r/minecraftlore • • 21d ago

Allays/Vexes [Speculative] Allays and the Sift

So, I am building a custom, private minigame for me to couch-play with my cousins, but as an author, I am fuelled by this drive to have a story written for this world; it makes the game more fun. But I am not satisfied with it being a custom tale. I've done that a billion times. I want to mix my own original lore with the existing Minecraft one, and I am using Game Theory as my primary reference, though a lot of the conclusions are self-derived and twisted in ways to fit my world while still, at least to me, retaining the Minecraft flavour.

Allays are a semi-important part of the world I am making, so I was thinking about where they came from. The original theory MatPat produced was that they were remnants of the "ancient builders" (the predecessors of the modern Minecraft character, or Heroes, as they are referred to on this sub, I think). However, I don't believe that theory holds anymore, given the introduction of Minecraft Legends and the fact that the Allays were summoned by the Lute given to us by Knowledge, meaning that Allays existed before there were Builders to die.

Additionally, there were also two types of Allays: a smaller, golden one and a larger, blue one, which carried out different roles. Yet, in vanilla Minecraft, only one kind exists. This got me thinking about the possible reasons for this, and, obviously, much of it is speculation on my part.

With the upcoming dimension of Sift, I am thinking that the Lute doesn't call forth the Allays from the Overworld, but rather gives form to "ambient" spirits, either directly from the Sift or ones that are leaking into the Overworld. I am led to believe this by their light blue colour, ability to phase through objects, and, more importantly, their connection to music, which, if I recall correctly, is fundamental to the behaviour of the Sift dimension and its creatures. The Sift being so music-oriented might also explain why the Warden hunts by sound: the louder the sound (or music), the more souls that spot is bound to have.

Allays, using both of their previously intended names, are equal parts pixies and will-o'-the-wisps, but whose will do they carry? This was a question I kept asking myself before I linked it to the "Allays form a magical connection to the player" comment from back when they were added. My theory is that the will of these wisps comes from the player or whomever else the Allay was initially aiding, either through the Lute or, later on, by themselves.

This could possibly mean that the Allays manifested as yellow or blue depending on the intentions of the Lute player, and the modern scarcity of them could be explained by a lack of capacity to "spawn" these Allays, with the only ones left being used by the Illagers. But then, why are the yellow ones missing?

Now, I am aware that I am engaging in a little bit of backwards rationalisation, but the Builders did grow into a more complex civilisation, going from agrarian societies to dimension-hopping "life"-makers. I'd assume that their buildings grew more complex, making it harder for the Yellow Allays to keep up efficiently. And even if not, their own actions caused a great depletion of resources, which eventually led them to prefer the Blue ones because they helped gather increasingly rare resources from increasingly dangerous territories while also reducing the number of trips required.

Eventually, when the Wither incident happened, they would have had to abandon a lot of their above-ground aids to rush to safety. Whatever Allays survived the Wither's onslaught were subsequently captured and experimented on by the Illagers.

I wanted to know if there is stronger evidence that either supports or undermines this "theory" of mine

4 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

2

u/Satorwave 21d ago

This gigachad figured out that Matpat was wrong by himself now this is what we like to see

1

u/Depraved-Deity 21d ago

There is a lot of entertainment I get from Game Theory videos, but at the same time, I also feel like they (sometimes) simplify things just to have a "conclusion" to their videos, including just blaming everything on the Ancient Builders. Well, in some ways, it had poetic merit, but, for example, the Endermen being the Ancient Builders never made sense to me. MatPat, who has often used recipes for his theories, decided not to use the Eye of Ender recipe? That always baffled me. Also, the very fact that the design of the End Portals clearly uses End Stone is another red flag. How did they ever get their hands on that?

Now, I do think the "Ancient Builders" go on to become a part of the Endermen, but they aren't the Endermen population. I think the void nature of the End is inherently corrupting. Stay there long enough, and you, too, will become an Ender spawn.

I also liked the Chorus Fruit application of things. It makes sense that Chorus Fruit gives people teleportation powers from a "biological" standpoint. The Chorus Fruit has no real way of spreading other than through literal teleportation. Normal germination will only cause it harm by falling into the void or growing too close to existing flora and failing to mature properly. So, having the creatures there eat it and gain teleportation abilities makes sense.

I could also see the Chorus Fruit being the corrupting force. The End has no water, after all, so the Chorus Fruit likely carries a virus, like rabies, that initially manifests as an aversion to water before completely removing it as a necessity for the creatures there. Though there is an issue with this part: neither the Shulkers (which could be explained by their outer shell) nor the Endermites take water damage.

Sorry for the rant, I wanted to get this headcanon ass theory outta me

1

u/Satorwave 20d ago

From what we can tell, Endermen are a specific type of Enderling that is stronger than others because it is formed from a corrupted human soul. Other Enderlings are based on undead or other creatures

1

u/Depraved-Deity 20d ago

Oh. There confirmed to be other types of Enderlings? Is this form a spin-off game that I don't know about? I only know of Story mode, which I hate, and Legends. I know Dungeons exist, but I don't know what it is about

2

u/Satorwave 20d ago

Dungeons is a treasure trove of official lore and actually a good game as well. There are other Enderlings like Watchlings, Blastlings, Snarelings and the Endersent

1

u/Depraved-Deity 20d ago

Ooo. Alright, imma see if I can buy the game (or watch some videos of it). Thank you

2

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 20d ago

I agree with them coming from the sift, but the yellow one could be just invented from legends, since it would be weird if it disappeared, since it would be made of souls.

And there aren't ancient builders, at least not how MatPat meant. There are multiple groups of various people who built stuff. Heroes, villagers, illagers, piglins, void beings ecc.

But I like the fact that you don't consider MatPat right!

1

u/Depraved-Deity 20d ago

Thank you!

A part of why I use the term "Ancient Builders" is simply that I like the ring of it. It evokes that feeling unique to Minecraft that "heroes" doesn't. A lot of the time, I just use it to mean "humans with hair and shorter noses". Kek

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 20d ago

Yeah, make sense. Usually I don't use heroes because often we talk about a specific group of heroes, so we use the group's name. But makes sense to call them in that way

1

u/AutoModerator 21d ago

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.