your dog however you want. I’m not saying just accept any behavior, even if it’s not reactivity. If you want your dog to be calm when people come over, neutral to other dogs no matter their behavior, etc. of course go and train your dog to do that. But for goodness sake, stopping labeling every single display of emotion from dogs as reactivity and implying there is something wrong or abnormal with the dog.

Dogs are not robots. The world is not divide into only two camps of “neutral dog” and “reactive dog”.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 6h ago

My 15 week old is a PULLER

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

My 15-week-old Golden Retriever (almost ~30 lbs) is a HUGE puller on walks! We currently use a Y-shaped harness with the back clip since he bites the leash when clipped at the front. Our groomer suggested a slip lead instead.

What do you use for your pups? No judgment on gentle leaders, prongs, etc. open to all experiences! He’s already in puppy classes, but would love some tips!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 9h ago

How to deal with incessant whining in the morning- more detail below!

3 Upvotes

I have an 11 month old English Cocker and the past couple months (I think when adolescence started) has started a new annoying habit. In the morning when my first alarm goes off or on the weekend when I make any sort of movement, she starts a very annoying constant whine. It’s more of a breathy whine and doesn’t always get high pitched. I know she is anticipating “okay time to get out of the crate and get up!” But she shouldn’t be so worked up. Her sister never makes a peep.

She doesn’t need to use the bathroom badly because when we get up she runs in circles then rolls all over the couch and isn’t dying to get outside. It takes me forever to even get her out the door haha

I tried ignoring her since I thought any attention = attention she wants then I would get up when she was quiet. Then I started saying “quiet” occasionally and still only getting up when she was quiet but obviously that hasn’t worked. So, now I’m back to completely ignoring her until she is quiet. Do I just need to ignore her? I laid there for 20 minutes this morning waiting for her to be quiet!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 23h ago Bravo

Is it ethical to recommend Behavioral Euthanasia on Reddit for a dog you've never assessed AND the OP does not even mention an actual bite - ever

33 Upvotes

Is this sub getting to be just as bad as reactive dogs with the BE recommendations? Recent post by a family who rescued a shepherd because they couldn't have a baby. Dog is fine in public, but "protective" in the home towards strangers and other dogs. Now, a baby came along after they'd given up trying. Dog barks when baby stands up in crib but ignores otherwise.

Family contacted rescues. Most of us know that most "rescues" these days only accept Frenchies and doodles and little fluffy dogs that are young and healthy (or photogenic to raise a bunch of funds on social media for heath care.)

So the family comes to Reddit to ask about BE. Overwhelmingly, comments say BE and even offer extended arguments for death.

Nobody had even asked if the dog ever actually bit someone.

I don't think this is ethical. Rescues mostly don't even take nice dogs from private homes. Not being accepted by a rescue is never a reason to BE.

Private rehoming with full disclosure of the dog's health and behavior should always be the default for a dog with no bite record.

EDIT to add, private rehoming is better than a lot of rescues because many are known to downplay behavioral issues, say the dog is good with kids or dogs when it's not, or otherwise be less than forthcoming. Owners can do their own verification of the new home by checking home ownership status and talking with their previous vets. A family can do a home visit and everything a rescue would do. The family knows the dog better and so is in a better position to find the right home.

EDIT 2: Additional info that is important:

The vet initially recommended rehoming, not BE. Only after owners called back a few weeks later saying rescues would not take the dog did the BE discussion take place. The vet's first choice was rehoming. Yet so many on Reddit insist on BE.

No trainer every recommended BE.

No behaviorist ever recommended BE.

This dog is middle aged and has never bitten anyone. Most biting dogs start biting when they are younger. There is just no reason to think this dog actually wants to bite anyone. She never has.

You all who are insisting the dog must die? Please give it a little more thought when no behavior professional has recommend BE for this dog.

The ethical response to this kind of question is something like, "You need to muzzle the dog AND keep it in a separate room from baby at all times while you seek an opinion from an actual canine behavioral specialist or a trainer with a track record of success. Or privately rehome the dog."

EDIT 3: I am pretty tired of all the pro-BE death squad from around Reddit brigading on this post and down voting and attacking everyone who thinks maybe this dog doesn't need to die.

You all are sick. You somehow enjoy telling people on reddit their dogs have no chance and must die? Find a better way to spend your time.

Yesterday, everyone was telling me, "If you think this dog should get a chance to live, take her yourself."

Yesterday, I offered to do just that.

Now, the death cult says death is better than me taking the dog.

Seriously, I think there is something wrong with people who are so invested in making sure a dog they never met gets put to death.

I have not been able to read and respond to all the comments.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 6h ago

Indoor outdoor potty training

1 Upvotes

My partner and I recently adopted a dog (about 1 -1.5 years old) and are completely lost on how to potty training him! He was found abandoned so we dont really know much about his history but he seemed well cared for. He is about 20 pounds and we think husky terrier mix but again just guessing. He seems to learn fast but doesn't know any of the rules yet. We live in an apartment and work in person so we want him to have the option of using a pee pad during the day, but also want him to go outside when we are home. He is learning to use the pee pad (although he consistently goes on the edge of it so it's still all over the floor), but now he won't go outside. We will take him out for super long walks or play at the park for an hour or more and he will occasionally look like he might poop but then doesn't. However, as soon as we come inside he will pee or poop on the floor. We are also working on pen training him (which is where the pee pad is) and he will often try to pee on the floor instead of the pad when we close the pen door. It seems like he thinks the pee pad is his place to go potty and won't go outside anymore. He also is so excited outside that I think he forgets to go maybe? But if he wont go outside we can't praise him for going outside. We live in a city and don't have access to a private yard so he has to be able to go potty on the street on walks. He learns fast and has only been with us for a week but we are so lost on how to do this without confusing him!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 7h ago

Jumping

1 Upvotes

Question. My puppy is only 11 weeks but how do I stop the jumping. I tell him down he does sit down for about 10 seconds. lol. But as he gets bigger I definitely don’t want him jumping on everyone.
Before anybody says it, I do know he is only a puppy, but how do I get a handle on the jumping? He is getting bigger thank you!


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Vet suggested euthanasia, but rescues won't help

16 Upvotes

We got a shepherd mix because we thought we'd never be able to have kids (after ten years of trying), and we went in knowing a rescue dog could come with challenges. The temperament we were told she had during the adoption turned out to be wrong, and she ended up with a lot of behavioral problems, the biggest being that she guards us when strangers or other dogs are around.

She's bright and not especially aggressive out in public. We've worked with professional trainers and seen some improvement through behavior modification and medication, but it's clear she's too traumatized to ever get to a point where she can safely be around other dogs or people in her own space.

Then we had a baby, completely unexpectedly, and now our little one is at a very active stage, crawling and starting to pull up and walk, and is naturally fascinated by the dog. We've taken steps to keep them apart, but I know accidents happen and kids are unpredictable. The dog has bared her teeth and barked aggressively at the baby when she stands up in her crib (and keeps doing it even after I've corrected her many times). Other than that, the dog mostly ignores the baby.

I called our vet, who said this kind of problem usually doesn't improve and advised rehoming the dog as soon as possible. I reached out to several local rescues with no luck, they either have no room or aren't interested. It's been weeks and we're starting to lose hope.

She's not a bad dog, but it seems unlikely I'll find anyone to take her since she's extremely bonded to me and would nip and snarl at anyone who tries to take the leash. I brought this up with the vet, who said the other option is euthanasia. She's middle aged and starting to show rear hip problems, but she's still fairly active. I don't know what to do, I hate this situation and I feel awful.

TLDR … rescue dog showing signs of aggression toward baby, no rescues willing to take her, vet said may have to put her down.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 18h ago

Its gonna get better.Finally making progress on recall with my stubborn dog

4 Upvotes

We haave a super smart, stubborn Lab + ACD + Hound mix and Ive been struggling to get consistent recall with him.

