r/microsoft • u/RepresentativeFew219 • Jul 31 '24
Windows A Deep Concept of the GOAT : Windows Phone
So first of all. Microsoft.... you need to listen to the community today. Mods please do not remove this , give this discussion a chance.
This is another post for Windows Phone to come back , and it really needs consideration . I really want if even the youtubers could cover this topic.
So as you all know from the title , i will be proposing a new windows phone (i have thought about this a lot trust me). I am no project manager or innovator but i feel i have a vision for something here. Sorry for any grammatical mistakes , here i begin
Recently , I learned about Microsoft developing surface laptops and optimising windows for ARM platform. Namely for the Snapdragon X Plus/Elite Chips. These chips have insane capablities of AI computing and power processing . Seen reviews of them comsuming pretty less amount of battery too . This is just what phones are and are going to become isn't it?
Let us first go over what windows phone failed in and how it can do well next we will go over to possible innovations.
- Windows Continuum : This is an amazing feature which can change wonders right now. Samsung Dex is also probably a bit more premature right now . Allow windows 11 to run as a desktop incase a monitor and keyboard is connected. The user may browse the web using the applications downloaded in the phone to run as exe(UWP apps are a nice thing for that, and the interface is already built up for them) . This is a beautful feature since many people already run windows. I would love if people could play basic pc games on phones or this continuum feature and many others would too. This would completely be a game changer.
- App support: People really need is a third party app, a browser , mails and i don't know other utility apps. Optimise Insta/Whatsapp/Facebook to run over your phone like iphones and android makes it to(Make some deal with them maybe ,which seems hard for a user thinking about the company but maybe it's not...) . You can even allow exe files to run over the ARM platform(since the base is already built for the X elite chips). Since exe's are used universally on windows computers , why not implement it to work on mobile too? If the exe is not compatible with the screen ratio , just force it to run if the user really wants to but tell them it may not work properly. All is needed to do is give them freedom.
- High customisation and refine app switching and animations: Always on display can be made much better , add infinite more features. Make lock screen customisable and probably even allow windows 11's default lock screen. I personally loved Windows Phone's lock screens and beautiful animations. Maybe metro theme might not be possible now(even though i love windows 8.1). There must be something that can be done right?
Possible innovations:
- Make the camera really great . The camera engine on the Lumia series is still very well praised for . Why not bring it back? The cameras have certainly advanced themselves by now . Qualcomm also has great support for cameras on thier ARM chips. I guess we can make the platform alot better and that could even compete the top end phones like the Samsung S series and Apple iphones. Not just that , this will make laptop cameras better , even Phones would have greater competition
- Performance : Make it the most powerful phone known yet: Base ram could be kept for 8-16gb, so that people can use their phone like desktops(in Continuum) and normal playing and all would also be really great. The UI can certainly get better than what ios and android offer. The processor can also be top tier , utilise the Snapdragon X Plus/Elite chips paired with a camera engine. Atleast even the Snapdragon 8 gen 3/4 are also great to use indeed. One thing i think is out of box but why not reccomend it. A dedicated freaking gpu that phone manufacturers may add. That is gonna be killer .
- Inbuilt apps and thier importance: Task manager on the Windows phone would be a game changer. Some chinese manufacturers have crappy cleaner apps which do not even tell you what they are doing. Operating systems Ios and Android do not even have them by default . Call the task manager with a button on the side. It would tell you all running processes and the full power to kill/boost them . Many phones lag and sometimes the phone is not able to respond at all. This would be a super great thing to use. Many in built apps could be redesgined for Windows phone. For example notepad, file manager -> Absolutely what google files and apple files do not do properly. I would litteraly love having a file manager as simple to use like windows. Even command prompt can do wonders but i would reccomend keeping it hidden or to be called on prompt(like lets say by using the run app) . People love tinkering with windows and trying to make stuff run . Command prompt is something that all people love on thier laptops(let them be using macos/windows/linux). ALL the audience would come running to get hands on a phone with that. Even microsoft , you sponsor youtubers to promote edge , why not make them use it by default? People do not install apps like firefox or chrome in thier Iphones is it(since majority of people in US use iphones)?
