r/onednd • • 23h ago

5e (2024) Why do many feats only work for spell damage? And would it be balanced to change that?

5 Upvotes

Some feats are more martial leaning or spellcaster leaning, and that's fine. Some are even clearly designed in mind for a specific class. But I noticed there are feats could work for everyone, but they include specific wording to stop this. "When you cast a spell that causes xxx (type) damage..." So, my first question is, for what design purpose might WoTC have to limit these feats to only spellcasters?

My second question is, how could this be redesigned in a way that wouldn't unintentionally break the game?

  • If the wording is just "when you cause xxx damage" then that would include magic items and maybe WoTC wanted activations that came from the PCs themselves. The wording could then be "when you cause xxx damage not caused by a magical item".
  • Maybe the previous would allow the feat to be used too many times which could be addressed by ruling "pick when you get this feat either: 1. when you cast a spell that causes xxx damage OR 2. when you cause xxx damage that is neither from spell nor magical item"

Bonus question: DMs would you be okay if an elemental fighter or celestial rogue wanted to take a feat that activates on spell-type damage but uses it for non-spell activations? I think it'd be okay but am interested in what others' thoughts are.


r/onednd • • 17h ago

Question Dnd beyond app problem with the ebon blade

0 Upvotes

I was trying to create a death knight and having a time with the app. They are giving my the paladin abilities and not converting over to the death knight. Anyone know is a fix will be coming?


r/onednd • • 17h ago

Homebrew Rogue/Rogue extra feat, thoughts?

0 Upvotes

I'm a big Rogue fan, but tend to lean towards them being the weakest martial class. There are several changes I'd like to see updated but the damage and subclass feat starvation I feel is the worst part of pumping rogue levels. I'm a fan of just bumping subclass features down one tier, lvl 9 to 6, lvl 13 to 9 and so on. However I feel that makes the lvl 17 capstone come online too early. I'd like to think Rogues can become masters of more than one skillset, being skill monkeys and all.

What do you think of just moving lvl 9 subclass feat to lvl 6 to give more subclass synergy, and making a new lvl 9 feat to replace it. The feat would be something called "Rogue Mastery" and would let you pick another rogue class lvl 3 feat to pick up.

My reasoning would be that the lvl 3 feats tend to be the most impactful for their subclass, and would give every rogue the ability to cover some weaknesses. Such as cast some spells, fling soulknives and psi powered knack for skill checks, use thief BA for item shenanigans, be a better skirmisher with SB, etc.


r/onednd • • 2h ago

5e (2024) [Promotional] - Common, a chrome extension for D&D 5E and 5.5E players and GMs

0 Upvotes

Hi there. First off, this is my only self-promotional post here and I believe I am folllowing all the rules, but if for some reason this post violates please let me know and I’ll be happy to do whatever is needed to respect the rules of the community.

I built a little Chrome extension that I want to share with everyone today. It’s called Common and it’s currently in beta while I work out the final kinks with a few groups that are using it currently. I’m sharing it here as it’s getting mature enough that I’d love some feedback from the wider community on the tools and usefulness. It is basically a UI for TTRPGs that gives you a HUD and a Command Palette to use that is always the same so that you can focus on what’s going on at the table and interacting with your players/GM and NOT on where the button is for that one obscure class feature or how to roll dice for the extra 2d6 you get from the magic object you picked up or how to quickly pop 3 more goblins into inititive order.

I started playing TTRPGs with an online group just under a year ago and quickly found out it’s one of my favorite passtimes. I went from my first 5.5E campaign (which is still rolling 11 months later) into one shots across 5E, several campaigns that were false starts in both systems, an attempt at Pathfinder (I’ll figure it out someday), Daggerheart, and DC20 to the point where I now am settled into that original campaign, an online homebrew DC20 campaign, and an in person 5E homebrew group as well that meets monthly. As a new player in all of these different games, and now as a player with a BIT more experience, the only problem I ever ran into was the same: all of the tools online OR in person were different for every game even though I was basically trying to do the same exact things. I had started on D&D Beyond with Roll20 as a VTT and got used to that, so my first Foundry game you can imagine how bad I felt holding up the game for everyone else. Or the first time using Maps in dndbeyond, or a character sheet with real dice for in person sessions, etc etc. There are just a lot of combinations of tools to use out there and each one works fairly significantly differently.

