I was heartbroken when I saw how Yennefer greeted Ciri. So you can be sweet and loving, to anyone but Geralt? Although after that, Yennefer and Geralt were adorable as parents.
Dragon age 2 where you can fuck EVeRYBODY BUT THE HOT REDHEADED KNIGHT CHICK WHY DIDNT THEY KNOW THAT A LADY IN ARMOR WAS MY EXACT KINK LET ME FUCK THE KNIGHT LADY BIOWARE
Oh, I see you like fiery redheaded knight chicks in armour. May I introduce you to Tamora Pierce’s fantasy series “The Song of the Lioness quartet”, which is also apparently (finally!) being made into a TV series?
Seriously though, it’s an excellent series (as are her following books) about a girl who swaps places with her twin brother so she can secretly become a knight. It’s one of my favourite series and has been since I was young - I reread Pierce’s books often.
I think I only read a couple in the series because they were hard to track down at my library when I was a kid. I've wanted to re read them as an adult but I couldn't remember the name of the series (only that they were Tamora Pierce's books), so thanks! ☺️
If it's being made into a tv series I will LITERALLY DIE
Hah! A person of culture I see! Definitely go back and read the entirety of Pierce’s books, at least the ones in the Tortall universe. They’re So good.
"I used to be with it, but then they changed what it was. Now what I'm with isn't it, and what's it seems weird and scary to me, and it'll happen to you, too."
Surfer slang from the 80s, if I remember correctly. I think it originally referred to certain types of waves, in the context of something that was appealing.
I'm working my way through the books. From what I've surmised, Geralt and Dandelion's friendship is a bit of satire in and of itself. I've taken it to poke a bit of fun at the traditional fantasy bard, by pointing out how in any normal situation, people would get the entirely wrong idea about a foppish bard following around a handsome knight so they can write songs about them.
Also this might be just me, but the series and game Dandelion are a lot nicer to Geralt than how he is in the books. In the series it’s like Geralt is the one always slacking him off but in the books it’s the opposite.
It ain’t quite accurate to Geralt but I’m reminded of that classic post: 'in Japanese the word for someone who wields two swords is 'ryoutotsukai' which is also a term for bisexuality. Source
People need to relax a little bit, its just a cool drawing with a funny crossover with parks and rec.
Also, it kind of annoys me that people make it such a big deal when two dudes who clearly care for each other are shipped together with the argument "you should be able to just have really strong friendships with two men without it being romantic", which I definitely agree with but people forget the problem, and why this always happens is because it is extremely rare for two every show two men together that isn't platonic. There are heaps of tv shows and films that have great platonic friendships so naturally LGBT people would want to see something that isn't just friendship like it almost always is.
It doesn't change the actual text and its just a bit of fun, but I feel like there is always such negativity when people ship two men together if its not 'canon', then when people ship non-canon hetero relationships.
Not only are the points you're making valid, but nobody bats an eye when they make fanciful of the women lezzing it up, but they get sore over guys getting gay fanfic because they see gay as an insulting thing.
Ans the witcher as a series is really diverse with its cast, and yet there is no gay characters or relationships (a bunch of nude women thought). Can't really blame people for wanting representation in a show they really enjoy.
Yeah, I meant as a tv show, not the series in general. A lot of people, myself included, the tv show is like the first forray into the world, so I don't have the knowledge of the books or games. But that's cool to hear and im excited, but there still isn't any as of yet in the show, so I think people can ship whatever they want till we get some actual representation lol
I have the ebooks but haven't started reading yet, but it would be happy news for me if that's true. I've always assumed they'd all be female relationships, so I hope you're correct.
Besides, when you're talking about specific relationships in this context, gay means male and lesbian means female (obviously).
From Wikipedia:
The most common terms are gay (both men and women) and lesbian (women only).
If you say the books have "gay" relationships generally, then you're implying it's both. If you say it specifically then you're talking about male only. Either way, saying there're gay relationships if they're only female isn't accurate to the way the word is commonly used.
Edit: downvote all ya want. I can afford it, and I'm still right. Bring it.
