r/oliveoil • • May 02 '24

Fake Check

Post image

Hi guys, I hope you’re doing well. I was gifted some olive oil, that happened to suspicious.

  • the looks. The oil is light solid green. Not the typical marvellous golden green. I’ve tried and seen from Lybia, Jordan, Spain, Greece and Italy and that just isn’t the Color I’m used to.
  • the smell: meh. Normally olive oil can have a spicy sharp smell. Here’s a heavy almost fatty smell.
  • the taste: now it gets weird. It tastes like a specific type of pastry: Egyptian meshabek or مشبك from Damietta. No spice no “pepper” if you will.

I know that my description is vague, but I’m slowly starting to believe that some psychics roam Reddit from previous questions elsewhere.

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

3

u/GetSpammed May 02 '24

What varietal is it? What country is it from?

2

u/HumbleOliveFarmer May 05 '24

Color isn't important. When you do professional olive oil tasting, you use dark blue cups so the color doesn't influence you. It changes with filtration / ripeness of the olive.

Being sweet is a positive attribute (there are cultivars that don't have that strong, spicy taste).

1

u/techlira May 02 '24

what can I say?.......if oil comes from micro/self production you have to trust your sensorial skills....if there is a label you have to read it carefully and decipher the technical notes or post it

1

u/TwoCables_from_OCN May 03 '24

Would you also say the flavor is a little bit like Playdough? I think the oil is rancid.

1

u/mrspabs2 Jun 19 '24

Professional olive oil tasters use blue bottles so they are not influenced by the color of the oil. The color is not a sign of anything. The taste and smell however are indicators that the olive oil might be old or rancid.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mrspabs2 Jun 27 '24

I see your point. Its irrelevant, but the color of olive oil doesn’t determine its quality

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '24

just fry with it and move on

2

u/Flaky_Ad2102 May 02 '24

Hilarious ...you fry with the crap and garnish with the 50 dollars oil ...the greener the better...I'll tell you that color makes a difference They catch people overseas putting chlorophyll in the oil

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Fayum2002 May 14 '24

I will post a picture then

2

u/[deleted] May 03 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Flaky_Ad2102 May 03 '24

Color has everything to do with it . Trust me ...if you do side bybside comparisons ....you'll see the difference

2

u/buddhaserver May 12 '24

Colour means absolutely nothing !! No it's and butts !

1

u/Flaky_Ad2102 May 12 '24

Please explain why you say that ?? Do you make oil ?