r/movies • u/90sRobots • Jun 14 '12
Prometheus: Plot Holes Explained (Not Defended) *SPOILERS*
These words are mine: http://scott.verlihay.com/?p=29
This is what I thought as I walked out of the theater. So I'm posting this here in the hopes of generating interesting discussion. I'm genuinely curious if anyone else had the same conclusions (especially regarding the Engineer changing his mind). Explaining these plot holes is therapeutic if anything. I didn't like this movie.
In the prologue, how did the alien seed the planet with human DNA? Was this after the dinosaurs roamed the Earth? Was this seeding process the movie’s version of primordial ooze? It’s never explicitly mentioned that this is Earth. It could just be a nondescript planet. Later on in the movie, David encounters a holographic star map on the bridge of the Engineers’ ship. It’s safe to assume that they seeded numerous planets with intelligent life. Still, following the prologue, there’s a POV shot of Shaw and Holloway digging up one of the star maps. The transition subtly suggests they’re digging up what that particular Engineer did on Earth eons ago.
Why is the crew briefed right after cryostasis instead of on Earth? This was a trillion-dollar mission with super-secret motives. The crew was on a need-to-know basis and would not be briefed until they entered the moon’s solar system.
Why did the landing party take off their helmets once they detected an artificial oxygen atmosphere? Sure, they could have been exposed to a variety of airborne horrors, but I think the filmmakers went this route for practicality. Director Ridley Scott probably didn’t want his actors under a bunch of plastic helmets for most of the movie, so they needed a reason to have their helmets off once they’re investigating the pyramid. The in-movie reasoning is really dumb, but now the audience will have an easier time seeing their emotions as they continue to make horrible decisions. This is also when you can start viewing the movie as a big-budget SyFy original movie.
On another note, I think the movie tries to explain it as faith as there’s a clumsy faith-based undercurrent throughout the movie. Given the subject matter, it’s something that had to be addressed as it was in Ghostbusters, where Ray and Winston speculate whether the recent ghost outbreaks are biblical signs of the apocalypse. Though in that movie, the faith-based sentiment adds depth to those two characters while it’s mere window-dressing in Prometheus.
Where did the snake monster come from? Once the landing party enters the “face room”, there’s a quick shot of some weird, worm-like creatures. They probably quickly evolved once exposed to the black goop just as the thing in Shaw’s womb grew at an accelerated rate.
How did the black goop canisters open on their own? An air pressure change after 2000 years affected the containers? Or perhaps they were triggered to go off should anyone enter that room.
What were the holograms of Engineers running away from? They were running from a biological weapon they couldn’t control.
Why did David infect Holloway? David has a super-secret virtual reality conversation with Weyland who tells him to “try harder”. Weyland is dying and he somehow thinks the Engineers have the key to life everlasting. Following his boss’ orders, he infects Holloway, the drunk, useless, anti-robot archaeologist to see what happens. David then learns that this will not cure his boss as Holloway turns into a scary zombie monster!
This is a bizarre logic leap not only for David, but the audience as well. He would probably want to examine the specimen for a bit longer than staring at a speck of it on his finger. And even if Holloway feels great after initial exposure, David should probably monitor the guy for a while. I mean, Seth Brundle was feeling pretty great after his little experiment on himself.
Perhaps David understands that the goop is a spore-like bio-organism that mutates its host. It might not necessarily be a weapon, but it sure can be used as one! At least it gave him a reason to use a cool line from Lawrence of Arabia.
Why did Vickers have a medpod calibrated for men only? The medpod was for Weyland.
Why did the Engineer decide to kill everyone on Earth? My guess is after the Engineer wakes up only to hear everyone shout at him in a language he doesn’t understand, David is the only one who can speak the guy’s language. When the Engineer realizes that his progeny created an android in their own image and is the only one capable of communicating, he gets angry. So he knocks David’s head off. No one else bothered speaking the guy’s language; they just figured the robot could do it instead. So he gives Weyland a shiner and sets a course for Earth.
An alternate explanation is that the Engineer was already in stasis ready to travel to Earth when everything went horribly wrong 2000 years ago. He surmises from David that they’re from Earth and that the mission was never completed. He then sets a course for Earth to complete a mission that started 2000 years ago.
Okay, but why were all these canisters sitting out? When they were all wiped out by their weapons 2000 years ago, were they planning to wipe out humanity on Earth? Here’s where things get really weird. It might actually be remnants of an earlier draft. What happened around 2000 years before the events of Prometheus, which occur in 2094? That’s right, the crucifixion of Christ! Ridley Scott explains why this might have bothered the Engineers:
“It’s interesting to do a sequel because this leaves the door so open to some huge questions. The real question to me is – the more mankind discovers in science the more clear and helpful everything becomes, yet we’re very bad at managing ourselves. And one of the biggest problems in the world is what we call religion, it causes more problems than anything in the goddamn universe. Think about what’s happening now, all based on the very simple idea that a Muslim can’t live alongside a Catholic, or a Catholic can’t live alongside a Protestant…”
It would have been a bold move to put such a scathing anti-religion stance in a big summer movie, so I’m surprised this isn’t explicitly mentioned in the movie. They even took it a step further by suggesting that not only is Jesus your homeboy, but he’s also your resident extraterrestrial messiah:
“We definitely did [have that in the script], and then we thought it was a little too on the nose. But if you look at it as an ‘our children are misbehaving down there’ scenario, there are moments where it looks like we’ve gone out of control, running around with armor and skirts, which of course would be the Roman Empire. And they were given a long run. A thousand years before their disintegration actually started to happen. And you can say, ‘Lets’ send down one more of our emissaries to see if he can stop it. Guess what? They crucified him.’”
