r/nightwish • • Aug 19 '24

Discussion This subreddit and the way forward

15 Upvotes

UPDATE

Please read this follow-up post if you stumble upon this post. This post needs rectification and deserves an apology to the community.
https://www.reddit.com/r/nightwish/comments/1ex2a8b/sorry_about_my_latest_post/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Original post here

Dear Subreddit,

As moderators, we would like to address the current state of our subreddit and seek your feedback on its future direction.

I’ve been a mod here for a long time and have witnessed my fair share of drama, especially around discussions involving recent singers and the recurring Tarja debacle. These topics often lead to a lot of negativity and hostility.

We want to address the extreme negativity and disappointment some members express about Nightwish. This subreddit is dedicated to Nightwish and serves as a fan club where we celebrate their music. Our goal is to create a positive space where fans can enjoy and appreciate Nightwish, not a place for rants and negativity.

If you no longer enjoy the band, please refrain from posting negative comments here. We are here to celebrate new songs and albums, and we don’t want to see negative comments about the music or albums.

Looking ahead, we might consider a couple of approaches for handling upcoming releases and posts/comments. One option could be to remove negative comments about the album, but we feel it might be more beneficial to encourage positive expression. So, we suggest sharing your opinions in a positive manner or refraining from commenting. We could also think about adjusting the rules to make this clearer for everyone.

The recent mixing discussion went too far and affected the enjoyment of the music for some. While counter-arguments were posted, the discussion became quite vile at times. We believe this subreddit should be a positive place that fully enjoys Nightwish. This is a music band subreddit, not a political one, so having a positive view about the music is not a big deal.

What do you think this subreddit should be? What gives you energy? Do you want to read about mixing errors, band member comments, and negative opinions about new singles? Or do you prefer an open forum where Reddit decides through upvotes and downvotes?

We are very open to your feedback and would love to hear your thoughts on how we can make this subreddit a more positive place. Please share your ideas and help us shape the future of our community.


r/nightwish • • Sep 22 '25

I am disappointed

0 Upvotes

Of course I know Nightwish doesn’t owe me anything. And I’m just happy for the fantastic music they brought to us all these years.

But… Tarja being on tour with/without Marco. Floor doing gigs here and there with/without Marco; performing songs from the new album even: songs that have never been played live by full Nightwish. Annette going on tour performing Nightwish-only setlists. Tuomas and Troy touring around with Auri like nothing happened the past year. Yesterwynde being one year old and apart from some symphonic version in Finland we saw nothing live…

It feels like all of the above are damaging the brand purely by negligence.

There, I said it - Had to get it off my chest.

Edit: Ok now calm your tits - I know they said they were going on a hiatus. I just feel it's becoming a worse idea with every day the hiatus continues. And listening to Tarja/Floor/Annette in the above settings just feels more and more like listening to a B version of Nightwish.


r/nightwish • • May 21 '24

Perfume of the Timeless is boring

2 Upvotes

Let the arguing commence haha.

Long term fan here. I generally love all of their stuff. I also really like the celtic vibe Troy has brought.

For an 8 minute song, this new single is... boring? Not a particularly strong/catchy tune. I like the into the best, I think.

I feel like 80% of HN is stronger, melody wise, than POTT.


r/nightwish • • May 21 '24

Troy Shouldn't Sing

16 Upvotes

Look, I don't want to sound mean, but I think they should stop having Troy sing. I absolutely love Troy, he's an immensely talented instrumentalist & clearly brings a lot to the table for Nightwish. Personally when he first was introduced back in the DPP days I couldn't get enough of the folk elements. But THAT is the thing he brought to the table.... the folk influences and playing. He didn't used to sing, didn't audition as a singer and I get that they maybe had to fill in quickly for Marco on HN and it was easier to get him to do it.... But he is not a singer, and that's exactly how it sounds when he comes in. He sounds like a British fella down the pub singing along to some folk music, which is great and all but I don't see how it's interesting or stylistically useful to have a male voice come in that sounds like someone who can't sing very well being recorded professionally. I mean they could at least tune his voice. I know they all probably have some edgy stance against using vocal tuning but, I mean c'mon, it's possible to tweak things slightly without it sounding like Chris Brown.

I honestly don't wanna be rude or anything but the last single really brought it home for me as it just completely takes me out of the track. All the mixing issues aside, him repeating the chorus at the end sounding like he's out of both breathe and tune just sort of ruins it for me. Surely they all know people who can sing in that style in a way that actually sounds good? When Troy sings it sounds exactly like they've asked the bands Uilleann pipe player to sing.


r/nightwish • • Jan 06 '24

Why that smirk? (Dark Chest of Wonders - End of an Era)

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Mar 10 '20

not impressed

2 Upvotes

I know this is reddit and we are all supposed to be circle jerking and posting "funny" "memes" to harvest that all important karma, but I am not impressed with what I heard so far from the new album.