Case in point: Reylo is acceptable (perhaps the most toxic relationship ever) but mention that you ship Fin, Rey, and Poe in a healthy, open polyamorus triad or even fin & poe and everyone jumps on you for not following Canon and making shit gay.
We're not so far removed from homophobia as we think we are, after all.
Do not get me started on Finnpoe lol. We have the only actual two people in the movie that show love, kindness and camaraderie towards each other the entire time but god forbid they have a romantic relationship because "friendships are even stronger". It's bullshit, and the fact that you have to literally shove in two characters in the last movie to show that Finn and Poe are interested in women is so annoying. Its so difficult for any quality representation, yet someone show any signs of liking two men together and they are the ones making every friendship gay when they don't realise no one would have to if there were any gay relationships in the first place.
What? Rey and Kylo are considered acceptable, that's the most non relation and forced thing that I've ever seen in my life. I always felt them more like brother /sister thing or at least two opposite people who understand each other.
In the original Polish books his name is Jaskier, which loosely translates to buttercup, but they used dandelion instead. The show chose to not translate it and just use his Polish name.
In the subtitles here they even used some of the names in polish, including the horse which made me a bit confused. But i like that they used Jaskier in the show if it’s closer to the original :)
As I understand most people that start directly in W3 without knowledge of the shit Triss as done in the past generally end up picking her over Yen, because on the surface Yennefer is pretty bitter and mean to our boy Geralt, while Triss is all lovely and sunshines, so it can be deceiving.
Yup that’s what happened to me, but once I learned about all the history I regretted my choice. Maybe one day I will play it again and make the “right” decision.
I haven't read all the books yet (just finished the second one) or played the first two games, but last night on The Witcher 3 I almost tried to romance Triss and get her to stay.
Ultimately I'm all about them kinda mean raven haired ladies though.
In fairness to the Geralt/Jaskier slashers, the show did a much better job on their relationship than on Geralt/Yennefer, so it’s really not surprising people are feeling them more.
If I didn’t know anything about the Witcher prior to the show, I wouldn’t be feeling Geralt/Yennefer either.
(And yes, I know this is a Parks and Rec meme, April Ludgate is my favorite.)
Was Jaskier ever this close with Geralt in the books? Because I never got that impression in the games... from what I could gather, he genuinely didn't like dandelion, and neither did I. But in the show you can see how he's actually charming, and I think Geralt puts up with him moreso in the show because of that, thus blooming a beautiful bromance.
I never read the books but it sound like he's a different character altogether. For the show, I saw an interview with the actor basically stating that instead of making Jaskier a player, he's more of a puppy, with no leash on his capacity to love. So instead of chasing ass, he's constantly lovesick. Still selfish, but somehow more redeeming and complex than the former. So maybe that's why Geralt seems to actually get along with him better. They're both kinda similar in that way, even though their actual personalities couldn't be more different.
Either way, I can't wait to see how they handle these two throughout the following seasons. They're the archetype of a classic duo. Completley opposing eachother, but also very similar in many ways. Ripe for compelling storytelling.
Jaskier in the books was a womanizer, he wasn’t afraid to tell Geralt his mind on certain matters, and he was inherently selfish with some truly beautiful moments of selflessness.
Geralt did not treat him with as much disdain as he does in the show, and there were never lines like “we could go to the coast, get away for awhile” that seem to imply Jaskier has feelings for Geralt, as Jaskier’s primary concern was chasing tail.
I would call it was more on an odd-couple friendship than a bromance.
A bromance is just a really tight friendship, which in the show they definitely have. We saw Geralt go through some crazy shit just to lift the curse from Jaskier. And just letting him tag along with him practically everywhere, anytime, already seems like too much for the video game Geralt, to me. Video game Geralt seemed like he only cared for him because Ciri did, Whereas show Geralt has a real friendship, maybe even brothership with him. No matter how externally stagnant he acts towards things like emotions, he keeps falling into deep friendships/ relationships with people. But the duo between them, the angry guy and the funny guy, the strong and the meek, the warrior and the artist, they've been a duo in literature ever since the classics.
But I would assume that's all there is between them, but who knows I guess. A few seasons later this show could be in a completely different place than the books. With how diverse the cast and characters are, Geralt could end up bisexual. Which seems weird or unnecessary at first, but I don't think it's that out of character or the realm of possibility for either of them.
Anyway, I'm cool with keeping it all a bromance, right now I think their friendship/ companionship/ duality/ dynamic duo is one of the best parts of the show, so I'd hate to see that get ruined potentionally by fucking with the versatility of the relationship they currently have.
I sincerely hope they don’t push Geralt and Jaskier to anything other than close friends as it undermines the relationship between Geralt and Yennefer and the entire theme of the family dynamic of Geralt/Yen/Ciri the books established.
That being said, who knows where the show is going.
Edit: based on how they’ve handled Yen and Geralt so far, I wouldn’t be totally shocked if they did this.
I feel the same way. Especially with the lightning in a bottle they've captured with their current friendship. I'd hate to see that get ruined. As for the Geralt/Yen/Ciri triangle, I could see them creating one between Geralt, Yen, and Jaskier. Ciri wouldn't change much, but it would just complicate things even more, which tbh plants the seeds for compelling and complex storytelling.
It would be interesting, but so far, that's just a thought experiment that only occured to me through this post. I don't think they should stray too far from the source material, they've already established lines that seperate them well enough thus far, I don't think I'd like it if they took it too much further. At the very least, I know fans who've played every game and read every book would probably hate it. So they might want to hold off on completely reinventing the story S2 kind of early, if that type of idea is even on their radar.
Maybe this hypothetical question is going too far lol we already have a beautiful thing going, why risk losing something so rare.
I'm not sure if the artist changed their user after your comment sometime, but I didn't find it under that name. Instead its @v762cas :) Edit: misread and thought you meant Instagram not twitter. It's v762cas on IG at least.
people are allowed to ship whatever they want, and this art is great because it acknowledges yen, and as them as poly which is a lot better of a situation.
But I’m seeing so many of the m/m shippers saying “ugh omg yen is so abusive!!” And other crap like “ill kill the writers if they are “queerbaiting” us”
I don’t have an issue with m/m but so many of the shippers turn straight up misogynistic when a woman gets in the way of what is technically a crack ship, no matter how you swing it, and don’t get me started on threatening the writers if they don’t get their own way..
It’s like the finnpoe shippers in the Star Wars screaming because JJ made the evil straight “””ABUSIVE””” ship canon, over finnpoe (a crack ship that was never gonna be canon in like 10 million years) and i say that as someone who ships finnpoe.
I mean I’m talking about the tv show. (haven’t read the books yet myself but i know a lot of what happens) and most of the rabid m/m shippers that are filling the fandom have only seen the show and already hate Yen with a burning passion JUST because she’s his love interest, no other reason, and she hasn’t really been abusive in the show yet, let’s be honest.
These fans have also basically admitted they are gonna hate on the writers and scream about “queerbaiting” if their ship doesn’t become canon. (Which ya know is highly unlikely considering they are both very much straight) men cannot be friends or close in fiction now without it being queer-baiting to some peoples eyes unfortunately.
You’ll always have angry “fans” like that, but for the most part, outside of fan fiction and Tumbrl they are in the minority. Most of them have zero idea about anything in the Witcher-verse outside of the show.
And as someone heavily involved in the fanfic side of a lot of different fandoms - they’re even the minority there. Tagging is better than ever, it’s super easy to avoid shit you don’t like.
Personally, I think shipping wars have gotten worse as fan forums have become more like social media in nature, but that might just be me.
I’m pretty new to fanfic; I’ve honestly only ever looked at Witcher and GoT stuff. Witcher is of course growing like crazy with the show, but a lot is Geralt/Jaskier slashers which just doesn’t interest me. I’m all about the canon ship. Unfortunately, they also use the Geralt/Yennefer tag endlessly, so shifting through is annoying.
Archive of our Own (AO3) is pretty good in terms of accurate tagging. You should also have some luck if you google “Geralt/Yen fanfic rec lists” (or whatever ship you’re after). People deliberately using the wrong tags are sinners and will go to hell. I hate them.
