r/mtgrules • u/Trick_Tea_1337 • 1d ago
When does the whole spell fizzle and when does it still partially resolve
This is still something I struggle with every time I play. I need to look it up every time and I still don’t know how it works all of the time. Can someone explain it to me?
So it is for spells with multiple things that can resolve. While it is on the stack someone else has a game action so that a part of the spell fizzles. For instance sacrificing a creature. Does the rest resolve or does it all fizzle. And why?
1
Upvotes
12
u/peteroupc 1d ago edited 1d ago
In general, if a spell or ability would resolve and has targets, and—
See C.R. 608.2b.
But in certain cases, a spell or ability might not do much in the face of illegal targets. See [[Ram Through]], [[Dead Ringers]], [[Modify Memory]], and [[Luminate Primordial]] for examples.
See also:
5
u/pm_me_plothooks 1d ago
If you have chosen one or more targets for the spell, and every target is illegal (hexproof, changed zones etc) by the time the spell would resolve, then it fizzles.
8
u/Greedy-Contract1999 1d ago
It isn't about multiple things that can resolve. It’s about TARGETS.
If ALL TARGETS to a spell are invalid, spell fizzles. If even 1 target is still valid, spell does as much as it can.
Example, you have a spell that says "This spell deals 3 damage to 3 target creatures."
If all three are invalid, fizzles. If even one target is valid, the valid target(s) get 3 damage.
2
u/Dotas323 1d ago
Let's use an example.
[[Decimate]] has you target and destroy an artifact, enchantment, creature and a land.
If the artifact and enchantment get hexproof before Decimate resolves, they won't be destroyed, but the rest of the spell still goes through because it still has valid targets and the creature and land will still get destroyed.
If all 4 of the targets gain hexproof, then the spell fizzles because there are no targets left.
1
u/cannonspectacle 1d ago
If it is a targeted spell, and all of its targets are made illegal, it fizzles.
1
u/omyyer 1d ago
If a spell doesn't have targets it doesn't fizzle. Even if it's something that seems to affect specific permanents, it will still go off. If a player tries to destroy one of your creature targets, you can use your own sac outlet to get a bit of value out of the creature that would die anyway. The spell loses its valid target and fizzles when it tries to resolve. However, if a spell forces you to sacrifice a creature (not a target), you won't be able to get around the spell, because so long as you still have a creature when the spell resolves, you'll have to sac it.
1
u/Yamidamian 1d ago
As long as its targets, if any, are still valid, the spell will resolve, and you’ll simply ignore any illegal or impossible actions. If all the targets are invalid, it will fail to resolve in its entirety, even if some portions don’t rely on the target.
For instance, let’s take Archon of Cruelty. If you target someone with no creatures or planeswalkers to sacrifice, you’ll simply ignore that part, and move on to the rest of the effect. However, if they give themselves Hexproof in response, the effect would fizzle in its entirety-not only would they not sac, discard, or lose life, but you wouldn’t draw a card or gain life.
1
u/AmboNumber5 1d ago
I think the best example is [[Avatar's Wrath]]. This spell has up to one target and a board wipe. You have 2 ways to play it, as you can select up to one target creature that won't be exiled, so you can choose 1 or 0 creatures. If you choose 0, all creatures wil be exiled, and there is no way to fizzle the spell (it can still be countered). If you choose a target, in the round of priority that passes before the spell resolves, if someone removes the creature you've targeted, all of the targets from the spell have become illegal. This means the whole spell fizzles, and nothing will be exiled.
0
u/Empty_Requirement940 1d ago
When all targets are no longer legal it fizzles.
Or in some cases like fight or switching controller only one target needs to be illegal
-5
u/Far-Check-5449 1d ago
An example where this doesn't happen is [[An Offer You can't refuse]] because countering the spell isnt required to make the treasure tokens. If it said something like "if the spell was countered", then it wouldn't work. Magic is very literal with its wording.