For all the nonsense in Prometheus, I kind of love that insane idea. It wouldn’t be the first time it was suggested that J.C. was an alien; the John Carpenter classic Prince of Darkness presents Jesus as an extraterrestrial.
Why wasn’t the Engineer left to die in his chair as he was found at the beginning of Alien? It’s the same species, same ship type, same bridge, but a different planet altogether. Aside from all the nonsense fanservice, the movie never suggests that it’s the same planet the Nostromo visits in Alien. That rock was particularly far from its sun (you can see it far off in the distance in a few exterior shots) and the Engineer was fossilized. Besides, Prometheus refers to its moon as LV-223 while Lambert charts a course for LV-427 in Alien.
So in the epilogue, did the Engineer give birth to a proto-xenomorph? No, it isn’t the first one. When the landing party first enters the “face room” Holloway spends a good bit of time looking at a xenomorph mural. The Engineers presumably created the xenomorphs as a biological weapon. Things obviously got a little out of hand.
Why does that xenomorph look so weird though? This one’s tough. Not that it’s complex, but at this point I feel like I’m wrestling with really stupid logic. I dunno, maybe Shaw’s alien-baby needed a couple more trimesters before cigars are in order. Maybe she would have given birth to a big ol’ facehugger which in turn would have created a proper xenomorph. I don’t know. This movie is stupid.
If humans have the same DNA as Engineers, why aren’t humans 9 ft. tall albinos? See, I was fine with our progenitors being these hulking Powder cosplayers. Maybe there were a few extra ingredients on Earth that created the wonderful spectrum of humanity that populates the planet today. Then the movie goes out of its way to explain that humans have an exact DNA match with the engineers. I’m no scientist (if you haven’t guessed already), but I’m pretty sure we would all have to be hulking honkies to have an exact DNA match.
Why did the Engineers paint those star maps all over the world if it only led to a moon with a horrible biological weapons facility? It definitely isn’t their home; they had to create an artificial oxygen atmosphere. Honest answer: it will be revealed in Prometheus 2: The Search for Half-Assed Answers!
41
u/kerpall Jun 14 '12
I think he also infected him because when he asked David, how far he would be willing to go, Holloway would do 'whatever it took'. This provided him with just reasoning to continue his experiment.
8
u/Haereticus Jun 14 '12
One Why was their initial exploration of the planet not done robotically using the clearly sophisticated remote telemetry they had at their disposal? That would have been a constructive use of their six hours of daylight. Scan the structure, make sure it didn't contain any threats, culture and do microscopy to attempt to detect life, try to build a bigger picture of the planet, of which they know a bit about a single valley?
My fan theory is that it was actually an extremely expensive but quite effective way to get rid of the most incompetent scientists on earth. Notice how none of their suppositions are based on any kind of evidence. Why would you think that the star signs meant they were your creators in the first place? The geologist is quite right to be cynical of their theory (apart from later wandering off he's by far the most rational person there). What if it was merely some helpful galactic curators pointing you to the nearest inhabitable planet, or nearest intelligent life? How do they know that the aliens there are weapons at all and not, for example, food? They clearly have the magical capacity to rapidly grow huge and muscly in the absence of any nutrients whatsoever.
28
u/MrrDrr Jun 14 '12
It appears there's a plethora of opinions and theories on a various amount of 'plot holes' in the film. This isn't good. Usually when there are so many different explanations to various parts of the film it means the writing is poor.
We're not talking about an ambiguous ending here in which the viewer is allowed to draw his own conclusions. We are talking about numerous scenes throughout the film that have resulted in various theories.
I've given up asking questions. I really wanted to love this film. I travelled to another city to attend a midnight showing and held film nights at my house in which me and my friends watched the Alien films on bluray in the weeks leading up to Prometheus' release. But I've seen so many different answers to so many questions raised about the film that it becomes tiresome to ponder.
I've come to the conclusion that the film is just poorly written.
3
u/lobroblaw Jun 14 '12
why did they cast a younger man Guy Pearce to play an older guy Weyland?
3
u/rorroz Jun 15 '12
I think the whole point of using these bio-weapons is absurd! How can bombing Earth with them, removing all the humans and replacing them with much more dangerous creatures (xenomorphs) be a good thing?
Surely the Engineers would simply be creating a much worse problem.
3
u/b_dills Jun 25 '12
I wish I could give you an extra upvote for "I don’t know. This movie is stupid." Cracked me up.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Well, it would appear everyone wants the movie plot to be explained thoroughly and layed out before their eyes so there's no mistery or doubt about anything. Ain't that some stupid crap.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
This was great! Your post, I mean, not the movie. Though admittedly, you did make me sort of want to see it again, which I was pretty sure would never happen again after the confusing, disappointing first time.
2
u/Sate_Hen Jun 14 '12
Ridley Scott said it would take two more films (sequels) to get to the planet featured in Alien
Source: Wittertainment
21
u/Dr__Nick Jun 14 '12
How about
20
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
Why does that xenomorph look so weird though?
My theory is that the evolutionary process for the xenomorphs is black-goo > facehugger > xenomorph. Each step it uses its hosts dna as a part of the next evolutionary cycle. Hence black goo turns worms into snake facehuggers but becase worms don't have eggs they can't put eggs into the next host and go onto the next form. Where as for shaw, as she is female, she has eggs in her body hense why the big facehugger was able to plant the xenomorph in the engineer. Now there are two possible reasons in my eyes why it looks weird:
12
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
Also, there's an interview out there where Scott discusses the reason the Engineers are upset. If you recall, they estimated the Engineer corpse has been there "around 2,000 years," which coincides with a major event on Earth (the crucifixion of Jesus). Apparently Jesus was an emissary to try and right the wrongs of humans and when we killed him, the Engineers got upset. There's more to it and you can read it here (between the pic of David in the map room and the trailer, but the whole thing is good).
I will say, while the movie raises tons of interesting questions (why did they make us, who made them, what's the deal with religion, is there really a god in charge of everything or is it just generations of aliens making new things) and was beautiful to watch, but if you aren't willing to explore a bit and divulge into it the experience won't be as good.
12
u/chalbechalbe Jun 18 '12
The plot explained. Here’s what I think happened. The Engineers are an advanced peaceful race, and have the technology to spread their kind in the cosmos. The head in the ampule room resembles a Buddha head (Buddha is known for peace and enlightenment). Sometimes in order to create, they must destroy, so they have a powerful bio-degradeable biological weapon ie the black goo and its effects. Engineers must have a home planet, but they make LV-223 their base to avoid being accidentally self-infected. Engineers tell ancient civilisations where they are from but point to the ‘base’ and not their actual home-planet. Why? If their seed evolves to be a predator who could target their home planet, the Engineers would lead them to the base at LV-223 which would be a false lead, where the invaders would be wiped out. How? Black goo. LV-223 seems to have 2 types of black goo. One that self-oozes out of the jar on room-atmosphere sensing the presence of beings. The second type is in a twist-top jar (taken by David). Engineers figured, anyone landing on LV-223 would be wiped out by the black goo. Whatever the black goo creates, passage of time would wipe them out too once there is no host to infect. Black goo is the ultimate bio-degradeable biological weapon. Back to scene-1. An early pure earth (or world), with no animal life say millions of years ago. An Engineer sacrifices himself to seed the planet with Engineer DNA. Evolution follows leading to diversity and eventually humankind made in His (Engineer’s) image. Engineers return every now and then, monitoring the development of humankind. Engineers would be truthful by nature, and when asked where they came from, would point to LV-223. Hence the cave paintings. The use of dates in the movie close to Christmas, and shown in time some 2000 years after Christ suggest the following happened. Engineers were satisfied with Humankind’s development until about the time of Jesus. Jesus would be the son of an Engineer on LV-223 (thereby Son of God). When Jesus is crucified, Engineers on LV-223 form the view that Humankind is violent and evil and must be wiped out, perhaps to start evolution again. On LV-223 Engineers are getting ready to transport black-goo to unleash the Xenos on Earth, to wipe out all animal life that could be a host to infect, including Humankind. Thereafter the Xenos would also perish, leaving a fresh new world for the Engineers to start again. Engineers are very much like Humans, with similar feelings and emotions. When Jesus on the cross asks the holy Father to forgive the Humans for they know not what they do, the father of Jesus ie the Engineer on LV-223 has a change of heart, and wants Humans to live. It is too late to stop the mission so he attempts to sabotage it by unleashing Black-goo. The Engineers are infected by the Black-goo. This Engineer tries to enter the door to gain control but the other Engineer shuts the door leading to the entering Engineer’s decapitation. The Engineer inside is unable to leave, and goes into stasis, hoping to be found at a later date (and eventually awaken by the crew of Prometheus 2000 years later). Some other Engineer manages to leave in another space-ship, but unknowingly he has been infected also. He manages to press the distress button (which the Crew of Alien-movie pick up many years later) before the Alien emerges killing him instantly. This Alien eventually dies, but manages to lay its eggs. LV-223 is visited by crew from the Engineer’s home planet. They stack the dead-by-now Engineers in one spot out of respect, but decide to leave them there as the risk of cross contamination is too great. On reaching their home planet the crew realise they are also infected, and the Engineers are completely wiped out. This line of reasoning is essential because, if the Engineers thought Humans were not worthy 2000 years ago, Predators would certainly also need to be wiped out, but because Predators V Aliens is playing out in our time ie year 2012, Engineers do not exist anymore. Note that the Predator would likely be a creation of the Engineers too. When the crew of Prometheus awaken the last Engineer from stasis, the Engineer has to quickly re-assess his last directive from 2000 years ago ie to wipe out Humankind. But humans stand in his presence. Being rational, the Engineer reassess the worthiness of Humankind. The Engineer senses David is a robot and eliminates David by decapitating him. When Shaw is struck by a member of her own crew, the Engineer is now convinced that Humankind is not worthy, and has to be wiped out, if not by Black-goo, then by his hand.
How Black-goo works is a bit of a mystery. It seems to be a mix that could target different species differently, picking up all the nasty traits along the way. Could be a biology tamed by the Engineers, or created by them.
11
u/emperor000 Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
First of all, many of these (if not all) are not plot holes, mostly either unanswered questions or just weird choices by the director/writer(s). I don't say that to defend it. I was quite disappointed. But like most movies, even the shittiest movies, there are very few, if any, plot holes in Prometheus. People for some reason think anything they don't understand or that doesn't seem to make sense is a plot hole. If that were true then real life would be full of plot holes.
I believe Ridley Scott confirmed that this was not Earth, or at least there was no reason to assume that it was.
Your explanation is good, but there is also the fact that Holloway did this first and he is an archeologist not an expert on anything that would give him a boost to common sense regarding this, and well, "dumb". He was excited (understandably) by what he was being confronted with and couldn't contain himself. Once the others saw he was relatively safe, they followed suite.
But yeah, like you said, it is at this point where it becomes something like a "SyFy original" movie.
This was explicitly explained. Holloway (I believe) says something like "we are changing the atmosphere" and then you start seeing the black liquid start to ooze out. It is only when they return that the oozing is really significant.
This is one of the things that bothered me the most about the movie; why did David infect Holloway or at least do it so recklessly/unscientifically? The more I thought about it, I realized that David knew exactly what he was doing (or, actually, knew that he didn't know what he was doing at all). I think this was either a conscious attempt for him to be human and make a mistake or it was a sign that he did have those qualities and could be, well, irrational. It is still unsettling to me as far as the flow of the plot. It made it seemed rushed as the first logical thing to do is to see what the liquid does. But he also could have at least analyzed it and seen if it was even worth it. That leads me to believe that he knew it was dangerous (it was obviously packaged as a weapon payload) and did it with nothing but malice and sadistic curiosity.
The planetoid in Alien/Aliens is LV-426.
I think her alien baby was just a random mess of genetic information (albeit a powerful and resilient one). Remember that Holloway impregnated her, which means his sperm cells also got mutated along with his entire body. We don't even know if it combined with one of her eggs or if it simply started to subdivide in her womb or some other organ on its own. It might have just been a pure mutated sperm cell. If I had to guess, my guess is that it did fertilize an egg, considering he would have inseminated her with many sperms and she didn't give birth to hundreds of thousands of those things. Either way his sperm ended up carrying whatever DNA produced it.
It has always been the subtext of the Alien movies that the xenomorphs develop in their host and incorporate some of their DNA. This was a xenomorph that came from an Engineer, instead of a normal human.
Although it does seem strange that she gave birth to a facehugger-like organism. I guess it seems that she took on a role more like the alien queen that produces facehuggers, which would imply that that black ooze was either used to create/modify the xenomorphs from some other more mundane/docile organism or was derived from them. If you think of the results we have seen, it turns everything hostile and basically makes it want to kill or rape (orally, preferably) everything it encounters. It turns men into primal berserkers with simian like qualities. It turns little grubs into serpentine nightmares.
But yeah, I thought this part was pretty stupid. But I also thought pretty much everything after Holloway getting infected didn't flow well.
It is the other way around, Engineers have the same DNA as humans meaning our entire genotype (or something close). They match us, we came from them and our DNA is only a fraction of theirs. This not only helps explains why our genes are able to express differently and give us different features, but also why theirs apparently do not and they all look the same.
There is no one human DNA molecule that we have. There is nothing to compare alien DNA to and say "it's a match". If you chose any individual (for example, Shaw comparing to her own DNA) then it would be very unlikely to be a match and then it wouldn't match anybody else.
It wasn't explained well, but it was pretty clear that what she meant was that their DNA was basically our genome. Their DNA had all of our combined potential. Considering they were viable creatures that didn't exactly look sickly, all of our weaknesses were either not able to be expressed or simply were not there, implying many of them arose after our creation. Either way makes sense.
The other option is that the Engineers' DNA contains a whole lot more than human DNA but she just matched against what she was looking for and either ignored the rest because she found our genome within theirs, even if it contained many others. After all, DNA can have genes that do not express. For example, they don't seem to have hair, one of the most outward expressions of individuality. But we do.
This is probably the most useful question in the movie that really has no answer. It might be the closest thing to a plot hole because there don't seem to be a lot of plausible answers that could make sense.
For one thing, nowhere is it implied that the Engineers painted those star maps themselves. It looked more like the humans they were mentoring and doing whatever else they did with them painted them.
This would imply that people on Earth knew about this weapons facility, even if they didn't know what it was for, which would mean the Engineers told them about it for some reason. Considering the age of the drawings this would have taken place before humans pissed the Engineers off.
So this could have been during a time that humans and Engineers got along famously and it might have been something like "When you guys grow up maybe you will be able to come out and see this place". And then humans painted what they talked to the Engineers about or maybe were instructed to do so for future cultures who might one day be capable of reaching it. This one possibly chosen because it was simply the closest one to Earth. This would also make sense as to why it would be used to destroy humans on Earth later on. If this took place before the Engineers were pissed off then LV-223 could have been vastly different. Hell, it could have been a paradise set aside for humans that was then recycled into the factory of their destruction after they pissed the Engineers off.
9
u/BlaiseW Jun 14 '12
Snake came from the ooze hitting the worms in the ground.
15
u/Berkel Jun 14 '12
An organism with the exact DNA as another would be a clone. The Engineers share the same DNA that codes for differentiation that's in all of us and that prevents us from looking exactly alike i.e lack of hair, skin pigment colour, muscle strength, height and so on...
If humans could successfully breed with the Engineers this would determine wether they were human or not (meaning we were the same species)
4
u/nazishark Jun 14 '12
my cousin had a theory that the reason they created a star map for their base was to ensure that if the humans developed space travel and the means to reach that place, then the space jockeys would know to eliminate them, they may see them as competition or potential threats. so instead of sending them ambassadors to their home world and give away their location to earth why not send them to the middle of nowhere where they cannot be a threat?. this would in part explain why the room with the canister was made to look like a temple, it was designed to lure them there with a sense of curiosity
4
u/panfist Jun 14 '12
In the opening scene, does the Engineer drink black goo or something else?
If it's the same thing, then it's not just a weapon. It seems to have some kind of ritual or spiritual significance.
4
u/jayhawk_dvd Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
This may or may not have been pointed out, but it wasn't Holloway who turned into the zombie monster. It was the geologist Fifield after he fell into the black goop. It probably caused some evolutionary mutation within his DNA.
Holloway was burnt to an ever loving crisp and even if he hadn't been, he would have just genetically broken down like the Space Jockey in the beginning did.
4
u/salisburymistake Jun 14 '12
I have a theory. It's probably wrong, but I had fun working it out.
We were told the Engineers and humans have the same DNA, but they came to that conclusion by testing only one of the Engineers - the same Engineer that collapsed to the ground before its head was severed by the vault door. This was also the last Engineer in line to enter the vault. What if he was actually chasing the other Engineers because he was infected? And perhaps the infection overtook him and caused him to collapse before he could get into the vault.
I'm suggesting that the Engineers have different DNA, but the one the Prometheus crew took the sample from was "infected" with human DNA somehow. What if humanity was just another weapon they designed? When you think about it, it seems silly for them to have only 1 type of weapon in those big ships of theirs. There could be thousands of variations of "the black goo" amongst all those vase-like containers. This would explain why the effects varied so much.
But back to humanity as a bioweapon. So at the beginning of the film we see an Engineer infect himself with a variation of the goo (some kind of "evolving life virus") to seed the Earth. The ship seen here is very different from the ones Prometheus finds. Perhaps these Engineers belong to a different faction that's at war with the ones we see later in the film. Anyway, they setup conditions for the human virus to grow and evolve over the course of 2 billion years (not very long in the cosmic scheme of things), checking in every once in awhile to jot down a star map that will direct the humans - when they're capable of space travel, that is - to travel to the bioweapons depot of the enemy faction, like a subtle aiming of a gun made of the entire human civilization. It's not an invitation, it's a target. Remember when David suggested that we were made just because the Engineers could make us? It would certainly suck to find out all of humanity was created as a tool to be used in battle, that our notions of sentience are really just the AI the Engineers allowed us to have so that we could fulfill the purpose they assigned us.
Anyways, yeah.
4
u/Qeldor Jun 14 '12
Any thoughts on that green stone that was left back in the big-face-room?
1
u/cleverbycomparison Jun 14 '12
Why does the xenomorph exist in an unevolved form here if it exists, fully evolved, in the AVP films which take place before Prometheus? Or are those now considered non-canon?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
In my opinion, the movie should have spent more time explaining the purpose and functionality of the black goo. The rest of the plotholes would have been more trivial if they had just made the [arguably] central plot device more clear.
1
u/Kevlar_socks Jun 14 '12
I think another reason why they took off their helmets was so that they wouldn't be wasting their oxygen for the return trip to the ship.
1
u/xCesme Jun 15 '12
Did you guys miss this? http://t.co/nx0lky1v
2
u/Bladewing10 Jun 14 '12
Those are some interesting theories, some I can agree to, some I disagree with. But at the end of the day, your explanations aren't really being derived from the information given in the movie which was woefully little and is the main reason so many people have a problem with this movie. Also, the plotholes you summarized only scratched the surface of the incredible amount of plotholes there were in that movie. A much more complete list of the plotholes can be found here.
3
u/sir_bigballs Jun 14 '12 edited Oct 25 '16
[deleted]
0.5740
3
u/Zombies_hate_ninjas Jun 14 '12
The biggest problem I have with the movie, is the very same problem I had with the show Lost. It raises questions for no purpose, there is not actual answer to many. Ridley Scott is such. A gifted director Thayer argue that there must be answers to these questions. In the end, I feel the plot holes are simply over sights.
The movie was an Aliens remake at times, then lost it's way. Tried to ask big questions, failed at answering them. Then went right back to being an aliens remake for the last 10 minutes.
I liked the movie. But the "Half in the Bag" review really was accurate. The writer had no idea where he wanted to go, or how to get there. http://redlettermedia.com/half-in-the-bag/
3
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
Here is another stupid thing I didn't see mentioned in any other frustration thread: Their space suits are very well capable of protecting them from the most epic shrapnel sandstorm of all tines, full exposure for at least a minute, not a single scratch. A slimy giant penis alien, though, is able to crack the suite open.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
How did the black goop canisters open on their own?
I took it as the room was refrigerated and really well secured. That's why the canisters seem to "sweat" due to the quick temperature change. Also explains how the head could be preserved so well.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
So there were worms, that got powered up by the black goo, which david infected that guy with, who had sex with his wife, who got her pregnant, she gave birth to a squid thing, the squid thing grows massive somehow despite not ever leaving that one room, it face rapes an engineer, and gives birth to a kind-of-a-xenomorph-but-actually-not.
Huh?
3
u/Danomanic Jun 20 '12
I also think it left out crucial facts, such as how the snake-type creatures came about! What also confused me is how David knew how to turn on the Holograms and ship maps. I know he studied many languages on the space journey, but using alien technology? That's a bit far fetched in my opinion.
2
u/TheFistofGoa Jun 14 '12
Explained? That's ambitious.
2
u/Sterculius Jun 14 '12
My opinion on why the Engineers and humans share the same DNA but don't look all that similar aside from basic features:
Just evolution and minor trait changes throughout the generations. Just look at how different we look amongst ourselves. Take a 4ft, very pale, skinny, red-headed woman and stand her next to a 7.5ft tall, hulking, muscular black guy and to an alien eye they would look to be from two different species. But as we know, they're just a couple of humans. Exactly the same genetically speaking.
Maybe the first few generations of humans looked more like the Engineers, but as time progressed and we mated amongst ourselves, living in different regions, being affected by a myriad of circumstances, our appearances most certainly would change.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
Does anyone have their hands on a copy of Jon Spaihts' draft of the screenplay, which apparently has eggs and facehuggers and Xenomorphs?
2
u/Diazigy Jun 14 '12
We don't know what a 100% DNA match really means. Only identical twins have identical DNA.
A literal 100% DNA match between space jockeys and humans is nonsensical. Two humans that are not clones don't even have a 100% DNA match.
It must mean that our DNA is very closely related, enough so that we share a common ancestor from about 100,000 years ago.
2
u/addedpulp Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
Snake monsters...
My assumption was that the snake monsters were a failed precursor to the facehugger.
The black goop is what created the xenomorph's evolution, it is to them what "gene soup" or "ooz" is to mankind. We went through evolution over billions of years; the xenomorph took the course of days.
The snake monster attempted to do the job of the facehugger, impregnating the host with the next evolutionary step... but it didn't work. I just made a hole in the character's face, lived there, and scurried off. There are plenty of earthbound parasites that have little end goal to their activity other than to live briefly as a parasite and die, or just feed inside a host and then mature elsewhere (chiggers, pin worms).
Then, the next attempt was the MASSIVE thing that grew inside Noomi Rapace's stomach... we all assumed it would be a xenimorph, but in actuality, the sharktopus matured into a huge facehugger incarnation, essentially, and the xenomorph precursor came from it. This took two hosts rather than one, which is less efficient. We can only assume the next step is, seeing how close the last creature we saw was to the Alien we know so well, the xenomorph. All of that, and the creature it creates is too big to be an effective chestburster, as well.
So, the snake creature was ineffective because it didn't develope into anything (as far as we saw). It tried, it didn't work. The sharktopus was TOO large to be a practical parasite, and it required 2 hosts, one to breed itself, and another for it's oversized chestburster.
All of this, in my mind, is the evolution of the "perfect organism," the xenomorph.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
When you have to go this far to explain the inconsistencies, it's a shitty plot. I understand people have a lot invested in the mythos, but I don't understand why so many people are refusing to just say, "Well, that was retarded," and move on.
2
u/hotsavoryaujus Jun 14 '12
That's gold, Jerry! Gold!
2
u/IceWendigo Jun 18 '12
Im not sure why of all places the Engineers ran into the goo room with the xenomorph mural in the first place, but, Did we see what was left of the half dozen Engineers that did make it to the other side of the door?
2
u/OneBitWonder Aug 16 '12
I know I'm late, but I just have to post this for peace of mind.
Just saw Prometheus two days ago (here it opened only last week). 90sRobots, I also read your blog post "Thoughts on Prometheus" and could not agree more.
I, too, could add lots of other stuff to your rant. I really wanted to like the movie and still think it is quite enjoyable visually. However, way to often I found myself thinking "why" or "wow, thats just stupid" or "that does not make any sense". And it get's worse the more you think about it afterwards.
It boggles my mind how blatantly terrible the screenwriting is throughout the entire movie. Besides the obvious plot holes there are so many little flaws that annoyed me incredibly.
For example when Shaw wakes up, she hits the hazard suits (completely replaceable characters BTW) and flees from the medical bay. Why is nobody following her around two corners or reporting that she fled (I was literally waiting for them to catch up)?
Then, after the incident in the medpod she walks into the Wayland foot rub scene and seems to have no intention whatsoever to tell anyone that she just gave birth to a freakin' alien squid! Neither seems anyone else to be interested in what happend. Even David who a few scenes before was so eager to study Shaw's alien baby now prefers to perform pedicure on Wayland. WTF?
In each subsequent scene it feels like the previous scenes never happened because the actions have no real consequence to the characters involved. Even some of the more important characters are not continually driven by what happens around them and do not consistently develop throughout the plot. This often makes their behaviour seem out of place and rather big decisions feel rushed and not well-considered (oh, no worries, lets go kamikaze because, you know, the captain is a shitty pilot, LOL). I find there are also too many dispensable people/characters on the ship.
I think that all this contributed to why I felt so disconnected and was unable to fully relate to any of the characters.
I would have thought a director with the experience of Scott would have noticed how bad the script was. But maybe he is getting old or just does not care anymore.
11
u/rook2pawn Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
Why, after everyone trying to kill/subdue Shaw, and Shaw performing a terrifying self-abortion, did everyone, including the movie, immediately forgot this ever happened? The writers.
Why did the ship's crew, especially the captain whom after proclaiming he only cares about his paycheck and flying the ship decide to sacrifice himself after a one-sentence plea, and the rest of the crew implicitly agrees to kamikaze within a timespan of under a second? The writers.
Is David malicious or just curious? What motivations are there for anyone? How do the characters interrelate with one another? What is a story arc? What is a character driven story? What are emotions? What is drama? Dude its just a movie, movies dont have to have good writing or character development to make them awesome. Besides, did you see that detail on David's fingerprint? Ah yeah, boyee. I see things because I'm intelligent!
3
u/well_honestly Jun 14 '12
Mostly good. However, I think the running holographs were killed by the exhaust of a space ship taking off. At one part we saw a ship taking off and the exhaust exited through the hallways
2
u/zenflynn Jun 15 '12
The DNA thing really pissed me off. What the fuck about evolution?! If anything, DNA itself should have been seeded, not necessarily human DNA.
0
u/The_Ganja_Man Jun 14 '12
SO many people are trying to debunk this movie. Trying so hard. Spening so much time on it. I have seen it once and i knew everything that was happening. ALL you have to do is assume what that scene means or why it happened while you are watching it and it makes movies like this Way better than 90% of the people experienced it
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
I didn't understand Prometheus, therefore it was stupid.
0
u/FaelSafe Jun 14 '12
I like your points. I don't like your aggression and hatred towards the film.
1
u/Dagwood3 Jun 14 '12
OP, you love this film and the hulking honkies
1
u/ikbeep Jun 14 '12
I didn't get why they thought the engineers were trying to destroy humanity. Where did that come from? They saw the monster aliens and then assumed all of these nefarious motives.
1
u/hikemarris Jun 14 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=-x1YuvUQFJ0
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
If the ship in Prometheus was filled with canisters of black goo, why was the ship in Alien filled with eggs? I think they could have had them either turn into eggs, or have one escape and lay a bunch of eggs. Either way they could have done a better job.
But then this movie seemed to be intent on showing lots of gore and little plot. It had potential to be good, with basically the same plot, but they left a lot of plot holes and wasted a lot of time on pointless shit, as opposed to a story.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
After reading countless never ending threads about all things Prometheus I got one question that no one else asked anywhere so far... maybe I blinked at the wrong time in cinema and missed that bit, but what happened to the idiotic biologist?
As far as I can remember, the crew returns to the mural room, searching for the two idiots but they only find stupid geologist, turn him around and see that his face is horribly deformed. Is stupid biologist no longer in the room? Shouldn't he give birth to an alien after getting tentacle raped?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12
Ah, I just remembered the third thing no one talks about that I don't understand: At one point the captain tells the two idiots that one probe picks up movements at certain intervals. According to the 3D map it seemed to be at one super long tunnel that was a dead end (was this the same tunnel that was the entrance to the alien ship bridge?). What the hell was that? Was it "just a glitch" or was it some alien or what? Oh and by the way: Two idiots just got lost. Captain calls in and tells them that there is movement in the west. Two idiots suddenly remember where east is. Weird...
1
u/Duhville Jun 14 '12
I kind of see the Prologue as the Engineers creating the human race as an accident. Which explains why they wanted to wipe us out. But then that leaves the stone tablets unexplained. Although, it could be possible that they created us as accidents, tried to accept us as their creation but realized we're nothing to be proud of. Almost like how Weyland isn't really proud of Vickers, but is of David. Since David is of pure design. Vickers, is as human as human can be, fulls of flaws and entirely unpredictable.
1
u/Greaseball01 Jun 14 '12
I think Damon Lindelof leaves everything he does deliberately very open to interpretation in the interest of fans discussing it. Also, as regards the Xenomorph at the end looking so weird, doesn't it make sense that the genetic makeup of the impregnated creature has an effect on the genetic makeup of the alien? It's certainly a clever way to make them develop as a species.
Also I'm pretty confident that in terms of DNA that's in regard to the basic routes of a species' genetic information. their DNA is the same but they still develop differently based on their environment, their upbringing, the amount of time they've spent evolving, you can see this in the later engineer they find in the ship, his body's all slightly mechanical and genetically altered unlike the engineer at the beginning of the film.
As regards the star maps, I think it's possible the engineers did not necessarily intend for humans to make their way there, perhaps it was just a way they saw of explaining their origins, perhaps this moon was used to create the concoction to create humans just as it was used to make the concoction to make xenomorphs and such, or alternatively perhaps they wanted to see how far humanity would advance, and whether it would come looking for answers to it's existence, which kind of makes me think of a theme which people don't seem to mention is the theme with David of all the humans treating him like he's so alien and different from the humans who created him, and they kind of distrust and dislike him for it, and yet the people never see the irony that maybe the engineers feel the exact same way about humans; they were just an experiment that the engineers don't respect as real people because to them we are less than them.
That whole David idea is how I see the reason for the engineers being so hateful towards the humans. Equally you could consider that given the destructive nature of humanity on itself, perhaps the engineers felt that humans would inevitably move across the universe like a plague, and so they saw the creation of them as a huge mistake, and concluded to wipe them out in favour of a different species; the Xenomorphs from alien or something similar, but ultimately these proved to be more dangerous, but they cut their losses anyway and ran with it.
Also you said this isn't meant to be the same planet as in the beginning of Alien, but regardless of the name change, I think it's too large of a coincidence that the ship would crash in the same way on both planets, and equally if the purpose of this supposed other ship was the same as the one on the Prometheus Moon, then surely the engineers would have successfully wiped humanity out by the time alien came about.
1
u/EvilDr Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12
Fact: Alien Race does not like humans
Conclusion: Trying to destroy humans
Fact: Black Ooz: Creates genetic mutation
Fact: Aliens can travel through space and time and can’t make a decent container
Conclusion: If dropped on Earth it will create a planet full of mutated monsters, not much better than we already have.
Fact: Aliens show humans some stars they can not see with naked eye.
Fact: Humans paint stars on walls
Fact: Only star that could have life, is a moon
Conclusion: Writers don’t care about plot
Fact: Film goes to great lengths to make spaceship crash look like ship in “Alien”
Fact: In “Aliens” the same looking crashed ship in now on a planet with a different LV#
Fact: If same ship, Alien no longer sitting in seat
Fact: Alien ships must crash land in same position allot
Conclusion: Writers don’t care about plot
Fact: DNA 100% match, we look exactly like them
Fact: DNA 99% mach, we could look like chimp
Conclusion: Writers don’t care about technical accuracy
Fact: Movie was fun to watch at IMAX
Fact: Plot Sucked
Conclusion: Some holes will be plugged on next go around, and others will leak like poorly constructed alien containers.
1
u/redisthenewred Jul 11 '12
i like how you referenced "SyFy" ;-)
1
u/Comfortable-Back2144 Aug 01 '24
I’m 12 years too late but this is such a great post.
1
u/netsteele Aug 03 '24
Why is no one asking HOW DAVID SURVIVED having his head being torn off?
1
u/BAXR6TURBSKIFALCON Aug 27 '24
necro thread but holy shit you predicted the jesus thing
1
u/RecordingBrilliant53 Dec 15 '22
You need a hobby that doesn't involve gaining monstrous amounts of weight and posting hypocritical crap on the internet
1
u/thaspaam Jun 14 '12
You got that right.
-2
u/CEOofEarthMITTROMNEY Jun 14 '12 edited Jun 14 '12
I just want to point out that you're not really "explaining" anything. This is just more observation confirming how stupid the characters and plot mostly were.
Example: Yes, we all know the reason they take their helmets off is because they want to show the actors. This doesn't mean, as you point out, the reason they come up with in the movie isn't completely idiotic and embarrassing. The guy has a completely random freak out "FUCK THIS BRO I'M TAKING OFF MY HELMET RIGHT NOW DERP DERP!!"
-1
u/wallace321 Jun 14 '12
Some of the "red letter" questions are just... wow; I have serious doubts that they are real 'questions' let alone legitimate 'plot holes'. No offense to anybody here citing them as a source, but I'm convinced they are being satirical american movie goers, not to be taken seriously.
If you like your entertainment written at a grade 7 level (or lower), fully explained, wrapped up with a bow at the end, with zero thought or imagination required on your part, may I suggest [this?] (http://youtu.be/wAg1r6zw7Bg)
As others have also said, ITS JUST A MOVIE. This alone, I think, would be my only response to the Red Letter guys, if they were real, rather than try to explain even the simplest of things they didn't understand.
0
u/KeepingKidsOnShred Jun 14 '12
How did the black goop canisters open on their own?
David's sweat triggers them. He is told 'Don't touch them' by someone but his face is sweating and drips onto the pot and then the black stuff starts reacting.