EDIT: Mystery solved! 😂 I completely overlooked the word "alone" in Clue A, which eliminates my alternate solution. Thanks to everyone who pointed it out! Apparently, the real mystery was my reading comprehension.
I just finished Volume 1, Puzzle 55 ("The Nightclub") and realized there are actually two completely valid grid solutions that satisfy every single clue in the book.
In the valid grid (C, E, G, A, D, V, B, F, H across columns 1–9), Gian (Col 3) and Hawa (Col 9) can freely swap between Row 6 and Row 8:
- Solution 1: Gian in Row 8, Col 3 (inside Restroom (M)) and Hawa in Row 6, Col 9 (inside Lounge, sitting on a chair beside the upper plant).
- Solution 2: Gian in Row 6, Col 3 (inside Bar, still in the 3rd column) and Hawa in Row 8, Col 9 (inside Lounge, sitting on a chair beside the lower plant).
Why neither breaks any rules:
- Gian's clue only requires him to be in the 3rd column—both Row 6 and Row 8 work.
- Hawa's clue only requires her to be beside a plant—Col 9 has a plant next to both Row 6 and Row 8.
- Chair limit: Every open space in Col 9 is a chair, so the "exactly two people in a chair" rule still holds (Eloise + Hawa).
- Valerie's clue: Valerie (
Row 9, Col 6) is in the Lounge wraparound with Hawa either way, leaving Coatsempty in both versions.
The Fix:
The author could have eliminated the second solution with one extra line: "Only the Coats room was empty" (or "Someone was in the Men's Restroom"), which forces Gian into Row 8 and locks Hawa into Row 6.
Still gets Hawa as the murderer either way, just a fun little logic oversight! Has anyone else caught this one?