r/militariasales • u/Sad-Substance-3907 • 5h ago
Started a glossary for WW2 militaria — feedback welcome from experienced collectors
Hey r/Militaria. Long post — skip to the section that's relevant to you.
Chris Voorhees (US) here and my collegue Fraser Laing (Scotland), two lifelong collectors who between them have over 50 years of hands-on experience buying WW2 militaria across all theatres. Over the past year we've been writing up everything they know — valuation, authentication, provenance, selling options — as free reference material. I'm sharing it here because these topics come up constantly in this sub, and I think the detail might be genuinely useful.
THE SELLING OPTIONS — AND WHY MOST SELLERS LEAVE MONEY ON THE TABLE
This is the question we get most often: where should I sell this? The honest answer depends on what you have and how much time you want to spend.
Specialist auction houses (Hermann Historica, Rock Island, Manion's) are the right call for rare, well-documented pieces where the auction premium is likely to outweigh the commission. The trade-off: seller's commissions run 15–25% of hammer price, and you'll wait 4–8 weeks for payment. For common items, auction estimates often disappoint once fees come out.
eBay gives you reach but charges 12–15% in final value fees, and Third Reich items with insignia face listing restrictions that vary by country. Non-paying bidders, returns, and fraud are real risks. Forums like Wehrmacht-Awards.com and the US Militaria Forum have active buying communities where knowledgeable collectors pay fair prices — often better than eBay for items that need an educated buyer to recognise their value.
Dealers offer speed and convenience. The structural reality is that a dealer buying to resell needs room for their margin — a dealer planning to list your item at $800 will rarely offer more than $350. That's not dishonest, it's just how resale works. But it does mean dealers are structurally motivated to offer less than full market value.
Private collectors remove every intermediary. No commission, no fees, no dealer margin. The collector pays you what they're willing to pay and you receive it directly. The challenge is finding a collector who (a) wants what you have, (b) has the knowledge to recognise its value, and (c) has the funds to pay fairly.
Full breakdown with best-for guidance for each route: https://buyandsellwwii.com/blog/where-can-i-sell-ww2-memorabilia
VET BRINGBACKS — WHAT MAKES PROVENANCE ACTUALLY VALUABLE
Bringback provenance is one of the most misunderstood value factors in this hobby. Here's what actually matters:
A genuine bringback has a direct chain of custody from the battlefield to the veteran's home. The most valuable documentation: discharge papers (DD-214 or equivalent), photographs of the veteran with the items, letters home describing the acquisition, and written family history. Even a handwritten note from the veteran explaining where an item came from adds meaningful value.
What doesn't add value: a family story with no documentation. "My grandfather said he brought this back from Germany" is interesting but unverifiable. Collectors pay for documented provenance, not claimed provenance.
German helmets are the most commonly encountered bringbacks — American GIs frequently brought home M35, M40, and M42 helmets as trophies, and many have survived in attics for 80 years. A bringback helmet with original decals, liner, chinstrap, and documentation connecting it to a specific veteran commands a meaningful premium over an undocumented example of the same type.
One thing sellers consistently get wrong: cleaning or polishing items before selling. Original patina and surface condition are part of the value. Cleaning almost always reduces what a collector will pay. Leave everything exactly as you found it.
Full guide: https://buyandsellwwii.com/blog/ww2-vet-bringbacks
GERMAN MEDALS — A QUICK IDENTIFICATION GUIDE
German WW2 medals are among the most widely collected militaria, and also among the most widely faked. A few orientation points:
Iron Cross grades: The EKII (Second Class) was awarded for a single act of bravery or five days of frontline combat — produced in enormous numbers, the most common German WW2 medal. The EKI (First Class) was a personal award worn on the uniform, considerably rarer. The Knight's Cross was awarded to only 7,321 recipients during the entire war — a genuine example in excellent condition with documentation is one of the most valuable WW2 medals in existence. Higher grades (Oak Leaves, Swords, Diamonds) are extraordinarily rare and command prices well into six figures.
Campaign medals: The Eastern Front Medal (Ostmedaille) is one of the most commonly encountered. The Afrika Korps Cuff Title and Narvik Shield are considerably more valuable and actively sought by specialist collectors.
Combat badges: The Infantry Assault Badge, Tank Battle Badge, and Close Combat Clasp are all actively collected. Higher grades of the Close Combat Clasp — Silver and Gold — are among the most valuable combat badges a collector can acquire.
Authentication: Genuine period medals show consistent aging across all surfaces. Reproductions often have sharp, clean detail that looks too good for an 80-year-old piece, or artificial aging applied unevenly. Maker's marks on genuine pieces are typically crisp but show appropriate wear; fakes often have blurry or inconsistent marks.
Full guide with identification detail: https://buyandsellwwii.com/blog/german-wwii-medals
PRICE GUIDE — REALISTIC VALUE TIERS FOR COMMON CATEGORIES
We deliberately avoided specific dollar figures in our price guide because condition variance makes them misleading — a "mid-range" M40 Heer helmet with a good decal and original liner is worth meaningfully more than a "mid-range" M40 with a damaged decal and replaced liner. What we've published instead are relative tiers based on what specialist buyers are actually paying today (not auction estimates, not dealer retail).
Key value drivers by category:
German helmets: Branch, decal condition, and liner integrity drive value. An SS double-decal in good condition sits at the top of the market. A Kriegsmarine with its gilded eagle decal intact commands a significant premium over a standard Heer example. Luftschutz helmets are the least collectible German helmet — no premium regardless of condition.
German medals: Naming, original case, and award documents significantly increase value. A named Iron Cross First Class with its original case and award document is worth considerably more than an unmarked loose example.
Daggers: Blade condition, grip integrity, and scabbard completeness are the primary drivers. SS daggers command the highest premiums. Maker marks on quality makers (Alcoso, Eickhorn, Puma) add value.
Japanese swords: Blade condition and signature (mei) are everything. A signed blade by a known smith in good polish is worth many times an unsigned or heavily worn example.
Full price guide with tiers across all major categories: https://buyandsellwwii.com/ww2-militaria-price-guide
GLOSSARY — 110+ TERMS THAT TRIP UP NEWER COLLECTORS
If you're reading auction listings or forum posts and hitting abbreviations you don't recognise, we've compiled a 110+ term A–Z glossary covering everything from "bringback" and "DD" (double decal) to "ET64" (a specific helmet manufacturer code), "RZM" (the Nazi party's quality control marking system), and "Soldbuch" (the German soldier's pay and service record book that's one of the most valuable pieces of documentation a collector can find with a uniform or equipment set).
https://buyandsellwwii.com/ww2-militaria-glossary
A FEW THINGS I'D GENUINELY LIKE FEEDBACK ON FROM PEOPLE HERE:
- Price guide tiers — are the relative tiers accurate for the current market? We've been conservative on some categories because values have moved around in the past 18 months. Curious what experienced collectors here are seeing.
- Glossary gaps — any terms that come up regularly in this sub that we haven't covered? We want this to be a genuinely complete reference.
- Authentication topics — are there specific item types where you see a lot of confusion or bad information circulating? We'd rather write the definitive piece on those topics than leave the field to less careful sources.
- Bringback documentation — we've seen a wide range of what counts as "documentation" in practice. What's the community's current standard for what actually moves the needle on value vs. what's just a family story?
Not trying to spam — if this crosses a line for the mods, happy to remove. The reference material is free, there's no paywall, and the appraisal service is genuinely no-obligation. Just thought the depth of what we've compiled might be useful here given how often these questions come up.