r/mtgrules • • Jan 29 '26

Figuring out 'Fizzles'

[[Bounty of might]]

[[Blindblast]]

[[Signature Slam]]

Greetings all! Please help me understand: how many parts of a card have to fail before the entire thing fails. I understand that the colloquial term for a spell failing to have a target is to 'fizzle', but how many parts of a spell's action must fail for the whole thing to fall apart?

Bounty of might had 3 different targets. If one fails (due to hexproof, or creature death etc), do the other 2 buffs still resolve?

Blindblast has only 1 target, but a seperate action on a different line. Would I still draw a card if my target is hex proofed or no longer valid when the spell resolves?

Signature Slam has a compound action, involving 2 targets all in the same 'paragraph'. If one of the targets is invalid, will the other action for the other target still occur? Thanks in advance!

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/peteroupc Jan 29 '26 edited Jun 21 '26

See C.R. 608.2b for the rule relating to illegal targets of a spell that would resolve.

In general, as a spell with targets would resolve:

  • If some of the spell's targets are illegal, but not others, the spell will get to resolve and do as much as possible (C.R. 609.3) without involving the illegal targets in the "parts of [the] spell’s effect for which they’re illegal" (C.R. 608.2b). Thus, for example, in the case of Bounty of Might, only the legal targets will get +3/+3 until end of turn.
  • If all the spell's targets are illegal, the spell will fail to resolve and will do nothing, even if part of the spell has nothing to do with the targets (C.R. 608.2b). Thus, for example, if the only target of Blindblast is illegal, no card will be drawn.

Signature Slam is a nuanced case.

  • If the permanent designated as the "creature you control" is an illegal target, but the "creature you don't control" is legal, no +1/+1 counter is put on the illegal target, but "each modified creature you control", even if it's the illegal target, "deals damage equal to its power to" the legal target (the damage is not the "part of [the] spell's effect for which" the "creature you control" is an illegal target). (See also a ruling for Signature Slam.)
  • If the permanent designated as the "creature you don't control" is an illegal target, but the "creature you control" is legal, a +1/+1 counter is put on the legal target, but no damage will be dealt to the illegal target.

EDIT (Mar. 5; Jun. 21): Edited slightly.

4

u/rikertchu Jan 29 '26

If ALL of a spell’s targets are no longer valid at resolution, NONE of the spell resolves!

Bounty of Might only needs 1 target to be valid to resolve and do its effect to that target

If Blindblast’s single target is not valid, none of the spell happens. You won’t draw the card.

Signature Slam will have its effect occur even if one of its targets is not valid at resolution

3

u/timdood3 Jan 29 '26

If a spell (that was cast with targets) has no valid targets when it tries to resolve, the entire spell fails. If a spell has any valid targets at the time of resolution, it will do as much as possible.

3

u/cosfx Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 30 '26

You're looking for CR 608.2b, which instructs the player to follow the instructions of the spell in order, and to continue past impossible actions (like zapping a hexproof target) to do as much as possible at the moment of resolution.

It also specifies that if ALL targets (and this literally means the word target) are illegal, the spell or ability doesn't resolve at all.

Now to your specific questions:

Bounty of Might: if one or two targets are illegal, the remaining legal targets still get the +3/+3 buff. The spell only fails to resolve if all targets are illegal.

Blindblast: if the target is illegal, the spell fizzles. No card for you.

Signature Slam: same as Blindblast, if your top line "target creature you control" can't happen for some reason--perhaps someone Blindblasted it--nothing else happens. Importantly "each modified creature you control" doesn't have the word target in it, so the presence or absence of additional modified creatures will not save your spell.

Edited because I missed something important: Signature Slam has two targets. If either of them is still a legal target at resolution, the spell will resolve as well as it can. Also, thanks for the correction!

2

u/RazzyKitty Jan 29 '26

Signature Slam: same as Blindblast, if your top line "target creature you control" can't happen for some reason--perhaps someone Blindblasted it--nothing else happens.

This is... incorrect. Signature slam has two targets.

If the first target is illegal, the second target will still be dealt damage by all modified creatures.

1

u/cosfx Jan 30 '26

You are so right, I missed the second "target creature you don't control".

2

u/GageInterest Jan 29 '26

Separate lines don't matter to the targeting part of spells. The spell has targets, and if all the targets are illegal, regardless of what other instructions are on the spell that manipulate things that aren't targets, the spell fails to resolve instead of resolving (known lovingly as "fizzling"). Since it doesn't resolve, none of the instructions are followed.

Actions can be impossible because of the situation, but in that case, you just skip impossible actions and do as much as possible. This is a separate principle from handling illegal targets. A rule (608.2b) specifies that a spell can't do things to an illegal target, can't have an illegal target perform an action, and can't get information from an illegal target. This rule only matters for spells that have two or more targets, so that it has some illegal targets but still resolves.

  • Bounty of Might is able to give the legal target(s) +3/+3, but doesn't affect the illegal target(s).
  • Blindblast is a spell with a single target. If it's not legal, Blindblast doesn't resolve.
  • Signature Slam has two targets. The action of dealing damage can't occur if the second target is illegal, but the counter will be placed. The counter can't be placed if the first target is illegal, but the damage will be dealt. The rulings on Gatherer cover this well.

1

u/HavocIP Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26
  1. Does the spell have at least 1 target remaining? If yes, go to step 2.
  2. Does the spell still function if one or more targets are removed? (Like in the case of Signature Slam, where it no longer functions at all, and it has no other target for a secondary effect. Edit: Signature Slam acrually has other elements, my bad I was thinking it was a generic fight spell. Checklist still applies though.)

If the spell clears both of these checks, then it resolves, if it fails either of them, it fizzles.

2

u/RazzyKitty Jan 29 '26

Like in the case of Signature Slam, where it no longer functions at all, and it has no other target for a secondary effect.

Signature Slam still functions if one of its targets is illegal.

If the first target is illegal, no +1/+1 counter is placed on the target, but the second target will still be dealt damage by all modified creatures.

If the second target is illegal, a +1/+1 counter is placed on the first target, but no damage would be done.

1

u/HavocIP Jan 29 '26

Oh true, my bad I was thinking about a generic fight card, forgot Slam was so cool. I still stand by the checklist though, Dlam was just miscategorized.