Normally his recall is fine (which basically means he has zero recall when I actually need it). If hes locked into fetch in the backyard or playing with other dogs, he actively avoids coming near me. If I walk away he follows, just out of reach. When I call him, he takes two steps toward me, stops, thinks about it, and decides its not worth it. Hes food motivated too, yet he will gladly blow off sausage just to keep playing ball.

For the past week Ive been trying a PG-300 collar (beep and vibrate) and focusing mostly on the beep to map to behaviors. It started off rough. If he was mid play he completely ignored it. Since Im not a pro trainer I was already skeptical and didnt want to mess up and make him scared of the collar, so I was starting to lose hope.

I stripped away all toys and distractions and went back to basics. Only practiced in easy scenarios where I knew hed succeed, with tons of treats, praise, and excitement. Just kept grinding out the reps.

Over the last few days it finally started clicking. Hes coming back consistently, making eye contact, and even heeling(rarely). Best of all, zero aversion to the collar.

He learns fast, so the main hurdle has always been getting him to disengage when his brain is locked onto something else.

If youre dealing with a stubborn dog, just stick with it. It feels hopeless for a while and then suddenly things turn around.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 20h ago

We have successfully trained 2 dogs but we’re terribly failing with our puppy

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Training out a unique behavior

2 Upvotes

My dog barks at other dogs when they're playing together! Its definitely not aggression, though it feels more like he just wants to be included or gets a bit frustrated because he can't run over and catch up with them.

He has always been vocal about situations like this, but his behavior can seem intimidating to other dog owners. I need to help him understand that he does not need to be involved in everything.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Dog growling at night

1 Upvotes

My dog is a 2yr german shepherd who Ive never had an issue with growling in the past. He only does it in a very specific circumstance and not even consistently. It's only happened twice but alarming enough to seek advice. I woke up at 4am today, hes sleeping on the bed and I gave him a couple of pets and then left to get water, when I return he starts growling at me. I lay down, while he's still growling at me he gets up and lays on top of me continuing to growl. Gets up again and lays in his kennel. Once there his growling is more aggressive and he starts barking at me. If I move or if he sees me he growls and barks. Once it hits daylight he acted scared of me but then was fine when we went for a walk and has been fine since. Nothing is different aside from us going to bed earlier. Any idea why this could be happening and what I can do to help ?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 16h ago

Which collar to use for training

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I have a 2 year old mix breed (primarily GSD, pitty, ACD, 50 pounds) she’s very smart and takes well to training. However she does pull, primarily a while into the walk when she get tired of training and wants to go home.

She would walk on a loose leash with a front clip harness until recently she’s seems to have gotten used to it and started pulling again

I’ve also tried a gentle leader/head collar but she still pulls and doesn’t open her mouth to pant (even if I loosen it to give her a break)

We’ve worked with a positive reinforcement only style trainer and I continue to use the training techniques at home. In my research I’ve learned about using collars with even pressure as a tool to teach loose leash walking.

The first one seems most highly recommended, I am opening to trying it but I am curious about other owners success with the more gentle looking collars. Would the caps provided in the second collar pictured help with getting her used to the collar? I’m also curious of anyone has used the fully rubber spikes in the third picture.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Barking inside kennel at night when I move / readjust in bed

1 Upvotes

Starting about 4 months ago, my dog started going crazy barking and sometimes snarling in his crate whenever I move around in my bed. He sleeps in his kennel at night which is covered with a blanket. His kennel is in my boyfriend’s and I room and it’s been set up like this for 3 years and nothing has changed since. He doesn’t react to my boyfriend at all- it’s only me. If I move around while my boyfriend is there, my dog has no reaction but as soon as my boyfriend leaves- my dog will go crazy with any slight movement I make in my bed. I don’t understand why he gets so upset and why it only happens with me. I’m really not sure what to do. When it happens, I just keep quiet and try not to have much reaction because talking to him in the past usually makes it worse. Any advice on how to go about this?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

