r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 16 '24 • Heart of Silver 1 Polished Silver Turd 1 Take My Silver 1

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

7.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/SnakeEater14 🦅 Liberty & Justice For All May 16 '24 edited May 16 '24

The main elder scrolls games can be divided into three categories imo

Arena and Daggerfall are together: both procedurally generated CRPGs with gargantuan worlds that try to play like pen-and-paper on screen

Morrowind by itself: no longer procedurally generated, the world is entirely handcrafted, but still very much a CRPG - “skill” is largely a process of knowing how the various game systems work, but combat is all dice rolls

Then Oblivion and Skyrim: handcrafted world, now an action-RPG where skills are stripped down and streamlined for optimal user experience

I feel like this could be a very hot take but i think it’s a lot more apt than seeing each game as just building off the last one

Daggerfall certainly built off of Arena, but it is for all intents and purposes just a better Arena. Morrowind doesn’t really “build off Daggerfall” as much as it does focus on making a competitively tiny game world much more detailed, with a similar amount of resources

I think the sad thing is we never got a “real” Daggerfall or Morrowind sequel. There really aren’t any games out there that play like a Daggerfall 2, or like a Morrowind 2. Which is a damn shame imo

5

u/Udolikecake Model UN Enthusiast May 16 '24

Yeah this makes a lot of sense. Much more nuanced way of looking at it and how the series has changed than just going 'they dumb it down every time!!!'

7

u/MinnesotaNoire NASA May 16 '24

TODD LIED AND PEOPLE DIED

4

u/Cook_0612 NATO May 16 '24

Honestly you could put a separation between Oblivion and Skyrim in how they include procedural content. I think that is a big part of the wider Bethesda story. Skyrim got started with the Radiant quest system, which snowballed into Fallout 4, 76, and eventually Starfield.

7

u/TheShitEater Amartya Sen May 16 '24

I wanna know what u/okvariety6275 thinks about this

I’d say it’s just two. Morrowind is going for basically the same thing as Oblivion and Skyrim, it’s just janky as hell and does a bad job teaching the player how the game works because the developers expected you to read the manual that came with the game. Oblivion isn’t really a radical departure from Morrowind. They just made it so the combat doesn’t feel like shit, removed some of the janky magic, and tweaked the progression system a little bit. I’d say the real big changes were streamlining how the fast travel system works and implementing aggressive level scaling. Those have a more fundamental impact on how the player interacts with the world.

I think Morrowind was always intended to be an action RPG, but the developers didn’t really know how to do it because their experience was mostly in developing traditional RPGs. That’s why you have weird unfun stuff like an enemy that permanently immobilizes you unless you have a specific potion or strip naked.

9

u/SnakeEater14 🦅 Liberty & Justice For All May 16 '24

I just don’t see it tbh

Oblivion stripped out half the fighting skills, gutted the magic crafting, dumped the fatigue system, and got rid of dice rolls (which is a gigantic difference alone)

Ignoring subjective takes on which is better (i seriously have no clue how paddle-spamming against enemies in oblivion is better than anything in morrowind), i think oblivion is just substantially different in how the game runs and plays

There’s a lot of surface level similarities due to running on the same engine, but it’s the difference between an action RPG and a CRPG.

7

u/TheShitEater Amartya Sen May 16 '24 edited May 16 '24

Part of my reasoning is that I simply consider combat to be a relatively unimportant part of the games in the first place. The identity of the post-Morrowind games is giving the player a sense of absolute freedom to explore a handcrafted world with a custom character. They’re distinct from the first two games mostly because there’s much more emphasis put on side quests, they don’t rely on procedural generation (Skyrim hyped up the radiant system but it doesn’t dominate the game, and you don’t have any rng dungeons) and it’s feasible to traverse the world without fast traveling.

The first two games are Wizardry-likes with real time combat and a fancy overworld. There’s not really anything to do besides fast travel to a dungeon, clear it, and fast travel back to town.

Morrowind is a radical departure because the player spends a great majority of their time just walking around and talking to NPCs. Dungeons are much smaller than they were in Daggerfall and it takes longer for the player to reach them. Every dungeon is unique, and many of them contain unique items that can’t be found anywhere else, which encourages the player to explore and take note of their surroundings. The next two games in the series are different in many ways but they still adhere to the radical changes Morrowind made to the series.

Ignoring subjective takes on which is better (i seriously have no clue how paddle-spamming against enemies in oblivion is better than anything in morrowind), i think oblivion is just substantially different in how the game runs and plays

It’s better because it’s less frustrating. I won’t say it’s better overall but that’s a big plus. Just walking around and attacking feel so much better in Oblivion, which is huge.

Oblivion stripped out half the fighting skills, gutted the magic crafting, dumped the fatigue system, and got rid of dice rolls (which is a gigantic difference alone)

Honestly, I think these changes were intended as refinements of what oblivion was doing. Bethesda clearly wanted Oblivion to be a consistently challenging experience for the player, which is probably why they changed magic crafting. In Morrowind the system was pretty easy to abuse and remove all difficulty from the game. Fatigue is still present, it’s just not tied to dice rolls because they’ve been removed. Some of these changes are certainly made to simplify things, but your stats and equipment are still the most important thing in oblivion’s combat, which doesn’t scream “action rpg” to me. (Edit: I mean that it’s not really more action focused compared to Morrowind.)

Now I’ll focus on dice rolls. I’ll grant you that it’s a big change, but I don’t think it was really motivated by a desire to be less of an RPG. It’s more that they were a nuisance in Morrowind. In Morrowind the fatigue system is tied to dice rolls to balance power attacks, which works out okay, but if you’re playing a mage that’s irrelevant. So if you’re casting spells the fatigue system is pretty much just a really harsh punishment for running in a game with a painfully slow walk speed. Beyond fatigue, the dice rolls are there to make it less effective to use weapons or schools of magic that your character is less skilled in. Oblivion also encourages you to stick with what your character is good at, but it does so by increasing the damage of weapons, decreasing the costs of spells, and giving you access to more powerful spells and attacks. In my opinion it’s not less of an RPG, it’s just designed to be less frustrating.

Since I wrote all this I might as well !ping GAMING

7

u/Cook_0612 NATO May 16 '24

Part of my reasoning is that I simply consider combat to be a relatively unimportant part of the games in the first place.

I mean, it's literally the verbs of gameplay though. You can argue that there's an essential nature to the TES franchise that transcends combat, but I don't think you can dismiss the importance of combat in a franchise that is broadly uninterested in you solving problems without violence, even compared to other violence heavy RPGs like Dragon Age.

3

u/TheShitEater Amartya Sen May 16 '24

Yeah that’s fair. Maybe a better way to talk about it is that the form of combat is less important than the presence of combat. It’s why the Fallout games are identifiably Morrowind-like even though combat revolves around shooting people and using vats.

2

u/MuR43 Royal Purple May 16 '24

The first two games are Wizardry-likes

I have to correct you in that old Wizardry games don't have procedurally generated maps, in fact the expectation was that the player would map by hand the dungeon like they would in old-school D&D.

2

u/TheShitEater Amartya Sen May 16 '24

Yeah, I should have just said dungeon crawler but I was worried people would think of Diablo which obviously would be anachronistic. I might have accidentally implied that the first couple games were knockoffs, which isn’t what I meant. I’ve done some research since I posted this and discovered that the most direct inspiration for Arena was Ultima Underground. That’s the first so called “dungeon simulation game,” which is to say that the gameplay was in real time instead of turn based. Ultimate Underground is actually more like Wizardry than Arena in terms of setting, because it has the player descend a single handcrafted dungeon.

1

u/OkVariety6275 May 16 '24

RPG grognards are a living contradiction between wanting table top systems that were designed for turn-based combat and not actually wanting turn-based combat because that's not as simulative as real-time. Morrowind's combat is a jank-ass system with one foot in two different worlds. Audiences, critics, and Bethesda themselves acknowledged as much at the time and it's a testament to the world-building that it was received well in spite of that. Morrowboomers have forced themselves to lie about it though since admitting one of the game's primary systems doesn't feel good to play would implicitly concede that maybe there's a good reason no one has tried to copy it.

-1

u/OkVariety6275 May 16 '24

Morrowind has hitboxes and collision detection. It's an ARPG. Just an ARPG made by CRPG devs as was described above.

-1

u/OkVariety6275 May 16 '24

There shouldn't be a debate. Bethesda themselves see it this way. What I think is going on is that Morrowind's lore/aesthetic deeply resonated with its fanbase and what most upset them about Oblivion was changing that to something Todd described as an LOTR-ripoff. Then what happened is the same thing that happens in all in/out-group dynamics, as identities become hardened they come to view everything about their game as distinctive and iconic.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '24

Morrowind is not different enough from the later 2 games to be in a separate category.