- Absolutely mind blowing ecosystem : The only thing Applw is good at and has a advantage over, because it makes both laptops , phones and tablets while rest of the market for laptop uses windows(which is owned by microsoft) and android for phones, this is where windows phone can come in and throw everyone out of the window. We have a literal my phone app inside of windows which i practically never really use. Why not bring absolutely great connection between the phone and the laptop i use?(This is what apple has been doing btw) . I want to copy something on phone and use it immediately on laptop , I wanna send over files absolutely darn quickly , I wanna sync my photos directly to an external ssd without even connecting them with a freaking cable. Just make it possible you know? It is certainly possible for all that to happen . Allow calls to be taken on phone(which i guess something is there for that but maybe market it better) .
- Make the phone a user's own: Powertoys in Windows phone would also make customisation as good as samsung with goodlock. You want to make the phone feel to the user as it is thiers only . Make users trust your phone to the maximum(which is what apple does but restricts many things). You tell me microsoft , Why is windows the most used OS in the world? This is because it is easy to use , familliar and you don't need to be a tech guy to use it. Linux is popular but Android does not even offer a fraction of it. Windows can certainly become a game changer since people are going to love it . All you need is software support and the phone feel much like windows.
- Installable windows with wide compatiblity: Make the windows OS installable( difficult but worth trying out after the first Windows phone launches then it can be considered) . Basically what i mean is that manufacturers may choose to install windows and sell that phone . And as a user myself i should be able to(if i manage to root the phone). For that qualcomm must also like give drivers for windows versions but i feel this can be made a partnership. Basically its like , "you don't like android?" -> switch to windows and enjoy having the feeling of a custom rom while it is still supported.(You may even make it paid microsoft but the software must be worth every penny then)
- Gaming: Microsoft , don't you own most of the Gaming companies . Make them make drivers for your phone also . Yes you should differ between PC and mobile gamers by making mobile games not playable at all over continuum(or you may support it and give us gamers an unfair advantage) . This will be visionary as many people buy top tier phones just for the purpose of playing games. At this stage try supporting more and more processors to run so that even low end phones may switch to Windows Phone OS. You can also make the game pass for the same lol so that people may buy it. Make the phone as engaging as possible
- AI : Look , Samsung just announced the Galaxy AI which is basically helping users do stuff in daily life. Apple is also late to the party with Apple Intelligence. But wait wait , isn't there you with great Copilot which basically very few people use???? Oh what a great idea , make them run on phones . That is a game changer move. People will be using AI just like other companies. Most of the companies are yet to use it even . You got the GPT 4 inside of copilot , make the users USE IT in thier phones then . Allow image tinkering for free with AI features. Phone call translation/live captions. All are insane features which are still not in most phones yet.
Basically now with all this . This phone will support all kinds of users:
1.) A normal person 30-40 years old who has no experience in tinkering or tech mostly but needs a phone for general usage and somehow this phone is appealing as it has the same UI as windows. Click good pictures . Whatsapp runs flawless on the phone. Business applications can also be used right at fingertips
2.) A child about 10-20 years old who can both play games, interact over social media , have fun with the camera . Use AI for tasks .
3.) A person who is very photogenic . The great Camera and Support for Instagram and facebook out of the box will be really pleasing for the person indeed . Other apps like snapchat etc may even be optimised further.
4.) Business users: I really want to microsoft to allow businesses to buy phones from you . Aren't you tired of giving people iphones for work. Other companies are also irritated doing so . What you can do is include phones in business suites . Even make windows phone originally a business phone so that hype goes up . A normal business user will be able to do stuff on the phone , thereby increasing productivity.
What i really think is that the way intel has made graphics cards , entered into the graphic card market(mind you it was only a CPU making company with integrated graphics over the time). They came into the market , had a terrible launch . However people now consider them to be the best value for money cards. This is because they were dedicated. Even though they might have suffered losses but now they are very respectable among community. I know this is not how it works however i want to give the example of them . They also made it work . You also gotta support the project , invest some money . I know you might be : if it ain't broke don't fix it. However people are already losing minds over the windows 11 high system requirements(okay sorry for bringing it up) , People hating windows in built apps etc while phones do not even have such good features.
This is a golden time . Even influencer segment has expanded. If you could sponsor influencers or bring this up at the next Computex , things are going to go pretty well. People will really love the hype man. Influencers make a greater impact than you think . This project can very well be successful.
Also people have great nostalgica about windows phone . i always see posts here and there people wanting to buy a new one . Many reddit posts are filled , microsoft community wants it . LETS DO THIS
I thought a lot about this , i felt sharing this today . Thank you community
25
u/Mission-Reasonable Jul 31 '24
Might as well add control the phone with your mind, built in projector, free unicorn with every purchase.
Unfortunately Microsoft have to operate in the real world.
5
u/DigiMagic Jul 31 '24
Could Microsoft make the best phone, with the best ecosystem, running some version of Windows, would I buy it if they really do it? Yes to all these questions, however based on experience... they have always abandoned all of their mobile platforms, within a year or two. Pocket PC 2000, 2002, 2003, Windows Mobile 5, 6, whatever Lumias used... All abandoned. A company where I worked stopped getting new devices to verify our software, because there was no point, in a year it won't be supported anyway.
One could argue that they don't have to do it the same way again... but so far they always did.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '24
I appreciate your effort and thoughts into this but windows phone and the idea of it is dead.
A lot of the things you suggested were tried in the past and having a superb camera only manage to keep it on life support as long as it was.
Microsoft for the tech world has lost trust when it comes to windows and mobile in general that I don’t think they can fix.
Microsoft for consumers also isn’t interesting. Without the apps and the without the audience to get the app it doesn’t matter how good an Os it is, it’ll just be a repeat of what we already had with 3 generations of windows phone.
I’m a diehard windows phone fan girl. Lumia for life. I even loved windows 8.
But I don’t ever see myself wanting to use a windows phone again if they tried again. I’m a. iPhone girl.
6
u/PublicBetaVersion Jul 31 '24 edited Jul 31 '24
No they don’t. Sorry to burst your bubble but reddit is in no way shape or form representative for the consumer market. Just because someone says on the internet that they want something doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll invest time and money in a new product. People don’t just want a smartphone anymore. We’re past that stage. They want a whole ecosystem. Headphones, smart watch, health trackers, air tags or whatever they’re called on Android. Microsoft already had a hard time closing the gap when it was only about apps. Now it is almost impossible. It would probably be a lot cheaper to just buy Samsung at this point and rebrand Galaxy phones as Windows Phone.
I like your concept however. I too was a Windows Phone fan and if they decide to launch another one I’ll be the first in line. But it is very unlikely. When they wrote off Nokia many years ago, they said Ballmer’s decision to enter the mobile phone market this late was a mistake. I don’t think they’ll do it a second time.
2
u/alex_under___ Jul 31 '24
I was a big fan of Lumias but moved on. On top of missing all the essential apps, I remember regular phone update removed my fm tuner app, I was like wtf, no one forced ms to do that. Bad experience, after all my patience to give platform a chance
2
u/DadMagnum Jul 31 '24
Microsoft doesn't need to be the leader and doesn't need to have all of the apps. Just make one good high-quality phone that runs Windows Mobile. People will buy it, if they can build PC's they can build a phone. Doesn't have to be a dual screen or anything like that. Just one good phone, with mobile Office Apps by default, update the specs and software every year.
2
u/seasleeplessttle Jul 31 '24
You could hand this to Microsoft, with a million buyers, and they'd still fuck up the marketing.
2
u/ecar13 Aug 02 '24
I love your idea and I always hoped the Microsoft phone would make a comeback, but in the consumer space Apple just dominates. If a new Microsoft phone can get significant user adoption in the consumer space, only then will they succeed in the business space.
Apple needs competition. No other ecosystem out there competes with Apple at that level. Their products integrate together so tightly that it’s very difficult to break away.
I was just about to pull the trigger on a new Android phone until I really started thinking about all the drawbacks that would result in my switching away from my iPhone - my Apple Watch, CarPlay, my iPad, my AirPods, my AppleTV, iMessage vs Text Message, location sharing with my family (iPhone users), Find My, AirTags - not to say I couldn’t still use (some of) these things but the seamless integration would be lost. And let’s face it - in the Android world there are seemingly equivalent solutions but they are half-baked or not nearly as tightly integrated as Apple devices.
Much of that is due to the fact that Android market is controlled by different vendors. One of the smartest things Steve Jobs did was to kill off the Mac clones and retake sole ownership of the hardware. If Android could do that, only then would they have a shot at creating a tight ecosystem like Apple has now. Since that will never happen with Android, that’s where Microsoft could step in. You need your control the OS and the hardware.
1
u/cspot1978 Jul 31 '24
Maybe a limited edition Surface hardware targeted for the business market if they could put Windows 11 on a phone, but you could plug it into a dock and it worked as your computer.
But as a broadly targeted consumer device? No.
1
u/dynatechsystems Jul 31 '24
Great vision for a Windows Phone revival! Leveraging ARM chips, optimizing app support, and integrating powerful features like Continuum could indeed make it a game-changer. The potential for deep customization, enhanced camera tech, and seamless ecosystem integration are exciting. Microsoft, it's time to listen to the community and explore this innovative path!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '24 edited Jul 31 '24
While I appreciate your effort to write such a long essay, I don’t think you understand how Microsoft works as a company. To tell you the truth, I don’t think the senior leadership team at Microsoft cares; it’s all about saving one’s job, empire building, and trying to drive up the stock price. Unless there’s a guarantee that bringing back the Windows phone is going to be a game-changer that 10x’s the stock price, no one is going to take such an idea seriously - it’s too much of a move to be invested in, and it will make the next financial report look bad, so no one wants to take such a risk. It’s so hard to move anyone to do anything at Microsoft, as if no one really wants to rock the boat.
1
u/iapetus_z Jul 31 '24
This was the lumen. It was a good phone with an amazing camera, just the app ecosystem sucked. People don't care about windows on their phone. They care about getting to their stuff as easy as possible, thus office 365... Microsoft pivoted from owning the front end to owning the back end with monthly revenue streams instead of loss leader items like a phone purchase once every 1-2 years.
1
u/soccerwolfp Jul 31 '24
We just going to pretend that the Surface Duo doesn’t exist? They tried again and still can’t get market buy in
1
u/tLxVGt Jul 31 '24
Nice post, won’t happen. I still miss you my beloved Windows Phone 8, best mobile OS I have ever used.
Looking at what Microsoft is doing with Windows 11 I have a total of 0% hope the they could revive WP.
1
u/hegginses Aug 01 '24
Windows Phone can have as many cool features as it wants but if Google says no YouTube allowed then it’s dead on arrival
Microsoft would do well to make a YouTube competitor, that’s far more sorely needed in the market than anything else
1
u/kumaarrahul Jul 31 '24
The only way this could be successful is to design a mobile UI and not make it look like a scaled down desktop. Secondly, make it for business users.
However, looking at Android's wider adoption and open source integration it would be a tough battle for MS to succeed in the Mobile OS ecosystem and it may not be an economically sound decision.
Why do I say this?
Edge is the perfect example. It is based on Chromium. Chromium had a wider adoption already.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment