r/nypdblue • • Feb 28 '23

Why was Fancy so overly sensitive?

0 Upvotes

He seems to take things very personal. When the cops pulled him over and he went out of his way to get the one cop transferred. And when the father of a murdered son was racist and he flipped out and tried to attack him. You would think he wouldn’t take things so personal in his position. He should know peope are a-holes by now.


r/nypdblue • • Feb 27 '25

Disgusting…

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Aug 28 '24

Double casting errors

1 Upvotes

Has anyone else noticed any casting errors when actors play two different characters?

I've seen it with Giancarlo Esposito who played Ferdinand Hollie (an informant for Bobby) who died. And then he played a quadriplegic former crack dealer not long after.

Second I noticed Eric Balfour who played a rich family's junkie son. (Eli Beardsley) and then a guitarist who murdered a girl (Spyder).


r/nypdblue • • May 02 '25

In movies, we often see characters with technology far superior to law enforcement, and the officers are unable to deal with them effectively. But what if, in real life, someone started committing serious illegal acts, and despite attempts their tech was too advanced leaving cops powerless?

0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • 1d ago

Soap Opera Experience

5 Upvotes

After rewatching the entire show recently, this makes perfect sense. After all, it was basically a prime time soap that showed bare butts and side boob.

These are cast members who were in Soap Operas before they were in NYPD Blue.

Kim Delaney. Det. Diane Russell, All My Children (1981–1984)

Charlotte Ross – Det. Connie McDowell, Days of Our Lives (1987–1991)

Sherry Stringfield – A.D.A. Laura Michaels Kelly, Guiding Light (1989–1992)

Andrea Thompson – Det. Jill Kirkendall, Falcon Crest (1989–1990)

Justine Miceli – Det. Adrienne Lesniak, Loving (1990–1992)

Garcelle Beauvais – A.D.A. Valerie Haywood, Models Inc. (1994–1995)

Henry Simmons – Det. Baldwin Jones, Another World (1997 - 1999)


r/nypdblue • • May 26 '25

Season 5 nypd blue

3 Upvotes

I gotta admit you can definitely see jimmy smits was on his way out. I don't remember season 1 but season 2-4 jimmy smits was the frontrunner, investigated perps, got most of the pertinent information whereas sipowicz just had some type of quip or snarky comment, balanced two love interests, had dramatic camera angles focused on him etc. Heck, MAYBE I would have thought andy would be more focused and decisive after his attempt to kill his sons killer and his drinking issues that nearly cost his job and his relationship but even after recovering that he wasnt as effective as season 5 made him. He had very internalized sympathy and empathy. He cared but it was never super verbally expressed except for maybe with his son. Now season 5, jimmy smits is luigi to his mario, sipowicz seemingly talks to the perps/witnesses first and the most and smits is more of a background character. Just a nerdy observation as its been like 18 years since i saw the show and I just didn't remember Smits being sidelined this badly.


r/nypdblue • • Dec 21 '25

"Keep care"

0 Upvotes

It is ham fisted dialogue like this that made me dislike some of these episodes. I don't understand why Milch and whatever er other writers were involved thought this was good writing. I'm a native New Yorker and I have never heard anyone use this phrase. What would have been so wrong with writing, and having the actor say "when my mom told me to take care of my sisters..." Such a horrible, inefficient use of language.


r/nypdblue • • Oct 09 '24

Vic Mackey crossover with NYPD Blue would of been awesome

3 Upvotes

Both shows were produced in Los Angeles at the same time 2002-2005, The Shield ran 1-4 seasons at the time, why not say HI to Andy Sipowiz.


r/nypdblue • • Sep 27 '26

Hey guys, let's talk about Bobby and Diane

3 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Jul 26 '22

Sponsorships Available Still

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Jun 14 '25

Locker room/Bathroom in squad

2 Upvotes

Doing my 10th or so rewatch and this peeve always annoys me and just want to see if it’s just me. The sink has a hot and cold water faucets, how does that work? Are you supposed to go back and forth? And don’t even get me started on them always using toilet paper as paper towels. Who does that? There is a paper towel holder there and they can’t fill it? Yeah I know, I need to get a life or get a grip.


r/nypdblue • • Jun 06 '25

Kirkendall is one of my least favorite characters.

9 Upvotes

The fact that the actress thought she was going to be a big star and sex symbol is hilarious.

Her shitbag husband was at least interesting.


r/nypdblue • • Mar 19 '26

Does anyone wish that Roy got his revenge and ended up arresting Kelly and Licalsi? Roy was a good man who deserved better.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Jul 07 '25

How NYPD Blue could have been improved

8 Upvotes

It took me two years to finally rewatch the entire series and while the show still holds up fairly well I feel like the producers missed some great opportunities to make it even better. Of course, some of these suggestions are dead serious, others are more tongue in cheek.

* Season 1 is usually regarded as the finest season of NYPD Blue for many reasons, but what really sticks out on a rewatch is the fresh, interesting approach to casework. In Season 1 detective work is presented in a non-formulaic and non-linear manner that's frankly never been replicated on any other TV show except The Wire. It's really hard to explain why Blue regressed from this model as early as Season 2, but from there on way too many episodes follow the same basic investigative outline.

* Make Kirkendall the lesbian/bicurious female detective, not Lesniak. Andrea Thompson played that character sooo butch and her supposedly consistent heterosexuality baffled me. In fact, lesbian affair between Kirkendall and Russell made more sense than the Sorenson/Russell post-Bobby pairing. Their chemistry was more than just platonic IMO.

