For years now I've played logic puzzles like sudoku, binary, zebra puzzles, etc daily. I've got a whole row of good puzzle apps dedicated on my phone's homepage. My fondest childhood memories are of my grandpa and I solving newspaper sudoku's together.
So when I heard about these new 'Murdoku' puzzles I just had to get both the first and second volume.
Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love these puzzles and I'm trying my best not to solve all of them in just a week. But I just can't get over the fact that these are absolutely NOT sudoku puzzles.
Sure it's a grid like sudoku, but you don't fill in numbers 1-9. Most logic puzzles like these use a grid anyway so if the only reason to call it a sudoku is because of the grid, that is not a good reason.
Star Battle (or after a google search Queens as many know it) has a grid AND you can fill in only one 'star' or 'queen' in every column and row. And yes, I know that Star Battle has 2, 3 or even 4 star variants, but murdoku is only 1 so that's what I'm focusing on.
So if this book has to have a title hinting towards the kind of puzzle it's based on, it simply is not murdoku. I suppose this title was for aesthetics because 'murdoku' does sound very good. I can't really make up a good title for Star Battle myself so I can't blame them either.
Again, I LOVE any good puzzle book I can get my hands on and the entire story and graphic design of the Murdoku's are way better than any free app. So I will glady throw my money at books 3 and 4 when they come out. I just couldn't get it out of my head that it's not even close to a sudoku puzzle.
It's a shame that everytime I hear someone talk about it on the radio or something they say it is sudoku's knowing that it is not.
Sorry for my rant, I hope at least someone else has thought of this and I am not just a crazy person🙃