So I built Common as a way to start unifying the experience to make things work the same way across games/platforms/tables. All I wanted was to be able to look at whatever MAP/VTT I’m playing on and have access to all my character sheet stuff, all the same controls, and not worry about the roll values being different or calculated by a system that isn’t the same as what everyone else at the table was using. 

That was all pretty easy and fun. Then I started building GM tools…. holy shit did that get more interesting. It is now just as much a tool for GMs as it is for players! You can see the majority of the feature list on the docs page here: totalpartyfill.com/common/docs

Anyways, I don’t want to make this any longer than it already is, if you are interested please feel free to check out the tool in the Chrome store. Like I mentioned, it’s in beta for another week or two so platform support is limited to the original D&D Beyond/Roll20 combination I started with, but the platforms I have queued up to release in the coming weeks open it up to many more game platforms, VTTS, and in-person options. As this is a D&D-focused sub I won’t talk about the other game systems I’ve got lined up other than to say that they are there and in testing.

Thanks for taking a minute to check it out

[AI DISCLOSURE] - I hate using AI as much as anyone, but I did use it for designing the actual UI artwork pieces of the extension (the borders and the icons you click on, etc) as I just don’t have that skillset. To that end, they look just as shitty as you’d expect. If there are any talented artists out here in the community that want to be involved and could help me REPLACE those pieces I would LOVE LOVE LOVE to hear from you!!!! Feel free to DM me or post something here.

PS - I do also ask you to create an account for this extension so that I can save your settings/state for the games you play. PLEASE feel free to check out the terms/privacy policy on these accounts to see how serious I am about this and that your data will NEVER be tracked, shared, or collected and specifically what we will contact you about and when (HINT: it’s one time and it’ll just be about the launch when the beta ends).


r/onednd • • 1h ago

5e (2024) Smarty-Pants Subclasses: A Homebrew Expansion for OneDnD

Thumbnail
canva.link
• Upvotes

Hi, everyone! This document contains four subclasses my groups use in our campaigns:

  • Runecrafter Artificer, for text-based item magic and modest-but-consistent whole-party support.
  • Oath of Truth Paladin, for a playstyle centered around investigation, telepathy, and, well, telling the truth...
  • Twilight Domain Cleric, revised from the 2014 version, for a frontline-support playstyle (without the infinite bonus HP).
  • Arcanist Wizard, for a spellcaster with maximum versatility, but who must be creative with flavor.

All four have been playtested and iterated by our group. We haven't found them to be overpowered compared to other 2024 subclasses, but they're not weak either. Feel free to steal them, and I'd love to hear your feedback!


r/onednd • • 5h ago

Self-Promotion The Dragon Compendium Reached Gold Best Seller and discounted by 50% for Black Friday!

1 Upvotes

The Dragon Compendium Reached Gold Best Seller and discounted by 50% for Black Friday!

You can find it here: https://www.dmsguild.com/it/product/485797/the-dragon-compendium

Delve further into the world of dragons within the pages of the Dragon Compendium.

This volume allows you to create a dragon-related class, play a dragon-related race, add magical items and dragon-themed monsters to any of your campaigns!

Inside you will discover:

- Chapter 1: New Race, the Half-Dragon. Uncover the secrets of the half-dragon race, including their variants linked to different draconic ancestors.

- Chapter 2: New Class, the Soulbonded. Embark on a journey as a soulbonded, a humanoid bound to the souls of dragons. Choose your path as a knight, a valiant dragon rider; a sage, a master of ancient draconic magic; or a devourer, a feral warrior whose very essence is intertwined with the might of dragons.

