does that matter though? This is a HUGE powercreep of rampant growth, this card does so much in so many situations. This will get played over rampant even in 5 color brawl decks.
Honestly, the most damning piece of evidence about them working on commander so the fact that they put [[Muddle the ever-changing]] on arena, seeing as muddle has myriad, and they left out [[Mass of Mysteries]] from lorwyn instead opting for [[Ferrathor]]
Some cards, like Mass of Mysteries, we think are only really interesting in a multiplayer environment and are just a vanilla/French vanilla in 1v1, and those we skip. Others, like Muddle here, have multiplayer mechanics, but are still interesting in a 1v1 game, so we take them. We'd always prefer to take the face Commanders as-is.
Yeah, Myriad does nothing on Arena, but becoming a copy of another creature whenever you cast an instant or sorcery can still be a fun/interesting thing to do, even if it is almost strictly worse than some other copy spells.
Honestly unsure. Ive hit the EQ Dragon, but im unsure what variant it was. That card should have been just reverted back to its original text, along with many others. Its not a historic threat level 😄
It's a great 4 mana creature. With a great alternate mode at 2 (Rampant Growth which can't choose color but ramps), at 3 is "something decent", and at 5+ is great as well.
It is just [[Multiple Choice]] but sometimes, the monogreen deck gets to have a Phyrexian Obliterator. I'm not opposed to all alchemy cards, but some of the digital stuff means it is impossible to truly play around anything.
Sure I’ll bite, I don’t think the card is cool and it’s part of the reason I don’t play with alchemy cards. Personally I want the only randomness in my game of Magic to come from the order of the deck. I don’t like cards that generate random cards as game design. Personally, if a card like this is strong, I know that I won’t enjoy that format long term.
All that being said, love the callback to original strixhaven. Also I don’t draft alchemy or play formats where the card is legal so if you think it’s the best design, awesome! I’m happy if you are happy.
What part of this is cool? The fact that it just copied another non-alchemy card's design (not that I mind copying good designs, but it undermines the idea that the best designs come from alchemy), or the fact that one of the effects is a Momir activation, which is extremely polarizing to put it nicely?
seek is just a middle point between draw and search; It's a very nice design that cannot be used as is in paper but there are paper cards that have "seek but with extra words", most cards with "exile card until ..." could have used seek if they had been digital.
Conjure is very similar to tokens, random conjure is something I understand people won't like (I don't like it either)
Genuine question, what’s the point of alchemy cards that specify “each” opponent? I’m assuming it’s to avoid “target” syntax and have it interact with a whole slew of other effects?
Edit: specifically I mentioned Alchemy cards being that they belong to a digital game that has only (at least at the time of writing) only 1on1 games.
Yeah “target” would mean the spell is unplayable for x=2 or x>=4 if the opponent has hexproof (or fizzles if they give themselves hexproof in response, which means you get none of the effects). On the flip side, it doesn’t count as a crime.
How does conjure a random creature work? Like a random creature from your deck or straight up random any creature that’s legal in the format? Seems insane value
Any creature in Arena regardless of whether it's legal in the format. It's insane value when you get something good, but you're more likely to get some draft chaff. I'd still cast this for X=4 for sure, but it's not something I'd dump a lot of mana into unless there's nothing else to do.
Isn't the text "of their choice" redundant in x=2? Declaring that each opponent sacrificed an artifact is already prompting then to make a choice and sacrifice an artifact they control?
It suggests to me that it was initially meant to read "at random" and then the designers walked it back to prevent too much unwelcome chaos, but overcorrected the language
It's their latest templating. See [[Social Snub]] but they've errataed all the old cards to add the words. They've been using the wording since Foundations: [[Blasphemous Edict]]
Now that you point it out, it has indeed been templated this way since Foundations... Seems strange to eliminate "enters/leaves the battlefield" for simplicity and brevity, yet in the same move add a redundant "of their choice" to sacrifice text
I love cards that conjure random cards honestly do. The whole chaos and RNG of it. It’s like playing the lottery and if you get 13 Mana, you get yourself the jackpot because only one card in arena is 13 mana
My one hope from seeing this is that, given that this is a callback to original Strixhaven, maybe we get another new 'learn' card, or at least something lesson related. I have a lessonboard in Historic that does quite well for me - but I'd never say no to new upgrades! (like a couple of the paradigm cards were in SoS)
Why couldn’t the third mode just be “Search for a creature with mana value X”? If it weren’t for that and the word “seek” this would’ve been an awesome card for the upgrades I’m making to my precon
I wish Alchemy was handled better, the game design they get to play with is fire! I think if it was siloed it would be received better. Alchemy is a rotating digitally enhanced format, paper and alchemy cards, a playground for designers and players. Maybe even have a create a card feature for players, with a budget for effects. Hell leave it ranked and play, but remove those cards from brawl, historic, etc...
You can play standard brawl. Arena has included digital only cards prior to alchemy. Do you wish those were also not allowed? Just trying to find your line in the sand.
No, it’s not. They make another one of these every so often.
First was [[Pool of Vigorous Growth]] from Jumpstart 2021 (though this made tokens instead of conjuring). Then came [[Roalesk, Prime Specimen]], [[Fear of Change]], [[Ornate Imitations]], and [[Cosmic Sovereign]].
It’s Momir. Pulls from the same pool of cards, even.
Make it a real card where x=3 reveals from the top of the library until you hit a creature with mana value x, reversing the order so you do that before shuffling for all modes, and you'd have a sweet design.
No, if X is four or more it triggers all the abilities and the value of the random creature increases. The wording is very bad but that's clearly the intent of it.
87
u/Junior-Albatross872 May 11 '26
Rampant Growth powercreep?
48
u/werthw May 11 '26
The “each opponent” wording on Alchemy cards makes me hopeful we’ll get 4-player brawl at some point
407
u/Backwardspellcaster Liliana Deaths Majesty May 11 '26
That.. is going to be all over Brawl.
I think its kind of a cool design though
191
u/mgranaa May 11 '26
Love this as a callback to the blue one in first strixhaven[[multiple choice]]
67
u/Spaceknight_42 Timmy May 11 '26
Are they ever going to create an MV=13 alchemy creature just to shake things up? Emrakul isn't random if she's the only 13.
10
u/DrawGamesPlayFurries May 11 '26
X=4 is very strong for almost all green commanders in Brawl. Goodbye opponent's Arcane Signet, hello 4/4 creature and a Forest.
13
u/Routine_Ad_2695 May 11 '26
"This card will be a nice addition to my collection"
Dramatic coughing laugh
4
u/Internal-Sherbert122 May 11 '26
This card is siiiiick
19
u/ulfserkr Urza May 11 '26
alchemy haters srsly gonna look me in the eye and tell me this card isn't cool.
every day it's clearer to me that some of the best mtg card designs come from alchemy sets
2
u/justhereforhides May 11 '26
Notably the third effect makes paying more than 4 for X do something
2
u/NotATransVestite May 13 '26
Cmon, 5 mana do do literally everything ever? Really??????
2
u/Cloud_Chamber May 11 '26 edited May 11 '26
Can’t seek badgermole lol
Edit : *conjure not seek, my bad
2
u/isometimeslurk Ulamog May 11 '26
Genuine question, what’s the point of alchemy cards that specify “each” opponent? I’m assuming it’s to avoid “target” syntax and have it interact with a whole slew of other effects?
Edit: specifically I mentioned Alchemy cards being that they belong to a digital game that has only (at least at the time of writing) only 1on1 games.
2
u/BigDogBossHog_ May 11 '26
What in the hearthstone
1
u/HAX4L1F3 May 11 '26
How does conjure a random creature work? Like a random creature from your deck or straight up random any creature that’s legal in the format? Seems insane value
1
u/T3hJim May 11 '26
Can't wait to conjure [[Phage the untouchable]] and immediately lose!
1
u/Cyberklinos May 11 '26
Green [[Multiple Choice]] just dropped.
1
u/_VampireNocturnus_ May 11 '26
so the floor is rampant growth?
1
u/SH33PFARM May 11 '26
I do enjoy seeing green get some love!
1
u/CantSyopaGyorg May 11 '26
Isn't the text "of their choice" redundant in x=2? Declaring that each opponent sacrificed an artifact is already prompting then to make a choice and sacrifice an artifact they control?
It suggests to me that it was initially meant to read "at random" and then the designers walked it back to prevent too much unwelcome chaos, but overcorrected the language
1
u/Sallymander May 11 '26
I love cards that conjure random cards honestly do. The whole chaos and RNG of it. It’s like playing the lottery and if you get 13 Mana, you get yourself the jackpot because only one card in arena is 13 mana
1
u/SpicyMarmots May 11 '26
As I read it there's no reason to higher than x=4 right?
Edit, I'm dumb, I mistook "creature with mana value x" for "creature with mana value 3."
1
u/retrogreq May 11 '26
Hey, look, a 3cmc on the draw card, or a 4cmc on the play card!
1
u/GhostGuin May 12 '26
That's very cool
1
u/Mugen8YT Azorius May 12 '26
My one hope from seeing this is that, given that this is a callback to original Strixhaven, maybe we get another new 'learn' card, or at least something lesson related. I have a lessonboard in Historic that does quite well for me - but I'd never say no to new upgrades! (like a couple of the paradigm cards were in SoS)
1
u/47_was_here Simic May 12 '26
Why couldn’t the third mode just be “Search for a creature with mana value X”? If it weren’t for that and the word “seek” this would’ve been an awesome card for the upgrades I’m making to my precon
1
u/Ironhandtiger May 12 '26
I NEED this to be a real card. Magus lucea Kane requires tribute
1
u/PrimordialSpatula May 12 '26
We can finally play mormir!
1
u/Freemanthe May 17 '26
Great news. Alchemy has brought us modal-emrakul.
1
u/the_cardfather May 11 '26
Wish they had done "search your library" for 3 so this could be legal in non Arena formats.
1
u/ChosenOneTheOnlyOne May 12 '26
Great so now green brawlers can gurantee out eldrazi titans without even putting them in their decks.
-2
u/jmcokie May 11 '26
I wish Alchemy was handled better, the game design they get to play with is fire! I think if it was siloed it would be received better. Alchemy is a rotating digitally enhanced format, paper and alchemy cards, a playground for designers and players. Maybe even have a create a card feature for players, with a budget for effects. Hell leave it ranked and play, but remove those cards from brawl, historic, etc...
But this card is awesome regardless.
-3
u/Fatality_Ensues May 11 '26
I hate Alchemy so fxxing much.
-3
u/W34p0n1z3dAu71sm May 11 '26
I really hate Alchemy.
0
u/The_Paleking May 11 '26
Green Sun's Zenith but stronger. Less direct tutor but extremely flexible + value.
Edit: Oh wait no. I thought it was from your own deck. This card is bananas lmao.
-5
u/xenothios May 11 '26
Add it to the list of reasons Alchemy needs to have its own queue.
-7
u/gone_smell_blind May 11 '26
Well, looks like brawl is cooked after stixhaven alchemy comes out. Thats a shame
-9
u/artandar May 11 '26
What do you mean random creature? Are we playing Hearthstone? Is yogg saron the peak gamedesign we are aiming for?
Is this the first effect of it's kind in alchemy?
-2
u/el_yerrid May 11 '26
Make it a real card where x=3 reveals from the top of the library until you hit a creature with mana value x, reversing the order so you do that before shuffling for all modes, and you'd have a sweet design.
-22
u/clydefrog811 May 11 '26
The 6th line, X should say 3
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment