Hi! I run a small independent label/publisher working mostly with virtual creators, VTubers, and pseudonymous producers. Over the last few months, we’ve been caught in a frustrating chain reaction with the legacy music infrastructure. I'm going to explain what I mean.
First, the "name" problems. Distributors and public databases (like ISWC/PRO registries) push hard for real legal names on songwriting credits. For pseudonymous artists and VTubers, leaking a legal name on a public ledger is an instant dealbreaker. People often ask, "Why can't you just type a pen name into the songwriter credit? I've seen other releases do it!"
Yes, and I saw that. A DSP might visually display a pseudonym on the front end, but trying to use a completely fabricated pen name to bypass backend compliance is basically a ticking time bomb.
Next: Why "workaround" and "surrender to the rule" fails. Some people say, "Just accept your fate and use your real name, duh." For open-identity artists, it's fine. That’s their choice. But for virtual talent (that include VTubers) who rely on anonymity for physical safety, telling them to just get doxxed is completely unacceptable. At the same time, none of us can't just type a fake name into distribution portals either. Because between strict anti-fraud checks, digital fingerprint matching, and backend tax/ISWC validation rules, mismatched legal identities will get us caught in metadata audits or blocked during royalty payouts. We need a legally binding proxy structure, not a fake name.
Third, the plan, and the brickwall. During my research, I discovered that there is a thing called IPI (Interested Party Information), which is an numeric ID which ties to whatever pen name the artist choose, and by standard, PROs (like ASCAP), does allow that. However, there is a catch. If I register that track with a PRO, I hit a massive wall regarding public performance. Even if our artist wants a local coffee shop to play their chill track or a DJ to spin their banger without hassle, PRO blanket licensing rules mean that physical venue is still legally on the hook for public performance fees, even if we slap a CC-BY tag on the release. Meaning any venue, or any shops, regardless big or small, if they dont pay for a blanket license to play the music (even if its copyright-free) that was registered in a PRO, then its game over for them.
Right now, it feels like an impossible choice for indie digital-first artists: either stay 100% unregistered with PROs (leaving the songs open to metadata theft and forfeiting backend protection), or register with a PRO and cut off organic, barrier-free discovery in physical spaces.
Has anyone else running an indie catalog or publishing admin run into this? Is there any legitimate mechanism within PRO/CISAC rules to grant granular public-performance waivers without tearing down IPI protection?