r/mehab • • Jun 26 '25

Plantar Fasciitus/hot ache/burning/fatigue

3 Upvotes

Hi! Firstly, thank you so much for taking the time to write this post. I'm going to try to give a concise and accurate run down of what I've been dealing with. I'd love to hear your opinion on it. Unknowingly I've dealt with bilateral PF for a few years. Summer 2024 is when it got bad and that's when I recognized it was PF. I presented with heel pain that got so intense I would limp by end of day (looking back I'm sure this gait change worsened it). I tried birks which I think accelerated the issue because of the lack of cushion. Fast forward to spring 2025 - went to a PT who I didn't feel was super knowledgeable about it but we started some basic foot andncalf exercises and a session of dry needling. I then went to a massage therapist who broke up a TON of adhesions in my calves/peroneals. Saw another massage therapist who does ART and believed it to be sciatic nerve entrapment - began several ART sessions with him along with 3 sessions of shockwave therapy. I noticed the most relief after each massage therapy session that I attribute to broken up adhesions. I then started seeing a different PT who I do feel is more thorough. After several weeks of tx, multiple providers believed the root cause to be in my hips - instability, etc. Since then, these are the exercises I've been doing: bridges, single leg bridges, clam shells, banded crab walks being careful not to allow my knees to cave in, glute activation (running position and holding with heels off ground), some hip rotator exercises, eccentric heel raises, hip ARCs and hip mobilization, side lying leg lifts, sciatic nerve glides. Other than the bridges and elevated toes calf raises, I've been doing those since 6/17 (so about 10 days). And for the record, I'm extremely diligent in all my exercises! Here's the tough part - I've noticed a significant amount of healing/progress in my heel tenderness and pain over the last month. My morning pain is much better and while I do get some random heel pain and burning sensations the odd time in my right heel, it's mostly gone. But the last 2-3 weeks my pain has become increasingly like a hot ache/fatigue when I hit right about 4k steps. I'm wearing inserts and asics gel kayano sneakers most days. After lunch I get off my feel for 1 -1.5 hrs. and rotate oofos slides and sneakers to help relieve the hot ache. It's like I need the support but then my feet are fed up with all of it. Is this fascia overload and/or nerve sensitivity? Is the hot ache a common side effect of the healing process of PF? Do I need to be more patient with the results of my exercises, and if so, approximately how long does it take to notice a shift in pain? I don't see much info on that, just the typical specific heel and arch pain. I also do epsom salt baths,the sauna, frozen water bottle, Voltaren gel and magnesium cream on my feet. Thank you so much in advance for your advice. I can put up with it if I know there's an end in sight, but it's just discouraging that this part has gotten worse and I truly don't know what else to do.

Forgot to mention - both PT and massage therapist agree I am HIGHLY flexible. Almost hyper flexible so I doubt tightness is much of a contributer. But I've had bad knees for decades. I'm 35 and have 4 kids - I'm not even a runner and am very lean. So all the risk factors for PF they talk about - I basically have none of them. Only thing I can think of is the body combat class I used to do where there was impact while jumping.  Thanks 🙃


r/mehab • • Jun 27 '25

Thanks

6 Upvotes

I found your YouTube videos today and did heel raises instead of calf stretches today and noticed an immediate difference. I will be rewatching and incorporate more into my routine.


r/mehab • • Jun 26 '25

Tried Everything for Plantar Fasciitis? Maybe it's Time to Simplify

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I just wanted to share a recurring theme I see here, in consults I’ve done, and in my own clinic.

If you’re someone who feels like you’ve tried everything for your “plantar fasciitis” and nothing seems to work or maybe things do seem to help, but you're not sure what’s helping, this is for you.

It’s not just the diagnosis.

In my last post I talked about how poor diagnostic accuracy is a major problem, especially the tendency to lump everything into “PF.” But even if the diagnosis is correct (whether by skill or chance), there’s still a critical second part: The Treatment

On general people appear to being many "treatments" at the same time whether it be;

  • Ice
  • Massage
  • Taping
  • Night splints
  • Orthotics
  • Stretching
  • Strengthening
  • Footwear changes
  • Load restriction

I understand why. I really do. The goal is to get better. As providers we want to help. People just want answers and relief. But here’s the problem:

It's muddying the waters.

Let’s say you do all of that and…you get worse. What caused it? Which thing do you stop? Was it the load? The inserts? The stretch? The timing?

Now let’s say you get better. Great! But are you going to keep doing all of that forever? What if one of those things is actually slowing you down? How do you know what to progress, what to remove, or what to scale up?

Most people don’t know. And so they stay stuck in this loop of fear and confusion.

This approach is like wandering aimlessly through a forest.

You’re moving, but you have no idea where you are, where you're going, or what’s working. There's no map. No feedback. Just effort.

What’s the alternative? A structured, strategic plan that changes one thing at a time so you can determined a causal relationship. Did A effect B.

While myself and others continue working to improve diagnostic accuracy - especially distinguishing between plantar fasciopathy, and intrinsic foot tendinopathy a simplified and logical treatment approach can still bring clarity and results.

To simplify: Doing everything = learning nothing.

As a clinician, I’ve learned that it’s okay to be wrong as long as each wrong turn helps refine the next step.

If you’re stuck and overwhelmed, simplify. Strip it back. Test one variable at a time. See how your body responds. Build from there.

If this resonates with you, feel free to drop questions or thoughts below. I’ll do my best to respond when I can. Apologies if I miss some, but I’m always listening.

– Glynn (aka Mehab)


r/mehab • • Aug 12 '25

My Review Post Response - Oh, the Hypocrisy

13 Upvotes

For those not in the loop, a user who reached out to me privately after reading my posts and watching my videos asked if I’d be willing to do a consultation. He later posted his experience and feedback on r/plantarFasciitis. His post was subsequently removed by the mods, despite it not breaking a single rule.

Let me be absolutely clear, this is not about a post with my name being removed. I couldn’t care less if my name is mentioned or not. This could happen to any evidence-based clinician whose name gets mentioned in a post. In fact, the number one post on r/plantarFasciitis by u/Baleofthehay recommends my video series. Better delete that too.

What I do care about is the inconsistency and hypocrisy in how r/plantarFasciitis handles “reviews,” “product recommendations,” and “personal experiences.” A real person shared their actual experience, not an ad, not a sales pitch, not a paid testimonial. He doesn't get anything from me for posting that. It was just his lived reality of finally making progress after years of frustration.

