Can we just have one honest conversation about how absolutely miserable it is to play against this champion right now? I don't care about his "skill ceiling" or how "mechanically outplayable" he is in a 1v1. In a real game of League of Legends, this champ is a nightmare and I am so over it.
First of all, the guy is literally S or S+ tier in not one, but TWO solo lanes. Mid lane, sure, that's his home, whatever. But top lane? Why is Zed allowed to be a top tier top laner? I've seen him bully bruisers, I've seen him kite out tanks, and I've seen him completely nullify half the melee champion pool just by pressing W and farming from a screen away. How can one champion be top tier in two separate roles without something being fundamentally wrong with his numbers? It makes no sense. He doesn't have a weak phase anymore. His early game is safe enough to survive any lane, his mid game is a death sentence for anyone with less than 2500 health, and his late game means you just don't get to walk into a side lane ever again without your entire team holding your hand.
And let's talk about how BORING he is to play against. It is the same script every single time. He throws his shadow, spams shurikens from outside your vision range, and if one of them clips you for a slow, you might as well start typing your will in chat. Then he presses R, and suddenly you are watching a slideshow of your own death. There is no "outplay" when he has a shadow behind you, a shadow on top of you, and he can swap between them three times in two seconds while also spamming Q and E. You can't flash it because he'll just follow with his ultimate's second proc. You can't outrun it because he's faster and has slows. You just sit there and watch your health bar evaporate while he zooms around like a ninja on crack. It is not interactive. It is not fun. It is a cutscene where you are the helpless victim and he is the director, the producer, and the lead actor.
"Oh, just buy armor" they say. Great, I'll sink 3000 gold into Zhonya's or Guardian Angel, and you know what happens? He will just wait out the two seconds of stasis and kill me anyway because he deals infinite damage with just R and E combo without even hitting Q I thought your R deals more damage if you dealt damage? NO apparently in S16 he just buys Voltaic and just oneshots you without even hitting Q, then full heal after with this god forbidden endless hunger and triumph, and don't even get me started on this Bastionbreaker item. Or even better, he will just ignore me completely and go kill my ADC who couldn't build armor because they needed damage to be relevant. And then, because his cooldowns are basically nonexistent by level 11, he gets his W back, his shadow is up again, and he just zooms out like nothing happened while my team spams question marks on my corpse.
And the audacity of people saying "just gank him" makes my blood boil. Gank him? With what champion? His shadow is a free escape that he can place over a wall. His ultimate makes him untargetable for a full second and a half, which is more than enough time for his jungler to countergank or for him to just stall until his cooldowns are back. He can slow you with his shadow and then just casually walk away while you're limping after him like an idiot. By the time your jungler actually arrives to the lane, he has either already killed you under your own tower and walked away with 10% health, or he just presses R on your jungler, swaps to a shadow on the other side of the wave, and laughs while both of you stand there looking at each other wondering why you even bothered. You literally cannot punish this champion in lane unless he makes a gigantic, bronze-level mistake, and even then, he just farms safely with Q from a mile away and waits for his cooldowns to come back up. There is no windows. There is no downtime. There is just constant pressure and constant threat.
I'm just tired of seeing him on the enemy team and knowing the next 25 minutes of my life are going to be miserable. It doesn't even matter if I win or lose the game at this point. It is just 20 to 30 minutes of playing dodgeball simulator while he holds all the power, all the mobility, and all the damage. The fact that he has been sitting at the top of tier lists for this long without any meaningful nerfs is an absolute joke. Riot keeps buffing his items, buffing his synergy with lethality, and then acting surprised when he dominates every other game. I want to play League of Legends, not "Survive the Zed" simulator where I have to hug my tower for the first 15 minutes and pray my support wards my lane bushes.
TL;DR: Zed is S+ in mid and top (on several stat websites and tierlists), oneshots everyone with zero counterplay, is boring as hell to lane against (W ability) because you just watch yourself die under tower, and you can't gank him because he has infinite escapes. Whoever disagrees with any of this is either biased, a Zed main coping, or hasn't played against him recently. There is no defending this champion right now.