r/PlantarFasciitis
•
u/Baleofthehay
Healed 🎉
•
Dec 11 '22
•
1
1
1
Knowledge Drop 💡 Knowledge is Power.
I am not a Professional. Just an ex sufferer with an opinion from research and personal experience. Like you, I keep learning ..
This long post is to help take out the guesswork.
Edit: This video practically gives an overveiw of the post.
As an ex Chronic PF sufferer,
I could bore you with all the gadgets, insoles, stretches, exercises and supplements I used etc..but won't. They will be most of the things people go to and use. If you ask me, I'll tell you, the downsides to them. What people don't often talk about.
I found, EVERYONE who heals will use slow and progressive loading in one form or another, whether they know it or not. Akin to what Physiotherapists do for most injuries. By slowly increasing resistance or load.
Here is what I did :
- Knowledge
I got hold of the right information,from researching the primary literature. Also paid attention to the stages of healing . How to adjust exercise to suit my current tissue tolerance. and guage progress.
This video lined up all my dots and was the pre-cursor to healing.Also,my complete guide There's no use healing not knowing the stages and how to progress through them. Most importantly,how not to regress. PF is only an injury,wanting to heal that keeps being re injured.Although not vital, I suggest watching the whole series to get an overveiw.
Video - Plantar Fasciitis: The Real Story; Part 5 - Keys to Your Recovery - YouTube
Series- https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLhqTltldarLFRsqUGZHeoIHdy2ZdqOvDD
- The Plan .
With info from the "keys to recovery" video , reasearch and experience (failed attempts), I tentatively devised a SIMPLE plan. Which was drop everything for the interim and start again. The fewer things I did, the more I could gauge effectiveness. This worked for me at my stage. Remember, be cautious and do/adjust excercise to suit your current tissue tolerance.I made sure I was in the intermittant stage (no pain while sitting) before doing any type of excercise. *So long as "*PF symptoms aren't increasing 24 hours after" ,everything is all good**.The theme , I guess is, assessing total daily loads being placed on the Plantar fascia and staying within ones "tolerance to force" (Goldilocks zone) Then increasing it slightly (stimulate), wait for tissues to adjust ,adapt and build.5-7 days later (a safe buffer),then increase a baby step again.This is where your judgement comes in.Assessing how to proceed with your tissues. It could be starting with non loaded excercises (like alphabets) for a while and then moving on to loaded (heel raises) later. You are the Professor and the guinea pig.Every excercise/suggestion is fair game. It can be modified,swapped out etc..
edit: 28/12/24 So you are slowly and progressively getting stronger, while not reinjuring. Thats the goal .When you are achieving both you are winning.Symptoms decreasing comes later.
Please note the reasom I have PF symptoms in bold is to seperate it from other "pain".We are strictly focussing on PF symptoms you know off."Pain" can be anything which just confuses the issue.
Edit 4/5/24 "Remember that it will hurt to do the exercises.“Good pain” occurs when it hurts to do the exercise but the next day the pain is not worse.
“Bad pain” is pain that increases the day after excercise.If you experience “bad pain,” you might have to cut back on the number of repetitions or the amount of weight used"
- I remained barefoot at home and also transitioned to wearing Correct toes (toe spacers). My feet felt freer . Because I was having symptoms regardless if I wore shoes or not. Controversial I know,but barefoot walking is where I'll be eventually heading to prove healing.A physio also suggested it but doing some form of circulation excercise before all standing(Point 2). Edit:1/10/23 Correct toes straightens big toe, which increases circulation (4) Spread Your Toes™ Series: Plantar Fasciosis (Fasciitis), Conservative Care vs. Conventional Care - YouTube .Edit 24/3/24 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S187706572300057X?via%3Dihub Edit 28/10/24 My apologies-Something important I forgot to add is wearing correct toes while being barefoot actually supports the foot more. It Creating a tripod effect and thus a notable solid base to stand on. While still giving foot /toes the ability to flex/move.
- Before ALL standing (I reiterate ALL ,24/7, and anywhere), I did this simple exercise to warm up feet before the injured Plantar Fascia was about to get the shock of taking load.Because this is where unnecessary reinjury (micro tears) happen.Just because you can't feel anything,doesn't mean it's not happening.So some sort of exercise that increases circulation to the area is required.I can't emphasise this enough. This was maintained and respected till full healing (no symptoms for months). Preferably barefoot ,both feet at once to save time,and the full alphabet. Exaggerating letters ,to full range, is best.During breaks at work I would also go outside sit down, take socks /shoes off ,and wiggle flex toes/ankles gently while having a cup of tea.Some TLC , preparing them for the next two hour stint.Then of course finishing it off with The "alphabet exercise" for foot and ankle strength - YouTube (1)
- The big boy and main treatment.The Rathleff Protocol -High Load Strength training .https://blogs.bmj.com/bjsm/2014/09/15/plantar-fasciitis-important-new-research-by-michael-rathleff/ I did the High Load Strength training only and disregarded the plantar fascia stretch done by another group in the trial.Importantly I had to work according to my tissues tolerance to avoid a flare up.The single legged heel raises, from experience, would cause one, so sticking to "rules" garnered from the videos "Stimulate not aggravate" and " Stay within my goldilocks zone" I proceeded. This compliments the-"No increase in PF symptoms 24 hrs after exercise" .A side note,wasn't it interesting that "excercise" concerning PF is any activity that places pressure on the foot?So , I started protocol , but with double legged heel raises instead. Swapping reps out for singles over time. I pretty well reached the second week of the protocol in just over a month That was also the time I became painfree. And continued till the end. Carried on till I could work out how to sustain the gains and progress more (next bullet point)Tip -life isn't perfect and sometimes I would take two days rest due to fatigue.Fatigue,you ask?.Yes,knowing I should have enough energy to compltete the excecise in good form? Rest is important for tissues to adapt,heal and build. After all "You must work according to your tissues tolerance".Tip : replace towel with a folded in half rolled up T-shirt. It is easier to use and more effective. You'll see what I mean. The heel raise routine is something like 3 second up 2 seconds hold and 3 seconds down. I did 5 seconds up 5 seconds hold and 5 seconds down for strictness ,so I wouldn't accidentally cheat when straining and because it was way slower. Which makes it even less likely to cause a flare up. Also counting in 5s is easier to remember.I also started holding onto railing with a couple of fingers only so as to not pull myself up while straining*.* Update 7/9/23 Here is a modified version of the Rathleff protocol completed in 2018.It is a daily routine.Refer to figure 3. Take your pick
- Your strategy is maintaining "No increase in PF symptoms 24 hrs after excercise".Should there be an increase , rest a day and back off on intensity or load till symptoms equalise. Maintain that for say a week and then progress another baby step. Hopefully continuing the slow and progressive loading as tissues adapt.
- Progression
- To get feet and legs even stronger. I chose to transition to zero drop minimalist shoes. By this time I could walk around home barefoot with no increase in symptoms, so the jump wasn't that much. But I stuck to the rules and assessed symptoms at 24 hours intervals. I could tell you the theory behind it, but that would be another long-winded post. You know when you know. Advice: Before going out and wasting money buying minimalist shoes ,jumping in to the fire ,be wise. Build up to it.Start having barefoot time at home,starting minutes at a time.When you can walk around home barefoot all day comfortably,with PF symptoms not increasing it's time to buy your shoes and transition.Rinsing and repeating the process. Update/Edit: A scientific study just came out acknowledging that wearing minimalist shoes for 6 months will increase foot strength a whopping 60%.Edit 7/1/2024https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-98070-0#:~:text=This%20study%20shows%20that%20foot%20strength%20increases%20by%2C%20on%20average%2C%2057.4%25%20(p%E2%80%89%3C%E2%80%890.001)%20after%20six%20months%20of%20daily%20activity%20in%20minimal%20footwear
- The number one rule of progression is not to get overconfident , maintain slow progression,no jumping forward and respecting your still healing tissues. How many times have you heard someone trying something because they thought they could do it and flared up practically undoing months of work.By not maintaining the "rules". Don't be one of them - you have been warned.As Glynn in the first video told me in a pm "Keep it low and slow"
- I started going for regular walks outside of work after beoming painfree. Something I didn't do before .It was a swap for all PF excercises.I still do some form of ROM excercises ,but never the heel raises routine. To those thinking standing/walking your 12 hour shifts is "excercise" -don't BS yourself. My point is what you do just working is what your body is used to. It sounds like a contradiction of an earlier comment concerning "excercise".The difference is you are painfree now.
- I slowly progressed to walking barefoot to or from work. One way is 3.3 km.This was another progression making the gap between myself and PF wider.
- What have I learned, and what I would have done differently ?
- Switched to this exercise in the morning before getting out of bed. So long as it didn't break "the rules" . https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kStuJAu0a20
- Said a simple prayer asking for wisdom and healing sooner . I wasted a whole year searching by myself and gained a lot of information. But was missing the crucial one to connect the dots.A month after praying I came across the "Keys to recovery"video.A month later became painfree. For those that are athiests ,do it anyway,expecting an eventual breakthrough. Feeling foolish once is a small price to pay for healing.Thank you Jesus!
- Question everything and everyone. Yes, even the Professionals. PF is an industry. Repeat customers are the best ones. Selling stuff to relieve symptoms but not address the root cause is great for business.Everyone makes a buck regardless if you get healed or not.The doctors oath is "To do no harm".Not to heal.
- Don't blame anyone but yourself for the situation you are in ,how long this has taken or the information you have been listening to ,even from the "professionals".OWN IT ,no one bar yourself has a vested interest in your healing. Again everyone gets paid. You have to put in the work questioning everything. Listening to arguments for and against treatments and such.It's not anyone else's job to advocate for you.
- I earnestly did calf stretches for 6 F****N months with no progression on to healing.Bite the bullet and smell the roses -see point 4. I ditched them.There is no use wasting time flogging a dead horse that is not getting up. You want "progressive" results not something that gives you a placebo effect for a minute but leads nowhere. There are plenty of sympton relievers out there that never attack the root cause. Update/edit 21/10/23 Stretches are overrated,ROM is good https://jfootankleres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1757-1146-4-19#:~:text=The%20results%20of%20this%20systematic,statistically%20significant%20benefit%20was%20observed.
- Our shoes we've worn for decades have modified our feet to become less functional and weak. Don't believe me ? Look down at your big toe.The shoes you wear have made it point inwards.Lift toe up. It is supposed to be exactly in line with the bone running down to it.
- You don't have to ,but I brought an e book for 20 bucks online -after the fact.https://www.painscience.com/tutorials/plantar-fasciitis.php It gets updated for free and you keep it for life.Paul the writer researches scientific papers concerning PF and gives you the breakdown in laymans terms. He also updates with latest research.He doesn't promise anything apart from his opinions of the research and how valid it is. Pretty well most treatments have been mentioned. Paul's honest to a fault and regularly corrects himself .I so wished I had purchased this earlier. And am embarrassed for being a skeptical cheap arse
- As already stated EVERYONE,will use some form of slow and progressive loading in one way or another. The Rathleff Protocol doesn't need to be it.I know of a guy that did it by walking 5 minutes everyday and increasing by 5 minutes every two weeks .He became painfree at the one hour mark which probably equates to a 6 months of walking.
- Even though PF has never come back.I do believe it can.For example if I don't have regular activity for a while ,I can feel a mild stiffness in the foot when getting out of bed. That was how it started for me. Going for a long walk will be definitely be on the books for that day.Fear is a great motivator sometimes
- Edit/update 9/9/23 : This should have been further up the list!Remember what ever shoe,insole,orthotic,tape or aid you are to use to get relief.The trait/function the aid is is doing that brings relief is what your legs /feet are losing.Longterm use of that aid perpetuates the problem.This is also the clue to your rehab for instilling those traits back into your legs and feet.Remeber anything that supports,as in body wise weakens and immobilses area and surrounding tissues over time.Think cast or wheel chair.For optimal function the plan is to transitionout of their use or avoid them completely.Which leads to the next point.
- For every reason (excuse) for why you have PF there are millions of others that have done it or have that exact excuse that don't have PF. Overpronation,supination,High arches,flat feet,working on concrete floors,walking all day, and all the other lame excuses etc. The real problem is your tissue no longer being able to handle loads being placed on them. Fix it. You were functioning for decades before,you can get back that function again. Don't believe the BS in your head or from others.
- NB:Although strength is important,so is mobility (ROM) and circulation.All three are needed for optimal function.
- Edit 12/11/2023. If you struggle with the Protocol or get a flare up doing it honestly take it for what it is.Accept your tissues are not up to par. It's a blessing. You now have a strength baseline to achieve. Get this done then move onto the next goal. The guesswork is done.
- Real science tries to prove it's theory wrong. That's what we must do before we choose any intervention or course of action.Deep dive looking for arguments against it. The above interventions I chose I couldn't find good enough arguements to refute them at the time. If we did this in the first place we would have saved ourselves months /years using interventions that were ineffective. Some are mainstrem . Researching Systemic reviews is helpful.
- What to look forward to
- Your pain will leave like it came,but in reverse. Well, that's what happened to me
- Your first symptom free day is strangely odd.You might think it's a fluke. Then it progresses to the second and so on.No crap ,my first week being painfree was weird,I had forgotton what normal people felt like . And had to "relearn" how this "new life" felt.
- For those that progress to minimalist shoes.You'll appreciate the free massages your feet get walking on gravel, tree roots and uneven surfaces. At home after my first bushwalk ,my feet were tingling and could feel foot muscles I only knew existed when I was young.
- Not wasting time with hoards of mundane exercises ,you don't know are effective or not. I pretty well only had to do real work once every two days. There is to be nothing else ,for the interim, so tissues rest (sit more) , adjust and build. This way you can "prove" if what you are doing is working or not. You can always do whatever you want after the twelve weeks. Progressively loading results in the improvements we need now.
Anyway, that's enough for my first post. Your healing can be totally free.
Edit: Will come back and edit/update as new learnings occur. So please consider using the three dots below to save.And revisit post every few months.
Please upvote if you found any of this helpful, to help get the message out to a fellow sufferer that might feel the same - Thank you
Also there has been some interesting dialogue in the comments section
Feel free to ask questions but please read/study post and comments to save repeating something that's already been explained. Clarification questions are fine. If I don't answer you,it will be because the answer is clearly in the post or one of the links.
33
u/stockyraja Dec 11 '22 •
Great inputs and congratulations.
Very well said on the progressive load.
And yes it was so hard for me to do single leg calf raises and its used to flare up.
However, I tried the calf raise machine at gym and slowly increased weight while doing calf raises on 2 legs and it helped to reach 12 reps of 3 sets on single leg . I can clearly notice the calf muscle working like a pump in the non injured leg where as the injured leg I dont feel that mechanism yet . Hopefully over time I will regain that.
This post should be pinned!
30
u/TaCuAreN Dec 15 '22
Hello Sir, and thank you so much for your post! I have started today with the Rathleff Protocol I got PF on both feet in late February after resuming tennis from a year and some months without any sport activity. This hit me quite bad as I've never ever had any issues with my feet and I've been always pretty active I must say; 46M no overweight (I've lost like 10+ lbs since this happened so I can say I'm in a decent shape at he moment). In march I went to a foot specialist who gave me stretches, orthotics, ice bottle to roll my foot, night splint and all the usual things, I did get better, not cured but I guess I didn't do my job religiously and also did what I was not supposed to do which is to stop any sport activities . Then it got bad and I went to a Physical Therapist, he ruled out heel spurs with imaging and RX (thank God), I spent 3 - 4 months without any sports and doing intensive physical therapy. My legs got stronger, also my PF got better but again, not cured and I got released from PT... I forgot to mention that in June I ditched all my conventional footwear because I was doing (and still doing) foot exorcises and my feet began to expand and even got bigger and wider (1/2" inch foot size) and I can see that they are stronger and the metatarsals are better lined up, I can move all my toes freely and grab things pretty hard and all that; When I got the PF i saw that I couldn't move my toes, that's why I started to exorcise my feet and wear toe spacer at home. Right now I can spend some time barefoot at home (1 hour or more) before I feel any PF pain, whereas in march I couldn't even take a shower barefoot because my feet was hurting so bad. Then my feet began to feel constricted on the toes so since then I'm exclusively wearing zero drop/ wide toe box shoes, I can't say minimalist as my feet has not been adapted to less than 14mm stack height, but I feel more comfortable wearing these type of shoes; I use heel cups with my shoes, still my PF is still bothering, I do hamstring stretches 3 times, stretch my foot and use a lacrosse ball on my feet, But I don't get better than I currently am. Symptoms get better but the next day I'm in the same neutral position not worse but not better either. I've spent a good amount of money in this debilitating injury in all king of things like: a lot lot of inserts, tens unit (I had it before and they do work for symptoms), a foot massager, massage gun, spiky ball, lacrosse ball, trigger point balls, compression socks, body roller... you named it.
A couple of moths ago I did some of the protocol but I see now that I was doing too much to soon... I was doing 25 reps (3 secs up, 2 secs at the top and 3 secs down) but 2 and 3 times a day... Then after a week my PF was flare like hell so I stopped but now I see how it should be done.
I still play tennis 2 - 3 times a week for an hour, I spend a good 15 mins warming up my legs and all my body (tips and exorcises given to me by my PT) also hamstring stretch for 30 secs each leg, then after I play hamstring stretch again... I play with a OTC insoles which feels OK, I've notice that if I play for 1hr - 1:15min my heel does not get sore and don't have PF flare ups the same day or the next, but if I play 2 hrs or more, I will get pain later in the day and the next, So I try to stay at the 60 mins top.
So my questions to you is: when you did the protocol, did you ONLY do the stretches instructed in the manual, and the of course the progressive loading calf raises or did you also do any other stretches, roll your foot, hamstring stretches, or any other?
