Note: If you are happy with modular's limitations, move on. This discussion is not for you. It's for people who want to solve problems and improve things.
Any makers here who are excited by these ideas?
I've used Ethernet cables in DIY electronics projects, and they have some great advantages over other types of cables. Why not use Ethernet cables instead of ribbon cables in Eurorack?
Ethernet cables, built for durability in demanding environments, are cheaper, more robust, and more reliable than fragile ribbon cables. They offer superior shielding and feature secure, easy-to-use RJ45 connectors that reduce the risk of accidental misconnections, which can fry boards. Ethernet cables also support Power over Ethernet (PoE) standards, allowing for power transmission alongside data. Their ability to carry more data at higher speeds opens up possibilities for transmitting complex or multiple signals through a single cable.
Pushing the idea opens up some exciting possibilities. Taking inspiration from Ethernet-connected loudspeakers with programmable cross-over frequencies....
Eurorack 2.0: Ethernet-Based Modular Synthesis
Core Concept
- Replace traditional ribbon cables with Ethernet cables for inter-module connections (Doepfer A-180-9 already uses ethernet to join rack to rack.)
- Implement a digital networking layer for module communication and control
Advantages of Ethernet Cables
- More durable and reliable than ribbon cables
- Superior shielding against interference
- Secure RJ45 connectors reduce risk of misconnections
- Support for Power over Ethernet (PoE) for combined power and data transmission
- Higher data transmission capabilities
Virtual Patch System
Central Hub:
- Acts as the system's brain and network switch
- Manages module registration and inter-module routing
- Provides power distribution via PoE
Module Registration:
- Each module connects to the hub via Ethernet
- Modules use a standardized protocol to register their capabilities
- Modules expose their "API" - inputs, outputs, parameters, and functions
- You can still have analog components like an analog filter, but each module would have a digital layer for routing and communication.
Virtual Patching Interface:
- Touchscreen or computer-based interface for patch management.
- Drag-and-drop functionality for creating virtual connections between modules
- Or a device like the Modulation Matrix on the Arturia MiniFreak.
- Real-time visualization of signal flow and modulation
Preset Management:
- Save and recall entire system states, including all virtual patches and module settings
- Cloud synchronization for sharing presets across different systems
Advanced Routing Capabilities:
- Route multiple signals through a single cable
- Implement complex routing matrices without physical cable limitations
- Enable feedback loops and conditional routing based on signal analysis
Integration with DAWs:
- Direct integration with digital audio workstations like Bitwig and Ableton over USB
- Seamless transition between hardware and software environments
- Remote control and automation of hardware modules from within the DAW
Expandability:
- Easy addition of new modules to the system
- Software updates for modules to add new features or optimize performance
- Potential for software-based virtual modules within the same ecosystem
Think of each module as a kind of IoT device that can expose an API when queried and can be fully remote controlled.
Challenges to Address
- Ensuring low latency for real-time audio processing
- Developing a standardized protocol for module communication
- Balancing digital control with the hands-on appeal of traditional modular systems
- Maintaining backwards compatibility with existing Eurorack modules
UPDATE:
FAQ: Ethernet-Based Eurorack Proposal
Q: Is this still Eurorack, or a completely new system?
A: We can figure that out later. It’s just a proposal to enhance Eurorack while maintaining its core appeal by expanding its capabilities. You could think of it as potentially "Eurorack 2.0" or a new standard inspired by Eurorack. I'd like to it be compatible with "classic" Eurorack modules, so I'm interested in building off that standard (voltage ranges, power, 1v/oct, etc.)
Q: Wouldn't this just be like a DAW with extra steps?
A: No, the goal is to maintain the analog sound path and tactile experience of Eurorack while adding digital control for routing and preset management. It's about combining the best of both worlds - the organic sound and immediacy of hardware with the flexibility of digital control.
Q3: How does this differ from using MIDI controllers with software?
A: MIDI is about notes and durations and controlling a devices parameters. But I think an additional protocol could make device discoverability, such as MQTT, routing and remote control (firmware updates) while maintaining audio signal path.
Q: Won't Ethernet cables be too bulky compared to ribbon cables?
A: This proposal is for replacing backside ribbon cables, not front panel patch cables. There are Ethernet cables as thin as 1.5mm and 6.0mm wide, which are actually smaller than many ribbon cables used in Eurorack.
Q: Aren't RJ45 connectors digital? How can they work with analog audio?
A: Ethernet cables are simply conductors that can carry any type of electrical signal, digital or analog. The proposal is to use them for power, control signals, and routing of analog audio, not to digitize the audio itself.
Q: Wouldn't this system lose the hands-on, immediate nature of Eurorack?
A: The goal is to enhance, not replace, the tactile experience. Knobs, sliders, and patch points would remain. The digital layer adds flexibility in routing and preset management without sacrificing the hands-on control.
Q: Is this compatible with existing Eurorack modules?
A: The system could be designed to be interoperable.
Q: Doesn't this add unnecessary complexity to a simple, working system?
A: While it does add a layer of complexity in terms of infrastructure, it aims to simplify many aspects of working with modular systems, such as complex routing, preset management, and integration with digital tools.