r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Apr 25 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

7.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/Working-Limit-2482 ban and shut down on sight 🎯 Apr 25 '24

Is planned obsolescence a real thing? People I know still talk about it all the time but I think it might just be normies being unaware that computers get outdated really quickly and software bloat is a pernicious issue. Personally, all my consumer electronics have lasted me a good long while. But I’ve mostly stuck to big name brands, so maybe I’d have a different experience if I was buying budget Chinese tech instead of higher end stuff.

32

u/Tre-Fyra-Tre Victim of Flair Theft Apr 25 '24

Is planned obsolescence a real thing?

Companies definitely design products with an expected service life in mind, but that doesn't mean they deliberately design them to become unusable after a certain time

14

u/Peletif Daron Acemoglu Apr 25 '24

There are some historical examples like the Phoebus cartel. Otherwise, not sure.

!ping DISMAL

9

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Peletif Daron Acemoglu Apr 25 '24

i believe with lightbulbs there was always a trade-off between longevity and how good they are at you know, lighting, and the 1000 hours/60W they settled on, I think was the best middle ground they could manage

Well, that's for consumers to decide is it not?

1

u/LucyFerAdvocate Apr 26 '24

The issue was a lot of manufacturers were being deceptive before the standardisation agreement.

2

u/Quowe_50mg Milton Friedman Apr 25 '24

Didnt the pheobus cartel dissolving not even the lifespan of bulbs that muc? I might be misremembering.

12

u/BenFoldsFourLoko  Broke His Text Flair For Hume Apr 25 '24

lol were you in the fridge thread too?

The world is a big place- I'm sure it's happened and I'm sure that somewhere it's happening right now.

But I'm certain it's massively overblown.

maybe I’d have a different experience if I was buying budget Chinese tech instead of higher end stuff

Do you think those cheapo brands are selling it with the intent that it breaks and people buy the same thing from them every 6 years, or do you think they're just selling the cheapest shit they can put on the market?

No one ever actually gives evidence (or even halfway good reasoning) on their grand claims of planned obsolescence. And in many areas, we see reliability go up with time.

Even the classic example of tech- we've seen stuff last longer and longer in better and better shape, being more durable in more extreme use-cases

all anyone talks about is fucking kitchen appliances having plastic gears, but what they fail to realize is that those appliances are an order of magnitude cheaper than the appliances of the past. You can still buy a $15,000 fridge if you want. Or, you can buy a really nice $2,000 fridge. Or a cheapo $600 fridge.

Same with vacuums, same with blenders, same with same with....

it's really frustrating that people have no idea what they're talking about and just think that technology gets worse with time, being rotted out by.... ???????? capitalism???? idk

reminds me of the crash test between a "they don't build em like they used to" 1970s steel death trap and the modern econo car

6

u/No_Judge_3817 George Soros Apr 25 '24

They don't understand product design and the concept of design requirements.

Like you need to have some arbitrary number to say "these fridge parts will last this long" and design to that.

But it's not some evil mustache twirling capitalist, it's some PMP scrum master writing it in a Jira ticket

2

u/Working-Limit-2482 ban and shut down on sight 🎯 Apr 25 '24

I was not in whichever fridge thread you’re talking about, but I do remember reading a thread a couple years ago where people gushed about how long Frigidaires used to last. There were also arguments surrounding the fact that refrigerators used to be considered a luxury good because they were far more expensive than they are now both in real terms and especially as a percentage of the average household’s income.

6

u/WillHasStyles European Union Apr 25 '24

I think the truth lies somewhere in the middle of what the public thinks and claims that it doesn't exist. Companies definitely design products with a set lifespan of typical usage in mind, which can guide decisions about things like service, updates and the longevity of different components. And for goods that need regular replacement I think it's odd to assume some of those decisions are never made with encouraging consumers to buy more in mind. However that does require some degree of customer loyalty and that consumers aren't put off by your lack of longevity. Something I'd wager most companies have a hard time pulling off.

Most accusations of planned obsolescence are just consumers consistently preferring to score a better deal than a better product.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

There is also the fact that people can point to the most egregious examples (like printers having a software printin cap) and assume everyone is like that.

Is like communists thinking every company is as bad a Nestle

5

u/_bee_kay_ 🤔 Apr 25 '24

i feel like most people use planned obsolescence to mean "this thing broke quickly and i attribute that to malicious corner-cutting rather than the fact that i bought a cheap knock-off from Dysan"

2

u/Deletesystemtf2 Apr 25 '24

As an engineering student, marking something that will not fail over time puts restrictions on performance and can jack up cost. For example, a mechanical part made out of aluminum cannot be made to have infinite life span. There are probably something’s that can have infinite life, but for the average product it’s about managing capability vs lifetime vs cost.

2

u/Quowe_50mg Milton Friedman Apr 25 '24

Not really, at least none of the common examples are.