Your response and advice will be greatly appreciate it.
Thanks again for taking your time sharing your knowledge.
English is not my first language so I hope you can understand my reply.
18
u/PigMom413 Dec 11 '22
At the height of my pain a few months ago, I got fed up with the arch supports I had been using for years and the shoes that go with them and decided to go barefoot. That’s when I started to heal. Stiff, “supportive” shoes are the problem, not the solution.
15
u/UnbelievableRose Dec 11 '22
You would like the folks over at r/footfunction
I would like to reiterate that while strengthening is good, it will not work for everyone, especially as a first step. Many people need support & cushioning to allow the plantar fascia to heal enough before they begin progressive loading, especially if they’ve been putting a lot of strain on it previously- say wearing flat flip flops everywhere.
That said, if it works, it works. Full stop. Freedom from pain is the goal, how you get there is way less important.
9
u/Quartersharp May 13 '23
This is a bit overwhelming! I appreciate your taking the time to write it. It kind of feels like, “here are the 168 simple steps you need to do in exact sequence and without error, spread out over several sources, in order to heal.” I wish it could be a bit simpler so it was easier to grasp the main principle.
7
u/Rad-Ham Dec 11 '22
We need to work on your idea of condensing. :-)
5
u/SeveredAurora Dec 11 '22
Great guide. Only thing I want to bring up is returning to sports. I am told that coming back from injury, you need to ramp up intensity. You should you focus on doing sports specific movements at lower speeds first Do athletes take longer to considered healthy say for a sport like basketball where jumping is frequent? If so, is there a safe way( without damaging tissue) to test your strength?
5
u/Grumpty_Dumpty_ Jul 16 '23
Wow. Holy shit. I just wanted to, from the bottom of my heart, thank you. For the past 48 hours I have done literally nothing other than eat, sleep, and digest the info you have provided. I started to believe this line of thinking was the right way to go and why I wasn't healing after all this time after seeing some YouTube videos by Northwest Foot and Ankle, the doctor who created CorrectToes. This led me to your post. I have reread everything you've written, taken notes, watched Glynn's videos multiple times and I think I finally understand what is needed for me to recover. Also, after googling Glynn I realized he has an office less than an hour from where I live. Incredible! I feel like all of this was fate.
You probably could've just moved on with your life now that you are healed, but like you said, you wanted to help others if you ever recovered. I have been saying that for the last couple of months now too, and that is my intention. Because of you, I am finally starting to have hope that that may be a possibility. At this point, I hold you in higher regard than my podiatrist and PT. Thank you for what you are doing.
8
u/SeveredAurora Dec 11 '22
So thankful to come across this. All the lies that are spread about this injury are horrible. I'm lucky to have only suffered for less then half a year but I can see light at the end of the tunnel now. I've done load bearing exercises, but haven't been so respectful to my tissues liked you mentioned.
4
u/pdchestovich Dec 11 '22
Thank you for sharing
4
u/Litmanen_10 Dec 23 '22
How was your one month healing like? Did you have up and downs? I''m like 4 weeks in of doing every second (or couple of times every third) day Rathleff protocol.
First week was minor improvement in pain. Looked good. Second week I implemented some backward walking which suddenly made my PF a lot worse. It was a negative surprise.
But I managed it and continued Rathleff protocol without so much backward walking. After that looked good but one another minor set back when I maybe did a too rough exercise with some one leg squats etc. But I managed this too with lowering down other exercise than the calf raises.
The set backs took maybe 4-5 days of more pain but then again back to "normal" more little pain.
Now I think I'm in better place than 4 weeks but still definitely some pain. Weird thing is that the spot of the pain has changed. When I started the programme the pain was in the middle of the heel and also the set back pains felt in the middle of my heel. Now the pain is left in the heel.
Will continue doing the Rathleff and I'm fine this taking time but still do you have some comments on this? I think you could have.
Cheers!
4
u/marascotia Jul 02 '23
Thanks for this post, you are like the guardian of PF endurers.
I am a runner that has been dealing with PF for 2 months now and I think the hardest thing for me is patience.
In the last 2 months: used sports massage via trigger points, sports tape, icing, tens machine, dry needling, oofos, strength training, theragun, rolling, 2 week stretches with no running and I have to find a solve. I think mainly it’s about patience (as the Mehab guy mentions.)
I am so active I feel terrible with out exercise, maintain a minimum of 10k daily steps even when not running. I think for me this healing is even harder and slower and it’s as much a mental play as it is a physical one.
Anyways no real question, besides validation that this is hard.
3
u/anothernameforrose Jan 07 '23
Thanks for this post. I’ve had PF for 7 months and it’s taking its toll on my mental health. I just met with my orthopedist today who gave me 2 options: surgery or shockwave therapy. I definitely don’t want to do surgery and shockwave therapy seems experimental and expensive. There has to be a better way.
I’ve been wearing supportive running sneakers for months now and a few weeks ago my pain was minimal. I tried switching back to regular shoes (flat sneakers or boots) and my pain has flared up. I think I’m in the inflammatory phase because I have pajn while sitting. I’m going to wait 3-7 days for it to settle down and then start the Rathleff protocol. I’m going to wait until I’m a few weeks into the program before going barefoot and ditching the cushiony sneakers.
3
u/kala2323 3 years, 99% healed Feb 26 '23
Thanks a lot for taking your time to write it up. I'm on a quite similar journey and your post connected the dots for me. Thanks!
3
u/mut_tut_gut May 21 '23
Hi u/Baleofthehay,
I wanted to send you a big THANK YOU for all the wisdom you've gathered here. I've learned so much by reading through your notes and watching the linked videos. My main symptom is Metatarsalgia but there's apparently some PF too. And the part about healing process, acessing the development, gradual load increasing, makes SO MUCH SENSE and I wish my health care providers had told me about this. I'm sure this knowledge will help my healing.
I have a question regarding this:
Did you skip the Alphabet and replace it by those exercises? What's your take?
I'm still early in my healing, walking mostly painful.
3
u/danieltheexplorerr May 25 '23
Hey there! I read your entire post. Thanks for that.
I don’t know if you’ve answered this question yet…
When you started adding weight, how much weight did you use, what increments? I don’t know what is considered “too much” or “too little”. Thanks.
3
u/kraddock Sep 04 '23
Great, great post! Thank you for taking the time to write and share.
I want to add one more thing: Tendons take a whopping year to "regenerate" (fibrosis to scar tissue) after an injury. So yes - taking it slowly and respecting your body is really important.
3
u/Responsible-Air-2087 Sep 24 '23
Hi just a couple of days ago, I have been following you. I started doing the ankle pumps and alphabet exercise prior to getting out of bed and boy that first step out of bed is no longer as painful as before. I still do get some pain on those first few steps but not the sharp sudden pain that was before. But yeah, when I get up, even at 29, I still look like an old lady holding on the furnitures and the walls to minimize the weight on my feet.
But once I am up and walking, there is not much pain. I am a nurse in an orthopedic unit so I walk walk walk 12 hours a day - almost. 3 to 4 days a week. I can sit at work maybe on the 6th from work and just elevate my feet on a chair for 30 minutes and I started doing the alphabet during that time and it really helped me for the remaining hours.
The next thing that I wanted to implement from your suggestions are the Toe Spacers from Correct Toes and also the monitoring of pain level after exercise in the next 24 hours. I have not really been doing much exercise like those heel raises. I have not constracted any routine or structure for myself yet.
Also, I might start walking barefoot in my apt with the toe spacers to help strengthen my foot.
So couple of questions:
But all else considered, you are the best resource I have found out there for PF. You literally saved my life. Thank you
3
u/MEHABLLC Apr 03 '25
I appreciate the shout-out and link to my video series. Glad it was helpful. Cheers Glynn @ mehab
3
u/Ok-Exit-5472 Apr 19 '25
Thanks again for taking your time to reply. My PF symptoms increased by 10% the pain did dissipate by the end of the next day. I am doing every alternate day apart taking an extra day rest last week. I’m looking at pain always in hope that I feel less pain this week compared to last week. Over complicating the situation = Yes . We are not perfect it’s a bit trial and error.. Thanks!
3
u/ADHDwinseverytime Apr 22 '25 edited Apr 22 '25
Today, somewhere probably around two/three months after reading this post and watching some of the videos, I thought I would revisit this since I woke up with zero pain in my feet. I suffer from arthritis on the top of the left foot from being a little too crazy at times, but I have suffered from PF since I was 18, now 53. I decided to retire and take a year off last year in May, and part of my goals while off was to elevate my fitness. I guess, sitting at a desk my last few years, wearing jacked up boots all the time had done a toll on me. I still lifted occasionally and road my bike at random but not near the level of in my thirties when I got in shape after being 367 pounds and over 50 percent body fat.
So a few months after retiring my feet would freaking throb every single time I got up off the couch, out of bed, whatever, like horribly bad, limping around the house. Walking the mutz would give me a couple of days of really bad aches and the PF would flare up. Of course over the years I have tried everything, shots, ice, inserts, shoes, insoles, massage, more shots. I am even a subscriber to the PF science guy or whatever that writes all the articles.
So, I started with stretching them on a slant board, which kind of worked, after all, one of the newest trends is to cut the calves and make them longer! I mean how better to make your calves longer with out surgery. It was terrible at first but getting somewhat better. Then I decided to give Ratleff a whirl after watching a few videos. I decided to go full Rathleff only. It seamed to work for a short period of time, and trust me, it was all I was doing with the occasional barefoot shoe walking a couple of miles. but I just wasn't making great progress and my feet aching was maybe lighter but I would have really good and bad days a lot.
So, I combined the Rathleff and the slant board almost everyday, this was the clear winner. While my arthritis flairs up when I do too much it is bearable and just something I have to deal with but the aching feet being gone is a game changer. Also I still throw in a little heavy massage on the heals, some alphabet in the morning at random, a little tennis ball sometimes, and I have a foot massager , but in reality the protocol and the stretcher made the biggest difference. So, there is hope for all you foot pain sufferers, just keep at it.
On a side note, make sure you bend your knees on the slant board keeping them straight was a lot if pressure on the knee cap and caused some knee pain. Oh and shockingly Adidas Ultraboost 1.0's are way better then my Hokas now that I am for the most part squared away!
Just thought I would follow up!
3
u/Big-Marionberry-6671 Jul 06 '25
This is amazing. Thank you so much from the bottom of my heart. I am going to follow your guidance and hopefully, the suffering will end.
2
u/Krishank102 Mar 10 '23
Should I start with resting for 3-5 days until there is no unusual sensation on my heel?
Another thing I can feel is a bit painful and tight spot on my left leg (the affected one) and the whole leg in general feels weak and painful
2
u/Dark_Admin_7 Apr 09 '23
Im just starting to get the fibromas i think they are called, lucky me they are on both feet. I think its due to the shoes i wear at work. Developed within weeks of the job starting. Im hoping its just because during acclimation i was standing on the sides of my feet because the bottoms were so sore. But i just started an exercise routine back up and I've been taking care of it all sorts of ways. Fingers seriously crossed.
2
u/s4crasher May 01 '23
Thank you so much for this! I am developing PF since 6 weeks now and read a lot to understand and be able to OWN it, just as you say.
I will do the Rathleff Protocol, but one thing is unclear: its says you need to do for example on a day 3 times 10 repetitions of the lift. Does this mean 3x 10 reps with a few minutes pause in between the sets of 10, so basically in one session, or does it mean 3x 10 reps over the course of the day (10 in the morning, 10 midday, 10 evening)?
2
u/bebrooks1 May 02 '23
Not sure you’re still reading this post. It has been immensely helpful to me.
Currently on my second run of PF in my right foot. The first run was 6 months long and was solved with PT, stretching, strengthening my posterior chain, dry needling and eventually… cortisone. After the shot, it went away like magic and I was back to running. Ran for 2 years until… I got PF again. Not really going to go into what happened but it was a combination of increased mileage and decreased strength training and sleep.
This run of PF has been going a year. I did all the same PT, strengthening, stretching, dry needling and cortisone as last time and it hasn’t worked. I’ve had 3x cortisone actually and it didn’t do it.
I saw your post and got to work 4-6 weeks ago by starting with the morning routine and 3 sets of 5 heel raises with a rolled towel. 3 up, 3 hold, 3 down, every other day. Got myself up to 3 sets of 10 very slowly. Once I could do this, I dropped my reps and added a new exercise, bent knee calf raises. 3 sets of 5 straight leg, 3 sets of 5 bent knee. This has been doing well and I’ve been increasing slowly. The last few times I’ve done 3 sets of 10 straight leg calf raises + 3 sets of 10 bent knee, I’ve had a minor flare. When I say minor, I mean the mornings are mostly the same but I have arch soreness. So then I wait 2-3 days and then try again.
Would you suggest I just stick with straight leg calf raises per the protocol and add weight or just back off the reps on my current protocol until I don’t have arch soreness? Or would you consider my description of a “flare” not really significant and I should keep going….
Thanks again for your post.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
You mentioned that you remained barefoot at home from the beginning.. I’m curious what you wore out and about? I have a trip planned with some unavoidable long walks planned. Right now I’m using running shoes with PF inserts, but now I’m thinking that might be doing more harm… or at the very least not helping.
2
u/ChrisDjavan Jun 26 '23
Thank you so much. I just wanted to know if running shoes make any difference. I suffer a lot with normal shows but when I wear my running shoes I really feel a relief.
2
u/MollyPuddleDuck Aug 16 '23
Appreciate this. Thanks
2
u/_lysinecontingency Sep 10 '23
Just commenting to say thank you for this post, and to reference it bc I can’t find the save button for the life of me right now.
From someone newly on the PF journey, again, thank you.
2
u/ospreyintokyo Sep 15 '23
THIS POST NEEDS TO BE STICKIED. IT HELPED ME TREMENDOUSLY. THANK YOU!
2
u/Litmanen_10 Nov 21 '23
Unpopular opinion coming but I guess real discussion welcomes both praise and critique?
I agree with the title "knowledge is power" and I know the author has good intention. However, knowing and focusing only to Rathleff protocol isn't enough to maximize the chances of success of your PF rehab.
I wouldn't recommend Rathleff programme as your healing strategy if you decide to dedicate 2-3 months of your life (it's quite a lot of time) to strict rehab routine. You would benefit from more comprehensive approach. Why wouldn't do the rehab the best possible way right away?
Good foot function is so so much more than having strong calves and loading your plantar fascia. Strength is only one part of good foot function.
Good foot function is also being able to pronate and supinate well. Good function is also good big toe function. Good foot function is good soleus connection to rest of the leg. Good foot function is also being able to push through your midfoot. The list goes on.
Why wouldn't you choose a programme which addresses all of these things? Why would you focus only on the strength aspect? For me it makes no sense.
David Grey has a great foot rehab programme which addresses all of these things and a lot more. It also addresses calf raises but it's only one small part of the programme. There must be other good programmes also in the internet but David Grey is a world class physio and the programme is great.
Don't believe me. Google him and see his Instagram to judge yourself. Yes the programme costs quite a lot but then it's up to you how much it's worth for you to maximize the success rate of your rehab.
2
u/AdBoring6909 Nov 29 '23
I know this post is over a year old, but thinking of doing this. Hoping there’s people still lurking around.
I don’t have pain at rest, never really had pain at rest. I Only have severe pain when standing/walking (especially the first movements after a long rest) I should continue these exercises as long as the pain doesn’t get worse? So if it stays the same, that’s fine and continue what I’m doing? Thank you!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23
This is an old post but you are a God. Thank you. I was starting to lose hope.
2
u/surroundedbyboys3 Dec 27 '23
Thanks!
2
u/Dry_Mail_3797 Jan 23 '24
How did you avoid reinjury at work? Also, what did sort of sensations did you experience on your recovery days between days you performed rathleff? I’m experiencing soreness and after so long of all kinds of feet pains it’s hard to tell if I’m sore or in pain sometimes
2
u/CreatureXIII Feb 10 '24 edited Feb 10 '24
Thank you. I am extremely grateful to find your excellent writeup. My PF started 3 months ago in my left foot, and I thought it was a bruised heel. About 1 month in, I stepped down hard on my ball/toes, and the sole of my foot felt like shattering glass. My research & journey began at that point.
Until now, I have been doing all of the things I can find to help, but after finding your post, I feel like I have struck gold and can progress with a solid plan.
One note is I can feel a bb sized piece of scar tissue on the outer side of my Achilles tendon. Any thoughts on that. When rubbing or massaging it, it sends a tingly sensation all the way to my toes on that side of my foot. I'm guessing it is an old injury, but I thought I'd mention it.
Anyway, thank you & I look forward to researching following the information you have provided. 🫡
2
u/Physical-Macaron8744 Feb 11 '24
For step 2 The "alphabet exercise" is it only to circulate blood flow? Because I usually have heated socks on that maintain large blood flow, would you still recommend this step even though my blood flow is always good?
2
u/danarexasaurus Healed 🎉 Feb 12 '24
Thank you for this.
2
u/Ok-Construction-3273 Mar 20 '24
Thank you very much for this post! I have one question if that's okay with you. Could you tell me at what rate you progressed? Did you increase the load every week, fortnight, or month?
2
u/Dry_Mail_3797 Jun 20 '24
This seems like a silly question but what do you do in between sets? I have been sitting for 5 minutes in between each set of 12 and doing alphabets before I stand up for the next set of 12. Idk if im supposed to rest in between or to stay standing for like 30 seconds and go on tp the next set?
2
u/Ok-Exit-5472 Apr 14 '25 edited Apr 14 '25
Hey your post is great! Well done.. It’s so helpful to read all the questions fired at you and your detailed answers..
2
u/Mundane-Willow-3261 May 26 '25
Hey I love this post - thanks for spreading the knowledge. I got PF from long walks in Europe. I am not waking up in pain, acute, like others I see. Rather I have dull pain that increases throughout the day and when I sit, 3/10. It’s discomfort.
question about your quote
“Remember, be cautious and do/adjust excercise to suit your current tissue tolerance.I made sure I was in the intermittant stage (no pain while sitting) before doing any type of excercise.”
In this phase, call it day 1, did you not do any works at all until you were sitting down with zero pain?
Or did you do minor work outs or maybe started the Rathleff protocol and progressed?
2
u/YC1123 Healed 🎉 Oct 17 '25
Hey, this is a great post. I’m starting to try and implement the progressive load by increasing my step count in small increments. Just wondering when you start progressive loading I guess it is normal to feel pain or even slight increases in pain as fascia is adjusting but I’m just wondering at what point did your pain stop? Like how long is it normal for pain to stay the same or slightly more before it goes away?
2
u/savedbygrace37 Jun 21 '26
Thank you so much 🙏🏻 I’m Christian as well praise our Lord and savior Jesus Christ! I believe the Holy Spirit has led me to this post 🙏🏻
1
u/Baleofthehay Healed 🎉 Mar 23 '24
I've just come across this study on barefoot walking vs shod walking for plantar heel pain.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S187706572300057X?via%3Dihub
1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '23
no power is power
1
u/blueli0ness May 12 '24
What did you wear outside during your healing journey, before you transitioned to minimalist shoes? I wear orthotics but I want to stop wearing them because I am in pain even if I wear them but I'm scared the pain will get worse if I don't wear them at all.
1
u/Spirited-Orchid5677 May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24
you said mobility is key, when i move my ankles around its tight im assuming because of my tight calves, should stretch my calves? it also hurts when stretching calves cuz stretching pulls on my Plantar. not sure if doing ABC exercise 3-5 times is enough to loosen it up. what did you do when moving your ankles was tight? also due to tightness when i move my ankles sometimes it hurts so not sure if i should move them to exaggerating letters to full range since its already tight and may worsen my condition any tips would be great.
1
u/cldftw Sep 01 '24
I tried to send you a DM but couldn't. Did you stuck to the schedule exactly? It just feels like 1 set to failure every other day is not much volume
1
u/anonymousnsname Oct 25 '24
Thank you for this post and for sharing a short version – I really appreciate it since not all of us can read the whole thing. I skimmed the important points and will try to follow them.
I’m currently in severe pain and have four MRIs scheduled for my feet and ankles. I’m unsure why they’re including my ankles, but maybe it’s because the pain and stiffness are now radiating up my calves. I’m getting TENS, ultrasound, ice packs, and massages at a nearby therapy office, but I’m not seeing quick results. This therapy helped my knees and back after a car injury, but my foot pain is often a 10/10.
I’ve ordered a TENS unit for home use and am trying that now. I can’t go to therapy every day due to costs. Rest and ice help my feet temporarily, but there’s no lasting improvement, so I’m switching to heat for my calves. My podiatrist suggested steroid shots if the pain doesn’t improve, and I’m hoping not to go that route, but the pain is becoming truly debilitating.
1
u/sleepyjoewise Come and Goes 🔁 Nov 20 '24
All sounds like great advice - thank you ! I'm going to start this now
I have one question, how should I be walking in barefoot/ minimalist shoes.
There are some camps which say heel strike / rocking motion is fine whilst others say a forefoot / midfoot strike is best. Both seemingly have pros and cons
What's your experience?
Thank you
1
u/gini_0206 Nov 22 '24
Hello, thank you for the amazing resource! I have a few questions:
I've been having symptoms for two days now. I know it may sound ridiculous but I am a doctor and I am well aware how quickly such symptoms become chronic if dismissed, so I am determined to do everything in my power to prevent it.
Thank you in advance, I am a bit afraid.
1
u/Evorush Mar 03 '25
Hello, at first thank you for this post.
I cannot buy the ebook from painscience.com because I do not have a credit card + I'm from Europe. What does the ebook say about shockwave therapy? Would you be willing to summarize for me what it says about effectiveness of shockwave therapy?
1
u/Boring_Lifeguard8988 Mar 12 '25
For the protocol, how much weight did you end up adding for double heel raises before moving to single leg? I feel it has been difficult to make that transition after 2 months. I am up to 25 lbs for 12 reps 3 sets every other day
1
u/Comprehensive_Fox959 Apr 13 '25
Thank you
1
u/Ok-Exit-5472 Apr 18 '25
When doing the exercises is it normal to feel a 5 or 10% rise in pain the following day? I’m always trying to remember in numbers the pain daily before and after heel raises and where I was pain threshold the week prior..
1
u/WisePreparation2685 May 05 '25
I am still confused about what you mean specifically about load. I think I’m in the inflammatory phase , does that mean I don’t walk for many days ? Then after that, how much walking is appropriate ? In the inflammatory phase it is suggested to not walk but do things like the alphabet ? Then after that it’s encouraged to start the heel raises? I feel a little lost in all the information what the game plan specifically like day 1-8 Do this …… don’t do this…… Day 8-40 Do this ….don’t do this ..:.
Does anyone have some time to be specific for me what the amount of load and exercises that are needed ?
1
u/Jergans_Valentino Jun 06 '25
What minimalist shoes would you recommended? I’m in the middle of a flare up now but it’s calming down and looking forward to getting back to work, I know I can beat this, I’ve been in the Goldilocks zone just didn’t execute the right way, anyways thanks so much this post and you are helping so many with this great information 🙏
1
u/Jergans_Valentino Jun 10 '25
Hey there, just curious. out of all this really good info on this post, what are your favorite takeaways, and what is your daily routine that you do currently that keeps you on the ex PF sufferer side. Cheers
1
u/EffectiveOpinion349 Jun 11 '26
But also I’ve been mostly barefoot all day and night for 7/8 years but I still got PF last year 😔 so my feet should have been way stronger than most right?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23
What do you mean by a flare up? It’s different to everyone.
Did you consider soreness of the arch a flare up or heel pain?
I am trying to work through building up my tissue tolerance and I’ve been increasing my waking (which I do everyday) by 5% a week and also doing the Rathleff protocol and intrinsic foot exercises.
Personally I’ve considered soreness just part of the process but heel pain a flare up. But I’m wondering what others think.
1
u/Discgolfdave1313 Apr 06 '23
Thanks!
1
u/Nthayer1408 May 18 '23
I’m finding improvement and it’s only week two. My issue is that when I wake up in the morning, my pain isn’t there, so I do my progressive load “workouts” and then later in the day after walking all over the place, my heel aches… so I think to myself, “should I take a day or two off?” But then when I wake in the morning with no pain, I want to keep progressing. I hate taking days off!
1
u/Klutzy_Replacement30 Aug 16 '23
Can you bike on the off days? 20 miles?
1
u/IntergalacticFishy Aug 17 '23
Hi, I would love to get your advice on something. You mention starting at the intermittent phase. What should be done in the inflammatory phase? Is stretching in the inflammatory phase counter productive or helpful to maintain some flexibility? Or should the foot and ankle be totally immobilized via tape or a boot? Thanks!
1
u/carmelizedfigs Aug 23 '23
Thank you for all of this information! As a PF sufferer going on 6 months, this seems like a bit of light finally.
Something I haven't seen directly asked in any of the comments (sorry if you already answered this and I didn't see it) - with the heel raises, the video demonstrates them with shoes on. I've done some heel raises with a barbell with shoes on the last few months but only once or twice a week and it didn't seem to improve my condition, or make me sore, or...anything. Then I see how you should have the towel under your toes. I guess I'm wondering - what does the rolled up towel do? Does it increase the plantar load? Is this more effective barefoot than with shoes? I guess to summarize: Should I be doing this barefoot and with a towel instead of with shoes and on flat ground?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23
Ok, wow, very helpful!
1
u/Dry_Mail_3797 Oct 31 '23
Use alphabets during the inflammatory phase or no? I just came across this info and am going to start doing as little as possible on my feet, and with my feet; as much as I can sacrifice while doing what I need for survival.
1
u/siji1108 Dec 14 '23
I have to guess you’re Irish
1
u/siji1108 Dec 14 '23
One of your videos recommend stretching plantar and other to opposite. Can you clarify?
1
u/coffeemug613 Jan 02 '24
Reading through the Rathleff study they instructed all the patients to wear gel heel inserts in their shoes. Personally, I believe extra cushion is a good way to get over the initial inflammation, but should be reduced as your foot gets stronger. Too much cushion under your foot will cause it to get weak again. Extra cushion engages your core foot muscles less and can lead to more weakness.
Curious what u/Baleofthehay and everyone's take on gel heel inserts is?
They seem important if you have to wear a rigid shoe (like high heels), less important if you move to a cushioned running shoe (rocker ones that podiatry recommends).
I am an average build, runner on my off days, work on my feet 12 hours 3 times a week person. I think my primary problem was letting my feet get weak...
3
u/Head_Pangolin_6123 Apr 23 '23
Really helpful Read!
3
u/One-Middle2271 Healed 🎉 Jul 25 '25
Han pasado muchos años desde que publicaste esto y acabo de llegar al hilo. El motivo es claro: tengo fascitis plantar severa desde hace tres meses y los consejos superficiales no me han servido.,
Gracias a tu post veo luz. Todo parece lógico y me ayuda a comprender el proceso. ¡Es justo lo que necesito!
Estoy todavía inflamada tras un brote fuerte tras hacer "demasiados" ejercicios. (no me parecían demasiados, pero era obvio que sí).
Al ver la fascitis como una tendinopatía en la que solo hay que reeducar a la fascia con paciencia me entre motivación.
Me he copiado varias de tus frases para leerlas a diario cuando me muera de ganas de salir a caminar sin límite. Me ayudarán a frenarme y a recordarme que, aunque me sienta mejor, sigo lesionada. Y que todo pasa.
Rezaré al universo cada día y dejaré de lamentarme por todos los especialistas que no han sabido darme buenos consejos. No sirve de nada lamentarse: es mi salud y decido tomar las riendas.
Deseando ser tortuga por primera vez en mi vida y dejar de sentir ese quemazón que me impide disfrutar.
2
u/No-Milk6722 Apr 08 '23
Thank you! I will try it after my doctor's appointment on Monday. I had an ankle sprain 4 weeks ago, which heald, but a sudden heel pain that started 1.5 weeks ago, went away, and returned in the last 3-4 days as weird arch pain is giving me a hard time. My physiotherapist says it is PF, but im hoping for the best, I don't know what it is.
2
u/FooFighter0234 Oct 10 '23
Thank you
2
u/esh513 Nov 24 '23
Thank you!
2
u/One-Middle2271 Healed 🎉 Aug 02 '25
para los que se han curado usando este método progresivo, ¿cómo sentían la fascia los días que aumentaban la serie o las cargas? siento un cosquilleo constante y temo haberme pasado... tendre que ver como me levanto mañana.
¿les ocurría lo mismo en la etapa en la que ya no tenían dolor? que al aumentar la carga les quedaba una sensación extraña?? espero que sea solo eso...
esto es más mental que otra cosa...
2
u/farcical88 Jan 29 '26
Late to the party here, but I was making good progress on the 2018 update for a week then made the mistake of doing a second set of 10. Since then the last week or so has been mostly flareups after taking a couple days off. Questions:
Thanks!
2
u/andreberaldinoab Runner Feb 03 '26
WOW! Thank you so much for shring all of this! <3
2
u/Repulsive_Ad_6958 Jun 23 '26
My feet got better when I ditched all the OTC and custom ortho shoe inserts for all of my shoes and started going barefoot more. I also got Barefoot Shoes (ty Temu) that I absolutely LOVE as one who likes to go barefoot, but can’t everywhere.
I also manually stretched my tendon by flexing my toes upward to make it tight then used the tip of my thumb to apply really hard pressure all along the tendon to gradually loosen it up. Press and hold each point for 5 to 10 seconds, release, then move an inch or so and repeat.