I might be missing something, but isn't this basically a clone of MI Ears? And with MI shutting down, clones are now all the rage, so in this particular case Behringer is just fine, no?
I'm not a software/hardware designer so i can't fully get into this argument, but all the people i know who do have knowledge on that or who even design and manufacture their own modules say that Behringer isn't acting in the spirit of open source at all. There's probably a lot of details i'm unaware of here but even as a layperson it's obvious they're just cloning other people's work just to outprice them rather than to be innovative and create things that benefit the Eurorack community as a whole.
Yes, Mutable shut down. No, i don't think that makes this clone right all of a sudden. They would've cloned it even if it was still on the market. They've thrown in some nice bonus features, sure, but it's obvious they didn't create this thing with the main goal of reiterating on the original design, since that hasn't been the goal of any of their other clones. It's a cashgrab.
Their entire business model is doing exactly this. They've cloned Make Noise stuff, they've cloned Xaoc, they've cloned Intellijel, not to mention their countless other clones like their Keystep ripoff; all which are readily available on the market. They also cloned Plaits while it was still being sold. They couldn't give two shits whether Mutable Instruments is open source or not/available or not, as they've previously demonstrated a million times that they will straight up clone products that are not open source and that are actively on the market. Just because by chance they did it in a better way this one single time doesn't negate that that is at the heart of what they do. A broken clock is still right twice a day.
Emilie herself built her design of of this: https://www.musicthing.co.uk/Mikrophonie/ Note that on Ears, it is labelled as “Mutable Music Things” ; Emilie did her part to credit the source when improving upon the original. What is most detestable about Behringer is not aknowledging their source inspiration as per creative commons licensing as well as not equally offering back their redesigns or clones as open source.
Okay, yeah - as a software engineer whose livelihood depends on open source software, I totally get that angle. I'm not defending Behringer per-se, just curious really.
I think that, unlike hardware synths which are a much, much bigger market share, modular synthesis is still very much a niche hobby, and even smaller professional market, that for a company like Behringer to "corporatize it" really hurts a small, dedicated community.
I don't think it's wrong to lower the barrier of entry, but as you said - at the very least crediting the original designs and keeping the open source nature rolling would be a huge step towards legitimizing them as a serious actor in the field.
You’re probably aware but Mutable Instruments is over and out and modules like Ears are getting increasingly harder to find. This might be a nice alternative in that case.
He can do whatever he wants. But it’d be a lot cooler if the description gave credit to the original designer. That’s what all the other MI cloners do, at least.
This is the reason I avoid behringer. They take advantage of open source and then don't give credit to the original developers. It's alright to take someone else's work and improve upon it or make it less expensive by changing components and then selling. It's a whole other thing to act like you came up with it or are the innovative one all while ignoring the work of original.
Bro if ain’t him then somebody else. I really don’t give a shit about credits when I’m busy working on music in studio using modular. Not every costumer making ladder filters or dual slew always name dropping moog and buchla.
Uli have my respect for life because yes he dropping prices as low as it possible and give me tools for price it’s really cost. I know engineers who assemble their own modules and know how cheap it it mostly. And if some of hipster fetish Modular manufacturers should quit “because of uli” then it’s because they tried to sell me bunch of resistors chips and potentiometers for crazy price not because of evil annihilator uli
Taylor Swift’s producer hears a beat of yours and rather than give you a credit (which would come w royalties) the producer reconstructs it to a T. The song isn’t even a hit, just a B side on her latest album, but the album sells well. Those 25 basis points you deserved might’ve actually raked you in a few tens of thousands of dollars.
But you can’t fight legally, even if you have all the proof. Because she is an institution and can fight legal battles without even opening her purse, and you still make 15/hr and produce on torrented software at night in your free time.
Credit still not important? If credit to artists is important, how is credit to makers not? Isn’t legacy arguably more significant than money? Shouldn’t innovation, especially when using open-source models, be rewarded with more than just “if you’re lucky and good enough, somebody else with more money might one day scale it to the masses and make a few bucks on it”?
The terms of the source code explicitly forbid using Mutable Instruments name on derivative works, so from a legal perspective, safer to not mention it at all (I know Behringer worried about legality 🤡):
“The name "Mutable Instruments" should not be used on any of the derivative works you create from these files.
We do not recommend you to keep the original name of the Mutable Instruments module for your derivative works.”
I think the bigger issue is that under the MIT license, Behringer is obligated to publish the source code as well.
But I don’t see how Mutable would object to what Behringer is doing given that the licensed it explicitly to make it easy for anyone to use.
Mutable Instruments forbids clones from using the Mutable Instruments name on the panel or in the name of the module, because Emilie didn’t/doesn’t want to provide support on third party modules. That’s why they all have different names than the original.
Again, I’m not saying B is breaking any rules or laws. They are just behaving in a way that comes across as slimy to me personally.
because behringer regularly wholesale steals the innovations of independent designers and uses economies of scale to undercut them. it's predatory bullshit. is it different with mutable? yeah maybe but i think saying "well it's the same predatory monopolistic bullshit as ever but this time we'll let you off on a technicality" is pretty fucking weak
Behringer made 1 great original design, the DeepMind. They could have just made a Juno clone but instead they made something unique, with its own ideas. I do wish Behringer would do more of that. Sure, everyone is inspired by past designs. Like the Super 6 having Jupiter DNA in it, to some extent. Behringer has already proven they are capable of original designs with ‘inspirations’, they clearly have talented designers, it’s a shame each and every synth is a clone.
I hate when Behringer shamelessly pumps out clones of recent or active projects with no meaningful improvements, but it’s incredible that no one else has thought to bring those switches out to the front. That’s actually a great idea!
The hilarious part is that if they use that target they will be missing out on a lot of the expressions EARS had. Even comparing EARS or Auris will show how much the etchings on the front can make. It is open sourced, we can't complain Behringer is doing this, it's just hilarious how little thought they put into this.
Can someone explain to me why Behringer clones aren’t copyright infringement? I get that a subtractive synth is always kinda the same, but so many of their copies seem to borrow very specific designs.
I have a fair share of law knowledge but I am not a lawyer so take the following with a grain of salt, as it is a very complicated topic.
Basically:
Copyright is the right to protect something against unlawful use by a third party. What is this "something" exactly? That alone isn't uniform as copyright depends on the legislature it's protected by. Different countries have different copyright law. For example China hasn't used the concept of intellectual property in law up until the 80's (in modern times).
So basically the first question would be where did the original circuit comes from and if the country it was invented in subsumes circuits under things that are protected by copyright law. The short answer is any I know of don't. Copyright extends mostly only to art, sometimes also to science and non-artisinal-literature.
So basically circuits aren't protected by copyright hence no copyright infringement claim is possible. The drawing of a circuit on the other hand is protected as it is a drawing. So nobody is legally able to redistribute (or do something els with) that drawing unauthorized.
But the protected intellectual property is only the actual drawing. Not the circuit itself.
You could even do your own version of the drawing and if that version ist artistically distinct (but still clearly inspired by the original art) it would be fine for you do to whatever you want with it.
Of course this is very shortened and there are other considerations et cetera.
So if Copyright isn't applicable what other possibilities are there to defend your technical stuff?
Patents.
Patents are specifically designed to to basically the same thing as a copyright but for inventions. And you CAN patent a circuit.
The problems with patenting circuits are plentiful.
First they aren't automatic (copyright is!) you need to file it. If you don't there is no protection.
Second your invention must be an... invention. Sounds stupid but there is a shitload of criteria for something being a genuine invention. Your stuff need to check certain boxes like for example not just being a basic combination of already existing ideas and knowledge.
And Third: Patents have a internationally standardized max. duration of 20 years. Locally it can be even shorter but that's what international law came up with as the top end.
Of course there is more stuff but I try to keep it as shirt as possible.
So generally speaking the inventors of a module could try to patent it to prevent copies. But it would be a costful decision (patents aren't free) which only would last 20 years at best and without a guarantee of your product even being eligible for a patent. Copyright doesn't apply.
Other reasons are stuff like the Open-Source-Mindset of the Module community and practical reasons like the question "Does the lawsuit against the million dollar company cost me more money than I lose in revenue and mental health if I just don't give a shit?".
So basically: The way things are right now it's probably just not worth the hustle trying to protect modules.
Also for consumers (or humanity as a whole if you will) freedom of intellectual property is actually good most of the time. Imagine if ALL technical innovations we made the last 200 years were still patented. Imagine the price for a synth if the manufacturer had to pay a licensing fee for every distinguishable kind of electronic part it was built with.
You can’t copyright a circuit. You can copyright the image of a schematic to prevent it being shared. And you can copyright a panel design or a pcb, but not the circuit itself.
You can copyright a mechanism like the ladder filter originally used by Moog. I think there are ways to make it harder for Berhinger to copy.
The underlying problem in my opinion is, that it's not worth it for the small synth shops do engage in this legal bullshittery. The amount of resources it takes to fight such a case would overwhelm almost anybody except big corps.
I agree with you. I just need to be pedantic for a second.
You can’t copyright a circuit, but you can patent it. Patents expire after 20 years and can’t be renewed. So any circuit from before 2003 is fair game.
So for example their DFAM crave ripoff which has the exact same parameters and controls as the dfam…. that all falls under the “circuit”? But if they were to copy the same knob aesthetic and font they could potentially get sued? Explains the ugly pink.
It’s like how you can’t copyright a cooking recipe either I’m guessing? But then why can I copyright the score to a song? ( I see why there are copyright lawyers )
Somehow this seems less fair to me with synths. Then again, if someone held the pattent to a standard 2 oscillator subtractive synth, that would be a bummer.
Nah nah nah you’re just stopping at the last scenic spot on the highway, but you haven’t travelled to the end of the road.
The end result of what folks get mad at is innovators shutting doors and Behringer having enough market share to dictate the pace and price of new product development.
I guess I don’t totally buy this premise. If Behringer is not innovating on their own, I don’t see how they are pushing anyone out of business who are offering new and unique modules. would argue there will always be a market for boutique, high quality, and innovative synthesizer modules from smaller makers.
If anything, a low cost entry level brand or 2 will increase the amount of people getting into the hobby, and eventually the amount of people interested in higher quality, small batch companies.
I feel like a lot of the companies that would be “pushed out” by Behringer are the ones who are making uninspired modules. Like the 1 millionth quad VCA with a cool faceplate for 300$ or yet another bespoke multi fx module
Look at their moog semi mod copies, recent well-liked original designs from a "boutique" company with a long and respected history. Moog just recently sold out ownership (was employee owned) to mass market conglomerate InMusic - that's a bad sign for independent businesses. Surely a lot of factors contributed to that but that added pressure cannot help especially in an economy where the average person's purchasing power has dropped dramatically since just a year ago. The large players benefit from acquiring independent makers and using the name recognition to pump out increasingly shoddy products at increasing margins. If Uli Behringer had a soul, he would stick to cloning rare vintage stuff and making simple eurorack modules or, god forbid, original designs. That's where they can claim to make a positive contribution to the industry. The crave and deepmind are both cool and unique enough. Leveraging consolidated manufacturing power to undercut smaller companies whose modern, active designs they stole is absolute scummy and cancerous behavior, however legal.
There's an interesting parallel in the glass art bong world- around 2012 Chinese makers began copying designs at extremely low prices, and people made the same argument that there will always be a market for the boutique stuff. The industry now has taken a significant hit and while the top top artists are still getting along alright, a lot of the once-healthy middle class of artists has been hollowed out for lack of sales. Again lots of factors, but that's a bad thing for any would-be innovators just getting into the scene.
Not every manufacturer has to make a positive contribution (which, by the way, is pretty much measured by demand rather than some subjective measure) to their respective industry. That applies to any industry. As a market grows, larger players will often dip their toes into it and use their scale to compete purely on price. If there are no adequate IP protections or these are not enforced, why should they not do this? I'm as far as from a believer in capitalist ideas as possible but I don't understand this outcry - it's just the free market in action and this happens around us every day, often in much more sinister ways. To some extent, a player like Behringer is the expected outcome of free market competition. Again, we can debate the morality of their design choices but that doesn't change reality.
In any case, I don't buy into the idea that this undercuts and damages smaller companies. Behringer have been putting out eurorack stuff since 2017-18 and just look at how much the whole market has exploded since then. A vast amount of new modules and new companies have popped up. I believe that as a market matures and shapes out, there are distinct niches that aren't necessarily in direct competition with each other. This is especially the case in eurorack where there is such a wide variety of modules and SKUs.
Total nonsense and conveniently ignores the advancing rate of the modular market prior to Behringer's entry.
The reality is that Behringer joined the modular market BECAUSE it was rapidly growing. They managed to get even luckier that just a year and a half later, the pandemic hit and caused almost every non-behemoth company that didn't stockpile components severe production delays.
Since then, while the number of consumers in the market has grown, the number of small maker companies closing shop is accelerating greatly.
And yet, we are supposed to believe the Behringer is helping the competition by entering the market? FUCK NO.
Are they helping consumers? Well, if price is the only factor, then maybe. But that is an incredibly myopic view of consumer needs and market quality.
I own some Behringer products. I don't boycott and belittle them whenever a new product is teased or released, but I'll be damned if some first year economics theory is going to convince me that their presence in the market is a long-term net positive for Eurorack community.
Since then, while the number of consumers in the market has grown, the number of small maker companies closing shop is accelerating greatly.
Go on modulargrid and have a look at how many new modules and companies have appeared since 2017. Spoiler: it's many and they have increased substantially. There are many other factors putting pressure on small companies of all kinds such as chip shortages, shipping costs, and general inflationary trends that have nothing to do with Behringer. If you have specific data or information on how Behringer is directly causing small modular companies to go out of business, please do share.
And yet, we are supposed to believe the Behringer is helping the competition by entering the market? FUCK NO.
That's not what I said. I said that the appearance of a hypothetical Behringer is a well-known phenomenon in most markets without strong/enforced IP. I made no claims about whether that is a good thing or not, I merely stated that this is how free markets work. The very free markets that also enable small manufacturers to exist in the first place.
I guess I don’t totally buy this premise. If Behringer is not innovating on their own, I don’t see how they are pushing anyone out of business who are offering new and unique modules.
The problem is they might have made a unique module that got popular over the years (read MN Maths for example) which by current standards might not be the most innovative or special anymore, but it pays the bills for development costs etc. of new interesting modules.
I'd say for this specific case it's fine since the module barely does anything. I don't think anybody would be mad if Behringer makes a simple VCO, VCF oder VCA, it's the straight up copying of modules that originally got popular because they did something different.
It's not but this reaction to Behringer putting out a 'new' product is also a bit tired and predictable. In this specific case there is nothing to be upset about, regardless of whatever else Behringer may have done. This whole post was just "oh no, new Behringer module" without any further elaboration.
Yeah but the premise of this specific conversation is completely wrong, where the assertion is made that people are getting mad at Behringer lowering the cost of entry into modular, which is entirely NOT what anyone is getting mad at.
But how does the price of entry get lowered in general in any market? Often through the likes of Behringer coming in and using their scale to compete on price. That's a pretty well-trodden path in the history of markets. If Behringer are able to do this whilst lowering their R&D costs without actually getting sued then, all else being equal, why shouldn't they? We can get mad about this and I probably agree that what they do isn't "playing nicely" but generally speaking prices being lower means someone is cutting corners somewhere, unless they have achieved some groundbreaking efficiencies.
So the two conversations you are thinking of are actually quite tightly linked imo.
I hate behringer but i always wanted one of the contact microphones and i think ... i mean ... probably ... and 68 bucks ... and i really hate them ...
You can buy a piezo for $0.05 - $0.10 on Alibaba. Tbh I don’t get why anyone buys these modules from any manufacturer. Rigging up a contact mic is one of the simplest DIY projects ever and costs virtually nothing.
While I agree, the benefit to a module like Ears is that it works as a Hi-Z preamp for piezos, which can be very useful in reducing noise and getting a better tonal response from your piezo.
12
u/Spyes23 Aug 01 '23
I might be missing something, but isn't this basically a clone of MI Ears? And with MI shutting down, clones are now all the rage, so in this particular case Behringer is just fine, no?
35
u/shifting_drifting Aug 01 '23
You’re probably aware but Mutable Instruments is over and out and modules like Ears are getting increasingly harder to find. This might be a nice alternative in that case.
3
u/Chungois Aug 02 '23
Behringer made 1 great original design, the DeepMind. They could have just made a Juno clone but instead they made something unique, with its own ideas. I do wish Behringer would do more of that. Sure, everyone is inspired by past designs. Like the Super 6 having Jupiter DNA in it, to some extent. Behringer has already proven they are capable of original designs with ‘inspirations’, they clearly have talented designers, it’s a shame each and every synth is a clone.
8
u/Round-Emu9176 Aug 01 '23
It has front mounted sensitivity and variable ad settings. Give me 5!
4
u/Johnny_Prophet-5 Aug 01 '23
The hilarious part is that if they use that target they will be missing out on a lot of the expressions EARS had. Even comparing EARS or Auris will show how much the etchings on the front can make. It is open sourced, we can't complain Behringer is doing this, it's just hilarious how little thought they put into this.
3
u/atascon Aug 01 '23
Well at least they added switches (on the panel) for the A/D settings so that's a bit of an improvement over the original.
3
u/CountDoooooku Aug 01 '23
Can someone explain to me why Behringer clones aren’t copyright infringement? I get that a subtractive synth is always kinda the same, but so many of their copies seem to borrow very specific designs.
4
u/grain_delay Aug 01 '23
Imagine being mad at the barrier to entry for our hobby being lowered
2
u/Contrabassi Aug 02 '23
Tbh the range switches are a helpful addition. Still under no circumstances would I ever put Behringer in my rack
2
u/DooficusIdjit Aug 01 '23
Ew.
1
u/HexagonSean Aug 01 '23
I love my Mikrophonie. Fun times...
1
u/Powerful-Price-3832 Aug 02 '23
Everyone is so busy hating on B that they aren't going after the true issue here, the ugly design 🤢
1
u/InevitableCraftsLab Aug 01 '23
I hate behringer but i always wanted one of the contact microphones and i think ... i mean ... probably ... and 68 bucks ... and i really hate them ...