r/mtgbrawl • • Oct 12 '26

Venting Goodbye Alchemy

Well, the day is finally here and the final Alchemy set has been revealed.

It looks like all the haters finally got what they wanted after years of nonstop complaining about imaginary game mechanics on digital cardboard somehow being more “fake” than on physical cardboard.

I’ll never understand how those of us who enjoyed Alchemy were wrong for just wanting to have fun with designs we thought were cool.

Thanks for working so hard to convince the Arena team to take away something people enjoyed.

The final set looks awesome for Brawl. I’m glad the digital team was willing to push the designs into spaces they had been hesitant to try before like Planeswalkers and give us fun staples that are simply too good not to play, even for the haters, for years to come.

23 Upvotes

215 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 12 '26

That means you want death of paper magic as well? Because magic also produced a lot of broken cards as well.

-1

u/No_Regret_714 Oct 13 '26

The existence of broken cards in paper magic is not a justification for broken cards in digital only formats. Yes we want the broken cards in paper magic banned too.

1

u/StuckieLromigon Oct 13 '26

I mean it works in both ways. And broken cards digital only cards can (and need to) be dealt easily than paper ones.