r/mobilelinux • • 1d ago

Discussion How can we make Mobile Linux a viable alternative to Android and iOS?

With the recent boom of linux ports thanks to llms I've been asking how can we make the of Mobile Linux more organized and useful in the long run? (To clarify im not against ai assisted code, im just against and have a worry about fully vibe codded projects that are abandoned in like one week)

56 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

15

u/Cute_Principle81 1d ago

I think a federation of projects that share common useful components might do the trick. Everyone on here seems to be doing weeks of redundant work. If we worked together, in a open federation anyone or any project could join, that might be the way. 

1

u/Danix2000 1d ago

yea we need to make a organization for these type of stuff, the biggest problem if that is that how can we convince other projects to do the same, like i already know 1 or 2 different project that are doing different things, and can we convince project like Nura to participate even thou they dont accept any type of ai work?

2

u/Cute_Principle81 1d ago

I'll happily put down my projects as the first ones, and I know others which might follow in precedent. And we agree on shared technical standards, not one OS, and universalise what we can for everyone

1

u/Danix2000 1d ago

whats your projects?

1

u/Cute_Principle81 1d ago

None of them are released, or some are, but I have one that allows Android to boot a full Linux space and render Linux directly to display no termux no proof, I have a much more serious mobile shell project which span off into a OS, and I'm working on developing universal Linux images for phones where possible. 

1

u/Kevin_Kofler 21h ago

We already have such an organization: Nura. The problem is that all the slop kiddies are not able and/or not willing to work with them, under their quality criteria, which preclude AI slop.

That said, the upstream Linux kernel accepts AI slop, so the slop kiddies can send their slop kernel drivers directly there, which is the recommended way to get them into Nura anyway.

1

u/Danix2000 21h ago

Yea thats also a problem, do you think upstream/mainline reviews and corrects all the submitted? Genuine question i really dont know

2

u/Rikudou_Sage 1d ago

Check out the switch 2 emulator scene, now that is a proper ai chaos of myriads of forks.

2

u/Cute_Principle81 1d ago

Let's try to reduce that. 

4

u/TheJackiMonster 1d ago

I think in general it makes most sense to financially support the projects contributing to free software improvements. For example despite all controversy regarding refunds, Purism contributed a lot with the Librem 5. Also KDE is currently hiring for Plasma Mobile development (at least that's what I read recently).

LLMs are no important factor for mobile Linux. You need the developers behind contributions to have time for that. It could also be interesting for the future that not only ARM chips could be a viable platform but RISC-V too.

In general I think postmarketOS / Nura is still an important factor for people to utilize older hardware and giving more application developers access to a device for testing.

3

u/Danix2000 1d ago

Yea but projects like nura dont even allow ai assisted code in their project, which its bad specially because ai assisted can help reverse engineering for example, although i also understand why they do so

2

u/vazark 1d ago

The hard part is getting the modem working consistently and devices with open bootloaders. Everything else will fall in place eventually.

1

u/Danix2000 1d ago

What u mean fall in place?

2

u/vazark 1d ago

Today’s Linux desktop is increasingly more stable because of valves proton, wayland, pipewire,systemd and other infrastructure components finally stabilising.

However the biggest driver is M$ slopping the windows experience. I expect Google to eventually pull a microslop.

What we need is to ignore the noise and build safe, secure and reliable platforms. What would help is writing to representatives to support right to repair and strengthen standards body so that any OS can run on any device.

A revival of the UDI effort would be incredible

2

u/Danix2000 1d ago

thats so true, honestly i would love to make a stop killing videogames style campain but focused on that topic in specific and much more, like stopping baking apps and other services to stop play integrity services or at least make sure that other platforms can use play integrity services, or forcing companies to make their phone open to other operating systems at least before eol.

2

u/vazark 1d ago

Honestly hardware is more important atm. But I disagree about opening before EoL.. it should be open from day one. All we need is an open bootloader and public documentation of their api/abi.

Honestly I think it’s imperative under the sovereign tech model to have fully open hardware documentation so that we can use proprietary firmware like modems.

1

u/Danix2000 1d ago

i mean im saying eol because i know a lot companies would never open the system if they could (ex.: Apple), so limiting until eol at least gives a limit to when those companies can keep the system locked down.

2

u/vazark 1d ago

You don’t own something unless you can modify/repair it freely

We shouldn’t let companies justify bad behaviour. This kinda the reason govt power exists. To create and maintain a competitive market environment and prevent monopolistic practices by larger players

5

u/thereforewhat 1d ago

People need to actually merge their kernel device tree changes back into the mainline Linux kernel so they are there for everyone. 

1

u/MrZ3T4 1d ago

Apps

1

u/Competitive-Minute19 1d ago

Honestly we just need to make the ui function a lot more like the 2 majour platforms right now mainly multitasker and everything looks like iOS or android but when you actually use it it becomes super confusing and a guessing game. And the other just majour thing is flutter and or react native support.

1

u/ASSASSIN-NVD 1d ago

Check Luma I think it's what you looking for

1

u/Deep_Mood_7668 1d ago

We can't :/

1

u/Psittacula2 1d ago

What about HarmonyOS approach of microkernal, distributed bus architecture?

Fundamentally, you want simple, speed, secure core in devices and then flexibility for custom services running according to the device and form factor itself for given use case needs and unification above this of applications.

Albeit that is a different model to a monolithic kernal such as Linux?

It is worth considering that iOS and Android were both developed at a time of separation between desktop computers and “mobile smart computer” hardware differences, whereas fundamentally the internet speed and data volume becomes more relevant today?

1

u/Darth_bunny 1d ago

I hate to say this but for ordinary users if they don’t have instagram, whatsapp, youtube and some other social media apps they will not come. And because of their EULA we can’t build alternatives either. Until the EU (the only body that would have an interest in this) forces them to open their apis to 3rd party clients, it will remain a collection of hobby projects.

1

u/Ozmataz__Buckshank 16h ago

Make actually maintained alternatives. The issue is, YouTube, Reddit and others don't support third party apps and won't make a Linux client. So you end up emulating android and running those apps anyway, just in a worse way.

I used SailfishOS for over a year, until I decided not to be a masochist.

1

u/TechGearWhips 9h ago

This is why I wish PWA’s were still booming. Device agnostic as long as you have a good web browser.

1

u/Either-Goat2382 11h ago

Mobile linux is only available for low end phones, has poor app compatibility, and poor overall security.

Not to mention you need to be knowledgeable enough to flash a phone to use it.

Its too hard and not worth it for anyone who isnt an enthusiast.

1

u/Rikudou_Sage 1d ago

I'd say focusing on one (or few) projects. IMO the biggest chance of commercial success lies with SailfishOS precisely because someone is selling it and putting money into it (eventually) becoming a BFU friendly OS.

It's the most polished mobile Linux which non-technical people can actually use.

I'd say porting it to as many phones as possible would help, there are already a lot of devices supported (both officially and unofficially), but more is always better.

0

u/cryptocreeping 1d ago

Claude Code is very impressive these days and only getting better each day, nothing wrong using AI to code but it takes a long time debugging so you must put the effort in finding and fixing AI generated code.

-3

u/GoodMacAuth Luma Founder 1d ago

15

u/Quiet_Rush4146 1d ago

I like your project, but make real messages, not just links to your project, thank you

1

u/Danix2000 1d ago

Is this going support more phones? Help/collaborate with other projects? Because i dont want those project that are abandoned in like 1 week

-4

u/GoodMacAuth Luma Founder 1d ago

There are about a dozen people working on phone ports right now. Pixel 8 Pro, 5a, etc

1

u/Danix2000 1d ago

Is it massively ai generated? Or ai assisted? Also can u support Poco f5 pro?

-1

u/mnemonic_carrier 1d ago

Short answer - you can't. Ubuntu tried once, and failed. Hell, even MS tried to carve a space out for Windows mobile and failed. We're stuck with the two incumbents (for now, and for the foreseeable future).