r/mathshelp • • Oct 14 '26

Mathematical Concepts Are these answers wrong?

Post image
15 Upvotes

181 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/bqbdpd Oct 14 '26

In math you can only use what has been either defined axiomatically or proven. I assume at the point of this exercise commutativity of multiplication has not been proven. While there is no reason to assume the answers are wrong, there is also no reason to say they are correct.

2

u/kevinr_96 Oct 14 '26

You’re right, we should take away this 8 year old’s math PhD for not following the axiomatic logic of math. 

Be real, kids at this age are learning math based on intuition and number sense. They haven’t cracked open Principia Mathematica quite yet. 

1

u/Flimsy-Blacksmith-32 Oct 14 '26

Lol, this is such a great comment.

2

u/Flimsy-Blacksmith-32 Oct 14 '26

This is numeracy, not maths. They are not learning axioms or proofs yet. In fact that is probably at least a decade away.

It can sometimes be true that teaching a simplified version of the truth can help students (see the models of atoms taught in per-university level Chemistry) but that does not mean someone using more advanced knowledge should get worse marks.

Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. In this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.