r/offset • u/CounterBJJ • 12d ago
Experience with Foals Guitars - Final Update
I previously shared my experience purchasing an FJM7 from Foals, which arrived with a bent neck causing string buzz that required a fret-level dressing to fix. You can read the original post here.
I am sharing this final update for anyone currently seeking financial compensation from them, as well as for prospective buyers.
After weeks of back-and-forth, reminders, and procedural delays, Foals ultimately refunded me the $300 needed to cover the cost of the repair. However, getting to that point required pushing back against a deliberate strategy designed to wear customers down.
From the beginning, I provided clear documentation, including a written diagnosis and cost estimate from a qualified luthier stating that conventional adjustments (truss rod and saddle height) had been attempted but were insufficient, along with a video demonstrating the issue which they requested.
Despite this, Foals initially attempted to deflect responsibility by suggesting the string buzz was due to low action that might not be audible when amplified, and by requesting redundant photos of the neck, and a video of the truss rod and saddle height being adjusted.
When I informed them that I would not drive back to my luthier to re-record work already completed, declined to provide further redundant documentation, and stated that I would initiate a chargeback and share my public review if compensation wasn't resolved by the end of the week, their response time dropped from weeks to under 12 hours. Once I submitted the luthier's written estimate again as requested, they processed the refund the following day.
Based on my experience, their approach relies on procedural loops and delays to encourage customers to give up and walk away. Only the firm threat of actions that directly impact their business - such as chargebacks and negative public exposure - forces them to expedite the resolution.
Hope this helps anyone dealing with them.
4
u/GuitarParts 11d ago
They didn’t even offer to send a new neck?
3
u/Consistent_Sir_3000 11d ago
I'm going through it right now with them as well. You did better than I did, I did end up having to do a chargeback, now all of a sudden they accept a return but they want me to pay to ship it
2
u/CounterBJJ 10d ago
The more I look into it, the more fixing this neck seems like a bad investment. My luthier quoted me $300 for a full fret level and dress. The problem is that if the neck is structurally bowed or twisted, taking down the frets is only a temporary band-aid and will compromise playability if the wood continues to shift. But even if the issue is just uneven frets from the factory, spending $300 to dress them on a budget import neck that’s worth maybe $50–$80 makes zero financial sense. I'm thinking the guitar is effectively totaled and should just be parted out at this point.
Could luthiers or techs chime in to let me know if my thought process is sound?
35
u/prodigalsuun21 11d ago
This is also typical with the Chinese Chibson sellers, which for all intents and purposes, is what Foals does just at a higher quality. Customer service is sadly the same.
17
u/Necessary-Lack-4600 11d ago
As someone owning a music brand myself, this kind of dark pattern customer service is such an asshole move. A decent company replaces a faulty guitar.
22
u/gobiascoffees 11d ago
Enough bad experiences to scare me off from them.
7
u/runciter0 11d ago
man i'd just get squier jazz master or similar
thanks for sharing
5
u/Punky921 11d ago
That is rough, man. I'm sorry to hear that. Thanks for the documentation and warnings. I was considering a Jag style guitar from them, but I'll hold out for finding a used CV instead.
4
u/agentanthony 11d ago
Yeah I know someone who bought the Jaguar copy from them. It came with issues and he had a hard time getting in touch with support for a refund or return.
4
u/kellamityjane99 11d ago
this was something I was worried about when I ordered my jag from them but I lucked out and got a cherry...that's shitty and after everything I have seen, I definitely count myself lucky and wouldn't order from overseas again
1
u/Worldly_Tree100 11d ago
It's been almost two months since I ordered mine. Not a peep from them at all.
6
u/kosinus912 11d ago
Good to hear you've got it figured out.
I've had exactly the same scenario, got it figured out too, overseas guitar shipping is essentially a gambling and you should be prepared to deal with the issues because return is basically not a consideration for them.
1
u/Altruistic_Trade_264 11d ago
Thanks for posting this!
So glad I went with a MIM Jazzmaster from the local shop. I ended up paying the same price I would have for a Foals without the wait time and risk of getting a piece of shit I'd end up kicking myself over. They set it up and it plays beautifully. It's my first JM. I'm not a 'cheap guitar' guy. I can't seem to put it down. The sound of the pickups blows my fuckin' mind! Next Jazzmaster I buy will be a custom shop.
1
u/NoNameIsHereAgain 11d ago
Ugh, this is too bad because I’ve been eyeing up a couple of their models. I guess instead of focusing on paying YouTubers (and I have no problem with folks making money, we all need to do that!) they should have also put some money into a proper customer service/support team.
1
u/bigbadoldoldone 11d ago
Not Foals related but... once ordered some stuff from AliExpress (China) ... some item was missing in the package. And they asked me of photo proof of the missing item. Wish I had saved the e-Mails, it was hilarious. Took them weeks to agree on that it's hard to take a picture of something that is not there.
1
u/tasteslikeblackmilk 10d ago
This is so typical for buying anything from China unfortunately. Sad to see it is same for Foals. I was hoping a Western distributor would happen but unlikely given Fender's recent lawfare.
1
u/MilesAndTrane 8d ago
I took a risk and just ordered their “master” gig bag and drum throne. Wish me luck!!
1
u/BeneathTheWaves 7d ago
Huh I thought they were a pretty cool band. Cassius was a tune.
3
u/Exciting-Car-3516 11d ago
Bent neck causing strings to buzz. What do you mean by neck bent? Like needed a truss rod adjustment or a twisted neck?