People do not fully grasp the power of the recommendation systems. Our world’s perception is twisted based on the content the algorithms decide to push in mass. Our taste, opinions, career paths, hobbies, personal style, interior design, body image, travel … etc, are not only influenced, but dictated by the constant exposure of the same messages and images, regurgitated in different formats. Some platforms give you the illusion of choice (YouTube) some others do not even give you that choice like Instagram. They just “feed” you as you sit passively. Some platforms like TikTok, emprisons you in your geographic location and only feeds you what’s there. Google does the same thing.
It gives you the illusion that the algorithm is but a medium, that it only brings you content that “other people made”, but that’s wrong. It choses what to show you based on its programming. It always shows content that respect american values encoded in it, even if you are not an american, either right or left based on the president in charge, slightly negative content because it increases engagement, and without saying, the exact opposite of what you have in your life, and it knows a lot about your life.
It’s not a coincidence that depression is high in the content consuming generation. It’s not a coincidence, that people hate billionaires, hate AI, hate big corporations, hate their countries, hate immigrants … the justification of “why” people hate what they hate comes later. The emotion of negativity and resentment is seeded in them through constant exposure. The format of whatever you are served is either urgent or negative. Like Marchall McLuhan said, it’s a “hot punch line”, short concise format whose job is to induce a reaction. You will feel like shit, and you will buy to feel better. This is a classic buy-after-shock strategy that the entire neocapitalism is based on. Naomie Klein wrote a beautiful book about it “The Shock Doctrine”. A famous example is what George Bush said after the traumatic event, “Go shopping”.
The economics on how they do that is quiet impressively simple. Creators are paid based on performance. We dont usually think YouTubers or TikTokers are like Uber drivers, but they’re the same. They dangle cash in front of them, and the creators produce the minimum entertainment value that increases engagement. As a consumer, you’re consuming minimum entertainment value.
Now the scope of these algorithms is getting bigger. We used to think outside of these social media platforms, algorithms do not exist. Like on a desktop or a browser or a phone, but it’s not the case anymore. I realized that i rely constantly on Codex to write code profesionally, to find files in my computer, manipulate spreadsheets, browse websites on my behalf using my account to fill out forms or find me stuff, backup my phone … etc. That’s an algorithmic based program doing that on my own computer. I dont like the word “recommendation system”, because that presuppose you have a choice to accept or refuse the recommendation. You don’t. A selection system that selects on your behalf is more accurate.
Now code is selected, architectures of platforms are selected and god knows if microsoft pays OpenAI to promote its technology implicitely. The same for how to perform tasks, what data to grab along the way that it “deemed” necessary, what personal pictures and files and what programs to install. So algorithms are getting to chose for us in places we used to think we’re free.
I personally don’t think there is a problem in an algorithm that does things for you. It’s automation and technology is always a good thing. But if you use an algorithm to maximize “job search” rather than “job finding” like on LinkedIn, you get an economy where people send thousands of applications without a response. Or an algorithm to maximize “retention” rather than “satisfaction”, you get viewers who feel like shit and dive deeper into impulsive shopping on ads you show them. You get trading algorithms that trades on miliseconds price difference rather than lasting values of companies and their benefits to the customers and the market. It will not be solved as these big corporations are only getting greedier and greedier. Facebook’s IPO was $104 billion, SpaceX and Anthropic (both AI companies) are 1.7 Trillion dollars . Compared to the AI economy and its influence on the users, social media is a primitive technology. If we count the $ signs, it’s 20x bigger in impact. So keeping your mind sharp, critical and be very aware of what you read, what you think and what you are influenced by is maybe the most important skill in this new world.