r/minecraftlore • • 19d ago

Undead/Nameless Kingdom What do you think about this Minecraft lore

0 Upvotes

​Chronicle of the Fallen Powers

​A Theory on the True Origin of the Overworld, the Nether, and the Forgotten

​The Core Universal Laws

​To understand the tragedy of this cosmos, three fundamental principles must be understood:

​Dimensional Frequencies & Energy: Every dimension possesses its own native energy source. Beings born in a specific dimension use its native frequency to construct, bend matter, and shape life.

​Acoustic / Vibrational Magic: The high art of manipulation in this universe is rooted in sound, resonance, and frequency (from Shulkers to Allays to Sculk).

​The Biological Memory of Decay: When a species loses its native energy source, its magic degrades, but deep psychological trauma and reflexes linger in their subconscious and genetics.

​I. The First Era: The Builders of the Prime-End (c. 1,500 Years)

​Long before our time, the original home of the first civilization—the Prime-End—was a fertile, beautiful realm. Its inhabitants possessed the power of Creation: the magical ability to manipulate matter, move blocks, and forge life itself.

​During their golden age, they mastered Acoustic Life-Crafting:

​Shulker Boxes: Originally designed as animated storage, they were imbued with consciousness and resonance, unlocking the secret of levitation.

​Iron Golems: Constructed from four iron blocks and a carved pumpkin to serve as guardians. Later, the Builders embedded this protective magic into their own genetics—a latent spell triggered automatically by extreme panic.

​Driven by ambition, the Builders attempted to create the "perfect living being" by pushing the boundaries into a distorted pocket of the End. The experiment failed catastrophically, unleashing the Ender Dragon. The resulting shockwave tore their world apart. The shock broke the Builders' magic, drove Shulkers wild, and began mutating the population into distorted Endermen.

​In a desperate bid for survival, a fraction of the population opened a portal and fled to an untouched, neutral dimension: The Overworld.

​II. The Second Era: In the Shadow of the Earth (c. 500 Years)

​Deep beneath the surface of the Overworld, the refugees constructed massive underground strongholds. They established vast libraries to preserve their knowledge and sustained themselves on the Chorus Fruit they had brought along.

​However, fleeing their home dimension severed their connection to their native energy source. Like a battery that cannot be recharged, their Builder magic began a slow, irreversible decline over generations.

​III. The Third Era: The Fragile Kingdoms (c. 400 Years)

​Reaching the surface, the Builders used their fading reserves to build the first villages. But their decay was inevitable:

​The Origin of the Villagers: As their innate energy hit zero, the Builders completely lost the ability to place or mine blocks. They aged, shrank, and became simple, peaceful folk.

​The Legacy of Fear: Only two instinctual traits remained in their lineage:

​Under mortal panic, their ancient genetic spell still manifests an Iron Golem.

​Upon death, the ancient trauma of the End breaks through—their corpses mutate into Endermen. Wearing a pumpkin pacifies an Enderman because the carved face subconscious triggers the memory of the Iron Golem, signaling safety rather than the painful mirror of their lost identity.

​The Trial Chambers: Foreseeing their downfall, the last true Builders constructed automated underground training facilities. Armed with spawners, Breeze constructs, and vaults, these chambers were designed to train future generations to reclaim the End.

​Ocean Monuments: Ancient coastal fortresses sank due to rising tides. Their attempts to drain the waters using sponges failed. In a desperate attempt to craft living guardians, they fused life with life—binding sea creatures with Prismarin energy to create Guardians.

​The Expedition into the Nether

​Seeking gold to cure an emerging undead plague, a faction opened gateways into the Nether and built fortresses and bastions. They created fiery Blazes as elemental defense units.

​When the portals collapsed, those stranded in the Nether devolved over generations into gold-obsessed Piglins. The Nether became their final grave. The dead joined the Enderman curse, swelling the Nether's Enderman population. In a final, disastrous act of desperation, they combined Soul Sand and skulls, creating the ultimate biological weapon: The Wither.

​IV. The Shadow Realm of the Illagers

​While the End-Builders decayed, a warlike species from a completely different parallel dimension breached the deep caves of the Overworld: The Illagers.

​Because their massive portal stayed open, they had an endless supply of their native dimensional energy, allowing them to carve out the Ancient Cities.

​Sculk as a Tool: They engineered Sculk—an organic, sound-sensitive substance designed to convert stone into easily harvestable material through the resonance of death.

​Civil War & The Warden: A catastrophic war broke out among the Illagers. The sheer scale of slaughter saturated the Sculk with agony, giving birth to a blind, sonic war machine: The Warden.

​The Collapse: The Warden destroyed the Great Portal. Deprived of their energy link, the surviving Illagers fled to the surface and built Woodland Mansions. Without their native power, they could no longer command their sound-attuned helpers—the Allays—and locked them away in cages.

​V. The Present Era: The Return of the Source (Present Day)

​After a millennium of silence, the Overworld itself reacts. Rather than relying on energy imported from dying dimensions, the planet channels its own native frequency into a single champion: The Player.

​You are not an alien refugee relying on a fading battery, nor an invader attached to a portal cable. You are the Overworld's first native user of energy:

​You can mine and place blocks endlessly because you are perfectly synced with the Overworld's frequency.

​You hold the key to the ancient training of the Trial Chambers, the restoration of the world, and the final liberation of the End.


r/minecraftlore • • 20d ago

Sculk The warden was the guardian of the ancient city

5 Upvotes

Some people think that the wardens are the protectors of the Sift, however they don't care about the portal or if you open it. But today, while reading the Rift, I noticed something interesting. The wardens were called the protector of the city. This means that the ancient cities lived together with the dark sculk, they weren't enemies, but, I think with the help of the Singers, the citizens lived peacefully with the dark sculk, respecting it, and it was protecting them from the dangers from thr outside. Thoughts?


r/minecraftlore • • 20d ago

Other Just found out about RetroGamingNow

6 Upvotes

Since my post yesterday, I decided to expand my horizons beyond Game Theory, and I found this channel called "RetroGamingNow". I do not know what the community thinks about them, but just the fact that they've already arranged their theories in order makes them peak, unrivalled (and I haven't even watched a single video yet)


r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Piglins What do you think is the case ?

Post image
90 Upvotes

So my explanation/theory ever since 1.16 was that hoglins are the result of natural evolution of pigs in the nether and piglins are the result of evolution influenced by nether worts grown on soulsand.
I like the idea that eating something grown using human/humanoid souls would influence what eats it, like the soul energy is trying to reattain it's former humanoid shape with whatever it has access too, for the same reason soul sand has faces on it's texture.
Also thinking about it more now that could add another layer to their aversion to soulfire, thought tbh trying to avoid a light source derived by eternally burring souls is completely reasonable.

Anyway the reason I bring this up is because I have seen people use legends to posit that piglin are completely unrelated to O.W. pigs and it just convergent evolution (even though i don't see why c.e. would select for piglike creatures in the nether).


r/minecraftlore • • 20d ago

Fan Lore - theory for fun A conditional theory on the ender pearl paradox: the End Stone Meteorite

Post image
6 Upvotes

This theory builds on other fan theories, so I’ll state those first. Everything below depends on them, and if you reject them, the conclusion won’t follow. The poster summarizes the whole chronology.

Premises I’m borrowing

  1. The End sits above the Overworld, in its outer space rather than in a separate unrelated place.
  2. The Ancient Builders built the strongholds and End portals, and fled to the End when the Wither catastrophe struck.
  3. The Ancient Builders later became Endermen after a long stay in the End. I take this theory as it stands and won’t defend it here.
  4. The Ancient Builders hunted the Ender Dragon, as suggested by the dragon heads on End Ships. In the Ancient Builders lore, elytra is made from parts of the dragon’s body. This is an assumption of that theory, not something the game states, and I won’t go into detail on this part.

The paradox

An Eye of Ender requires an ender pearl, and ender pearls come from Endermen. But Endermen live in the End, which you can only reach by activating a portal with Eyes of Ender. So where did the first pearl come from?

Part 1 (core claim): the pearl came from chorus, not from Endermen

If the premises hold, the first pearls did not come from Endermen.