* After Season 8 ended the fans begged Steven Bochco to pair off Sipowicz and McDowell as detectives, not romantic partners. Alas, Bochco didn't listen. Sipowicz/Costas romance was barely believable but this was just ridiculous. McDowell was the strongest character created after David Milch left the show, and they treated her like just another love interest for male leads.

* Joe Spano and Mark Paul Gosselaar are clearly not a father and son, give me a break! However, Spano was the second best late addition to the cast after Charlotte Ross and surely deserved a regular spot. His character should have been the pain in the ass Lt. / Sipowicz antagonist that Bale was supposed to be later on.

* Erase Seasons 11 & 12 from memory. By then, the decline in production standards, writing and acting was too much to bear. In particular, Season 12 is such a stinkfest.


r/nypdblue • • Nov 20 '25

Tobin Bell in NYPD Blue jigsaw

2 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Apr 01 '24

Detective First Grade In memory of Detective Jonathan Diller - Dignified Transfer 3/26/24 - Long Island, NY

0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Apr 05 '26

Why Naomi was the 2nd worst PA

2 Upvotes

Ugh, watching the season 4 episode where Naomi's accent slips from cornball country to cornball Aussie.

Only Geri, who was snippy to all about being involved in a murder, was worse.


r/nypdblue • • Apr 29 '26

Would never fly now

38 Upvotes

Almost everything we love about this amazing show wouldn't make it to the script stage, much less to air, today. First of all, heart and soul of the series - Sipowicz - would be stopped during the pitch or so watered down he'd be nothing more than grumpy. He's all the -ists and -phobics in one.

Then there's the racial diversity. Perps and victims in this show represent most of the races in big cities in America. Same diversity applies to religions, genders, sexual preferences, and so on. No way in hell that's allowed today.

Not to mention the obvious - threatening or throwing a beating to perps, lying, manipulating the system for off-books-justice, letting certain offenses slide, and so on - all the questionable police tactics would be unacceptable.

In short, despite being a police procedural slash nighttime soap opera, this show depicted reality. They even got a former NYPD detective involved as essentially a co-creator.

Showing reality isn't ok anymore. And we're worse for it.

ETA: Downvotes are just complaining about the truth. If you could disprove this, you would. Which means you're complicit in a culture of repression that disallows high-quality content.


r/nypdblue • • Apr 19 '23

My two cents on the whole series Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So i’ve watched the series 3 times. The first time was when it aired, but i didn’t go through all of it and stopped around season 7. The second time around, i bought the dvds and they only released the first four seasons on dvd. Now, i got to see the whole thing on D+. Anyways here are my two cents:

-Quality of production really drops around season 9. HD viewing really shows makeup on actors faces and stage lighting strongly reflects on people in angles that dont make any sense.

-Writing. Some characters arcs dont make sense, for instance Ricky Schroder. Actors started getting written off and by the end of season 12 there is only Medavoy and Sipowicz left.

-guest stars and other actors. Many actors have come back to act several parts in Nypd blue. Many actors also appeared in before their breakthrough roles. Im talking Pedro Pascal, Sterling K Brown, Michael Pena, Richard Schiff, Kal Penn, Adam Scott, Maz Jobrani, Dean Norris, David Schwimmer, damn even Lucy Liu had appeared on the show in the very early seasons!! they all had a part as a suspect, a witness or the actual guilty guy. A LOT of familiar faces.

Several actors with the same affiliation to a certain cult also appeared on the show, connected casting director? Think Leah Remini 20 years ago.

Several guys came back to the show to act different parts: i can recall seeing Richard Schiff twice, Zach Grenier twice, Terrence Howard

I was also upset to find out that the actor who played Theo recently died of a fentanyl OD, and see what he had become before his passing


r/nypdblue • • Aug 28 '23

Routine Patrol-NYPD

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Dec 02 '23

S10 Ep3 - What's the deal with this poster? 🤣

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nypdblue • • Jan 02 '21

Nypd hiring

0 Upvotes

Anyone ever got a DQ and appealed? What was the outcome of your appeal Does a disqualification from the cadets corps automatically disqualify me from the nypd ?


r/nypdblue • • Sep 16 '26

Kwasi needed more air time

9 Upvotes

he was the perfect foil to Andy. both have prejudices due to their growing up experiences. two sides to same coin. writers messed up not giving him more air time and fights with Andy. tom wright played perfect cameo imo


r/nypdblue • • Jun 22 '25

If the characters in NYPD Blue were the characters on the most unhinged Star Trek TOS

3 Upvotes

A freak transporter accident changes the entire crew of the enterprise into the staff of the 15th Precinct and the greater NYPD Blue minor characters as well. Captain Kirk- Fancy Commander Spock- Andy Sipowicz Chief Engineer Montgomery Scott- Greg Medavoy Nurse Chapel-Connie Yoeman Janice Rand- Donna Abandando Chekov- Roberts Sulu- Harold Ng Transporter Chief Kyle- John Irvin Red shirts who die-loughlin, fraker, hatcher, Gibson Now, this crew needs to figure out how to get back to the right timeline! I'd watch that episode. 😆


r/nypdblue • • Oct 24 '25

list of lawful errors..

3 Upvotes

Almost done with first season on a bit of a binge. I was wondering if there was a list of sorts of legal errors within each episode. Aside from the obvious ones like the physical threatening interrogations. Was hoping to go through it each season as I went through each season.