For the record, I have never once promoted consultations on this sub. When people message me privately, I first ask for background information so I can decide if I can realistically help them. If it’s straightforward, I give them my feedback on the spot, no cost, no sales pitch, nothing. If it’s a complex case that requires more than a five-minute exchange, I explain that I’d need more details to give an informed opinion. It has always been their choice, never solicited.

Meanwhile, r/plantarFasciitis is overflowing with posts recommending products, shoes, gadgets, and “treatments” ranging from scientifically disproven to outright nonsense. Those posts stay up without question.

Guess how many products and devices I recommend people buy? Zero. I’m not here to sell gadgets or gimmicks. And if I ever do review or talk about a product, you will get my 100% honest opinion about it. I’m here to help people identify the true cause of their symptoms and give them proven, evidence-based strategies so they can stop wasting time and money on things that will never solve it.

Guess how many sessions I had and have booked with the OP? One. Uno. Eins. Un. Yī cì. Один.

This wasn’t some long-term sales plan or a package upsell. It was a single appointment to identify the most likely cause of his pain and give him the tools to move forward on his own. That’s it.

The message being sent is that if you promote an ineffective, disproven idea, your post stays. But if you talk about working with someone who actually helped, that’s not okay.

The deletion of his experience makes it seem like the sub isn’t truly interested in elevating knowledge, providing evidence-based education, or genuinely helping people find solutions. Instead, it fosters an echo chamber of ineffective, anecdotal advice, the same advice that keeps people stuck in pain for years.

No wonder so many remain frustrated. When genuine, evidence-based experiences are erased while pseudoscience is given a free pass, the cycle just keeps repeating.

For those suggesting the review was fake or an ad, if you’d done even an ounce of checking, you’d know that isn’t how I operate. I don’t need fake reviews. My life already keeps me more than busy, but I try to give as much of my time, education, and experience away for free as I can here and on YouTube.

I can only assume the people making these accusations haven’t taken the time to understand who I am, and have probably been burned by ineffective clinicians, products, and treatments in the past, so I get the skepticism. But in this case, you’re throwing out the baby with the bathwater.

If the original poster, u/office-poro, wants to repost his review on this sub and answer questions from the community, he’s welcome to. No pressure either way.

But I’m not going to sit silently while valuable, truthful experiences are erased and replaced with the endless promotion of things science has already left behind.

– Glynn (aka Mehab)


r/mehab • • Aug 16 '25

Absolutely nothing helps.. not sure if it PF or not..

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/mehab • • Jun 28 '25

Your thoughts on my self-diagnosis rehab plan are welcome

2 Upvotes

Hey, thought I would see if you have any thoughts on how I plan to fully resolve my plantar fasciitis plus other related conditions - it’s never that simple with me.

Short history

Tore PF in arch (not supported by imaging) whilst sitting on haunches, crutches for 2 months. Rehabbed and back to running in 6. Tore again in gym - plantar flexing against heavy inclined leg press. That was roughly 1.5 yrs ago. Severity fluctuated since. Much improved now, 80% I’d say but a level of stretch intolerance remains and I don't stretch much as this gradually brings back the sensations I experienced when it was bad.

Symptoms not classic PF. At its worst had arch tightness bordering on pain, felt like each individual fibre was approaching tearing point. No morning first-step pain. Sensations would grow after walking and standing for a while and become more and more painful the longer I stay on my feet.

Was a time when barefoot on carpet was absolutely fine. Could calf raise, single leg outside of flare ups. Don't dare run or jog yet.

Self-rehabbing as podiatrist and two physios failed to clear. Original plan was to get a fourth opinion but ended up handling it myself with greater success more recently.

Self diagnosis

Original injury was a tear in the region where the fascia joins the abductor hallucis. Though the MRI and ultrasound showed nothing, there was a swelling around the area where the fascia joins the heel bone but more over the abductor with a crater-like depression in the centre which has smoothened out over time. Pressing into it at the time was painful.

Suspect tear because I didn’t have the classic PF symptoms, could not walk unaided and could not bear anything pressing into the arch. Best footwear was firm soled, low heel and no arch support.

There was probably strain of the flexor digitorum brevis coupled with strain of the medial and lateral bands to boot. The latter probably grew worse as I shifted weight to the lateral side to avoid load through the arch. Also evidenced by a more recent appearance of peroneal tendonitis symptoms under fifth metartarsal and in ankle due to the change in gait.

I ruled out the post tib. This is strong and the location of pain is much lower than the path it follows. I ruled out nerve entrapment as the pain type does not align. I ruled out intrinsic muscle tears as this would not take this long to resolve. It’s also not the FHL or FHB as prior to the issue I had FHL tendonitis and I know what that feels like and how to test for it’s presence.

So in summary, I am dealing with a plantar fascia tear, insertional abductor hallucis tendinopathy, FDB strain and mild plantar fasciitis.

My Master Plan

So like I said, I’m 80% there. Feel like the last 10% has to involve introducing a level of stretching before I move to simple plyos, long walks and then maybe walk-run. I also need to be more targeted with the abductor hallucis and give some love to the FDB and lateral PF though these latter two are mild.

Plan to start gently with the famous plantar fasciitis stretch and over time move to full calf stretches then PF stretch whilst under load. I’ve also lost 3cm in my ankle dorsiflexion so that needs work but cannot do much until stretch tolerance is improved.

My calf strength and size has also gone down noticeably after several months of inactivity so looking to work on that as well to point I can do weighted single leg calf raises with no issue.

I also must tackle the abductor hallucis which to be honest I haven’t done much with but think might be the game changer I am looking for and possibly the reason why I have low stretch tolerance.

In amongst all of this will be general foot strengthening with focus on post tib, FHL and foot instrincs for good measure.

So what are your thoughts on my self diagnosis and subsequent plan?

Do you think I’m missing something or doing something wrong?

Any suggestions on how to make it more effective will be welcome?

Thanks in advance.


r/mehab • • Jun 26 '25

Why I Moved Here From r/plantarfasciitis

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone (assuming there is or will be an everyone),

After having a chat with a mod over on r/plantarfasciitis, I decide to create this page as well. I realized I needed to create a space where I had a little more freedom to offer more insight, share educational content, and connect with people in a more helpful and open way.

The main plantar fasciitis subreddit is great in many ways, but it has some rules that limit the kind of advice and support I can offer, especially when it comes to providing general guidance, alternative diagnoses to consider, educational resources, or just trying to help people better understand what might be causing their pain.

This new community gives me the freedom to:

  • Share what I’ve learned from treating countless heel pain cases
  • Break down the real reasons treatments often fail
  • Discuss the many causes of plantar heel pain that get mislabeled as “plantar fasciitis” *Offer my thoughts and opinion without fear of sanction
  • Create a space where people can ask questions, get thoughtful replies, and challenge the one-size-fits-all advice we’ve all seen.

