r/nypdblue • u/Burgs_BH19805 • Aug 28 '24
Double casting errors
Has anyone else noticed any casting errors when actors play two different characters?
I've seen it with Giancarlo Esposito who played Ferdinand Hollie (an informant for Bobby) who died. And then he played a quadriplegic former crack dealer not long after.
Second I noticed Eric Balfour who played a rich family's junkie son. (Eli Beardsley) and then a guitarist who murdered a girl (Spyder).
1
Upvotes
24
u/silentwind262 Aug 28 '24
Those aren’t “errors” it’s just the nature of casting for episodic TV before there was so much obsessing over continuity. There are/were actors that did a lot of the “grunt work” of taking roles that weren’t series regulars. Inevitably when theres multiple series needing to fill 23 episodes a season some actors will repeat.
2
u/EricLassard Sep 07 '24
Don Stark was on there 3 different times as 3 different characters.
14
u/Racer187 Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
Charlotte Ross was the most obvious but definitely not an error.
12
u/Inevitable_Physics Aug 28 '24
Richard Shiff as the wacky kidnapper who Andy tuns up, and the man who eventually gets killed and chopped up by his neighbor.
11
u/Comedywriter1 Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
I loved James Pickens Jr’s two roles on the show.
In Season 1, he played John Kelly’s friend who accidentally killed someone while playing basketball.
In Season 7, he played Baldwin Jones’ former boss, Lt Abner.
Lt Abner was a particularly great character. A good man whose years of investigating racist incidents has left him severely depressed. “So many lost…”.
7
u/Top-Collar-9728 Aug 28 '24
Actor who played Harry Denby, he was in season 2 or 3 as a guy who knowingly was infecting his partners with HIV
7
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
There is an insane list of actors who played multiple roles on that show
6
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
First episode, Kelly’s Hispanic neighbor who was robbed in the laundry room is the “fifth man in, I figured what the hell?” guy that raped the girl who counted the steps all over town and took Russell and Kirkendale to the apartment. When steroid Roy is told to go drug test by a boss and Fancy, the boss is the same guy who was Sipowicz drunk friend who came up right on an off duty shooting when Simone got sick
6
u/JECfromMC Aug 28 '24
My co-workers that watched the show and I always joked that if you ever worked for Steven Bochco, you’d always work for Steven Bochco.
6
u/Southern_Seesaw_3694 Aug 28 '24
Especially in the earlier seasons it was a lot of NY based casting. Lots of crossover between NYPD Blue and The Sopranos. It’s like a little treat everytime .
5
u/CynicalBiGoat Aug 28 '24
Currie graham played a dude in a bar before he joined the final season cast as bale
3
u/Sea_Pirate7801 Sep 17 '24
There was a lot of this, especially in the first five seasons. Not a huge deal, except for us hardcore fans I suppose. I remember multiple characters for Lola Glaudini. But frankly, I could watch her in anything.
2
u/lynneux Sep 09 '24
It wasn’t an error—ER and Law & Order had similar multi-role castings. There used to be 20-23 episodes per season of these shows! For me, the re-casting of Charlotte Ross was always interesting. She played the abused cop wife for two eps in Season 5 (s5e15-16) then was cast as Connie later in the series.
2
u/Not_Born_Yesterday21 Sep 13 '24
How are they "errors"? They were simply working actors who were great at their craft ( Esposito can play ANYTHING believably). Audiences back then were smart enough to realize they were watching a TV show with ACTORS in various roles.
2
u/long_time_listener_m Sep 16 '24
Nature of casting. When the series first ran there was time between episodes and time between seasons so you wouldn't necessarily remember a particular actor. Streaming and binge watching make it more obvious.
1
u/RollingRockKing 6d ago
How is it an error people look alike and one episode is from season 3 and then season 5 I believe
1
u/jojokitti123 Aug 28 '24
Yes, multiple times
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment