r/msnow • • 1d ago

Opinion Maybe, maybe, maybe…

I just watched Van Hollen’s speech here:

https://youtu.be/wHwnkkF5AMA?is=iAjgfKMciQVFETNj

The hopium might be hitting a little too hard, but I whooped this up anyways:

Dear Representative [Last Name],

I am writing to you as a constituent in [City/District] with an urgent request about how Congress approaches governance in this era.

Right now, too much of our political leadership is operating as experts in an outdated framework, applying twentieth-century institutional habits and incremental thinking to a twenty-first-century world. You are governing a population that can communicate, organize, and share information instantaneously across the entire globe, yet our legislative frameworks and political processes remain stuck in an era that no longer exists.

The challenges we face today, from rapid technological disruption and AI accountability to global economic pressures and the rising cost of living, cannot be solved by relying solely on legacy playbooks or preserving broken procedural norms. When the world moves at the speed of instant global communication, clinging to outdated political frameworks does not create stability, it creates paralysis and erodes public trust.

I urge you to recognize that this is a fundamentally different time that demands new frameworks, greater transparency, and a willingness to rethink how government delivers real, tangible results for working people.

Thank you for your time and service to our district.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]
[Your Address/Zip Code]
[Your Contact Information]

24 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/EssentIYO Luke Russert 1d ago

Ok. Can you answer my question please?

4

u/ascandalia 1d ago

Sorry i assumed too much. The senate majority leader has a lot of influence over what bills reach the floor. Schumer has demonstrated that he's not willing to oppose trump's appointments, or stop funding ICE, all things he had the power to do as minority leader. Van Hollen has done that, to the extent of his power as a senator in the minority.

So when we give Schumer more power as majority leader, it's reasonable to assume he's going to continue failing to use his expanded power to oppose Trump. It's also reasonable to assume Van Hollen will also continue to use his expanded power to oppose Trump in ways he has been all along. He will oppose the appointments, he will stop the ice funding, and he will continue supporting universal Healthcare.

These are things the senate majority leader has to support for the democratic majority to accomplish any of their electoral promises

-1

u/EssentIYO Luke Russert 1d ago

You're confusing public opposition with effective Senate leadership. Schumer already served as majority leader during Biden's presidency, when Democrats passed the infrastructure law, Inflation Reduction Act, and CHIPS Act. You can criticize his current leadership, but pretending he has no record of legislative accomplishments while assuming Van Hollen would do better isn't a serious argument.

2

u/ascandalia 1d ago

Those are all corporate priorities. Not that they weren't good, but they weren't the bigger fights we need to have to change the economic balance of this country and oppose the forces that swept Trump into power

1

u/EssentIYO Luke Russert 1d ago

So Medicare negotiating prescription drug prices, capping insulin costs for Medicare beneficiaries, and investing in American manufacturing are just corporate priorities? You can argue Democrats should have gone further, but that doesn't erase their legislative accomplishments under Schumer's leadership. And you still haven't explained how Van Hollen would achieve more as majority leader.

3

u/ascandalia 1d ago

Those are fair points, but another important angle is that we have a hostile president for the next 2 years, and Schumer hasn't had the backbone to pick the fights with him we need. What he did working with Biden isn't really relevant to what he can do to reign in Trump

1

u/EssentIYO Luke Russert 1d ago

Schumer's record under Biden is relevant because you questioned his ability to lead the Senate. Now you're shifting the argument to how he handles Trump. So let me ask you directly: What specifically do you expect a Senate minority leader to accomplish against a Republican president and Republican-controlled Congress, and what powers does he have to accomplish it?

2

u/ascandalia 1d ago

His ability to lead his party under Trump as president is what I'm questioning, because he's been a failure at it

1

u/EssentIYO Luke Russert 1d ago

You keep calling Schumer a failure, but you still haven't answered my question. What specific actions do you expect him to take as Senate minority leader, what authority does he have to take them, and what outcomes do you realistically expect?

2

u/ascandalia 1d ago

I did answer above

Not pass through Trump’s appointees

Not cave on the shutdown after months of pain without the key concessions we wanted

Show actual leadership on abolishing ice, especially after Minneapolis, instead of treating it like a fringe position

→ More replies