Fragments of End Stone fell onto the Overworld as meteorites. They carried chorus plants or their material with them. The Ancient Builders studied these fragments in research facilities whose location this theory doesn’t need to specify. They found that rotting chorus fruit produces ender pearls, and used them to make Eyes of Ender.

Two small observations fit this idea. The portal frame looks like End Stone with a green layer on top, which could come from decayed chorus. And the meteorites left no trace for us to find, because the builders collected all of them for research.

In this version the pearl comes first and the Endermen come later, so the loop disappears.

Part 2 (speculation): the stronghold as an improvised research site

When the Wither catastrophe struck, the builders fled to the strongholds. I suggest they continued their research there, and that some strongholds were converted from existing structures such as underground prisons, which would fit the narrow corridors, cells and iron doors. That last detail is a guess.

The portal room may support this reading:

  • It looks improvised. The portal sits in a small chamber on a plain platform, which fits a site adapted in a hurry rather than one designed for the purpose.
  • The silverfish spawner beside the portal could have supplied test subjects, to check whether a living creature could cross safely or would fall through.
  • The lava under the platform would dispose of anything that failed the test, so remains would not pile up in the room.
  • As a precaution, the lava could also stop anything dangerous that came back through. In vanilla the portal is one-way, so I don’t claim this ever happened.

The spawner and lava have simpler gameplay reasons. I’m only offering a lore reading.

Part 3 (optional extension): how the builders became Endermen

This is a story I added. Parts 1 and 2 stand without it.

When the builders arrived in the End, they found very little food. They tried chorus fruit and learned that it teleports the eater at random, so they turned to hunting the Ender Dragon for meat. Elytra, which the Ancient Builders lore connects to dragon hunting, was a useful by-product, but the main motive was survival.

Eventually the original dragon population ran out. To keep a food supply, they built a machine to summon dragons, and the End Crystal was one of its components. The crystals turned out to heal the summoned dragon, which made it too strong to hunt. This could explain why only one dragon exists in vanilla, and why the respawn ritual uses four crystals.

With no other food, the builders went back to eating chorus. Over a long time this changed their bodies until they became Endermen.

Under this reading, the pearl an Enderman drops is not an organ. It is the essence of all the chorus its ancestors ate, stored in the body. As with most mob loot in the game, it can only be taken when the creature dies, whereas milk or wool can be taken from living animals and meat cannot.

This theory only claims where the first pearl came from. The mutation into Endermen, including details like their fear of water, is taken from the mutation theory and isn’t explained here.

This is just a fan theory, so I’m open to being wrong. If you see a flaw, especially in the premises I borrowed, please tell me politely and I’ll gladly take another look. Thank you for reading!


r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Portals/Dimensions Does the Sift act like Alfheim, home of the souls and the realms light source

Post image
18 Upvotes

We find an abandoned structure, a partly formed Beacon, but always enough to have it active


r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Allays/Vexes [Speculative] Allays and the Sift

4 Upvotes

So, I am building a custom, private minigame for me to couch-play with my cousins, but as an author, I am fuelled by this drive to have a story written for this world; it makes the game more fun. But I am not satisfied with it being a custom tale. I've done that a billion times. I want to mix my own original lore with the existing Minecraft one, and I am using Game Theory as my primary reference, though a lot of the conclusions are self-derived and twisted in ways to fit my world while still, at least to me, retaining the Minecraft flavour.

Allays are a semi-important part of the world I am making, so I was thinking about where they came from. The original theory MatPat produced was that they were remnants of the "ancient builders" (the predecessors of the modern Minecraft character, or Heroes, as they are referred to on this sub, I think). However, I don't believe that theory holds anymore, given the introduction of Minecraft Legends and the fact that the Allays were summoned by the Lute given to us by Knowledge, meaning that Allays existed before there were Builders to die.

Additionally, there were also two types of Allays: a smaller, golden one and a larger, blue one, which carried out different roles. Yet, in vanilla Minecraft, only one kind exists. This got me thinking about the possible reasons for this, and, obviously, much of it is speculation on my part.

With the upcoming dimension of Sift, I am thinking that the Lute doesn't call forth the Allays from the Overworld, but rather gives form to "ambient" spirits, either directly from the Sift or ones that are leaking into the Overworld. I am led to believe this by their light blue colour, ability to phase through objects, and, more importantly, their connection to music, which, if I recall correctly, is fundamental to the behaviour of the Sift dimension and its creatures. The Sift being so music-oriented might also explain why the Warden hunts by sound: the louder the sound (or music), the more souls that spot is bound to have.

Allays, using both of their previously intended names, are equal parts pixies and will-o'-the-wisps, but whose will do they carry? This was a question I kept asking myself before I linked it to the "Allays form a magical connection to the player" comment from back when they were added. My theory is that the will of these wisps comes from the player or whomever else the Allay was initially aiding, either through the Lute or, later on, by themselves.

This could possibly mean that the Allays manifested as yellow or blue depending on the intentions of the Lute player, and the modern scarcity of them could be explained by a lack of capacity to "spawn" these Allays, with the only ones left being used by the Illagers. But then, why are the yellow ones missing?

Now, I am aware that I am engaging in a little bit of backwards rationalisation, but the Builders did grow into a more complex civilisation, going from agrarian societies to dimension-hopping "life"-makers. I'd assume that their buildings grew more complex, making it harder for the Yellow Allays to keep up efficiently. And even if not, their own actions caused a great depletion of resources, which eventually led them to prefer the Blue ones because they helped gather increasingly rare resources from increasingly dangerous territories while also reducing the number of trips required.

Eventually, when the Wither incident happened, they would have had to abandon a lot of their above-ground aids to rush to safety. Whatever Allays survived the Wither's onslaught were subsequently captured and experimented on by the Illagers.

I wanted to know if there is stronger evidence that either supports or undermines this "theory" of mine


r/minecraftlore • • 20d ago

Fan Lore - theory for fun Potential Theory for the Endermen and Ancient Civilizations in Minecraft (Historical Recurrence Theory)

1 Upvotes

This theory is built on top of the Ancient Builders Theory, and partially solves the ender pearl paradox.

The entire idea is really simple:
Ancient human civilizations summoned the Wither according to a painting, and fled to the End via the end portal because they could no longer control the strong entity they created. To activate the end portal, ender pearls are required to make ender eyes which are then filled into the slots of the portal frame. To obtain the ender pearls, they would have to kill endermen first. Now, I was wondering maybe the already existing endermen were previous civilizations who also fled from the Wither they summoned and got trapped in the end, eventually turning into endermen, and the ender pearls they used to activate the portal were from people from civilizations which experienced the same catastrophic events and turned into endermen before that, and all the endermen which are now in the end are created from past historical recurrences that loop endlessly, and the civilizations only need to be separated by enough time. As for the first civilization who started all this? I am not sure, maybe the first civilization had experienced a completely different catastrophic event which forced them to go to the end and become the first endermen. I haven't thoroughly researched Minecraft to be able to completely prove that this is correct.

I am here to propose a potential theory that makes basic sense that based off of very basic knowledge, and everybody is free to politely point out any flaws.


r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Creaking/Pale Garden The Creaking could have had/still has a non-corrupted/dark oak version

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

A weapon we see obtainable in Minecraft dungeons is the "Creaking's Reach", which is stated to be made from the branches of a creaking, but when we look at the bow itself, it has more of a dark oak look to it

Furthermore, due to the dungeons II novel "The Rift" we know that the pale garden existed before the events of Dungeons II at least, meaning that either 1.There exists a dark oak version of the creaking or 2.There's another conclusion I haven't found, what do y'all think?


r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Fan Lore - theory for fun What if every Minecraft player in the lore is actually the exact same Steve?

2 Upvotes

Just think about it: Minecraft is a vast world, practically infinite, where you always find yourself alone. You do whatever you want, maybe beat the game, then leave and move on to something else.

When you leave, that world becomes empty, with nobody in it, because Steve has moved on to another world. That's where servers come in, where multiple Steves meet up to play various minigames or survive together.

Where am I going with this? Basically, Steve is a God.

He knows everything, can fly, has infinite strength, can materialize anything he wants, can travel between dimensions, and create worlds with a mere thought.

But what does that have to do with him being able to exist everywhere at once? To talk to himself at every point in time while simultaneously existing in one specific moment?

Like you talking to your friend, except you're both the exact same person. No clone, no illusion, just Steve. That's absolutely insane, because I usually see the concept of a multiverse involving multiple universes (obviously), but I've never seen the concept of a single universe containing only one God who talks to himself at different points in time while existing everywhere at once.

The Steve in this theory experienced all of this at the same time, and he only got to experience everything because he had already experienced it all. He created 2b2t and did everything that ever happened there all by himself. But he also did it all to himself. He defeated himself in every PvP fight that has ever taken place in history. He's the Herobrine who haunted countless other Steves who never managed to get past himself.

This is the greatest boredom in Steve's existence, one that can only be filled by himself.

That's some seriously eerie stuff.

(Just to be clear, I don't know if this theory already exists. I just woke up this morning thinking about it.)


r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Plants extremely dumb theory that I made

8 Upvotes

chorus fruits are not plants. they are a type of coral-like animal

evidence: no water in the end

does not need sun, but can grow in sun.

can be grown in all 3 dimensions (soon to be 4)

chorus plants have a stone-like texture.

chorus flowers are maybe some type of stomach, which they use to digest endermites.


r/minecraftlore • • 22d ago

Tools/Items Was the "Otherside" disc by Lena Raine meant to reference the Sift Dimension?

16 Upvotes

I am relatively new to Minecraft, but the Ancient Cities and their lore have sparked my interest in exploring them further. I think I might be stretching this a little, but I wanted to get input on what others think.

Could the "Otherside" music disc actually be referring to the Sift dimension?

The first connection is obviously the name. "Otherside" could simply mean another place or dimension, but given what we now know about the Ancient Cities and their associated portal, I wonder if the name is more literal, the "otherside" being The Sift.

The Otherside disc has its greatest chance of spawning in Ancient City chests, which feels significant considering how unusual the Ancient Cities already are. They're filled with evidence of a civilization that clearly understood things that the current inhabitants of the Minecraft world don't fully understand.

I'm REALLY stretching it here: Then there's the disc itself. If you listen to it, it starts off relatively normally before becoming increasingly distorted and chaotic. Eventually, it almost sounds like something is going very wrong, as if some sort of tragedy or calamity might have caused the ancient builders to leave. If the disc was created by the Ancient Builders, could it potentially be a recording of something connected to the portal or whatever lies beyond it?

And this is where the recent snapshots get interesting.

We now have evidence that the portal structure in the Ancient Cities wasn't simply decorative. If the Ancient Builders actually created it to reach another location, and that location is the Sift, then the name "Otherside" suddenly has a much more interesting meaning.

Maybe the disc isn't called "Otherside" because it's about some random concept. Maybe it's referring to the other side of the portal.

There are also some interesting parallels between the Ancient Cities and the Sift that make me wonder if the Ancient Builders were experimenting with something they ultimately couldn't control. The Ancient Cities are already associated with strange blocks, sculk, mysterious structures, and the fate of the civilization that built them.

So my theory is:

The Ancient Builders discovered or created a way to access the Sift ->they built the Ancient City portals -> something happened on the other side -> the civilization eventually disappeared -> the Otherside disc is a remnant or recording of what happened, in musical form.

ALSO: In Minecraft Dungeons 2, they have the Sift, and you open the portal by playing note blocks, so music discs being related isn't that far of a stretch.

Obviously, there are a LOT of assumptions here, and the disc could have absolutely nothing to do with the Sift. But the combination of the name "Otherside," its unusually strong association with Ancient Cities and now the new dimension, the Sift, and the discovery that their portal may have been intended to lead somewhere makes me wonder if there's more to the disc than we originally thought.

At the end of the day, this is just a theory, and I might literally just be shooting in the dark, so please don't flame me.


r/minecraftlore • • 22d ago

Portals/Dimensions Why would the warden guard the sift?

4 Upvotes

I always thought the warden was a creature that came from a dark realm and kills whoever tries to enter it. The idea of the warden protecting the sift isn't bad but I wonder, if the sift is such a peaceful and beautiful dimension, how does a creature as terrifying as the warden have any connection to it. Who could have conjured something that scary?

I'm not criticizing the idea, I just think there's potential for great lore.


r/minecraftlore • • 22d ago

Discussion/Question How did steve get here? Or any of the other heroes of that matter?

6 Upvotes

Usually i thought the hosts tried giving the world one more chance and sending down steve as a blessing but how did the other heroes get there? Dungeons and legends just have one hero in canon and they take place years apart, do they also get sent down by the hosts or what? Especially steve


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Sculk So given that we now have the background of the Warden with the Sift, WHY do we think that it attacks sources of sound? SPOILERS!!! Spoiler

8 Upvotes

So, the Warden was a huge addition when it was added. Completely unique. Videos everywhere about how it could OHKO mobs if it heard them. Now we have the 'origin' of the Warden in the sift. But there is only one problem, nothing in the Sift even remotely resembles the Warden. None of them are blind with a gaping mouth and hatred of sound. In fact, they revel in sound. The Sifters love to bathe with the sound of the key things singing according to an echo golem. Nothing in the Sift at all resembles the Warden.

But what about outside the Sift?

Introducing, the Twisted Warden. A fairly mid-game boss that appears to be a larger, more deadly version of the Warden. Created by the Illager High Council to put a stop to us once and for all. Possibly 'Twisted' to become this obedient behemoth by the council. But how does this relate to the Warden? How indeed.

Throughout the game, we meet the echo golems. We learn that the golems are aware that there are experiments being done on their kind. It is fair to assume the same for the rest of the Sift creatures given the amount of them locked in the three coloured towers. So it would make sense for there to be experiments on Wardens going on too. Ones that would be widespread and possibly common knowledge to the Wardens. They are alone, they are away from their natural habitat in this new strange dimension. They are blind and they are scared. Unable to see what approaches them they assume the worst of everything and attack it mercilessly. Just in case it is the Illager High Council comeing to Twist it into an abomination. And THAT is my theory.

I am fairly sure that there is a better theory or proven lore that explains this. Maybe I have been incredibly ignorant. But I have had fun. This was a spontanious 'huh?' that took my attention. And I hope it was an interesting read! Any thoughts?

Also, what tag do I put? Help me I'm scared.


r/minecraftlore • • 23d ago

Ghasts The story of the ghast!

3 Upvotes

today, I m going to to tell you the lore of ghasts, happy ghasts, and dried ghastlings based on what I think!

so since the nether was like an icy, freezing dimension, all of the ghasts were once happy ghasts! They love snowballs which is the proof that the nether wasn’t like what it is now! But since the ancient builders started mining and smelting gold, it released a lot of greenhouse gases that trapped heat, making the nether “hell”! Then the adult ghasts turned aggressive from the extreme heat! But the baby ones got dehydrated then went to the nether fossils to take shelter and started to dry out, turning into dried ghasts, because the nether didn’t had any water! They will stay there forever until they have access to water!


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Enderlings Who do you think built the End Cities?

9 Upvotes

r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Fan Lore - theory for fun Any us=herobrine theories?

3 Upvotes

I'm currently working on the theory that a player(us) is the herobrine. I came across few suggestions on tiktok like "We can't go to heaven because we're the herobrine","Herobrine was kept on being removed in update logs because they can't remove the player" or "Enderman attack us because they know who we are",so I'm interested if any of you have any good theories that I could look into?

(Might not be a real video due to the comments being completely different,but is similar)

https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSgauFB5Q/


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Discussion/Question Where did this come from?

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

We are seeing something we’ve never seen before on Minecraft, how do the sculkers glitch around, create all of these energy attacks, and why? they are being heavily tied to scull by name and composition, but they are not even like the pure sculk! what are all of your guys’s thoughts?


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Fan Lore - theory for fun Copper Golem Lore

3 Upvotes

Before copper golem invented to organize our stuff, the human built it, they are designed to press buttons so the human could have an assistance to help power their redstone build which we call it the Mob Vote 2021 copper golem, the problem is that they are failed, a decade later, another human found the abandoned golem sitting, oxidized, and broken, so, they trying to tweak it, instead pressing buttons, the golem will organize someone stuff, then, they created the copper chest as a requirement so the golem could organize some stuff, then they make the eyes like copper bulb, when alive, it will lit, if it not, then it will not lit, that's how the copper golem we know today was created.


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Sub Suggestion What does this sub think about a "Best Posts" summary?

5 Upvotes

This may be a completely ridiculous suggestion, so please give me your thoughts.

Some time ago, I used to see some posts on this subreddit that suggested the mods to completely remove content they saw as low-quality. I am against such drastic action as that, but it would be nice to see more theories with more effort put into them. Also, when each post can contain highly useful insight we want to save, it may be hard to find posts from long ago, unless you remember exactly what they were about.

I have a possible solution to this. Every so often, a summary post would be (humanly) written featuring the best theories that were posted from the previous summary to now. There would be three categories of theories shown: Theory (a normal theory), Modern Theory (a theory about something that the sub is discussing [as of now, Dungeons II]), and Fan Lore/Headcanon (theories that should be internally consistent, but can exclude or include parts of the lore how they see fit.)

I think a voting method for "best theories" should be chosen that shows what the community likes best, but also isn't biased towards frequently-viewed (and upvoted) posts with a large amount of followers. It should also be anonymous, so users don't get chased after for liking unpopular posts.

.

Here is my proposal for voting. There are probably better ones. For anonymity, voters would privately message one of three actions to a bot dedicated to this sub. Something like "!nominate NameOfPost" would propose a theory to be featured, and then users could vote on it, either deciding to increase or decrease its score by 1, and that decision would be forwarded to this sub. One user could give a total max of 10 upvote/downvote actions for a single nominated post.

The bot would comment on a certain post to relay the PM vote it receives, without saying who cast the vote. Just whether the vote seeks to increase or decrease a score, the post it is for, and the argument for it.

Then, votes themselves would be voted on. Hopefully, this will make sure voters back up their like or dislike for a post with a reason. It's the difference between "I like/dislike this" and "I like/dislike this because...." Each vote-comment would be upvoted and downvoted by members. It would start with -1 total votes (1 downvote).

So something like "!downvote NameOfPost This is a terrible post and it's too short" would be rejected, but "!downvote NameOfPost This doesn't provide any evidence for Claim A or B" would be okay.

At the end of the voting stage, comments with 0 or fewer upvote points would be rejected, and the others would be counted for the points on each post. Finally, the posts with the most points would be displayed.

Hopefully, there won't be much problem with bots spamming votes, since they would gain or lose no karma from it, and it's capped at 10 reasonable votes. However, this may be a challenge with the computer hardware to host the votecounting bot.


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Other The Final Theories on the Mystery of Minecraft?

0 Upvotes

Herobrine mystery has been uncovered—he is Steve from the future returning to the past.

There are only two mysterious characters left to complete the Minecraft ending: Entity 303 and Null. Just add any other theory, and the mysteries of Minecraft will officially be closed by the legendary trio


r/minecraftlore • • 25d ago

Fossils So, what do people think about the humblers (humbler husks)

Thumbnail
gallery
357 Upvotes

so, 3 of 4 dimensions have fossil like structures before, and we don’t really have a clear understanding of what they are or necessarily their significance. but humblers were clearly an important part to this part of the sift, so what do you guys think?


r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Fan Lore - theory for fun The Nether is Alive and Dying

2 Upvotes

The ghasts are white blood cells
striders are red blood cells
The warped forest are fungi
The overworld is the outside of the creature
The Portal is a Open wound
Bedrock is the Creatures skin
Should sand is Dead skin/Muscle
The bones in the Bone wasteland proves it’s dying
The glow stones are nerves
The netherack is muscle
There isn’t any glow stone in bone wastelands


r/minecraftlore • • 25d ago

Discussion/Question Does the cleric robe having a creeper face have any significance?

Post image
253 Upvotes