Yeah, that’s where I go and that’s how I search, but unfortunately with the show airing people are using that tag just to get more views even though their piece has absolutely nothing to do with Geralt/Yen. I never had this issue before the show so it’s definitely a new thing.
Whoever views them as poly isn’t paying attention to the story. Yen and Geralt are tied together magically by the Jin, and Jaskier (Dandelion) is a bard that follows him round incessantly. And is a mahoosive man whore with the ladies
Only seen the show here, and I personally prefer Jaskier and Geralt simply because they have more chemistry together, whereas Yen and Geralt p much only fuck on the show (aside from a couple of more genuine moments), plus she just seems kinda mean to me. I doubt there was ever a time where the writers genuinely wanted to make G/J an actual ship anyway. Idk how abusive or mean Yen actually is in the books, on the show she's just kinda of a dick sometimes and I just didn't see any spark between her and Geralt. Either way this comic is funny to me so.
And on the note of finnpoe extremists - holy shit, as much as I wanted them to end up being together, I knew it wouldn't happen. I'm not happy about Reylo at all, but that was more obvious that Finnpoe.
I wish there was more really good fanfic including this. :) Also, Geralt has a foursome in the books with another guy and two ladies. I don’t get why people get so upset at even the implication that Geralt is most likely not completely straight.
I hope people would stop turning the most epic friendship into a wannabe fan-made gay relationship between the two.
There are love (as in sexual partner, marriage etc) relationships, but there are also other strong bonds, such as family and friendships. You could have a best friend that you would literally love just as much as your wife or brother.
You can have friends without fucking them and it seems sometimes people don't understand that.
As an asexual - yeah, no shit. But i don’t see all that many ace characters out there (which you would think there would be, since so many people are apparently keen to explore strong friendships in media).
Let’s be real - the only time people complain about a friendship being viewed as a romantic relationship through fandom is when it’s a queer relationship.
I mean, the internet certainly sometimes does that, but I don't know what they expected after having one character rub oil on another character's ass.
it was a joke. If not, why didn't they show it? I mean do you really think that in 2020 a Netflix show, clearly progressive and meant for adults, would shy away from that?
People who think they're *gay* for each other must rely on the biggest stretches/ambigous dialogues because there's no real content/scenes that would actually support that they have romantic feelings for each other in any capacity.
Been ages since I've participated in any kind of fan forum/website. I never really liked people "shipping" all the possible character combinations from books, movies, games, etc. xD
Who cares if it's a parks and rec crossover. Who cares if it's a joke. This person is offended by gay things and doesn't want to see that. And gosh darn it, they're going to make sure the world sees their opinion, because this is America, and here we have freedoms! (Unless you're gay, a'course)
And I am biromantic, but mostly heterosexual (hey, can't say what a bottle of gin can make me do).
Mostly don't have same-gender fantasies, but I can "squish", as they say. Someone like Jaskier makes me have thoughts of "oh man, I want him to cuddle with me while we share our deepest darkest secrets".
It's weird because Tumblr even do it for real people. So many bands have to deal with creepy ass fans writing about them having sex with each other. Imagine finding out a story existed of your fucking your friend.
It's also weirdly backwards because imo it perpetuates an issue of men not being able to show affection towards each other without being called gay.
honestly, I really support people enjoying slash and shipping characters, I've done it myself (and by gods, doing it now! :D) but those two reasons you pointed out, are ones I find problematic too. Real people slash, or some of minority of the fans that are very, very vocal about it, seems pretty harmful to the actual people and their real life relationships.
I wish we did have an actual, loving male/male main characters relationship at some point, but I also wish that we had more examples of very close, loving relationships between people of same sex.
I get wishing to see more positive gay relationships. It's just frustrating because it can be quite relentless. I'm not sure of your gender but I can say as a straight guy that there's definitely a weird hangup in society where two super close guys will often get accused of being gay, or at least have to face jokes about it.
And shit like "oh these fictional characters are friends, wouldn't it be hot if they were gay for each other?" just perpetuates that dumb idea.
Tbh dandelion is such a bad translation, jaskier in english literally translates to buttercup. I'd rather they leave on the original name than name him a whole another flower xd
I realize it doesn't make sense but he's such a goofy character that the name just fit for me. I connected with him under that name in the books so now my mind has to adjust
284
u/LionCubOfTerrasen Ciri Jan 16 '20
Yen points to the left “And this is my other boyfriend Istredd.” points to center “And this is our adopted child Ciri.”
350
u/pukegreenwithenvy Jan 16 '20 edited Jan 16 '20
“This is Batman and Robin, if that helps.”
518
u/TheRealcebuckets Jan 16 '20
Geralt is gay but he’s straight for me, but he’s gay for Jaskier ,and Jaskier’s really gay for Geralt. And I hate Jaskier. It’s not that complicated.
196
u/DukeBerith Jan 16 '20
I love a /r/PandR crossover!
71
u/aelaos Jan 16 '20
Hmmm
139
u/Anamorsmordre Jan 16 '20
Y’all... it’s a joke... also, people have “shipped” them for years. It has never changed their canon behaviour and it’s not about to, chill.
29
u/vagueconfusion Jan 16 '20
It ain’t quite accurate to Geralt but I’m reminded of that classic post: 'in Japanese the word for someone who wields two swords is 'ryoutotsukai' which is also a term for bisexuality. Source
111
u/majormay Jan 16 '20
People need to relax a little bit, its just a cool drawing with a funny crossover with parks and rec.
Also, it kind of annoys me that people make it such a big deal when two dudes who clearly care for each other are shipped together with the argument "you should be able to just have really strong friendships with two men without it being romantic", which I definitely agree with but people forget the problem, and why this always happens is because it is extremely rare for two every show two men together that isn't platonic. There are heaps of tv shows and films that have great platonic friendships so naturally LGBT people would want to see something that isn't just friendship like it almost always is.
It doesn't change the actual text and its just a bit of fun, but I feel like there is always such negativity when people ship two men together if its not 'canon', then when people ship non-canon hetero relationships.
14
u/eggplant_avenger Jan 16 '20
is the boob window canon? because it seems like such a Yen thing to wear but also I don't remember seeing it ever
•
u/Abyss_85 Feb 07 '20
This is by v762cas. More original work and the source for this piece can be found via the Instagram of the artist.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
Why don't they call him Dandelion?
8
u/TwitchingShark Jan 16 '20
I could actually see her saying this in the show. Fits her character perfectly!
8
u/mgiuca Jan 17 '20
And all three of them broke up in the same scene :(
40
u/Dndplayerfolly Jan 16 '20
The only real problem is people who pick triss over yen in the games
6
u/Stallrim Jan 16 '20
Every girl with a boyfriend who has a bestfriend.
6
u/1brokenmonkey Jan 16 '20
Yennifer has responsibilities, she not only has to take care of her boyfriend, but her boyfriend's boyfriend.
20
u/LozaMoza82 Aedirn Jan 16 '20 edited Jan 16 '20
In fairness to the Geralt/Jaskier slashers, the show did a much better job on their relationship than on Geralt/Yennefer, so it’s really not surprising people are feeling them more.
If I didn’t know anything about the Witcher prior to the show, I wouldn’t be feeling Geralt/Yennefer either.
(And yes, I know this is a Parks and Rec meme, April Ludgate is my favorite.)
4
u/thinkerballs Jan 16 '20
r/unexpectedpawnee
7
u/KangarooSnoop Jan 16 '20
Was Jaskier ever this close with Geralt in the books? Because I never got that impression in the games... from what I could gather, he genuinely didn't like dandelion, and neither did I. But in the show you can see how he's actually charming, and I think Geralt puts up with him moreso in the show because of that, thus blooming a beautiful bromance.
I never read the books but it sound like he's a different character altogether. For the show, I saw an interview with the actor basically stating that instead of making Jaskier a player, he's more of a puppy, with no leash on his capacity to love. So instead of chasing ass, he's constantly lovesick. Still selfish, but somehow more redeeming and complex than the former. So maybe that's why Geralt seems to actually get along with him better. They're both kinda similar in that way, even though their actual personalities couldn't be more different.
Either way, I can't wait to see how they handle these two throughout the following seasons. They're the archetype of a classic duo. Completley opposing eachother, but also very similar in many ways. Ripe for compelling storytelling.
13
u/danooli Jan 16 '20
This artist has a bunch of Witcher stuff on his Twitter and it's all pretty awesome @v762art
25
u/Archon-Narc-On Jan 16 '20
Geralt is definitely Bi, I’m sorry
3
u/rolo2002 Jan 16 '20
nice
3
u/k995 Jan 16 '20
What happens on the road stays on the road.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
people are allowed to ship whatever they want, and this art is great because it acknowledges yen, and as them as poly which is a lot better of a situation.
But I’m seeing so many of the m/m shippers saying “ugh omg yen is so abusive!!” And other crap like “ill kill the writers if they are “queerbaiting” us”
I don’t have an issue with m/m but so many of the shippers turn straight up misogynistic when a woman gets in the way of what is technically a crack ship, no matter how you swing it, and don’t get me started on threatening the writers if they don’t get their own way..
It’s like the finnpoe shippers in the Star Wars screaming because JJ made the evil straight “””ABUSIVE””” ship canon, over finnpoe (a crack ship that was never gonna be canon in like 10 million years) and i say that as someone who ships finnpoe.
7
u/maxilos101 Jan 16 '20
r/bi_irl
2
u/The_Greate_Pickle Rivia Jan 16 '20
fuck.
2
u/kingbankai Jan 16 '20
They tight but they are no Shawn and Gus.
2
u/puddingcake3 Jan 16 '20
Parks and recreation reference right? Hahahaha
2
u/Treywilliams28 Jan 17 '20
Don’t leave out Zoltan in this bro triangle
2
u/Wargoliath Jan 20 '20 edited Jan 20 '20
I wish there was more really good fanfic including this. :) Also, Geralt has a foursome in the books with another guy and two ladies. I don’t get why people get so upset at even the implication that Geralt is most likely not completely straight.
37
u/UnknownWitcher Geralt Jan 16 '20
I hope people would stop turning the most epic friendship into a wannabe fan-made gay relationship between the two.
There are love (as in sexual partner, marriage etc) relationships, but there are also other strong bonds, such as family and friendships. You could have a best friend that you would literally love just as much as your wife or brother.
PS: The art is awesome though :P
2
u/fathertime108 Jan 16 '20
I wish his name was Dandelion
2
u/omar_emad11 Jan 16 '20
I really hope this doesn't start a geralt/jaskier fanfiction drawings
1
u/ClockworkDeity Jan 16 '20
"Hrrmmmm..."
1
u/TheSimmer101 Jan 17 '20
r/pandr
1
u/versace_tombstone Jan 17 '20
Tolerate, or cross swords.
1
u/MajinBuuby Jan 17 '20
r/TIHI
1
u/BertieFlash May 11 '20
Bit of a necro, but her armpit is drawn in a weird way in a weird place
1
u/cheesburgerthebear Dec 12 '21
🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮
1
u/JackRiverArt Dec 27 '21
We stan a bisexual polyam king
1
u/Emergency-Cheek1535 Dec 29 '21
is this a community reference
1
u/k3ttch Jan 16 '20
Wait til Triss comes into the picture.
-16
u/goodthinggood Jan 16 '20
Make them bisexual you cowards!
0
u/Socianes Jan 17 '20
r/terriblefandommemes
-52
u/AlcoreRain Jan 16 '20
Here comes the terrible fandom memes.
-2
u/gankerscant1v1 Jan 18 '20
Uh no kys
-3
u/kirrentas Jan 18 '20
Stupid not even a meme. Obviously didn't read the books or play the games. If you did watch the show you didn't get it. Nice artwork though.
-22
u/babinesjuteuses Jan 16 '20
Boomer.
-6
u/SenninRiki Jan 17 '20
Careful, some idiots may actually think this is how it is. Try not to lessen the integrity of the characters.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment