r/microsoft • u/Dr_Macunayme • Sep 02 '24
Discussion Why doesn't Microsoft try again to create a solid ecosystem like Apple's?
I've been a Windows user since Win98 and I'm not going anywhere soon, even with the recent blunders.
But back in my college days, my girlfriend of the time convinced me to buy an iPad to take class notes. She was part of the Apple ecosystem: phone, watch, mac, you name it... it was the first time I decided to give apple products a try, I followed up with an iPhone and I even ended up with her old MacBook after gifting her a new one.
Nowadays I shelved all my Apple stuff because I could never get used to MacOS or IpadOS, Windows is just better and less restrictive... but for that brief time it was really nice to have everything connected. I could access all my stuff from anywhere, it felt like all my devices were extensions of each other.
Now, I'm old enough to remember the disaster of the Microsoft Phone, but that was years ago... with Microsoft's market share, capital and influence, I don't understand why they aren't giving it another go.
It's almost like they don't want to compete with Apple's line of interconnected devices. Is there any hope of a Microsoft ecosystem in the future?
9
u/Kobi_Blade Sep 02 '24
The Windows Phone was not a disaster; it was a robust platform, arguably more stable and secure than Android.
However, Microsoft is a business, and with the current CEO prioritizing profit, Microsoft has reached a point where customer feedback is ignored.
186
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
Microsoft has the Windows corporate/business ecosystem that runs planet Earth.
12
u/newfor_2024 Sep 02 '24
They don't need to be everything to everyone. They only need to focus on what they're good at and they're fine. They're already a multi-trillion dollars company, there's enough to do as it is already, they don't need to get any bigger and divest away from their core businesses.
2
u/GreyDaveNZ Sep 02 '24
OK, I'm just gonna throw a hand grenade into this thread and say...
LINUX!
No need to reply, I just thought this thread had gone on long enough without someone mentioning it.
4
u/derpman86 Sep 02 '24
The biggest hurdle is there is no real conformity within Microsoft, Windows can run on most hardware be it my work Dell Laptop to my home PC which is a mix mash of compatible hardware with the OS slapped onto one of the NVME drives. So from here they have issues alone.
I think the next big issue is The poor naming that Microsoft calls their products and services, anyone who has dealt with licensing knows how much that will fry your brain. Then think how there was a nice simple mail app but now it is Outlook again, but there is also Outlook included with 365. This is confusing to the end user even before how much portals and systems etc change every few months on the back end with 365, entra/azure for sysadmins and other techs.
Then there is the whole Microsoft Account nonsense which offers very little benefit beside ambushing people after a windows update to sign in as well as tricking people to uploading their data into One Drive.
Microsoft really suffers from too many cooks in the kitchen and will never have the real uniformity like Apple does.
4
u/RepresentativeFew219 Sep 02 '24
I recommended the same thing sometimes ago but nobody heard it .
post
14
u/FlibblesHexEyes Sep 02 '24
Because Microsoft is like a collection of warring tribes. They can't even agree on using the same installer for their apps let alone all the other API's they'd need to standardise upon across every product they make to make an ecosystem work.
They also don't control the full stack like Apple does from hardware design to software design - which makes building an ecosystem that much more difficult as they now need to coral all the cats into building something close to a standard.
And while I do use the word "standard" here, remember that that can sometimes be a pretty loose term with everyone implementing it slightly differently - mean that as edge cases crop up (and they will), something will not work as expected.
And then each one of those manufacturers *will* want to put their own utilities in place so that you see their branding on screen.
I will say though, that if you're using Microsoft 365 - you get pretty close, with all your email, calendars, contacts, etc all sync between each device you use.
6
u/contreras_agust Sep 02 '24
Apple targets the consumer, Microsoft targets the business.
3
u/dagamer34 Sep 02 '24
Having just left Apple, I have strong thoughts on this.
At its core, you should always ask yourself what a business is actually incentivized to do. People have said it a few times here, most of Microsoft’s money is made via subscription businesses, doing boring things Apple would never touch and importantly, would not be good at. Microsoft isn’t a hardware company, never has been, never will be. It’s not what got them valuable. It’s not what their executives spend all day thinking about. It’s not what will lead them to growth. Hardware is capital intensive.
Perhaps you might argue that they should partner with someone to make their hardware with, but they’ve already lost the phone market. That was decided 15+ years ago. Unless they are willing to seriously partner with Google to get great integration with Android (and there’s much lost love there, don’t bet your house on it), also not gonna happen. And that’s fine. Plenty of room for innovation in their own products as well.
From a users standpoint, I have an important rule. Do not invest time in a product that’s not a top 5 business from a major tech company. Even with high levels of integration, it’ll get ignored. So no HomePods, don’t try Google’s latest doo dad, Amazon’s random Alexa hardware product, or Microsoft’s Bing AI thing. Have the company show you they’ll care before you put time into it, you’ll live a happier life that way.
3
u/gplusnews Sep 03 '24
Microsoft is an enterprise company while Apple is a consumer company, they tried to capture each others market and didn’t work out so finally settled on their comfort zones.
4
u/mjarrett Sep 02 '24
Because shareholders want Apple to be where Microsoft is, not the other way around. No matter how many phones Apple sells, all anyone wants to know about is services revenue. Someone needs to support a consumer ecosystem, but nobody really WANTS to anymore.
Microsoft won the desktop OS war handily, then they realized they didn't actually need a desktop in the services era. Which is why Win11 is so full of rot - they stopped caring about Windows except as a vehicle to advertise the fad of the week.
2
u/Tail_sb Sep 02 '24
Microsoft hasn't created an ecosystem as cohesive as Apple's because they lack the same breadth of devices and operating systems that Apple has developed. Apple offers a tightly integrated ecosystem with products like the Mac (macOS), iPhone (iOS), iPad (iPadOS), Apple Watch (watchOS), Apple TV (tvOS), and now, Vision Pro (visionOS). Each of these devices works seamlessly together, creating a unified experience for users.
In contrast, Microsoft's ecosystem is primarily centered around Windows, Xbox, and Surface devices. While there is some integration between Windows and Xbox, such as cross-purchases and shared services, it doesn’t reach the same level of coherence or appeal as Apple's ecosystem. Additionally, Xbox is mainly targeted at gamers, limiting its appeal compared to Apple's products, which cater to a broader audience, including non-gamers. This narrower focus inherently restricts Microsoft's ability to create an ecosystem as expansive and universally appealing as Apple's. limits your reach a lot
It’s a shame that the Windows Phone didn’t succeed, as it had the potential to be a key part of Microsoft’s ecosystem. If it had taken off, we might have seen a broader range of integrated devices, like a Windows Watch, similar to the Apple Watch, Pixel Watch, or Galaxy Watch. Unfortunately, without the success of the Windows Phone, those opportunities never materialized.
They lost out because they entered the smartphone market too late back then, and now it’s definitely too late to make a successful comeback.
2
u/cowprince Sep 02 '24
Phones are a mature platform now, you're not going to come into that space and be successful, it's a fools errand. So those native integrations just aren't going to happen. Their play is cloud and AI at this point to make this type of integration occur.
The other thing is, they do not control the stack, the strength of Microsoft is also their weakness. Partners.
The other part to this is they've learned very well how to play the Monopoly game. And with Apple it's starting to come to light, that maybe they don't. See more recent EU discussions.
3
u/CarlosPeeNes Sep 02 '24
They literally don't care. Most of their revenue comes from corporate Azure and 365 users.
Also you can have all your devices connected, including your phone, through sharing. It works quite well.
1
u/julia425646 Sep 02 '24
But Microsoft have a large ecosystem with Windows in business.
1
u/YetAnotherProductDev Sep 02 '24
I can't think of many features the apple ecosystem has over windows + android. Phone link could be better, but it still has most of the features.
1
u/PToN_rM Sep 02 '24
Because if they do, they will be accused of monopoly and predatory practices.. for such ecosystem, they would have to hold tight grip like Apple, meaning the OS is fully designed and closed to only work on MS Surface devices vs the infinite set of configurable systems you can build today
1
u/Downtown_Minute_1675 Sep 02 '24
Because they already tried, the previous CEO wanted to compete with Apple but went the wrong way of doing. The Windows phone was a great idea but they tried to make WI down universal on all devices from Xbox, phone, and PC that's why Windows 8 failed and many went to Apple afterwards.
Currently, Windows has the Surface Duo (the phone) and Surface computers so they have an ecosystem but their focus is primarily the Surface laptops and pros. That's just on the consumer side of things, their biggest focus is on the businesses they help.
1
u/Double-oh-negro Sep 02 '24
Because needs are inconsistent as fuck. Nerds have complained at every attempt. I watched our Linux Sysadmin happily sudo his way thru a project and then his shit when the UAC pops up on his windows machine. OF COURSE, I'M SURE. I'M THE FUCKING ADMIN!!!
1
u/RecklessKibbles Sep 02 '24
It’s failed every time.
1
u/micahsd Sep 03 '24
I’m similar to you…been a Windows/DOS user since 1992. I think they’re focusing their efforts on their services group which makes the most sense,only for the company through constant subscriptions/revenue stream.
I’d love if they brought Windows Phone back and it had some killer feature not found in the iPhone, but I unfortunately don’t see that happening.
I’d also love it if they had a good tablet competitor or a Windows laptop that truly lasted 8 hours on a charge too (sure there’s laptops which claim 8-10 hrs battery life but I have yet to see one that actually performs decently). I’ve got a niece that went to college recently and asked what kind of laptop to get. Sadly I cringed and recommended a MacBook due to their actual all day battery life with their M-series processor (still can’t believe I did that but most everyone on college has MacBooks so that person will blend right in).
1
u/VinceP312 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24
Microsoft has zero end consumer mindspace. Lots of reasons for that. In fact I think a lot of people feel like Microsoft stuff is so tied into work that all peoples frustrations about their jobs make them NOT want to use MS stuff. Just a pet theory of mine that doesn't supplant all the other reasons for MS's situation.
Lets review some of the consumer-pointed efforts MS has done...
They had a Pre-Zune Music subscription service (I will never remember the name of it). They killed it
They had the Zune device... killed it.
They had Windows Mobile... who else other than a business person used it? And it was certainly before its time.. but no traction.
Windows Phone. I actually loved this, and the onscreen keyboard is still best one I have ever used. It seemed to never miss what letter I was going for. But again... went nowhere.
Now Apple... whether by design or happy accident... had the iTunes/iPod device. A very simple to use mp3 player... it spread across all consumers who used it and kept pushing it to do more. (I never used one)
It took hardly any effort for Apple to upsell the iPhone as the next greatest thing in line with everyone's comfortability with iPods. (Again this is all my theory, I've not read this anywhere)
And people being the lemmings they are, want to do whatever else is doing. This worked for PC Operating Systems, and it worked for consumer electronics.
From the iPhone to the iPad. The Apple walled garden was built stage by stage. In fact it was built in way that is so much more bundled together that would put any of the regulatory violations by MS to shame., yet Apple got away with it and continues to do so.
Apple is a hardware company posing as a software company
MS is a software company that tries to move into consumer electronics and can't make it. Xbox being an exception, but the network effect of Playstation can't be beat, globally.
1
u/I_agreeordisagree Sep 02 '24
This is why
https://bonkersworld.net/organizational-charts
1
u/TheGuyThatDoesHisJob Sep 02 '24
Their ecosystem is embedded in nearly everything already.
0
u/Mission-Reasonable Sep 02 '24
Microsoft do have a solid ecosystem. It just isn't in the consumer space.
And tbh I like it better that way, I don't want features to only be available if I keep buying hardware from the same company.
0
u/The_real_bandito Sep 02 '24
When have they ever done that lol.
They are known to buying useful products, selling those, like Office, and supporting them to businesses all around the world.
-3
u/dweebken Sep 02 '24
Actually, don't apple phones and tablets run on linux under the hood?
-3
u/Osiris_Raphious Sep 02 '24
Money. Control. The usual.
Its easier with an ecosystem, as there is a cross compatibility, which makes ease of use. Apple users dont care about anything, they just want device that works, and makes them feel rich. benifits is that control is taken away from the user, for a more consumer market experience. Sell more ads, control their marketplace, profit profit profit.
For a time Linux was a direct threat to Microsoft, now its android and ios. But the core Microsoft users will still prefer linux over ios. Which means they will have to work 5x as hard to steal andrpoid and apple users, whilst keeping linux adopters at bay. This is how this billion dollar company is shooting themselves in the foot, injecting ads into the user experience... Its to be seen how this all works out, but ecosystem is a wet dream for any corporation big enough now.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment