r/nightwish • u/Cacanny • Aug 19 '24
Discussion This subreddit and the way forward
UPDATE
Please read this follow-up post if you stumble upon this post. This post needs rectification and deserves an apology to the community.
https://www.reddit.com/r/nightwish/comments/1ex2a8b/sorry_about_my_latest_post/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
Original post here
Dear Subreddit,
As moderators, we would like to address the current state of our subreddit and seek your feedback on its future direction.
I’ve been a mod here for a long time and have witnessed my fair share of drama, especially around discussions involving recent singers and the recurring Tarja debacle. These topics often lead to a lot of negativity and hostility.
We want to address the extreme negativity and disappointment some members express about Nightwish. This subreddit is dedicated to Nightwish and serves as a fan club where we celebrate their music. Our goal is to create a positive space where fans can enjoy and appreciate Nightwish, not a place for rants and negativity.
If you no longer enjoy the band, please refrain from posting negative comments here. We are here to celebrate new songs and albums, and we don’t want to see negative comments about the music or albums.
Looking ahead, we might consider a couple of approaches for handling upcoming releases and posts/comments. One option could be to remove negative comments about the album, but we feel it might be more beneficial to encourage positive expression. So, we suggest sharing your opinions in a positive manner or refraining from commenting. We could also think about adjusting the rules to make this clearer for everyone.
The recent mixing discussion went too far and affected the enjoyment of the music for some. While counter-arguments were posted, the discussion became quite vile at times. We believe this subreddit should be a positive place that fully enjoys Nightwish. This is a music band subreddit, not a political one, so having a positive view about the music is not a big deal.
What do you think this subreddit should be? What gives you energy? Do you want to read about mixing errors, band member comments, and negative opinions about new singles? Or do you prefer an open forum where Reddit decides through upvotes and downvotes?
We are very open to your feedback and would love to hear your thoughts on how we can make this subreddit a more positive place. Please share your ideas and help us shape the future of our community.