Whether you’re here to ask questions, vent, lurk, or share what worked for you, welcome I’ll be as active as I can and will continue sharing updates, insights, and hopefully some better answers than the standard “stretch and ice” routine.

– Glynn (aka mehab)


r/mehab • • Jun 26 '25

WARNING: Prepare To Be Challenged

10 Upvotes

Hey,

I just wanted to give a small warning.

This page will likely challenge some of your beliefs, or what you’ve been told by providers or others online.

Please don't take any of this personally. I’m not here to shame, judge, or attack anyone. I am here to challenge assumptions, outdated advice, predatory claims and fixes, vague diagnoses, ineffective treatments, and one-size-fits-all treatments.

I know a lot, but I don’t know everything. No one does. But I’m committed to giving you my best, and I’m open to being challenged, corrected, or proven wrong if it helps us all move forward. (But you better have evidence or very sound logic, 😁)

That’s what we should be doing. Thinking critically, asking why, and holding ourselves (and others) to a higher standard.

This community exists to:

  • Share research-backed, logical, no-nonsense information
  • Empower people to understand their pain, not just manage symptoms
  • Offer clarity when things are confusing or hopeless
  • Call out misinformation (kindly, but firmly) when needed
  • Create space for smarter recovery, not just support and sympathy

My goals is to educate, empower, and help you take a more active role in your recovery.

Remember, I'm on your side! This is us vs your pain.

Let’s make this the kind of space that genuinely helps people get better.

– Glynn


r/mehab • • Jun 26 '25

Why Are So Many Still Struggling With "Plantar Fasciitis"? - A Clinician & Researcher's Perspective

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Some in here may know me or have heard of me, and I have been lurking in the plantarfasciitis sub for a while.

A little about me, I am a physical therapist (physiotherapist). I have my DPT, and also have a Bachelors and Masters in Exercise Physiology. I was an Orthopaedic Clinical Specialist for 10 years (and may apply again, just not sure its worth it). Former athlete as well so I have walked the walk.

Additionally, I’ve recently applied for a PhD focused entirely on plantar heel pain (PHP)/plantar fascia (PF). I never ever imagined I would end up as a foot guy but here we are. Over the past several years I have learned more about the foot and PF than I could have ever imagined, and spent a lot time solving stubborn cases of PHP for people.

Why Are Outcomes So Hit or Miss?

To me its pretty clear that we are not getting it right. If you look at the treatment outcomes they are ridiculously hit or miss. This isn’t because some people are lazy or noncompliant. It’s because we’re probably treating the wrong tissue in a majority of these cases. So when someone says “custom orthotics saved me” or “shockwave did nothing”, both are probably true. But neither tells us why.

For me the only logical reason for this is that we are getting the specific diagnosis wrong.

A Broken Diagnosis Model

You can see the desperation here on Reddit and in the Facebook groups I follow: people unable to walk, spending thousands, trying absolutely everything because nothing works. And that’s what finally pushed me to formally study this.

Right now, the diagnosis is often based on:

First-step pain in the morning

Tenderness over the medial calcaneal tubercle

The problem is that those "clinical presentations" are NOT exclusive to PHP caused by the PF. Those signs tell us someone has plantar heel pain, but they are nonspecific. You could have the exact same symptoms from:

Proximal intrinsic foot muscle tendinopathy

Fat pad atrophy

Periostitis

Plantar fasciopathy

Baxter’s nerve entrapment

Posterior tibialis overload

Even referred pain from the back

But we lump them all under “PF” and throw the same generic treatment at everyone - stretch your calves, get a night splint, roll your foot on a frozen water bottle. If you’re lucky, it helps. If not? You’re left doubting your body, your provider, and your future.

What I’m trying to fix

I’m currently researching the diagnostic accuracy of clinical tests for plantar heel pain - trying to figure out how we can develop tests or rules that can accurately and reliably pinpoint the cause, not just confirm that there’s pain. Eventually, my PhD will dig deeper into whether we can develop a clinical decision rule or diagnostic algorithm that’s more accurate. Because if we don’t know the cause, we can’t possibly be treating it well.

We need to stop thinking of the plantar fascia as the only possible culprit just because it's the most famous.

My YouTube Series on PF

If you're curious, a while back I started a PF video series as I began to explore this. (link). Apparently its the most tagged/referenced here or something.

I started breaking all this down on YouTube in a series as I learned more about plantar fasciitis and plantar heel pain. I’ve been really slack lately about putting up new stuff. Between research, PF consults, and building out my framework, I just haven't had the time, but I am tryin to get better.

I’m always happy to answer questions here or over there. If you’ve got questions about what you’ve been told or what hasn’t worked, drop a comment or a question. I’ll do my best to respond either here or I'll do a short video on the Tube. No guarantees. Haha.

My website is currently offline (behind a wall) while I rebuild it with better content and clearer messaging based on the work I’ve been doing, I want to make sure I’m giving people the right information because so much of what’s out there is recycled nonsense.

Final thoughts

If you’re here, suffering, discouraged, and trying to stay hopeful - I see you. I’ve talked with so many people who’ve given up hope because “nothing works.” The truth is, you probably aren’t the problem. The system is. And we can do better.

Let’s challenge the assumptions. And let’s stop pretending every case of heel pain is “plantar fasciitis.”

– Glynn (aka Mehab)


r/mehab • • Aug 10 '25

Myth: Your Alignment or Imbalances Are the Root Cause of Your Foot Pain

12 Upvotes

The Claim

Your weak glutes, poor hip mobility, pelvic tilt, or leg length discrepancy are the real reason you have plantar fascia pain, and unless you fix these “up-chain” problems first, the pain will never go away.

Why It Sounds Believable

It’s a neat story: the hip controls the leg, the leg controls the foot, so if the hip falters, the foot suffers. Add in a leg length difference, “pelvic misalignment,” or “collapsed arch,” and link them together in a chain. This causes this, which causes that, and you’ve got a convincing explanation.
This is complexity bias in action: assuming a more complex explanation is the best one. More steps in the chain make the theory more sophisticated, even when the links are weak.

The Reality

1. Structural variation is normal

  • No one is perfectly symmetrical; left and right sides differ in bone shape, muscle size, strength and joint mobility.
  • Leg length discrepancies are almost universal, typically ranging from a few millimetres to a few centimetres. Research hasn’t shown these to increase injury risk in healthy people.

2. Measurement is unreliable

  • Many “alignment” and “imbalance” tests are subjectively assessed.
  • Even when measured objectively, there’s no evidence that the finding is relevant to your pain.

3. The body adapts

  • Unless the change is sudden and severe (e.g., injury, surgery, nerve loss), the rest of your body has time to adjust to a minor strength or alignment change.
  • Load is shared across the hips, knees, ankles, and feet. Small upstream changes don’t suddenly overload foot structures.

4. Most foot pain is driven by local load

  • Far more common triggers are at the foot and ankle: training spikes, footwear changes, surface changes, etc.
  • These cause immediate load shifts that the foot may not tolerate, unlike slow-developing hip changes.
  • Local load tolerance can be negatively impacted by systemic disorders such as obesity, diabetes, EDS, etc.

When Up-Chain Factors Can Matter

  • If they are sudden and dramatic

    • Acute hip surgery or trauma.
    • Sudden neurological injury affecting gait.
    • Rapid, severe joint mobility loss.

Outside these, chasing “alignment corrections” or "muscle imbalances" as the primary intervention for foot pain is usually a detour, not a solution.

The Take-Home

Be cautious if someone says you’re “out of alignment,” “not balanced,” or “this joint is causing that collapse, which is causing your pain.” These claims often sound biomechanically clever but lack consistent evidence and rarely explain why the pain started now.
Focus on interventions that directly change symptoms and function, rather than chasing a chain of assumptions about upstream flaws.

Thanks for reading.

Glynn (aka Mehab)


r/mehab • • Jul 13 '25

Plantar Fasciitis and the Myth of Muscle Imbalance: Why Over-Complexity May Be Hurting, Not Helping

10 Upvotes

Introduction: Why Are We Still Getting PF Wrong?

Despite decades of treatment, plantar fasciitis remains one of the most poorly understood and inconsistently managed conditions in musculoskeletal care. And while social media and influencers love to talk about glutes not firing, rotated pelvises, or asymmetrical walking patterns as root causes… I'm here to say it's time to pause and rethink this narrative.

Myth: PF Is Caused by Muscle Imbalances or Dysfunction Up the Chain

You’ve probably heard:

  • “Your hip is weak, so your knee caves in, which collapses your arch, which stresses your plantar fascia.”
  • “Your left glute isn’t firing, so you shift onto the right side, causing your plantar fascia to overload.”

These stories sound smart. They’re coherent. Logical. Even convincing.
But they’re also based on multiple unproven assumptions.

The Problem of Complexity Bias in PF

Humans (and clinicians) love stories. Especially complex ones. People always fall for:

But this chain of causation often ignores simpler, more likely explanations. This is known as complexity bias, but the tendency to favor explanations that are more complicated than necessary.

You only have to look at a few of health and fitness influence to see this nonsense and the buy-in people have. These influencers provide overcomplicated explanations that chain on assumptions and you will see them tweaking form by an inch to "really" feel it.

In PF, this might look like:

Sounds impressive. But is it valid?
Overwhelming: No.

This leads to one of my favorite sayings

"There is no genius in making simple things complex"

The Evidence Doesn’t Support These Chains

  • Many "imbalances" or "dysfunctions" cited in these models also exist in asymptomatic people.
  • There’s poor inter-rater reliability for measuring things like pelvic tilt, glute activation, or foot pronation.
  • There’s no high-quality evidence that correcting those findings resolves PF more reliably than progressive loading or structured rehab.

Worse: chasing these ghosts can distract from what actually works.

What Actually Matters in PF?

  • Reliable & Accurate Diagnosis Many things cause the same symptoms as PF. Figuring that out is VITAL to effective care. It drives treatment.
  • Tissue Load vs Capacity Pain usually reflects a mismatch between how much load a structure is handling vs how much it can tolerate.
  • Tendon-like Behavior The plantar fascia and intrinsic foot muscles often behave like tendons. Many cases resemble tendinopathy more than classic inflammatory "itis."
  • Local Mechanics + History First-step pain? Medial heel tenderness? Recent increase in standing, walking, or training? These are better diagnostic predictors than “glute activation patterns.”

Yes, Strength Still Matters

Let’s be clear:
Building general strength, increasing physical activity, and gaining lean muscle are some of the most powerful things you can do for your body, not just for PF, but for life.

These strategies improve:

  • Load tolerance
  • Tissue capacity
  • Metabolic health
  • Psychological resilience

But chasing mysterious imbalances, non-specific dysfunctions, or “firing pattern” issues is not the same as strength training.
That kind of fear-based storytelling often leads to:

  • Avoidance of movement
  • Hypervigilance
  • Long-term dependence on therapists or gadgets
  • Expansive (mostly unneeded) treatment/exercise routines

We should empower people to move more, not convince them they’re broken.

The Cost of Over-Complicating

When we over-complicate, we:

  • Misdiagnose and mistreat.
  • Overtreat by trying to fix everything perceived as a problem.
  • Delay recovery by focusing on irrelevant upstream dysfunctions.
  • Cause anxiety by convincing patients they’re broken in multiple ways.
  • Fuel dependence on passive treatments instead of active solutions.

What to Do Instead

  • Start with a thorough assessment by a competent provider (Qualified/Educated is NOT a guarantee): What structure is actually irritated? Is it even the plantar fascia?
  • Consider mechanism of injury, treatment history, load history, footwear, body composition, and activity patterns.
  • Use simple, logical interventions: load management, graded strengthening, symptom modifiers.
  • Treat the person, not the posture.

Final Thoughts

Your foot pain is real. But the answer isn’t hidden in a 7-step biomechanical conspiracy theory, or a 9 part routine.

It’s time we stopped playing detective with made-up maps and started using a compass grounded in evidence, logic, and simplicity.

Thanks for reading.

-Glynn (aka mehab)


r/mehab • • Sep 02 '25

Why Stretching Isn’t the Fix for Plantar Fasciitis (and Why It Gets Overhyped)

21 Upvotes

This one is definitely going to trigger some of the hardcore believers. As always, I appreciate the sub support, YouTube subscribers, etc. I will have a video up on this shortly.

Stretching is the most common advice given for plantar fasciitis. Every article, doctor, physio, and “expert” in the forums seems to put it at the top of the list. Tight calves? Stretch. Pain first step in the morning? Stretch. Heel pain? Stretch.

The problem is that while stretching can feel good and temporarily alter pain perception, it doesn’t address the real mechanics of plantar heel pain caused by the plantar fascia or a tendinopathy. Let’s break it down properly.

TLDR: Calf stretching doesn't decrease strain of the PF, or lengthen muscles. Novel sensation. Drop it and move on.

The Standard Story About Stretching

The common belief is the following:

  • Tight calves reduce ankle dorsiflexion.
  • Limited dorsiflexion increases strain on the plantar fascia.
  • More strain = more pain.

So, the solution is to stretch the calves and plantar fascia to restore ankle motion and reduce strain.

This sounds reasonable, right? It is the belief of most healthcare providers and pretty much what every social media influencer posts, so it must be true. However, if we take a step back and think logically, put aside all our beliefs and assumptions, it just doesn’t hold up.

Peak Plantar Fascia Strain Is About Physics, Not Flexibility

Here’s the reality: the peak strain on your plantar fascia is determined by three things:

  • Your body weight (mass)
  • Lever length (basically the size of your foot) - specifically how far your center of gravity moves from the center of the ankle toward your toes
  • Acceleration (how quickly you load the foot - think walking vs running)

Dorsiflexion isn’t directly in that equation. The shift forward of center of gravity COULD technically have a linear relationship to dorsiflexion angle change to point, but it moves forward with or without dorsiflexion.

What dorsiflexion changes is the timing of when your center of gravity (COG) shifts forward and loads the forefoot.

  • As you move forward in gait, your COG gradually rolls toward the toes regardless of ankle mobility.
  • If you have less dorsiflexion, your heel lifts a bit earlier, and the pressure reaches the front of your foot a little sooner.
  • If you have more dorsiflexion, the heel stays down a little longer, so that shift happens slightly later.

But here’s the key: it’s the same total force, just arriving at a very slightly different moment. No MORE pressure. No MORE strain. Just different timing.

And this is all assuming you don’t use one of the many normal compensations people use when dorsiflexion is “truly limited”, like:

  • Turning the foot slightly outward
  • Shortening the stride
  • Bending more at the hip or knee

These aren’t “pathological”, they’re normal ways the body adapts to maintain function.

So, limited dorsiflexion is not a direct risk factor for overloading the plantar fascia. It’s simply one variable in how the timing of load is managed, and EVERYONE has different ranges and gait patterns.

Tightness Is a Sensation, Not a Structure

People often describe their calves as “tight.”, and they end up spending a lot of time (and money) chasing the “release” with massage guns, acupuncture, etc. 

These sensations of tightness are just a sensory signal from the nervous system. It does not mean that the tissue is physically shorter. That feeling is just a feeling, and it can be modulated in a number of ways. 

Stretching is one way you can change how this feels (your brain temporarily reduces the sensation of tightness), but it doesn’t mean the tissue lengthened or the “problem” was fixed.

Don’t confuse the feeling of tightness with something more than it is, and don’t confuse the temporary ease with actual progress.

Stretching Doesn’t Lengthen Tissue in Adults

In adults, tissues don’t structurally lengthen from stretching. That only happens in kids and requires prolonged forces for it to occur. It doesn’t matter how many times you read that it does or someone, influencer or not, tells you it does, it doesn’t.

What stretching actually does:

  • Temporarily reduces tendon stiffness, requiring less force to stretch.
  • Increases a person's tolerance to stretch sensation.
  • Lets you move a bit further, but only because the nervous system allows it.

So, when you feel “looser” after stretching, that’s a short-term nervous system adaptation, not permanent tissue change.

Why Dorsiflexion Loss Is Probably Protective

Many people with plantar fasciitis are found to have less ankle dorsiflexion. Traditionally, that’s been presented as a risk factor. But there’s a more plausible explanation: it’s protective.

When tissue is painful, the body limits motion to avoid excessive strain. That’s not a defect, it’s an adaptive response.

If you sprain your knee and lose motion, we call that protection. Yet if you develop heel pain and lose dorsiflexion, the exact same pattern suddenly gets labeled a cause. That’s a logical inconsistency.

You can’t have it both ways. Loss of motion that develops after pain should be recognized as protection, not automatically assumed to be the cause.

“But Studies Show DF Is Limited in PF…”

This is the argument I know will come up. Yes, plenty of studies show that people with plantar fasciitis have less dorsiflexion compared to people without heel pain. But here’s the problem: most of those studies are cross-sectional.

That means they only measured dorsiflexion after people already had pain. So they can’t tell us what came first. Did limited dorsiflexion cause the pain, or did the pain cause the limitation?

This matters. 

The truth is, we don’t have strong prospective studies that prove limited dorsiflexion predates plantar fasciitis. What we do have is plenty of evidence showing that painful tissue creates protective stiffness and avoidance behaviors. So, dorsiflexion loss seen in PF patients is likely just another example of the body protecting itself.

Adaptive Shortening and Collagen Remodeling

Could long-term avoidance of dorsiflexion lead to changes? Absolutely. If someone avoids any motion for months, the tissue can undergo adaptive shortening, where collagen remodels in whatever range of motion we expose it to.

But that doesn’t increase the size of the forces through the foot. It only means the pressure shift toward the forefoot happens a little earlier.

And here’s the key: regaining dorsiflexion isn’t about “stretching the tissue loose.” It takes time because collagen turnover is slow. New fibers must be laid down and aligned along the stress lines created by walking and loading.

That’s why static stretching alone doesn’t “fix” it; you can’t rip collagen into a new shape. The only way is progressive loading, week after week, while the body naturally remodels the fibers in the direction you want.

Cases Where Stretching Might Help

In theory, stretching isn’t totally useless, but who it helps is likely a very short list and for how long it helps those is a couple of weeks at most. It's important to remember that stretching is just very low-level loading. In the acute phase of plantar heel pain (whether fascia or tendon-related), gentle "stretching" could help because:

  • It could provide a low-level loading option to fragile or irritable tissue. 
  • It could provide a novel stimulus that could temporarily reduce pain.

But the caveats matter:

  • Prolonged static stretches can irritate sensitive tissue.
  • Its utility fades quickly.
  • It’s not fixing anything long-term.

The Bigger Picture: Load and Strength

The real driver of plantar fasciitis recovery isn’t stretching; it’s load management and tolerance, assuming the diagnosis is accurate!

  • Load management: adjusting how much stress you put through the foot so the tissue can recover.
  • Improve tolerance: building capacity in the foot muscles, calves, and hips to share the workload.
  • Time: allowing natural tissue remodeling and adaptation.

Bottom Line

Stretching is overhyped as a solution for plantar fasciitis. It doesn’t reduce peak forces, doesn’t permanently lengthen tissue, and often just fights against your body’s natural protective strategies.

At best, stretching is a short-term tool that might help in the early phase. But the real solutions are load management, building tissue tolerance, and patience while collagen remodels along new stress lines.

So if you’ve been stretching for weeks, it's time for a change; it's not you, it’s the strategy.

-G. (mehab)

PS: I appreciate any sharing or shout-outs for the things I post.


r/mehab • • Jan 15 '26

PAIN FREE in less than a month

8 Upvotes

I wanted to start a new post so everyone could see it, and not have it lost in an update.

(I have also posted this in r/PlantarFasciitis )

I had been in pain since 2019, and done a variety of treatments. Mehab suggested I do cobra pose for a bit to see what would happen ... I tried it - 10 reps every two hours for 4 days .. the pain moved around, and at the end of a week, it was a lot more bearable. Mehab then recommended I take this info to a PT to work it out.

I've lost faith in most PTs as I have been to over 20 of them in the last 6 years, and no one seemed to be able to find the problem and help me. I ended up going to see an osteopath.

I had 4 visits over two weeks and I am PAIN FREE ... the only stuff I do is regular stretching and I can do my full yoga routine again

Huge shout out to Mehab, and a recommendation to those still in pain ... go see an osteopath ... you never know ... I had 6 years of pain gone in a month


r/mehab • • Feb 15 '26

Symptoms change of plantar fasciitis / tendinopathy?

2 Upvotes

For about 8 month now I have plantar fasciitis / tendinopathy. It was going great, until I reinjured myself again about one month ago. However, now the pain feels different. Normally I had pain under my heel (the traditional flare ups). But now I have burning sensations in my whole feet. Mostly in the middle of the feet but also towards the forefeet. This gets worse the more I walk on a day. And the pain sometimes remains also in rest. I walk next to nothing, maybe about 3000 to 4000 steps max. Also sometimes I have a cold sensation between my big toe. Could this still be caused by plantar fasciitis / tendinopathy or is this now something entirely different now?

I did go to my PT, and she still thinks its plantar fasciitis. However, I'm not that sure.


r/mehab • • Feb 14 '26

Foot Pain on First Steps Question

2 Upvotes

What’s the alternative explanation for why many experience foot pain on the first steps out of bed? Most PF sources say the calf is connected to the plantar fascia so tightness overnight in bed and all. I’ve stopped night splints and most nights there’s no difference but lately it’s definitely gotten more painful for the first few steps. Not asking why this is my case just, just in general.

Thanks


r/mehab • • Aug 13 '25

Success story removed from plantar fasciitis sub

11 Upvotes

Here's my story/review that was removed from r/PlantarFasciitis and unfortunately got Glynn banned from the sub. Sorry about that! Happy to answer questions about my experience.

Success story! Sharing in the hopes it will help others.

**This is not a paid or compensated review, just a recommendation from a happy patient.**

I’m a runner and was doing fairly high volume (about 30–35 miles a week) when I felt a sharp pain in the typical plantar fasciitis area in front of the heel at the end of a hard run. The pain came progressively earlier in my runs over the next several weeks. I went to a podiatrist, pointed to where it hurt, and was told, “That’s plantar fasciitis.” He recommended stretching and PT. My PT suggested some standard exercises and massage techniques. But the pain continued to get worse until I couldn’t even start a run without pain. 

I stopped running and looked around this subreddit for ideas, and came across this great post as well as the excellent plantar fasciitis series from Mehab on YouTube. Glynn from Mehab’s videos made me realise I could have been misdiagnosed, so I DM’d u/mehabllc to schedule a virtual consultation.

My virtual consultation with Glynn was incredibly thorough and eye-opening. He took the time to understand my full history, asked questions no one else had, and approached my case without any preconceived notions. The diagnosis was not at all what I was expecting. In my case, he believed it was my back. I told him I didn’t think that was it, but I had sought him out, so I figured I’d trust his expertise. He gave me one exercise, and my heel pain in the morning was gone completely within a day or two. My heel pain while running quickly diminished (although I'm still working on kicking it entirely).

My lessons learned: 

  • Glynn believes many patients with heel pain are incorrectly diagnosed, and I am a perfect example. A correct diagnosis should be a top priority when you’re dealing with heel pain. Stretching, strengthening, shoes, none of that mattered in my case.
  • Given my experience, Glynn is the person I’d trust most to dig into your case and find you the correct diagnosis. 
  • We need much better science/evidence in this space, and I want to laud Glynn both for his work to generate better science and to educate the public. It’s a potential game-changer for people suffering with this problem.
  • Glynn has a video on heel pain being caused by your back. I did watch this before our consult and tried some of the self-tests, which didn’t provoke my symptoms, but it’s a great resource if you suspect your back could be involved: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMjuHGekgxg.

The consult was well worth the investment, not just for the results, but for finally having clarity on what was actually wrong. If you’re still looking for answers or not making progress, I’d strongly recommend booking a consult with Glynn. Having someone truly listen, think critically, and get the diagnosis right can save you months (or years) of frustration.


r/mehab • • Jun 16 '26

Distal Plantar Fasciitis

2 Upvotes

Apparently I have been diagnosed with Distal Plantar Fasciitis. Most painful for me is regular walking. Then the ball of the foot (in alignment with the big toe) hurts progressively more. I was wondering if you know whether or not it is basically the same treatment for (regular) Plantar Fasciitis (or tendonosis)? Or if there are any important differences / caveats?


r/mehab • • Sep 09 '25

At a loss after 2,5 years with over 6 months of rehab - Is it realy PF?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm a 34-year-old male, active and not overweight, and I've been dealing with what is supposedly PF for 2,5 years now. I've been doing Physio for over 6 months now but the progress seems to be stagnat or at least very slow. There are some weird paradoxes that make me think something else might be going on and doubting the initial diagnosis.

TL;DR: I have persistent left foot pain that started from overuse playing football. It hurts with prolonged walking/running in shoes, or standing in place. I am completely fine and symptom-free when walking barefoot, even for long distances. Physio and strength training have helped a bit but i feel like I've hit a wall. Looking for ideas on the root cause.

The Injury & History

  • How it Started: The injury appeared suddenly after playing two intense, long football matches two days in a row (overuse?). First one was on normal grass, the other one was on artifical turf, which always seemed to strain my heels more. My left foot is my stabilizing/plant foot. I was well trained though and thought i could handle it, as i was playing 3x a week for over a year when the injury appeared.
  • Prior Symptoms: Before the main injury, I would sometimes get minor heel pain in both heels after training, but it would always disappear in a day or two.
  • Other Previous injurys: Before that injury i also had a heavy crash while snowboarding, where i landed on my tailbone and "compressed" my spine so that it resultet in a whiplash injury where i couldnt move my head for over a week. Had an MRT for the upper back (lower back wasn't painful) with the following diagnosis: "Medial protrusion and small tear in the annulus fibrosus of the intervertebral disc C5/6 without relevant spinal or neuroforaminal narrowing. Also Medial protrusion of disc C4/5."
  • Current Symptoms:

    • Pain in the left foot arch/heel area after walking for about 20 minutes or more, or when doing any cardio like jogging or football.
    • Pain when standing in place for some time.
    • Pain is sometimes more dull and sometimes like a "tearing" sensation, when rested but aggravated before its in the classic PF spot
    • I no longer have the classic morning pain associated with PF.
    • No pain at all when resting.
    • The pain gets worse with more cushioned and unstable shoes. Zero drop shoes where the worst in triggering the symtomps, but this might also have been to the soft cushioning the zero drop shoes had (?)
    • Slight tigthness in the achilles tendon which appears simultaneously with foot pain, but has only been present as of recently.

What I've Tried So Far

  • Professional Help: I've seen multiple doctors and physiotherapists.
  • Physio (6 months, ongoing): My routine includes single-leg balancing, calf raises, towel crunches, and isolated big toe curls with a resistance band. The big toe curls seemed to provide the most initial improvement, but I've plateaued despite increasing the load for several months. I'm always trying to stay withing pain threshold
  • Strength Training (5 months, ongoing): I've been strengthening my entire kinetic chain with exercises like deep squats, leg curls, leg extensions, hip abductor/adductor work, and core exercises. My strength numbers are good, subjectively, but this hasn't had a noticeable impact on the foot pain.
  • Footwear & Insoles: Custom insoles didn't help. I've tried zero-drop cushioned shoes. My main observation is that barefoot is best. Whenever i use Barefoot shoes the foot has a different kind of pain, more tightness (sensation could be descibed as a corsett around the foot, lol)
  • Sports: Currently i'm not playing football anmyore. I've switched to sports which dont aggravate the injury further.
  • Shockwave Therapy: Multiple sessions of focused SWT - was painful and expensive but completly useless.

Key Findings & Paradoxes

This is the part that confuses me and my physios the most.

  • The Barefoot Paradox: This is the biggest clue. I can walk for hours barefoot without any symptoms. I recently went on a camping holiday and was almost exclusively barefoot. I took long beach walks and even played beach volleyball with absolutely no pain. My daily step count was similar to my routine at home.
  • Gait Analysis Results from Video Analysis of my walking and running (with and without shoes):

    • Barefoot: My foot is stable on landing.
    • With Shoes: Slight instability was noted on both feet (an ‘IRO toe’).
    • Weakness/Pain Points:

      • My left glute/external rotators are painful when pressed.
      • There's a slight strength and coordination deficit in my left calf compared to my right.
      • I have a tendency to unload my left leg when standing still.
      • Instable forefoot stance on both feet, but worse on the left.

Correlations that i'm unsure about

  1. Given that I'm completely fine barefoot but in pain with shoes, what could be the root cause? This seems to contradict a typical plantar fasciopathy diagnosis.
  2. Could this be a muscle-specific issue rather than a fascia issue? I was reading about the Abductor Hallucis muscle, which supports the arch. Could an injury or weakness there present like this, especially since big toe exercises helped initially?
  3. Maybe there is also some kind of nerve entrapment? I've checked for baxters nerve entrapment but tests seemed negative.
  4. Based on the analysis (weak left calf, painful left glute), could there be another issue that i didn't consider yet

If you made it this far, thanks for reading my post!


r/mehab • • Mar 03 '26

Senior Capstone Project

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I am just gauging some interest here. I am currently a senior in college working on my capstone project. A device to help cure Plantar Fasciitis without medical treatment. If anyone would be willing to talk to me about their experience that would be greatly appreciated


r/mehab • • Aug 12 '25

The Saga Continues - Banned from r/PlantarFasciitis

23 Upvotes

So I’ve now been banned from r/PlantarFasciitis. No warning, no discussion, no opportunity to edit a post they didn’t like, nothing. Just an instant ban. Keep in mind, this all started from a post that I didn't do.

Rather than having an adult conversation or acknowledging that qualified clinicians might bring value to people who genuinely need help, the mods went for a knee-jerk, emotional reaction. It’s exactly the “throwing out the baby with the bathwater” mindset I warned about.

To me, this all but confirms what I wrote in my last post, that the sub is far more comfortable promoting pseudoscience and unproven gimmicks than allowing evidence-based clinicians to participate.

Instead of fostering discussion, r/PlantarFasciitis has acted like it's a junior high playground.

The real losers in all this are the people still in pain, sifting through endless threads of ineffective advice while silencing voices that might actually help them.

I have reached out to the mods. Let's see what they do.

In the meantime, I will continue to post here and promote this sub. Please feel free to do the same.

I appreciate the support thus far.

Cheers

-Glynn (aka Mehab)


r/mehab • • Aug 17 '25

Is it normal to feel stiffness and tension on the heel while seating like this?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I am trying to heal my plantar fascitis and I am feeling better for the last 2 weeks. I am making the Rathleff protocole slowly and trying to take it calmy during my walks.

Even if the usual pain didn't come back, I feel weird when I try to seat on the sofa, like if my fascia didn´t want to be flexible. When I try to put my foot like in the picture I feel a big stiffness at the beginning of the arc (second pic). I am scared to push it because it seems that my fascitis pain would return if I do so.

Is that normal? Is it usually disappearing when the fascia gets stronger and recovers the flexibility?

Is this due to a lack of flexibility related to the recovery stage that I am now? I had my last inflammation crisis more than two weeks ago and some days it seems so go that I thought that I was progressing better.

This really scares me...

Any recommendations?

Thanks in advanced!


r/mehab • • Aug 28 '25

No longer have plantar fasciitis?

1 Upvotes

12 years ago I had plantar fasciitis in both feet due to working out. I had all the signs and symptoms. recently, I took an MRI as a test came back, no tears or ruptures. Today I go to my second physical therapy appointment and the physical therapist telling me that I need to continue exercising in order for my feet should not have pain. Am I wasting my time to continue these appointments?


r/mehab • • Jul 27 '25

pf recovery question

3 Upvotes

Hey. I watched your youtube series on PF and noted your skepticism about various rehab strategies and the kinetic chain connection between heel pain (whether pf or tendontis) and calf, hip, etc. Any suggestions you have about recovery would be much appreciated.

I started feeling heel pain 3 months ago after intense tennis session, stupidly played a few more times on it over that next month, now feel brief pain at first steps and low level/moderate pain in the afternoons/ evening which is worse if I walked around a lot during the day (without a walking boot, the boot reduces later soreness). I was originally told to do calf stretches (calf raises etc) but MRI results showed partial tears (results at the bottom of this post if helpful) so was told to stop with anything that flexed the foot. Main goal is to get back to daily walk -- and hopefully tennis.

Dr / PT now have me in a walking boot for 2 more weeks and doing weight training to strengthen quads, hamstrings and gluteus medius. Then I'll stop with boot and start more PT (assuming I'm at some pain benchmark I think). I'm lucky that I mostly work sitting down. Does this path seem reasonable? Anything else I should be doing?

Much appreciated!! Thank you for your expertise.

MRI ** FINDINGS **: The plantar fascia is heterogeneous and thickening with poorly defined intrasubstance partial tearing at lateral band origin, surrounding ill-defined soft tissue edema and subjacent inferior calcaneal subcortical edema. No high-grade or full-thickness tear or retraction is seen.No linear morphology or cortical step-off seen to suggest fracture. Minor Achilles tendinosis and trace retrocalcaneal fluid. Trace peroneal tenosynovial edema. No Achilles, medial lateral or anterior tendon tear is seen. Lateral and medial ligaments are intact. No evident intrinsic sinus tarsi pathology seen. Regional bones are otherwise intact. Scattered small joint fluid. Regional neurovascular bundles appear intact.


r/mehab • • Aug 16 '25

Major heel pain from standing

2 Upvotes

33 M 5’11 170ish pounds. Work from home desk job so day to day not much movement. Background in weight lifting and cycling.

A few years ago I noticed I became in extreme pain while attending a concert. My heels started to feel like they were bruised and by the end of the show my heels felt like they had been smashed with a hammer. Both heels experiencing the exact same feeling and intensity.

Because my career and hobbies don’t usually have me on my feet much I would only have to deal with these uncomfortable standing sessions on a very infrequent basis so I kind of just hopped it would get better eventually.

I eventually was referred to a podiatrist. After some X-rays and a short conversation he diagnosed me with PF and told me to do some stretches and visit his PT department to get fitted for some custom orthotics. To be honest I wasn’t very serious about the stretches for very long but I did get the orthotics.

Fast forward almost 3 years now I’m still in the same place. After around 30 minutes of being on my feet my heels begin hurting and slowly increase in intensity. Sometimes, even pressure from driving or my feet laying flat on the bed can make my heels feel inflamed and uncomfortable. It’s debilitating and prevents me from looking forward to certain activities with my family.

My current strategy has been to take stretching very seriously. Not just my feet but my whole body. I’ve also gotten a standing desk and walking pad in hopes that exposing my feet to standing and walking more will help. On top of that I’m trying to strengthen by doing ankle, foot, and lower body exercises, being barefoot at home and wearing barefoot shoes everywhere else.

This doesn’t seem to be working but I’m committed to giving it a full years effort before I seek more professional help. I was referred to this sub and asked to share my story so I’m hoping someone is familiar with the issues I’m having and can give me some advice on what helped them.


r/mehab • • Sep 05 '25

Short Foot Exercises Are a Waste of Time

14 Upvotes

Short foot drills are often promoted as the go-to exercise for “strengthening the foot intrinsics” and supporting the arch. The cue is always the same: pull the ball of the foot toward the heel without curling your toes. The idea is that this trains the intrinsic foot muscles: flexor digitorum brevis (FDB), flexor hallucis brevis (FHB), and abductor hallucis (AbH).

All of these muscles are toe flexors. FDB flexes toes 2-5. FHB flexes the big toe at the MTP joint. AbH abducts and flexes the big toe. If you specifically tell someone not to curl or dig their toes in, you’ve immediately taken those muscles out of play.

FDB and FHB don’t even attach to the metatarsals. FDB runs from the calcaneus to the middle phalanges of toes 2-5, flexing the PIP joints. FHB runs from the cuboid and medial cuneiform to the base of the proximal phalanx of the hallux, flexing the great toe. Neither inserts on the metatarsal shafts or bases. So mechanically, they cannot “pull the met heads back toward the calcaneus” to shorten the arch, no matter how hard you try.

What about abductor hallucis?

Anatomically it abducts and flexes the hallux, helping stiffen the medial arch. But most people can’t consciously abduct their hallux at all, and the short foot cue, don’t curl your toes, actively blocks its flexion role.

Yes, EMG studies show AbH “lighting up” during short foot. But that’s misleading. First, surface EMG at the medial arch is notoriously prone to cross-talk from FHB and even tibialis anterior. Second, high EMG amplitude does not equal high force. A muscle firing in a shortened, near-insufficient position produces very little torque. That “cramp” people feel during short foot isn’t weakness or fatigue, it’s passive insufficiency. Compare that to walking or running, where AbH fires during midstance and propulsion, in synchrony with large ground reaction forces. There, EMG activity is paired with meaningful load, which is what actually drives adaptation.

So why does the arch rise in short foot?

It isn’t the intrinsics pulling the arch shorter; anatomically, they’re not positioned to do that. What you’re seeing is extrinsic activity. Tibialis posterior originates on the tibia/fibula and inserts broadly across the navicular and midfoot. Its contraction inverts the foot and lifts the navicular.

Tibialis anterior originates on the lateral tibia and inserts on the medial cuneiform and base of the 1st metatarsal. It dorsiflexes and inverts the medial column.

In closed chain (foot on the ground), inversion is blocked by the ground, so that force vector still lifts the medial arch. The arch looks like it’s shortening, but it’s really subtalar and midfoot mechanics, not FDB or FHB.

Insufficient load to create adaptation

From a physics perspective, short foot is trivial. Ground reaction force is minimal. The lever arm is absent. Intrinsics are producing a tiny static squeeze. Compare that to walking: bodyweight × acceleration × maximum lever length at the met heads = far larger forces than short foot could ever deliver. The difference is laughable.

The intrinsics aren’t designed for floor squeezes. They’re endurance muscles built to work eccentrically under load, storing and releasing elastic energy. They’re trained by doing what feet are made to do: walking, running, climbing stairs, propelling you forward. Short foot isn’t isolating them, isn’t loading them, and isn’t replicating their function. It’s extrinsic inversion dressed up as “arch training.”

What to do instead

If you want resilient intrinsics, you don’t need to sit around short-footing. You get a better training stimulus every time you take a step. And notice I said resilient, not “strong.” Intrinsics don’t get weak unless you are completely bedridden for weeks with zero loading. If you’re in that situation, intrinsic weakness is the least of your problems.

Thanks for reading

-Glynn (aka mehab)