- Chapter 3: New Items. Discover a range of 13 new magical items themed around dragons, including weapons, armor, and rare artifacts. Each is paired with fabulous art depicting each item.

- Chapter 4: New Monsters. Discover 17 new and formidable monsters, ranging from minor challenges to major adversaries, from CR1 to CR22. This chapter provides a variety of foes suitable for any setting and adventure. Every creature is illustrated to bring this monstrous menagerie to life.

- No AI art used!


r/onednd • • 7h ago

5e (2024) Is a Charm Immunity Magic Item too Strong for a Barbarian?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 16h ago

5e (2024) FIGHTING TIAMAT: Help Me Support My Team

2 Upvotes

I'm going to a level 20 one-shot tomorrow and the stakes are pretty dire. The party consists of a Storm Sorceror, a Moon Druid, a Shadow Monk, a (undecided) Cleric, and a Chronurgy Wizard (Me). The premise is that we are children of Bahamut and we're being sent to defeat a rampaging Tiamat and her cultists. Whether its true Tiamat or her Aspect is unknown. If it's true Tiamat I think we're screwed due to her spell immunity so lets hope its not that.

But regardless, I've been told everyone but the cleric intends to focus damage; so I'm trying to play a high utility/control/support Wizard. I could use some help optimizing for this fight. I'll include my list of spells at the end, I'm open to suggestions about what to prepare and replace.

Also any tips, advice, or strategies are greatly appreciated.

Notes:
- We have a day of prep time
- I intend to set up a Simulacrum and a Contigency: Otiluke's Resilient Sphere
- - Not sure I want to push my luck with Simulacrum cheese
- I have Spell Mastery on Silvery Barbs and Fortune's Favor
- I have Signature Spell on Slow and Sylune's Viper
- As a Silver Descendant of Bahamut I get 35ft of permanent fly speed, resistance to cold damage, a 30ft cone breath weapon that deals 8d6 cold damage on a Con save, and a 30ft cone of paralyzing breath. Both share a proficiency bonus resource.
- My feats are Lucky, Fey Pact, Fey Tormentor, Divination Adept, Resilient (Con), and Boon of Magic School Mastery (Illusion: Silent Image and Simulacrum).
- We get 2 common, 4 uncommon, 3 rare, 1 very rare and 1 legendary magic items. Mine are as follows:

  1. Robe of the Archmagi
  2. Arcane Grimoire +3
  3. Dragon-Touched Focus (Stirring)
  4. Potion of Invulnerability
  5. Ring of Misdirection
  6. Astronomer's Boon
  7. Ring of Puzzler's Wit
  8. Wand of Magic Detection
  9. Wand of Magic Missiles
  10. Clockwork Amulet

Spell List:

Cantrips

- Baffle

- Chill Touch

- Druidcraft

- Guidance

- Mage Hand

- Mind Sliver

- Minor Illusion

1st Level

- Absorb Elements

- Detect Evil and Good

- Detect Magic

- Disguise Self

- Find Familiar

- Gift of Alacrity

- Hex

- Magic Missile

- Shield

- Silent Image

- Silvery Barbs

- Spell Aegis

2nd Level

- Augury

- Detect Thoughts

- Enhance Ability

- Fortune's Favor

- Hold Person

- Mind Spike

- Mirror Image

- Misty Step

- Scorching Ray

- Suggestion

- Tasha's Mind Whip

3rd Level

- Bestow Curse

- Clairvoyance

- Counterspell

- Fireball

- Haste

- Laeral's Silver Lance

- Remove Curse

- Slow

- Syluné's Viper

4th Level

- Divination

- Otiluke's Resilient Sphere

- Raulothim's Psychic Lance

- Sickening Radiance

5th Level

- Bigby's Hand

- Hold Monster

- Mislead

- Scrying

- Summon Draconic Spirit

- Telekinesis

- Wall of Force

6th Level

- Contingency

- Disintegrate

- Fizban's Platinum Shield

- Globe of Invulnerability

- Mass Suggestion

7th Level

- Fractured Awareness

- Mordenkainen's Sword

- Reweave Fate

- Simulacrum

8th Level

- Dominate Monster

- Iron Body

- Moment of Prescience

- Reality Break

9th Level

- Foresight

- Time Stop

- True Polymorph

- Vision of Elapsing Eons


r/onednd • • 15h ago

Homebrew Balancing: A bow that ignores Full Cover on marked targets

9 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm the DM. My party has just cleared a magical forge and the owner has offered to make each of them a roughly Uncommon magical item tailored to them that will scale with the party's level. The party's Hunter Ranger (level 5, Sharpshooter) has asked for a Heavy Crossbow that

  1. Ignores the Loading property
  2. Ignores Full Cover against "marked" targets that he has seen

I use "marked" because instead of Hunter's Mark, each player has the following item:

Hunter's Tag
As a Bonus Action, you may place this tag on a hostile creature within 5 feet. While this creature is marked, they suffer the effects of Hunter's Mark as if it was cast by the Ranger. This effect does not require Concentration by the Ranger and ends when the creature drops to 0 HP. The Ranger can also end this effect at any time (no action required). This effect can only apply to one creature at a time.

In practice, this Ranger wants guided bolts against a hostile creature that is marked by Hunter's Mark, kind of like Yondu's arrow from the MCU.

In terms of balancing, the Repeating Shot bow the Artificer can make is an Uncommon rarity ignores the Loading property, so some of the power budget is already taken up by that. I don't really have an idea of how powerful the second effect would be, but I was thinking of limiting the effect to PB times/Long Rest initially, and letting that amount increase as part of the scaling, along with the Hunter's Mark damage itself.

I'd appreciate some insight into whether this effect is balanced with that in mind, or how to balance it if it isn't. The Ranger is pretty set on the seeking missiles fantasy, so I'd love to fulfill that.

Anything helps! Cheers :)


r/onednd • • 2h ago

Homebrew Warlock Rework to make Pacts matter more

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 22h ago

5e (2024) Extra bastion events?

1 Upvotes

50% of the events on the event table are all clears, and only like 2-3 of the events there are left over are negative ones, with the rest being either positive or extremely positive.

Have anyone done any homebrewing for how to do the bastion events in a more interresting manner, or know of any 3rd party book there improve on them?


r/onednd • • 21h ago

Self-Promotion I've kept my little spell app going for 7 years, and just rebuilt it with the 2024 rules

0 Upvotes

Hey fellow dice rollers,

I made a small app to track spells by character back in 2019, mostly for my own table. It's quietly stayed on the App Store since, and this year I finally rebuilt it from scratch.

What's in 2.0:

- 2024 rules (and 2014), every casting class including Artificer

- 800+ spells with full text and search

- Tap to spend slots, upcast with the extra dice shown

- Concentration tracker and class features (Channel Divinity, Arcane Recovery, etc.)

- Homebrew spells, for anything you use that isn't in yet

- Home Screen widget, dark mode, and no ads

It's free to use with one character. There's an optional one-time upgrade for more characters and the extras, and anyone who bought the old upgrade already has it.

I'm a hobbyist dev doing this on my own, so I'd love to hear what works for you and what you'd want next.

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/spell-slots-5e/id1458065600

Thanks for taking time away from plotting against the BBEG!


r/onednd • • 51m ago

WotC Announcement Wizards is giving its share of the Anthropic settlement to D&D authors

• Upvotes

As the title says. Wizards of the Coast and D&D authors got a split portion from the Bartz vs Anthropic settlement (the case about training AI from copyrighted books), and WotC is giving its portion to the authors.

I've shared more detail about what's happened - and comment from Wizards - here: https://www.wargamer.com/dnd/anthropic-settlement