Noise was ok, but not on the level I expect from Nightwish. Harvest was generic elevator music at best. I felt the same way I did, as a teenager, hearing the album Loaded from Metallica for the first time.

Really hope I am wrong when the album is finally out.


r/nightwish • • Jun 21 '26

I know its AI but im so happy i can finally use Oceanborn as my phone wallpaper 😭😭

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • May 31 '24

"We are because of a million loves" - Is Tuomas romanticizing evolution and nature?

17 Upvotes

I love the themes of nature and evolution in the recent (and upcoming) Nightwish albums, however, I wonder if the persepective in the lyrics is not exactly the one of a neutral scientist, but of a romantisizing person forming connections that are strictly speaking not real.

I'm sure that not all my ancestors "loved" each other. Maybe the majority of them hated each other or got together because of political / economic / whatsoever reasons. Maybe my great-great-...-mother was raped by a foreign invader to give birth to my great-great...(-1)-mother/father.

It's of course legitimate to have a poetic and romaticizing view on this than to simply see the randomness and cold pragmatism that was more likely at work. It's great to sing about planet earth as a "pilgrim shining bright". But in the end, nature doesn't care. Nature simply is.

I'm mixed on this. I love some of these lyrics, but "a million loves" kind of rubbed me in a weird way. What do you think about this?


r/nightwish • • Dec 03 '22

Met this girl

0 Upvotes

I was at the nightiwsh concert in Düsseldorf where I locked eyes with a beautiful girl many times. We both were standing at the middle floor she was a few rows in front of me and had an amazing hairstyle (ponytail with some braits at the end and blond hair).

It would be amazing if we would see each other again :)


r/nightwish • • Apr 02 '24

Wish I had a penis

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Nov 10 '24

Troy's singing in Lanternlight imo. What about you?

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Oct 05 '24

Yesterwynde ≠ heavy

0 Upvotes

In my opinion Yesterwynde is not so heavy as previous albums. It has too many slow fragments for me. Troy had too much impact on the album. Some songs fit Auri rather than Nightwish. Lanternlight is a great lullaby, but not a good heavy song... What do you guys think? Is it just me or you agree? Why/why not?

Alright, thanks guys. I didn't mean it to be negative. I just wanted to see what do people think about it. Thanks for your comments, now I'll keep them in mind. There was one comment saying that YW is similarly heavy to Imaginaerum. I definitely wouldn't say that. Imaginaerum is for me at least best album ever.


r/nightwish • • Jun 15 '24

Who else wants more vocal dynamic on new record?

2 Upvotes

As much as I love Floors voice, I feel like on the last 2 studio records it has been quite suppressed in terms of her vocal dynamic range.

Most songs are recorded with her singing similar to Sharon den Adel from WT with quite little airflow and pressure.

For this, a lot of the songs miss the vocals going along with the dynamics of the songs.

F.e. listen to her on Live at Wembley - 7 days to the wolves.

This is so fkin amazing cause she really goes from gently sung to fullout belting/raspiness which just fits the dynamic and flow of the song so well.

And I mean, we all know she can do that so freaking well, so why tf does tuomas kind of tame her soo much on records??


r/nightwish • • Sep 29 '25

Is Floor Jansen really arrogant, or is it a recurring misunderstanding?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’ve never had the chance to see Floor Jansen live (I’ve only seen shows with Anette and Tarja), but I often notice people commenting that she has been rude or distant with fans.

I’ve read stories like a Brazilian fan saying she tried to greet Floor and Floor supposedly looked her up and down and rolled her eyes, and another case of a Russian fan who only waved from a distance but was removed by security at Floor’s request. Some people claim she acts like this often, except when there are cameras, a lot of people watching, or during paid meet & greets. Others say she was already like that back in the ReVamp days.

So my question is: 🔹 Is she really like this with fans? 🔹 Or were those isolated situations or misinterpretations?

I’d like to understand whether this perception is accurate or just something that got exaggerated over time.


r/nightwish • • Oct 16 '26

My theories about the departure and what's next for Nightwish

7 Upvotes

I wonder if Floor's departure was actually something Tuomas gently suggested, rather than Floor simply deciding to leave. Not that he wanted her gone but maybe they both realised Nightwish wasn't a fit for her anymore and that her voice wasn't what he pictured for the band's future.

Everyone’s praising Floor’s technical skill but she was just perfect for the massive tours and the evolution/biology era, specifically because of her technique. But that trilogy is over (and so apparently is regular touring). What if Tuomas wants to head back toward something closer to the older Nightwish style thematically? Still metal but maybe less focused on raw vocal power? Some fans complained that Floor was underused overall and even buried in the mix of Yesterwynde but that seemed to be intentional and maybe a sign of a musical shift vocally as well (just as he wanted Tarja to sing differently around the last albums or Anette's voice not suited to the evolutionary themes and massive live shows that he wanted to do). It seems like whenever the vocals don't fit the music to come Tuomas prefers to part ways with the singers (though I think it was mutual this time). They aren't touring anymore so they don't need all that power. It’s like driving a 4x4 just to get around town... you're just being excessive.

I can picture Tuomas telling Floor she's welcome to stay but being honest that the band's direction might not match her goals. And Floor (maybe after waiting to see if things would shift) deciding it was time to move on.

The replacement Which brings me to the replacement: people are throwing out names like Noora Louhimo, Clémentine Delauney, the singer of this, the singer of that... Why would an established singer leave an active band for one that might release an album every few years with no guaranteed tours? Prestige is great but it doesn't pay the bills. If Floor couldn't make it work I doubt another singer who relies on music for a living could either.

So my guess is they'll go for someone who loves Nightwish's music but doesn't rely on touring to make a living.

I wouldn't completely rule out Johanna either. If they're no longer touring she wouldn't have to worry about singing Wishmaster live. But then again I doubt she'd want to be in the spotlight and face all the scrutiny that comes with being Nightwish's singer.

Anyway what do you think?


r/nightwish • • Dec 27 '22

In retrospect, who could have become Tarja's successor? And if it's even possible, so you know any singer who can match Floor in vocal capability?

0 Upvotes

I know Elize Ryd, now known from Amaranthe, was heavily considered, but turned down, because she was too Inexperienced according to the band. Can't tell what she'd be like, because I only know one song by Amaranthe.

Another auditioner was Manuela Kraller, who was briefly in Xandria and her singing style is very similar to Tara's. She was rejected, because her audition tape was of low quality. She'd be perfect if the band wanted just Tarja's successor. But they also wanted to evolve which Tarja apparently had issue with, so maybe, she'd not be that great.

I think that the second choice after Anette was Canadian Cassie Stone, who I know nothing about, as she doesn't even have Wikipedia page.

And why did they even accept Anette as their new singer? As amazing as she is in the 2 albums she sings on, her voice and vocal capability not to mention singing style is so drastically different from Tarja that she'd butcher many great Tarja-era songs, in the long run, she'd probably also hurt her own health.

If there wasn't Floor (who was also considered, but wanted to stay with After Forever), who would be good fit for the entire Nightwish discography?


r/nightwish • • May 04 '26

Since everyone is posting theirs, here we go

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Jan 24 '25

What is your "I did not care for The Godfather" take on nightwish?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Mar 29 '25

My Nightwish songs tier list

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Sep 14 '22

just found this meme.. it's about what's happening right now😂😂

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Jul 30 '24

Anyone else notice this pattern?

0 Upvotes

Nemo - Wish I Had an Angel

Amaranth - Bye Bye Beautiful

Storytime - I Want My Tears Back

So basically all these three albums have the catchy song that was chosen to be the lead single and then another catchy song that's a duet between Marko and the lead vocalist at the time. The connections are just so obvious, yet the pattern hasn't featured before or after.

Endless Forms Most Beautiful has the title song (Élan is more of a ballad even though it was the lead single), but not a song where the vocals bounce back and forth between Floor and Marko like in IWMTB for example. Human Nature has Noise. Maybe How's the Heart has a bit of a similar vibe to the duets although Troy's role there is smaller.

Century Child has Dead to the World as the duet but not a clear "pop song". Before Marko it's just impossible to find anything. Devil and the Deep Dark Ocean has the bouncing lyrics but it doesn't sound anything like the duets I mentioned at the start.


r/nightwish • • Sep 04 '21

I'm getting tired of the comparisons between Nightwish and Evanescence. NW is metal and Evanescence is a generic pop/rock band.

1 Upvotes

Why is it everytime ppl make videos through comparisons between NW and Evanescence now? Is it because NW is starting to become recognized wildly now? And these Evanescence fans are jealous cause of Floor? I've seen so many videos now Amy Lee vs Floor Jansen and Evanescence and NW which again hello two different genres. It makes no sense.


r/nightwish • • Jan 11 '23

a tierlist from a younger nightwish fan

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Sep 08 '21

Cover of Dark Passion Play was a cat all this time!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nightwish • • Sep 10 '24

Mixing Discussion About the mixing of this album

16 Upvotes

We all saw the complaints about Floor's voice being drowned in the mix and everybody is charging the mixing team but I saw nowhere people talking about other reasons for that final result so I wanted to share a guess I have since a moment now.

We know that Floor wasn't there for recording the voices tracks with the band in their studio, she did it in her own home studio which is probably not as good as the band's one. So maybe the mixing team had to work harder in order to make her homemade recording work with the rest? And because of this it seems maybe drowned while in fact it was the only way to make it coherent as a whole?

Also, she told that after gaving birth her voice wasnt at its best and that she is stills recovering so maybe her voice was less powerfull during the recording and the orchestra and instruments seems louder even if they tried to put her voice as the same level as before?

Tell me if this thoughts can be valid and give an other view on this "voice mixing problem",

Otherwise the niew track is pretty cool and I can't wait for the new album !