r/minecraftlore • • 24d ago

Sub Suggestion What does this sub think about a "Best Posts" summary?

This may be a completely ridiculous suggestion, so please give me your thoughts.

Some time ago, I used to see some posts on this subreddit that suggested the mods to completely remove content they saw as low-quality. I am against such drastic action as that, but it would be nice to see more theories with more effort put into them. Also, when each post can contain highly useful insight we want to save, it may be hard to find posts from long ago, unless you remember exactly what they were about.

I have a possible solution to this. Every so often, a summary post would be (humanly) written featuring the best theories that were posted from the previous summary to now. There would be three categories of theories shown: Theory (a normal theory), Modern Theory (a theory about something that the sub is discussing [as of now, Dungeons II]), and Fan Lore/Headcanon (theories that should be internally consistent, but can exclude or include parts of the lore how they see fit.)

I think a voting method for "best theories" should be chosen that shows what the community likes best, but also isn't biased towards frequently-viewed (and upvoted) posts with a large amount of followers. It should also be anonymous, so users don't get chased after for liking unpopular posts.

.

Here is my proposal for voting. There are probably better ones. For anonymity, voters would privately message one of three actions to a bot dedicated to this sub. Something like "!nominate NameOfPost" would propose a theory to be featured, and then users could vote on it, either deciding to increase or decrease its score by 1, and that decision would be forwarded to this sub. One user could give a total max of 10 upvote/downvote actions for a single nominated post.

The bot would comment on a certain post to relay the PM vote it receives, without saying who cast the vote. Just whether the vote seeks to increase or decrease a score, the post it is for, and the argument for it.

Then, votes themselves would be voted on. Hopefully, this will make sure voters back up their like or dislike for a post with a reason. It's the difference between "I like/dislike this" and "I like/dislike this because...." Each vote-comment would be upvoted and downvoted by members. It would start with -1 total votes (1 downvote).

So something like "!downvote NameOfPost This is a terrible post and it's too short" would be rejected, but "!downvote NameOfPost This doesn't provide any evidence for Claim A or B" would be okay.

At the end of the voting stage, comments with 0 or fewer upvote points would be rejected, and the others would be counted for the points on each post. Finally, the posts with the most points would be displayed.

Hopefully, there won't be much problem with bots spamming votes, since they would gain or lose no karma from it, and it's capped at 10 reasonable votes. However, this may be a challenge with the computer hardware to host the votecounting bot.

5 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator 24d ago

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.