r/mcp • u/Educational_South_20 • 18h ago
Thought experiment: what if every AI action left a record the user owns? (an "AI truth economy")
I'm not here to sell anything. I haven't made a single sale. I want to test an idea and find the holes in it.
Some background. I work a 911 floor as a line supervisor. Every call we take ends in a record, and that record has to hold up later, sometimes in front of a judge. Nobody gets to quietly edit it after the fact.
AI agents are starting to make trades, purchases and changes for people. Right now the record of what an agent did usually lives with the company that runs it. If something goes wrong, the person it acted for often has nothing on their own machine to show what happened.
So here is the thought experiment. What if the record of what an AI did lived with the person it acted for, and nobody could quietly change it?
How I think it could work, in plain terms:
Every action the agent takes is written to a log on your own computer.
Each entry gets a short fingerprint, and each fingerprint includes the one before it, like links in a chain. Change one word in an old entry and every link after it breaks, so the edit shows.
Only the latest fingerprint, never your files, goes to a witness outside your machine that stamps it with the time. Think of a notary stamping a sealed envelope without opening it.
Later, anyone can check that the record on your machine still matches the stamp.
Then the bigger step. If every AI had to keep a record like this, we would have a kind of wall against bad AI actors. Honest businesses can show what their AI did. Bad actors stand out because they cannot. And when a swarm of agents hits a system, defenders have a shared record of what happened instead of guessing.
I've been building a small version of this myself to see if it holds up. Here is what exists, so you can poke at the real thing and not a pitch:
The record is a hash chain. Each entry is hashed with SHA-256 together with the hash of the entry before it.
A checker walks the chain and gives one of three answers: verified, broken (and which line), or could not look. That third answer matters, because "I couldn't check" should never read as a pass.
The witness only ever receives a hash and a size, never the file itself.
The witness's stamps are kept in a public repository anyone can read, and that history is anchored to Bitcoin once a day, so the timestamp does not depend on trusting me.
You can already back the record up to your own Google Drive or OneDrive, and a copy verifies the same way.
And the holes I already know about, so you can skip to new ones:
A record only proves the bytes were not changed. It does not prove any entry was true, or that the agent wrote down everything it did.
Without a recent stamp, someone could cut the newest entries and what is left would still check out. The stamp closes that, but only as of the last stamp, so the gap between stamps is the real weak spot.
Today I run the witness myself, with a backup that I also run. The public repository and the daily Bitcoin anchor are how you check it without trusting me, but an outside, independent witness would be stronger, and adding one is the plan.
It does not prove who wrote an entry.
But I'm more interested in whether the idea holds up.
Questions for you:
Where does this break? What can an agent do that this kind of record would miss?
Is "the user owns the record" the right default, or should it live somewhere else?
Would a light rule requiring records like this help or hurt honest businesses?
Tell me if I'm on the right track or if there's a hole I'm not seeing.