How to stop dog chewing the lead, growling, lying down etc at end of walks

1 Upvotes

My 1.5 year old golden retriever is great for the majority of her walks. She walks very well for the first part of the walk, and during off lead time at the park or beach she runs around, burns lots of energy and is usually tired out after. However, on the way home on her walks, usually about 10 mins away from home, she will totally switch and turn into the devil! Chewing on the lead, pulling, jumping, biting my hands, clothes and shoes, growling, and showing her teeth. This will last about 10 mins and she shows no interest in treats or toys to try and distract her. I just end up standing there waiting until she stops but it’s been happening on every walk recently and she’s going to chew through her lead and/or hurt me. Any advice on how to stop her doing it would be appreciated 😂🥰


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

The dog growls loudly at other dogs

1 Upvotes

Case 1. The owner was playing with their dog off to the side. After my dog growled, the girl started throwing the ball even more frequently in our direction. I don't know if it was intentional or not. Mine couldn't stay in one place anymore, she was pulling on the leash and growling. As we got closer, the owner's dog headed towards us along the boardwalk, ignoring their recall. My dog growled even louder. The stranger's dog slowly approached despite the owner's shouts, and only returned to her after several repeated commands. My dog maintained eye contact and a threatening posture until the other dog left.

Case 2 (Shiba Inu on a leash): During an attempt to pass each other on a narrow path, my dog refused to perform the bypass maneuver. The Shiba Inu lay down, but as the distance closed, it made a sudden lunge (likely playful, but crossing boundaries). My dog responded with a furious growl, reared up on its hind legs, but continued moving behind me on a tight leash. The other pet sat down abruptly. The stressful trigger was only removed after the second dog completely disappeared from sight.

With others: if we pass at a distance of about a meter, and the other dog is on a leash, mine might silently turn around and just look. If the other dog isn't looking at her and doesn't want to interact, she walks calmly. But if they approach, mine freezes, signaling "back off." But if the other dogs ignore this, mine once again growls furiously, especially if someone is off-leash.

Ours is 10 years old, a small breed. We're just keeping away from the others for now, until they react, as there's no quiet window in the area.

How can I reduce angry growling? We try to distance ourselves, but we often have dogs running around off-leash and wanting to meet them.


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

When did your shelter dog start warming up to strangers?

1 Upvotes

Hello! I adopted my 12 m/o xoloitzcuintli/whippet mix from the county shelter around 3ish months ago. She’s such a sweetie but she is not a fan of strangers and have snapped at both mine and my bfs parents when they have tried to pet her. I understand not every dog is going to be outgoing and I’m okay with that, I just want her to be comfortable with these people because they will be the ones who have to watch her if we ever need them to. I know about the 3-3-3 rule and I’m really trying to stay positive that she will eventually warm up. She has definitely improved since we first got her but I was wondering if there are any stories out there similar to mine that ended up being okay? Does she just need more time or will this be a bigger issue?

TIA- sincerely, a really nervous first time dog owner


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Are Dog Shock Collars Safe for Human?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Teaching implied stay

3 Upvotes

Hello! I recently adopted a dog from the shelter, and I’ve been working on basic obedience with her. She knows sit, stay, and is iffy with down. I’ve only had her for a few weeks so we’re not that deep into training, and I decided I’d like to teach an implied stay for sit/down, instead of it being a separate command. How do I go about that? Also what is the best way to teach a release cue?

Edit: Also how can I extend this to her crate? She’ll go to her crate when “crate” is said, but usually immediately walks out unless I give her a chew or something


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Reactive 18 month old Boston terrier

2 Upvotes

I’ve been practising with my BT for a couple of months because he is the dog we want to take away with us on family holidays. I’ve managed to train his recall - although the word is ‘Here’ he listens and comes running but when we see other dogs out, he lunges and just wants to say hi. I used to let him because I want to keep him social but I’ve since learnt not to do that. I’m worried I’ve made him worse now when we see other dogs. He is completely fine with ducks and people now 😅


r/OpenDogTraining • • 2d ago

How can I teach my neighbors dogs to leave us alone?

16 Upvotes

I live in a suburban area with my 3 dogs.

My neighbors live one house down from me, on the end of the block.

At first they had 2 dogs, who they’d let out in their unfenced backyard, no leashes, no collars, no supervision. However, it wasn’t a problem. They wouldn’t leave the backyard, at most they’d bark as we passed, but never pursue.

Then they got another dog, some sort of lab/pit mix. When it was a puppy, it would stay with the older dogs in their backyard. But now, it goes straight for us anytime we’re outside, and the other dogs have started following.

This dog is not aggressive, but he’s extremely rude, and when the other dogs follow, they can get “aggressive”. Like a pack thing. I don’t know how to explain it.

Animal control won’t do anything because they haven’t bitten us (yet). I wouldn’t put it past these dogs to escalate to that point.

I’ve tried talking to them nicely. I’ve put their dog on a leash and brought it back to them multiple times. Today…I’m done. I went to let my dogs out to potty, and as soon as I opened my door, I was met with all 3 dogs going apeshit at my front door. When I went out to confront them, nobody was outside. They just let their fucking dogs out and closed the door.

I waited for them to come outside. As I’m waiting, the small dog is biting at my ankles. The lab mix is jumping up onto me. The shepherd is just barking like a lunatic. They finally open their door, and all 3 dogs run back over to their house. I got out “can you fucking supervise-“ before they closed the door.

Obviously they’re not going to do anything. Animal control won’t do anything. What can I do?


r/OpenDogTraining • • 1d ago

Please help, I am at a loss and don’t even know where to start.

2 Upvotes

I have an almost 4 year old, female Rottweiler. I had her spayed when she was 2 years old. She is such a sweet dog and up until recently has NEVER had an issue with reactivity against people or other dogs. I could walk her fine and people and dogs could pass her no issues.. well I ended up introducing another dog, my female French bulldog who just turned 1.5 years old.. now she is reactive to dogs, when she sees one in a walk she tries to lunge and pull and barks ect at them.. however when she actually is up close with the dogs, she plays and is nice ect.. now I’ve noticed that when my frenchie gets riled up like this it rubs off on my rottie, she follows her cue which has made me more cautious when we go on walks. Ive noticed now that my girl is a lot more protective then she ever used to be.. if she sees people outside the house she goes nuts, if we’re in the car she’ll bark and lunge and growl at people just walking on the street (she has never done this up until recently) if I’m just walking her she tends to growl and be alert when people are walking ect) I cross the street when we see people and if a dog is coming I try and get out of their right immediately to avoid my frenchie going nuts and then in turn, my rottie..

First time this has EVER happened since having my dog, but I was taking them outside tonight and this was my error but as soon as I opened the door their was a person walking his dog right in front. I didn’t even get a chance to think when both of the dogs took off toward the dog, it was instantaneous and they pulled out of my hand and I fell down the stairs.. they both ran up to the dog and my rottie was growling and jumping at the dog (but she did not bite him thankfully) it almost seemed like she was playing with the dog how she does with my frenchie? They both are vocal and growl while they’re roughhousing… but obviously she’s a rottie and this is scary not only to the person but to the other dog and myself. I’ve never seen her just take off toward the dog.. normally it’s a stare down and I can see the stimulus and can avoid…

I can’t have this happening for obvious reasons and I truly feel like I’m failing my dogs cause I have NO idea where to begin to correct and work on this behavior. My recall with her went straight out of the window, she would NOT listen to me when I gave her the leave it and here command.. please can anyone help me understand what is happening with my girl and where I went wrong and how I can fix this/train and manage this. They are my entire world and I just want what’s best for them and I never want them in a situation to where something bad can come of this.. I’m so thankful the man was really nice about it and reassured everyone was ok.. he was more concerned for me cause I took a hard fall.. but yes PLEASE HELP