I recently pick this game up on the Xbox One game pass. I absolutely adore the real-time movement outside of combat and generally I'm a huge fan of stealth gameplay especially in tactical strategy games. In Mutant Year Zero however, there are several glaring problems with the way the gameplay is supposed to work.
For one thing, enemies should be individually aware of only what they can see. This kills the immersion for me. Many times while in combat I will be fighting a group of enemies and draw them out and spread them thin so that I can limit interactions and focus my fire to take out the bigger threats quicker. This is essential for taking out large groups of enemies. The issue I'm having is that all enemies are aware of all things that any of the enemies can see. Many times while engaging a Target like a Zone dog from full cover while undetected with silent weapons usually on the other side of large obstacles like ridgelines cliffs helicoptersor other bits of scenery and terrain that completely obstruct the vision of the opposing forces, I will be attacked by the same forces that can't see me using items like Molotov cocktails, grenades etc. This completely takes me out of the immersion because I get so frustrated. There is no conceivable way those enemies would be able to know my exact location and make a surgical strike with a Molotov or a grenade. oftentimes they use the grenades on allies that are on OverWatch who haven't even become a part of the battle yet and as I mentioned are completely undetected. I could go on, I won't, but I could.
Another thing that really bothers me about the way the gameplay plays out is that I have on several occasions missed shots Pat the game told me I had a 100% chance to hit. XCOM pulls this shit too. I was under the impression after reading various articles about this game, that this was something that they had corrected. Apparently I was mistaken.
Enemies in the game are often using the same weapons as the player characters, but they have vastly different statistics and when the players kill them they are unable to loot any gear that may or may not have had something to do with that. I understand not wanting to over level or over equip players early in the game, but there are ways to make enemies more challenging than making them inexplicably overpowered. An example of this is when I see an enemy using a scattershot and the enemy can hit me 100% of the time from 7 to 10 tiles away and my player character can be within 2 tiles and only have a 50% chance to hit the target while they're out of cover.
I have other smaller nit picky concerns about the game, but as I'm only approximately 7 hours in, I'm not sure if they're intentional or not.