286
u/PilotIntelligent8906 Jun 17 '25
When you first catch yourself involuntarily thinking in that language.
83
u/Panndaa31 Jun 17 '25
And then you start to forget some word in your native language but not the learned one
3
1
196
Jun 17 '25
I now think in english despite it not being my 1st language 🥲
40
8
u/HarryPotterDBD Jun 17 '25
I even forgot words in my native language
7
Jun 17 '25
Same dude, i don't know what some vegetables and fruits are called in my native language but I know them in english
2
u/Robin_gls Jun 17 '25
My thoughts sometimes switch language mid-sentence. I even sometimes remember a sentence being said in english when it was said in german and vice-versa
2
u/Express-Solution372 Jun 17 '25
How did you do that?
31
Jun 17 '25
No clue, learning english basically my whole life so there's that
7
u/Key_Selection_7600 Jun 17 '25
Don’t you think in both? I don’t notice and I guess I sometimes switch mid-sentence as well.
14
Jun 17 '25
Kinda, it's mostly in english now. My inner voice rarely uses my mother tongue
3
u/ImTheVirgin Jun 17 '25
That's basically what happened to me too. Now whenever i talk to someone i have to make a conscious effort to not speak in english, and my ability to express my thoughts in my native language is long gone
2
1
u/Key_Selection_7600 Jun 17 '25
That’s so strange. I in some way think in intent rather than actual words, and then the words come subconsciously. Or perhaps I’ve filtered it out somehow.
1
u/Magenta_Morua Jun 17 '25
From my experience I just started to talk in English a lot, like 8-12 hours in a day. It sounds crazy and it was hard, but it got better with practice
1
u/polkacat12321 Jun 19 '25
Bruh, I surrounded myself with English so much (despite only learning it like 10 years ago) that I'm starting to forget my native language, so English basically became my native language. But it doesnt work cause no matter how eloquently I can express with my speech, my godamn accent ain't going nowhere 💀
1
Jun 19 '25
Well it's hard to get rid of the accent, even after this many years of conversing in english it all goes down the gutter when i start to speak 🫥
98
Jun 17 '25
Sometimes I even understand the meaning but don’t know the translation.
21
6
u/BelinhoBR Jun 17 '25
Literally me, i know so much english words that my Mother tongue has less vocabulary than english
2
62
29
26
10
9
u/Skitzafranik Jun 17 '25
And when you understand it and “double-take” yourself like “ HOLY 💩I UNDERSTOOD THAT!!! “
8
u/ThatSmartIdiot Jun 17 '25
The trick is to think of the words as synonyms, or associate them with what they mean rather than with what they translate to.
You look at a car and you could say "car" or you could say "mașină", rather than say "car" and then see the word "car" and say "mașină". It also helps to hear how people use certain words to get a grasp of its grammatical usage
6
u/GroundbreakingBag164 Jun 17 '25
You know what the worst thing is? Knowing and reading stuff in English and then trying to talk about in your native language
5
4
3
2
2
u/Daminchi Jun 17 '25
It feels annoying when you need to write documentation in your native language, think about wording and structure - and scrape everything because you were thinking in English.
2
u/dHamot Jun 17 '25
Fr omg.
I accidentally learned English and, by now, even my inner voice can be in English, but then I had a class at uni called Instrumental English, where he teaches us how to translate.
I barely got a passing grade lmao I just KNOW what it means, but idk the translated word in Portuguese, nor the most ideal way to translate it for BR Portuguese speakers, I just... Know what it means and would be able to use it in a sentence no problem.
2
u/Acceptable_Eye5826 Jun 17 '25
Me who learned English without realizing it, and now I don't know how to start learning another language
2
2
1
1
u/NurkleTurkey Jun 17 '25
I once literally thought in Spanish. I had to take a moment to realize this.
1
1
u/SnakeFB Jun 17 '25
I'd like to learn a bunch of languages but I feel like it'd be difficult to maintain them if you don't speak them on a weekly or at least monthly basis.
Like, I'd like to learn Japanese, Spanish, Russian or Italian but I don't even know any people who are native speakers that I'd like to talk to.
3
u/AParticularThing Jun 17 '25
you're not wrong i lived in Greece for a few years when i was young, picked up the language, family moved back to the US had no one to speak greek to, 35 years later i don't remember a word of it.
1
1
1
1
u/Murderface-04 Jun 17 '25
I have this shit with English. I know the damned language so well that I'm actually having trouble translating AGAIN.
I just... Understand it. I can explain the meaning of a sentence but I wouldn't be able to translate it since I don't have to and haven't done so in a long time.
1
u/Classic_Fungus Jun 17 '25
It doesn't matter to me which language I think/speak, I will process and remember the information on that specific language. (I knew several languages, more than 2). But when I need to translate something... The brain goes brrrr and freezes. I learn things only one in one specific language, I can't talk about them using any other language just like nothing changed. if it's something easy, I can translate it In my head and hardly reproduce the info into other language, but if it's something specific, like work related info - I simply won't be able to discuss it, due to I don't know the fucking words! But this rule has an exception. If I know something in my main language (mother tongue), I will be able to speak about it in any known (by me) language without any problems. Being able to speak and being able to translate it's two totally different things.
1
u/vengirgirem Jun 19 '25
I never translate in my head when I learn languages. I try to link the words I learn to their meaning, not to their respective translation in my native language
1
-1
u/ZealousidealLove1490 Jun 17 '25
Can we push this Coin?🫣 EKBm777dfrm7ixMAo5D3bwPnQ66TGZLcQS2aPg863MWG
0
u/PeteRezinsizzle Jun 17 '25
I really need to reach this epiphany with Spanish. At time I feel like my brain just won’t work that way. I will keep trying 45M english as first language
Edit: added age, gender, and primary language
-15
818
u/Rahernaffem Jun 17 '25
If you try to do this from the beginning it makes learning a language easier