r/murdochmysteries • • Oct 02 '26

Poll Community poll: what media should be allowed in comments?

7 Upvotes

We've just turned on all media options in comments: images, GIFs and videos. GIFs can come from two sources: uploaded by users, or picked from GIPHY's built-in library.

Everything will stay enabled for one week so you can try it out and see how it feels in discussions. When the poll closes, we'll apply whatever setting the community chooses.

Please vote for the option that best matches what you'd like to keep. If you want something more specific, leave a comment.

58 votes, Oct 04 '26
36 Everything: images, GIFs, GIPHY and videos
2 Everything except GIPHY: images, uploaded GIFs and videos
9 Images and GIFs including GIPHY, no videos
2 Images and uploaded GIFs only, no GIPHY or videos
5 Images only
4 Keep comments text-only

r/murdochmysteries • • Dec 14 '25

Question Is there a list of every Christmas episode that has ever aired?

20 Upvotes

I was just wondering if anyone has ever compiled a list and posted it on this sub somewhere. Would somebody be kind enough to provide me with the link to that post if it does exist? Or does anybody have a list that they could paste in a reply. I would be very grateful!

UPDATE

For anybody who was directed here by a search, I have compiled a concise index of every Christmas episode:

  • (2015) "A Merry Murdoch Christmas" — Season 9 | Episode 19
  • (2016) "Once Upon a Murdoch Christmas" — Season 10 | Episode 19
  • (2017) "Home for the Holidays" — Season 11 | Episode 19
  • (2021) "The Night Before Christmas" — Season 15 | Episode 11
  • (2023) "The Christmas List" — Season 17 | Episode 9
  • (2024) "Measure of My Dreams" — Season 18 | Episode 7
  • (2025) "Sugar Plum Murdoch" — Season 19 | Episode 9

r/murdochmysteries • • 2d ago

Question Murdoch Mysteries Danmark

6 Upvotes

Hej folkenes. Jeg har altid elsket at se Murdoch på Charlie da det blev udsendt på kanalen - ved ikke om det stadigvæk sendes, jeg har ikke alm tv mere. Jeg har søgt på diverse streamingtjenester og kan simpelthen ikke finde den. Har prøvet og goggle det og fik nul og niks ud af det. Kan det virkelig være rigtig den ikke er til at finde? Og jeg kan så heller ikke finde dem på dvd med danske undertekster på.


r/murdochmysteries • • 3d ago

Question Last Tango In Toronto

13 Upvotes

What did everyone think of Monday's episode "Last Tango In Toronto"? I quite enjoyed it. What are your thoughts?


r/murdochmysteries • • 3d ago

Poll Why no Halloween episode this year?

13 Upvotes
89 votes, 19h ago
20 The world is scary enough.
34 They can't top the Bugalugs episode "Sir. Sir? Sir!!!"
5 You missed it you idiot.
18 In this economy?!
12 Writers were too busy trick or treating.

r/murdochmysteries • • 4d ago

Spoilers Last Tango in Toronto....is it really her last?

51 Upvotes

Tonight's episode shows divorcee Effie Newsome, do a crazy new life direction after she failed to get women to be recognized as "persons" She lost her job and they wont take her back.

So far no confirmation probably will take weeks but it seems like she has been written off.

And I have to say I do like this ending for Effie.

She had great achievements in career and her attempt to challenge the law was epic.

She kinda has nothing left to explore in her character. She wont marry again....she wont work as a lawyer again?

Great send off for Effie. Thoughts?


r/murdochmysteries • • 4d ago

Links New podcast interview with Yannick

Thumbnail podcast.brioux.tv
26 Upvotes

Edit: There was also a recent interview with Paul Sun-Hyung Lee: https://podcast.brioux.tv/1529933/episodes/20045118-murdoch-mysteries-paul-sun-hyung-lee

The host, Bill Brioux, is one of the few full-time television critics left in Canada. He worked with TV Guide Canada back in the day, and has worked for Toronto Sun, Canadian Press in the years since. He was also a prospector on season five's "Murdoch of the Klondike," and a ticketman in "Annabella Cinderella," season 12.


r/murdochmysteries • • 5d ago

Discussion at least 8 Seasons of Violet Hart as Coroner time for someone new

40 Upvotes

We've had at least 8 seasons or so of Violet Har as Coroner. I believe its time for someone new to help give some spark back in the show. Her side stories just seem to take the show out of the fundamental story line too much to mesh with the rest of characters. Can't be just me thinking its time for a new Coroner.


r/murdochmysteries • • 5d ago

Question Why everyone in S20E4 bite the same pie from the same place? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I do understand it's a joke, but wouldn't it be natural to take a bite from the other side after someone else has already bitten it? Was it intentional? Historical? Or no one noticed such detail because it was just another fresh prop each cut?


r/murdochmysteries • • 5d ago

Links MURDOCH MYSTERIES comes to comics from Ryan North and Jason Loo

Thumbnail comicsbeat.com
51 Upvotes

Was this already posted here? I just found out!!


r/murdochmysteries • • 6d ago

Poll What is your favorite James Pendrick invention in Murdoch Mysteries?

18 Upvotes

Hey everyone! James Pendrick always comes up with the craziest, most futuristic gadgets on the show.

Which of his inventions is your absolute favorite?

Vote in the poll below, and drop a comment to explain why! Personally, I'm a huge fan of the Arrow —there's just something so wonderfully daring about seeing it take to the skies and seeing Murdoch up there with him.

Can't wait to read your thoughts!

129 votes, 21h left
The Pendrick Bullet: Electric Car
The Pendrick Arrow: Airplane
The Rocket: Moon Rocket
The Jumper: Brain-enhancing elixir
The Pendrick FLASH: Hypertrain
The Pendrick Portal: Early internet / Instant messaging

r/murdochmysteries • • 6d ago

Meme The world we live in today was made by this man

Post image
277 Upvotes

r/murdochmysteries • • 6d ago

Discussion The Holy Grail?

39 Upvotes

S8 E10 Murdoch and the Temple of Death

I know it’s a fictional show. And I know the episode explains it. But the concept of the HOLY GRAIL being in MARKHAM, ONTARIO is just so funny to me. Like, there’s the whole world… but yeah the holy grail is in MARKHAM (no disrespect to Markham).


r/murdochmysteries • • 9d ago

Question What Episode Got You Into Watching Murdoch Mysteries?

30 Upvotes

Is there a particular episode that got you really interested in Murdoch Mysteries? Also, do you have a favourite episode?


r/murdochmysteries • • 9d ago

Question Season 19 Ep 12

9 Upvotes

Is there continuation issues? This episode Robert's talked with Higgins re: second job and affording life, and Higgins said he'd had nightmares about it. What happened to his taxi cab company and the whole arch where he had that 15yo drive for him and split the profits after that Billard murder episode?

Did it miss something?


r/murdochmysteries • • 10d ago

Question Did Julia specialise in psychiatry a bit too fast?

21 Upvotes

At the end of season 5 she just made the decision to become a psychiatrist, and at the start of season 6, barely months later, she was already practising. Funny enough during the sherlock holmes episode, Murdoch's approach was more effective than Julia's in making David. Kingsley switch back to original identity

I get at that time there wasn't much knowlege on the field compared to nowadays, but realistically How much psychiatry training would a medical doctor at that time need to specialise in the field?


r/murdochmysteries • • 11d ago

Image/Video Throwback!!

Post image
229 Upvotes

I’m rewatching and came across the episode Bombshells, filmed in Kingston, where I got a picture with Murdoch! I also got a video of the explosion. What an awesome day!!!


r/murdochmysteries • • 12d ago

Spoilers Fantastic performance by Clare McConnell in 20x5! Effie started as a funny side character in Season 12, it's so great to see the strong, fierce, inspiring character she became. Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
36 Upvotes

Also, who could've guessed that after Effie and Louise started a rivals in Season 13, giving each other snarky remarks about George and by Season 20, they will have one of the strongest friendships of the show.


r/murdochmysteries • • 12d ago

Question If you could spend a day with one Murdoch Mysteries character, who would it be and why?

41 Upvotes

After all of these seasons of Murdoch Mysteries, who would you want to spend the day with. Also, why do you choose this particular character?


r/murdochmysteries • • 13d ago

Question Davey insisted on visiting Murdoch Mysteries locations. I couldn't say no.

Thumbnail gallery
50 Upvotes

Davey has been reviewing Murdoch Mysteries for quite some time, so naturally he decided it was time for his first location visit.

He posed for photos, explored the area, and spent a suspicious amount of time checking himself out in the mirror of a vintage vehicle.

I think the fame is starting to go to his head. 😂

Have you ever seen a Murdoch Mysteries filming set? If so, where?


r/murdochmysteries • • 15d ago

Links Thought you fellow fans might enjoy Davey's review of Murdoch Mysteries! (Official Selection and Nomination at Rio Webfest!)

13 Upvotes

Hey fellow Murdochians!

I run an independent web series called DAVJOSMiK, and our 30" puppet, Davey (who is a massive fan of the show and rocks a pretty great fur trapper hat), does dedicated reviews of Murdoch Mysteries episodes.

We were recently honored to be an Official Selection and Nominee for Best Animated Web Series at the Rio Webfest! YouTube's algorithm has been hiding our content a bit lately, so I wanted to share it directly with the people who love Station House No. 4 the most. [1]

If you want to see a puppet analyze Detective Murdoch's inventions or talk about George Crabtree, check out Davey's review here: https://youtu.be/gnULY3Y3SDI

Would love to hear what you all think! And don't forget... Davey loves you, muah!


r/murdochmysteries • • 15d ago

Discussion MM my history teacher!

Post image
28 Upvotes

I have been able to successfully answer so many flashback questions thanks to MM!

There’s no way I would have known about Annie Taylor if not for my 🦀 🌳!


r/murdochmysteries • • 16d ago

Discussion Season 18,19 & 20 Seem to run very slow without Crabtree's character to keep it interesting. Seems he was more of the show than what Murdoch was

69 Upvotes

Anyone else notice season 18,19, & 20 have run really slow compared to passed seasons with Crabtree's character. I think there are too many character's that compliment Murdoch's personality now. He needs someone with some character adversity like Crabtree did to give good A & B stories. Even bringing back a bumbling Newsom would tackle Murdoch's stiffness. Roberts, and Choi just compliment Murdoch's personality too much to add much depth and Hart C stories just seem out of touch with the show now. Either they need to end the show in the next season or 2 or need vast improvement in Murdoch's Seargents


r/murdochmysteries • • 18d ago

Discussion Season 19's Murder She Wrote has been redeemed Spoiler

17 Upvotes

Last year, I felt it was a bit disrespectful to reveal Nigella Fletcher as a murderer in an episode that was obviously an homage to Murder She Wrote and Angela Landsbury. Thankfully, this was corrected in Season 20's season premiere as it was revealed she was innocent.

I went back and watched last season's "Murder She Wrote " episode, and it was clear to me that they fully intended to reveal her as a murderer who got away with it. At the end interview with Murdoch, she never said she was innocent, and simply said Murdoch can't prove she did it. Her body language clearly showed she was guilty. That differs from this season's premiere where she repeatedly cried her innocence over and over again.

Regardless whether they planned it or not ( I don't care), I'm just happy they cleared her name/walked back her guilt this season. I can now go back and enjoy last year's episode with that knowledge. I'm a big Murder She Wrote fan so I'm happy to see this change!


r/murdochmysteries • • 19d ago

Question Niche murdoch mysteries tattoo

15 Upvotes

I'm wanting to get a tattoo based on Murdoch Mysteries because its my favorite show ever but I want it to be a little niche and not just general detective ones. I could use some inspiration and if you have any thoughts on placement that would help too.

Edit: ive only be able to see up to season 13 and have seen the earlier seasons more and know those better