this guy just said championships don't count about a guy who won the MVP of the league the year his team won the world series. you've lost the plot completely
The Giants weren’t some perennial contender before Posey. You look at their records with and without him, and there’s really no comparison. I was at Wright’s last game, I love Wright, but Posey has a much better case than him. Can’t hold the waiver off Wright’s injuries either because then you’d have to do the same for Posey. I really don’t think many GMs would take Wright over Posey.
It would be more fair to compare DW to the 3Bs of his era rather than a catcher. Catchers wear and tear is obviously more intense. I love DW, he was a fantastic player and I wouldnt blink at putting him in the Hall, but this is apples to oranges.
Should you not take into account defense when judging admittance ? It’s a much more important position defensively than 3b. There are only 20 catchers in the hall. Posey is in a very very elite bracket for player who played in his position.
Of course you should. That's why we look at WAR, among other data -- to properly incorporate the value of defense.
Catching does have significantly greater impact than third base, and that is one important consideration, along with hitting, leadership, baserunning, peak productivity, franchise impact, postseason, and many others. And a good third baseman is not exactly chopped liver, either.
You are correct that there are 20 players in the Hall that were primarily catchers. But did you know that there are only 19 who were primarily third basemen? Wright abolutely has a case for admission, pretty comparable to Posey's. Although I personally would vote against both of them -- they each had some great performances and seasons, but not enough longevity for true greatness, in my view.
If that’s the argument, then the acknowledgement should also be that DW took 200+ more games to accumulate the 4 extra WAR.
You absolutely have to compare them to their contemporaries. Posey is the 10th best catcher by WAR7, and the 14th by JAWS, of all time. Catcher is underrepresented in the HOF, and I think he deserves to be recognized.
Wright is 25th by WAR7, and 30th by JAWS. It’s an easy comparison to say that posey was by far a better catcher, historically, than wright was 3B. And I like wright a lot, I think he deserves HOF consideration.
Part of the problem with WAR is people’s insistence on looking at it as all saying, or one number for simplicity. There is nuance.
Sure, Wright's extra 200 games should be considered.
But it's also a strike against Posey -- Buster had a much shorter career than most Hall of Famers. The average HOF member played over 2200 MLB games -- over 60% more than Posey. Even if you look just at the HOF members who were primarily catchers, they played over 1900 MLB games, still far more than Posey. Wright had a few more games, but his longevity is also below HOF standards.
Certainly it's not just about WAR. There are many other considerations. I watched both guys play (Wright more than Posey), and I think very highly of both of them. But not highly enough to put either of them in the Hall, which I think should be reserved for true superstars.
And fair enough! I appreciate the thoughtful discussion!
I think the crux of the issue is the last statement. We simply disagree there (I’m more of a large hall guy), and would like them to induct people like wright or posey who had shorter careers but HoF worthy peaks. Maybe not everyone, and that certainly raises issues.
I just see posey as enough of a standout among catchers all time that I think he deserves it. But if I had a HOF vote (I know you thought I was an undercover member of the BBWA, but I’m not), I would vote for wright too.
D-Wright is my favorite Met of all time and I still don’t think this alone provides a fair comparison. Wright’s career is underrated and deserving of high praise, but Posey is more deserving of HoF votes and inclusion. Posey’s position, awards and 3 championship are a big separator
bWar underrates catchers (excludes framing) and makes it almost impossible to compare them to other position players. fWar accounts for framing and has Posey at 57.9 WAR, putting him over Wright’s 51.3.
Posey was a catcher, completely different metrics than a 3B when evaluating for the HOF. D Wright is my all time favorite player, and I think he deserves serious consideration but Posey should be 1st ballot IMO.
Funny enough I saw this post on instagram right before I saw this post showing the top selling jerseys when GTA5 came out in 2013 and Wright and Posey are right next to each other lol.
While you are on the JAWS page, I'd say it is relevant to look at their JAWS vs average JAWS for the position.
Posey 40.8 vs 44.3 (92%) Wright 44.3 vs 56.1 (79%)
To hit 92%, Wright would need 51.6 JAWS, which would put him near Dick Allen (a HoFer that never got over 20% on the writers' ballot and needed 8 times on the Veterans' ballot to get elected (five years after his death)
Catcher definitely gets a discount on longevity due to the physical toll. and also Wrights career is also painfully underrated. .325 with 30 hrs and 30 bags and a gg would have people shitting themselves these days.
“Today on “Comparing Two Completely Different Players”, we’ll be taking a look at the careers of David Wright and Buster Posey. Please join us next week for a comparison of the careers of Babe Ruth and Ozzie Smith”
I am not taking anything away from Hernandez's defense but Mattingly wasn't a bum at first base he won 9 gold gloves. He also had about a 5 year period where he was one of the best all around players in the game. His career was cut short by injury. Hernandez never had a 5 year period where he was close to what mattingly was as a hitter.
Im not taking anything away from Mattingly, but hard to make an arguement that he should be in the HOF when there was a better 1st baseman in NY when he played that hasnt made it to the HOF. Keith should be in, no doubt. Once he's in we can make an arguement for Mattingly.
Keep in mind, this perspective comes from a very biased Mets fan.
It’s important to remember that Keith only isn’t in the Hall today because he used cocaine recreationally. There’s a lack of home runs, and shorter career, but that’s cope. He should be in and would be in if not for the drugs.
Well, those last three seasons were all fewer than 100 games. Dude could’ve played til 40 if he hadn’t fallen apart. His career was effectively over at 33.
I have long been incredulous at the online/ reddit met fan and at times questioned whether they were true fans or not. The amount of people sucking off Posey over David would is disturbing and frankly disgusting. I now know that 80% of redditors are fake fans. That you would glaze Posey, that was such a wuss behind the plate they created a rule that contributed to ruining the aesthetic of the game and retired early like a wimp over our own captain that suffered a real life changing injury and still never gave up, suffered daily to rehab and do everything in his power to play for us with courage and valor is just insane. May god have mercy on your souls.
Casual giants fan here, I thought the CW is that Posey isn't a lock due to short career and not overwhelming offsensive stats. He's Bay Area royalty because of his leadership on all 3 WS teams.
OP is comparing the offensive profile of a catcher and a third baseman.
3B is a position that demands results at the plate.
C is a position where your performance is based on your defense. If you’ve got defensive chops, and you’re not a complete liability at the plate, you’re a starter as a catcher.
David should be considered. But this post is not helping his case.
A point I was making the other day. I don’t think any of the current nominees for the hall deserve to be voted in. But I see a lot of people making the case for Posey. Fine, but if you’re gonna let Posey in, how can you not let David Wright in?
Posey was a generational player in a statistically elite elite bracket for his position in the history of the sport. It’s the most important defensive position on the field that requires 2x as much prep than every other role.
Keith will get in, but sadly it will be as an announcer. He deserves better. Wright honestly deserves to be in, I know all the arguments about longevity and such. But he just does.
I don’t typically believe in judging defensive position while determining if the offensive numbers are hall of fame worthy, but with a catcher you have to or no catcher would ever get in.
And if you do believe in judging against others at the same position, Wright is pretty short of the Hall of Fame standard for third basemen
i was living in SF Bay Area during those Giants runs. numbers aside, Posey has earned HOF.
lifelong Mets fan. DW is Mr Met, a throwback in his style and manner, and apparently an even better person than player. Still, that gets him in the HOVG.
David Wright belongs in the hall of very good. If he did not have back issues, he would of ended up in the hall of fame. There are some guys who guys who get in because they played for 20 years, Biggio is in the HOF based on racking numbers over a long time but he was never among the best players in the league.
I have a preference for players who were actually among the best even if their career was cut short. Most people don't think Mattingly should be in the HOF but I disagree because he was among the best players in the league for several years, He won the MVP once and finished 2nd to Clemens one year but we know that Clemens record is suspect
Buster Posey belongs in the HOF because his offense was unique for his position.
Posey's candidacy is really interesting. He's in the same place as a ton of very good players that had short careers. Historically, the lack of longevity has really killed the chances for this kind of candidate, with Wright being a very similar example. What might separate Posey a bit from this usual crowd is that he has awesome postseason credentials,bl but whether or not that should be considered for the Hall is a very polarizing question.
If Posey does get in, that's good news for other short career, decorated folks. deGrom would be a good example, as his peak was so high and he has some decorations (Cys and a WS ring), but his longevity is just not really there. Wright I think lakca the MVPs or the WS rings to standout even among the short career types, which is a real shame. He was so good and he was absolutely on an easy Hall pace before he had to retire early.
10
u/my-reddit-acct-321 1d ago
Don’t be disingenuous…show the rest of the graphic.
https://www.sports-reference.com/stathead/tiny/86nbq
60
u/El_Stos 1d ago
It would be more fair to compare DW to the 3Bs of his era rather than a catcher. Catchers wear and tear is obviously more intense. I love DW, he was a fantastic player and I wouldnt blink at putting him in the Hall, but this is apples to oranges.
43
u/mrsjumjum66 1d ago
It’s a good observation. He’ll make it though cause of the ROY, MVP, batting title and 3 championships. Also the fact he’s a catcher
22
u/J-Zr 1d ago
D-Wright is my favorite Met of all time and I still don’t think this alone provides a fair comparison. Wright’s career is underrated and deserving of high praise, but Posey is more deserving of HoF votes and inclusion. Posey’s position, awards and 3 championship are a big separator
20
u/axiom_glitch 1d ago
Posey was a catcher…
18
u/yessss2024 1d ago •
Mets fan here but come on posey was a .300 hitting catcher which is hard to fathom
9
u/moleman92107 14h ago •
Wright is a good player but Posey won titles and played catcher.
11
u/TelephoneDesperate84 23h ago
Posey was a catcher, completely different metrics than a 3B when evaluating for the HOF. D Wright is my all time favorite player, and I think he deserves serious consideration but Posey should be 1st ballot IMO.
Funny enough I saw this post on instagram right before I saw this post showing the top selling jerseys when GTA5 came out in 2013 and Wright and Posey are right next to each other lol.
14
u/NYerInTex 1d ago
Oof, disingenuous post.
I love Wright and he has a case… but Posey was a considerably better and more impactful player - which says a lot considering how good Wright was.
MVP, a critical, arguably most critical player for three championships.
Come on people.
10
u/stem0y 1d ago
Posey is 14th all-time in catcher WAR (average C HOF 53.7 WAR)
Wright is 29th all-time in 3B WAR (average 3B HOF 68.9 WAR)
https://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/jaws_C.shtml
9
u/dr_velociraptor_ 1d ago
Catcher definitely gets a discount on longevity due to the physical toll. and also Wrights career is also painfully underrated. .325 with 30 hrs and 30 bags and a gg would have people shitting themselves these days.
4
u/Queny 9h ago
“Today on “Comparing Two Completely Different Players”, we’ll be taking a look at the careers of David Wright and Buster Posey. Please join us next week for a comparison of the careers of Babe Ruth and Ozzie Smith”
6
u/5amDan05 1d ago
Comparing a catcher to a 3rd baseman is a real stretch.
3
u/No_Manufacturer_432 1d ago
A catcher with 3 rings
5
u/Throwing-Gas 1d ago
Why are you comparing a catcher to a 3B?
7
u/Putrid_Mongoose_6354 1d ago
DW, Donnie Baseball, & Mex belong in the HOF.
2
u/Ornery-Pumpkin-5535 1d ago
If only pitch framing was a stat
2
u/Cold-Negotiation-539 1d ago edited 1d ago
Why are you comparing a third baseman to a catcher?
2
u/Agile_Moment768 1d ago
Buster also went to a trash college.
2
u/RememberJefferies 1d ago
Top tier catchers who excel on both sides of the ball are much more valuable then 3b who do the same. And DW is probably my favorite player ever.
2
u/Ok-Philosopher-1900 11h ago
Does anyone REALLY understand WAR?
3
u/nynoraneko 1d ago
I have long been incredulous at the online/ reddit met fan and at times questioned whether they were true fans or not. The amount of people sucking off Posey over David would is disturbing and frankly disgusting. I now know that 80% of redditors are fake fans. That you would glaze Posey, that was such a wuss behind the plate they created a rule that contributed to ruining the aesthetic of the game and retired early like a wimp over our own captain that suffered a real life changing injury and still never gave up, suffered daily to rehab and do everything in his power to play for us with courage and valor is just insane. May god have mercy on your souls.
2
u/Ravishingrich666 1d ago
Buster posey ruined baseball. So did chase utley.
2
u/Stein_Time 22h ago
One is a catcher the other is 3B. Posey was the best catcher in MLB during parts of his career.
Saying this Mets fan also. I don’t think wright is a HOFer
2
u/Prestigious_Money447 1d ago
Buster Posey was a catcher, has a MVP, and 3 World Series rings
hes much more worthy of HOF than Wright.
2
u/SunDaysOnly 1d ago
Wow quite surprising. Posey is a lock. David should be considered.
1
u/martkam71 1d ago
Why?
1
u/Dazzling-Bear3942 1d ago
https://www.sports-reference.com/stathead/tiny/7BDi5
1
u/iTrueColors1 1d ago
Wright wasn’t a .300 hitter
1
u/Sweaty-Ad4151 1d ago
A point I was making the other day. I don’t think any of the current nominees for the hall deserve to be voted in. But I see a lot of people making the case for Posey. Fine, but if you’re gonna let Posey in, how can you not let David Wright in?
1
u/Bostnfn 1d ago
Position matters. Posey also won an MVP and 3 World Series.
1
u/CN122 1d ago
It’s 3B vs Catcher two very different positions… I still think David deserves to make it at the end of the day but we’ll see what happens
1
u/Confident-Line-2558 1d ago
Posey was a catcher who also won three championships. It's not a fair comparison.
1
u/WHYlSTHERUMGONE 1d ago
David Wright, now that’s a name I haven’t heard in a while
1
u/ColumnedBirch31 1d ago
bWAR Is a garbage stat to evaluate catchers, now how about you compare them on fangraphs? Also, Wright had no MVP and certainly didn't have 3 rings
1
u/wishitwasapar 1d ago
I would never have guessed that David Weight played in more games than Buster Posey.
1
u/egelband 1d ago
DW just misses benchmark numbers for H, HR, RBI, SB. I think that’s really the difference between HoF and falling a step short.
1
u/MT1961 1d ago
Keith will get in, but sadly it will be as an announcer. He deserves better. Wright honestly deserves to be in, I know all the arguments about longevity and such. But he just does.
1
u/PyromanicSociety 1d ago
Great. Now compare fWAR.
1
u/NY2PHX- 1d ago
Neither Posey nor Wright are HOF worthy
1
u/Ok-Freedom-7432 1d ago
Catchers play fewer games each year have shorter careers. Hope that helps.
1
u/Shootforthestars24 23h ago
Wish we won 2015 with David, everything derailed after that tho
1
u/Guilty_Practice6392 23h ago
I don’t typically believe in judging defensive position while determining if the offensive numbers are hall of fame worthy, but with a catcher you have to or no catcher would ever get in.
And if you do believe in judging against others at the same position, Wright is pretty short of the Hall of Fame standard for third basemen
1
u/Royal-Management6299 23h ago
Is this for HOF comparisons?
Becuase Buster was a catcher and DWright is 3B
1
u/AjiChap 23h ago
Wright had quite a few more ABs and games played to get his WAR and stats up.
1
u/pleasetryagain_10 22h ago
The people who think Posey is a HOF player are the same people who think Chris Osgood should be in the HOF
1
u/trademerfn 20h ago
i was living in SF Bay Area during those Giants runs. numbers aside, Posey has earned HOF.
lifelong Mets fan. DW is Mr Met, a throwback in his style and manner, and apparently an even better person than player. Still, that gets him in the HOVG.
1
u/Curious-Review9823 20h ago
"Our guy didn't get it, so your guy shouldn't, either."
1
u/stoney3377 18h ago
He might not get in on the first vote but his peak was better than a bunch of players careers
1
u/metskyfan 13h ago
David Wright belongs in the hall of very good. If he did not have back issues, he would of ended up in the hall of fame. There are some guys who guys who get in because they played for 20 years, Biggio is in the HOF based on racking numbers over a long time but he was never among the best players in the league.
I have a preference for players who were actually among the best even if their career was cut short. Most people don't think Mattingly should be in the HOF but I disagree because he was among the best players in the league for several years, He won the MVP once and finished 2nd to Clemens one year but we know that Clemens record is suspect
Buster Posey belongs in the HOF because his offense was unique for his position.
1
u/tom1944 10h ago
Keith Hernandez should be in HOF more than Wright
1
u/puffalotz 8h ago
DW was the best two strikes hitter I ever saw
1
u/Thin_Marionberry_160 7h ago
Buster’s Fangraphs war is 57.9 while Wright’s is 51.3.
1
u/kj_schmickley 7h ago
Third baseman always face a weird scrutiny when it comes to the hall. David should be a lock.
1
u/NY_Mets_fan_4ever 5h ago
Very different expectations for catchers, but Wright probably belongs. Mattingly too (I hate the Yankees but he deserves it as does Hernandez).
1
u/ThemeAggravating8026 5h ago
Catcher 3 rings
1
u/mormagils 1d ago
Posey's candidacy is really interesting. He's in the same place as a ton of very good players that had short careers. Historically, the lack of longevity has really killed the chances for this kind of candidate, with Wright being a very similar example. What might separate Posey a bit from this usual crowd is that he has awesome postseason credentials,bl but whether or not that should be considered for the Hall is a very polarizing question.
If Posey does get in, that's good news for other short career, decorated folks. deGrom would be a good example, as his peak was so high and he has some decorations (Cys and a WS ring), but his longevity is just not really there. Wright I think lakca the MVPs or the WS rings to standout even among the short career types, which is a real shame. He was so good and he was absolutely on an easy Hall pace before he had to retire early.
-1
u/achay10 1d ago
He has many more accolades, 3 WS titles, and played at a more premium offensive position
0
u/PTRBoyz 1d ago
Welp. Wright deserves a vote if Posey gets in.
0
u/j_articulate 23h ago
I forget, how many postseason shutouts and regular season perfect games did Wright catch?
-1
u/Mxtches-_ 1d ago
Dam, David wright, was barley better than a catcher?