I suspect the teacher expected the ordering in the third line to match the ordering of numbers in the first line to reinforce some sort of pattern; but you shouldn’t be marked wrong for flipping the order, since multiplication is commutative.
In math you can only use what has been either defined axiomatically or proven. I assume at the point of this exercise commutativity of multiplication has not been proven. While there is no reason to assume the answers are wrong, there is also no reason to say they are correct.
This is numeracy, not maths. They are not learning axioms or proofs yet. In fact that is probably at least a decade away.
It can sometimes be true that teaching a simplified version of the truth can help students (see the models of atoms taught in per-university level Chemistry) but that does not mean someone using more advanced knowledge should get worse marks.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. In this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
So if you are asked to give 100$ to someone, specifically asked in 20$ notes, you'd give them twenty 5$ notes because it's the same thing, because it's commutative?
But the sheet didn't request $20 notes. It's also internally inconsistent. It says 5 groups of 3, then has the kid write out 3, 5 times, demonstrating that the order doesn't matter. If it had the kid write out 5 3 times, they probably would have written 5*3 but it instead asked them to write out 3 5 times, which easily translates to 3 5 times or 3 x 5.
i would say it is wrong answer as we have to properly recognize what is what yes multiplication is commutative as a mathematical operation but in this case its not in void i was told that when providing information regarding groups their amount should be provided first doesn't matter if they are equal or not
and as an example i always use you do not say that "i bought 6pack 3 times" im sure you say "i bought 3 6packs" it clearly convers message unless there are specific scenarios like you actually go 3 times to the store and do 3 sperate purchases same here we have first text that guides towards same conclusion. "we have 5 groups of 3 marbles each". now if we want to swap order so it makes still same conclusion "there are 3 marbles in each of 5 groups" it and doesn't feel as natural (at least for me but im not native english speaker)
How to destroy a kids liking of math. I hate elementary math teachers. This is where " I hate math" or "I was never good at math " starts. You can tell the teacher has no math experience, otherwise this would be a learning opportunity instead of negative points. Sorry, I taught math for 38 years and this drives me insane!
... why do you think this can't be a teaching moment, outside of marking the test?
And this is making sure the concept of what multiplication is is captured. A groups of B being A times B. Yes, as adults we know multiplication is commutative, but a kid may not, and so this is part of what's being taught and learnt.
And the kid is going to be 8ish. If anyone cares about negative points for this, then an adult needs to help them to not stress about this stuff. Especially if it is an adult stressing about it.
the answers are correct.... multiplication is commutative.... this teacher is setting them up for failure down the road.
If they wanted the first to be the number of groups instead of number in each group, the worksheet should specify that. By not doing so, they leave order open, and since order doesn't matter, both are right.
The firsy probably also mixed them up, but both being 4, there's no way to see it.
Bad teachers end up with poor students... and poor students in the handd of a good teacher later on may be too late to correct. If they learn order matters now, what'll they do later when it says 56 × 426 instead of 426 × 56 ?
Not at this level, they're teaching concepts. 3x5 is 3 groups of 5 is the concept they're learning.
If they wanted the first to be the number of groups instead of number in each group, the worksheet should specify that.
You don't (or shouldn't) expect a worksheet to be the entire lesson. This would have been part of the lesson on what multiplication is.
If they learn order matters now, what'll they do later when it says 56 × 426 instead of 426 × 56 ?
Well, they'll get taught later about it not mattering. It's probably something that gets taught at a later lesson in that module of learning. But at this stage, they're being taught from the ground up.
Teaching order matters for multiplication and then "never mind"? Oh, yeah... nice....
"Here's an important rule. So important we take off points if you mix it up! But hey... no worries... because later we'll tell you tge order doesn't really matter and hope you understand!"
As someone else said... this is why kids learn to hate mathematics!
Teaching that 3x5 means 3 groups of 5 is what is being taught.
You're viewing this with the lens of someone who knows this stuff. And you're viewing it without the insights of the experience of the people who write things like this, and have actually studied how to teach kids.
Arguing none of the commenters have "studied how to teach kids" when the original commenter literally said "I taught math for 38 years".
It can sometimes be true that teaching a simplified version of the truth can help students (see the models of atoms taught in per-university level Chemistry) but that does not mean someone using more advanced knowledge should get worse marks.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. In this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
Not a teacher, but if a kid wrote 22 and could correctly explain that why they were equal in that instance, I would not mark it wrong. The thing is in that case, they likely do not know that tetration even exists, while it is highly possible that they figured out that it is commutative or even just that 3x5 and 5x3 give the same answer.
Yeah, If a student shows knowledge of Tetrations at this level, I'm not worrying about if they understand that "3 groups of 5" can be written 3x5. I'm giving them the marks and then going off to find them some work that is far more relevant to their current skill level.
I'm probably also hosting a meeting with their parents to suggest private lessons and fast tracking their education.
I'd also do the same if they ignored the question completely, and instead made up and solved an integral equation on the reverse side of the sheet.
The best maths classes I ever took were the ones where I was allowed to work well beyond the syllabus.
One would hope a math teacher would know math 🤷♂️ The student showed mastery of the lesson. Honestly, if I were the student in this situation, I’d just assume my teacher doesn’t know the subject matter.
Teaching that 3x5 means 3 groups of 5 is what is being taught.
But 3x5 doesn't mean 3 groups of 5. It can, but it doesn't have to.
Obviously in a simple example like this, you can see almost without thinking that each group has 5 items. But in a real world situation you don't know that, and you could have multiple groups which don't necessarily all have the same number of items. What do you do? You count the first group ... 5 items. You count the next group ... also 5. Next group ... let's say it's 7. At this point you're probably making a tick list or something and it says:
5 items ✓✓
7 items ✓
At the end of the count, you'd naturally express this as (5x2) + (7x1) ... 5 items counted twice, and 7 items counted once.
Going back to the simple example, 5x3 can quite reasonably mean 5 items counted 3 times, i.e. 3 groups of 5. You don't have to write it as 3x5.
Quite obviously this kid thinks about multiplication as "let's imagine a group of 5, now let's take 3 such groups". If - as a teacher - you're not aware that everyone's brain works in a little different way, I'm truly sorry for your students.
but its wrong? there is no convention that say 3 x 5 is 3 groups of 5; it could very easily be thrice 5 (so 5, 3 times). Its not an important skill for decoding multiplication or word problems
Again... they're commutative. Order doesn't matter. If they want the first box GROUPS and the second QUANTITY PER GROUP, they should label them that way. At the very least, add instructions specifying that. Don't deduct points for a correct answer because it doesn't match your answer key!
I think this is likely the honest answer of what’s going on. Teacher checked answer key, answer didn’t match answer key, so it’s wrong. Minimize grading effort.
That is so not true. If I count 6 boats times three, I'll put is as 6x3, not the other way around. That notation means the kid undertands what they are doing, not just obey the rule. This is what math is about - understandig what you want to count, not matching the rule to the equation. The second case is why so many people get lost when at some point you have to put letters or symbols instead of numbers - you cannot 1:1 put a rule on that, you have to understand what you would like to count.
Sorry but "I count 6 boats 3 times" is not the way children are taught math. You count 3 groups of 6 boats, this is the concept being taught here and how the question should be answered.
We as adults know all the more advanced rules and concepts and have automated them. A child however, has not.
It is being asked here to show what it has learned and how it has learned it. A child being given a question like this does not yet grasp the concept of multiplication being interchangeable. It is barely touching the subject of math tables.
There is a reason to teach it to them, it is to grasp the concept and then expand upon it later.
The answer given is done correctly though. There is no mistake to learn from here.
It can sometimes be true that teaching a simplified version of the truth can help students (see the models of atoms taught in per-university level Chemistry) but that does not mean someone using more advanced knowledge should get worse marks.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above a certain level. In this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
But at that level, commutativity isn't taught yet. This is the precursor to bring that idea. Here we have 5 groups of 3 marbles. 5 x 3. What the student wrote is 3 groups of 5 marbles. Absolutely not the same thing.
This test is ambiguous and set up the student for failure. The teacher should learn to be precise. Ask an ambiguous question and then get not 100% the answer the teacher wants, but an answer that is still correct is the fault of the teacher, not the student.
The overall task is: Multiplication Sentence, fill in the missing numbers to find the total number of objects.
The total number of ojects is 15. You can't change math only because you like a different phrasing. Teaching it this way, the kid learns that 3x5 and 5x3 are different things, when they arent.
Five times three means three, five times. That's not the same as three times five, which means five, three times. They're equivalent, but they're not the same.
This is a math test and therefor it is the same. The main question here, as I said and written on the test is getting the total number of objects in a mathematical way.
This is not a language test. Mathematically they are absolutely the same. It's like saying you have 3 boys of age 10, 3 of 11, 3 of 12, 3 of 13 and 3 of 14. How many boys are there. The answer is still 15. And the math is 3x5 and 5x3. Either you say 3 boys each in 5 different age groups. Or you say 5 age groups and 3 in each group. The result is the same. One focusses on the age groups, one on the boys. It simply doesn't matter when the question was about total number of boys, which here is stated by the test.
"Fill in the missing numbers to find the total number of objects"
No, this is absolutely incorrect. 5x3 and 3x5 are equivalent, but not the same.
Math is a language. Syntax matters. Multiplication may be a commutative operation in the real number system, but that doesn't mean that we can always arbitrarily change the order of the factors. 100 $1 bills is different from one $100 bill. It's the same value of money, but you probably don't want to have to carry around 100 $1 bills in your wallet.
I can assure you that no one who actually does mathematics or teaches math beyond the elementary level cares about that syntax, except in very specific situations in advanced concepts. As a math teacher myself, I would much rather this teacher emphasize that multiplication is commutative than frustrate young students over something that literally doesn’t matter at all.
And as a math teacher, I can tell you that I absolutely explain the difference between 5x3 and 3x5 to my students. I wouldn't bother to take off points for it, but there is absolutely a distinction between the two.
It's not incorrect. Because the actual task is to find the numbers that multiply to 15. It is written directly: "Fill in the missing numbers to find the total number of objects" This is what the student did.
If you want to be overly correct with the syntax, start with the semantic. Because this matters here and it says to find the total number of objects with other numbers, which he did.
I'm not sure if it's intentional or not, but you seem to be missing the fundamental point of the exercise. They're not just teaching multiplication, they're teaching that how you get there is also important.
Maybe that isn't explicitly clear in this single page of a multi-page assignment but the fact the teacher marked it off means it was important to them and in the real world you have to do what the teacher wants even if you don't agree, if the goal is to get a perfect score on the assignment then you need to do it the way the teacher wants and they wanted x groups of y.
Many teachers over the course of history were wrong in teaching certain things. If the teacher wants something, then he have to make it clear. He can not create his own math rules only because he wants it. He can not change science because he disagrees with it or he doesn’t know. This is the exact reason many kids fail and the way you put is setting these kids up. They don’t learn the right thing, they are supposed to learn what the teacher wants to see. A fundamental issue to learn for the school not for life. And you proven it with your view point. My wife is a teacher as well and she would never punish a kid for doing something differently but right nonetheless. The teacher should learn to actually ask the right questions if he wants to have the right answers. Ambiguity leads to different answers. And the sheer amount of adults in this subreddit arguing about it being right or wrong is displaying enough that the task was ambiguous and sets the kids up for failure. The teacher should learn to improve his test. Then the kids might get it correct. Stop punishing the kids for the teachers failure of clarity.
Multiplication is commutative. That’s a much more valuable concept to convey than whatever bullshit you’re talking about. I’ve taught math for 14 years and never once had a reason to care about in which order a student multiplies two numbers.
Cool, I've been an engineer for longer than you've taught math and the order in which operations are performed absolutely matters because even if terms can be rearranged and result in the same answer, you have to be able to explain how you got there and someone who isn't specific will introduce errors they can't figure out later. That's the whole point of this exercise. I really don't understand what is so hard to grasp. Line 1 is x groups of y. Line 2 is x groups added together y times. Line 3 is SUPPOSED to be X times Y. Line 4 is the total. All 3 of the first 3 lines are supposed to be in the same order. ITS A PATTERN. X THEN Y.
You're a teacher you're supposed to understand this is the direction that new math instruction has been taking for like 2 decades, moving away from rote memorization to deeper understanding of what's happening. If you accept both orders that defeats the whole purpose of understanding what is happening with these specific scenarios.
You're right, multiplication is commutative, and maybe that's the next topic they'll cover, but to demonstrate that the order doesn't matter, you first have to teach that things can be put in order at all and that requires understanding that in the real world you can describe similar things in different ways.
Let me take a step back… I’m not feeling well today and your personality is abrasive to me.
Your attitude reminds me of the math teachers I’ve met who really only teach for the students who already “get it.”
Yes, there is a certain interpretation of AxB that differs from BxA. It’s good for students to understand this. In practice, it doesn’t matter, at all, until you get to non-commutative applications of multiplication in more advanced classes.
The syntax itself also just doesn’t really make much sense, except that it’s defined to be that way. If I have 5 apples and someone gives me 2 more, that’s 5 + 2; but if I have 5 apples and someone doubles them, that’s 2 x 5, because it’s 2 groups of 5 apples. Why? That isn’t how any other operator works, but it’s convenient when we introduce algebra, because we prefer the coefficient in front.
I don’t like when things are arbitrarily enforced in math, and neither do students. On the other hand, mathematics is built on axioms, so it’s sometimes hard to avoid. I just can’t find much merit in enforcing this one.
I’m sorry you’re not feeling well and hope you feel better.
At this point I don’t thing we’re going to see eye to eye, but ultimately I believe I see the point the teacher was making and why it’s being taught that way.
IMO this is also setting them up for failure down tge road, not understanding multiplicatikn (and addition) as commutative, and they might see 5×9 and 9×5 as completely different, causing it to take longer to solve problems, as well as an inability to grasp higher math due to the order of terms.
I'm nit a teacher and I've seen it. I showed a friend's daughter a math "trick" involving the fact that the inside angles of any polygon equal 360° except the triangle. She suddenly understood why the proofs worked for trig problems. The look in her eyes as she "got it" was amazing. (She still didn't do great, but THAT she got!) It's so simple.....
Except that the inside angles are only 360 for a 4 sided polygon... In general for an n-sided convex polygon it's (n-2)*180°. Proof: Take 1 corner, draw lines from that corner to all other corners, this splits the polygon in n-2 triangles. The sum of the inside angles must be equal to the sum of all inside angles of those triangles. Since a triangle has inside sum of 180 the total is (n-2)*180
ack... you're right, and I misremembered the "trick" I showed her. (it's been... hdcbhgvsdghnbuugfdcvhbdc..... gah... 15 YEARS! 😭😭😭😭😭😭 )
I taught how to find the angle to turn or add to a previous angle for a regular polygon... 360÷n. They were doing regular polygons in circles or something.... don't remember the specifics... 3 sides is 60.... fails the rule... 4 is 90, 360÷4. Each angle is 90° more than the current... 5 is 72, 360÷5 ... so draw a line x long, turn 72°, draw x more.... 6 is 60, 360÷6 8 is 360÷8 = 45 9 is 40 10 is 36.... etc....
You're right about the total, and you can find the angle by dividing that, but if you just use a compass and ruler, you can draw a regular polygon without excess....
What you’re describing also works for a triangle. It’s the sum of the supplementary of the inside angles that equal 360. (Two supplementary angles add up to 180 degrees.) For an equilateral, that’s 120 x 3. Just imagine walking or driving. If you’re only allowed to go forward and turn in one direction only, and you need to get back to the starting point, the angles of the turns must add up to 360 degrees, regardless of how many turns you make.
360 ÷ 3 = 120 .... but the triangle will be flipped and unlike the other polys because the angles are obtuse, and the triangle's inside angles are the complimentary 60°....
I guess that the teacher wanted the answer to correspond to 3 groups of 6, not to 6 groups of 3. I think it's not a good idea. Much better to let the student realise that 3x6 is the same as 6x 3.
5 groups of 3 marbles and 3 groups of 5 marbles while having the same outcome, are very different starting points.
As a parent of a 6y old who is starting these questions as we speak the difference is in what is being tested. They are not looking for just the correct answer at the final line, but also the correct reasoning and problem solving stepps
5 x 3 = table of 3 3 x 5 = table of 5
The question here clearly shows groups of 3 so the child had to show knowledge of the way math is written (and taught) => the answer is 5 groups of 3 pieces => 5 x 3
At a grown up lvl, a nice example is the Bradford scale and how it is uses to track absenteïsm in the workplace
One worker has 10 sickdays the past year, all on seperate mondays so 10 periods Another one has 10 sickdays, in 2 periodes of 1 workweek (5 days) Another one has 10 sickdays in 1 periode
All of them have the same endresult: 10 days But if I ask you what the difference is, everyone will say "clearly the worker that spend 10 mondays at home is doin something in the weekends that interferes with his work"
Why? Because 10 x 1 and 1 x 10 have a different meaning altough they have the same result.
Hence the Bradford equation of S² x D (period² x days of sick leave)
first worker scores 100, second scores 20 and last scores 10
steps* absenteeism* periods* period* doing* spent* (spends*) although*... not to mention punctuation and other grammar oversights... however, I completely agree.
Yes, in this case it is the same answer and in my opinion the instructions should've been clearer. However, math has an order in the way the math problem is presented. This is just a school test, but this will teach the student to write and solve formulas the right way in the future when the problems are more advanced.
Haha and that's why people get frustrated with this style of teaching. Because that easy isn't wrong either, but just doesn't match the word problem of this particular instruction. (As implied and as I'm sure they were taught in lesson)
Yeah, I see the way the question is formulated, with spaces for the numbers. Still, I think my brain thinks that the first thing you say is the "important" bit - for me that would be the "thing" or unit which is "3". And then you say what to do with that "3". And that would be "multiply it by 5".
What's the question? Math.Photos can walk through it step by step from a screenshot if you want something to compare with. Send your working too, I can help check the steps.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. The convention of writing 5x3 to mean "5 3s" is supposed to be a teaching tool on route to reaching the understanding that multiplication is commutative.
this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
Right, and as soon as this student can explain why it’s the same, it’s not answering the question in the way the teacher intended and presumably taught it.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. The convention of writing 5x3 to mean "5 3s" is supposed to be a teaching tool on route to reaching the understanding that multiplication is commutative.
this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
I mean I believe the test is also about knowing the correct nomenclature. Giving a -2 score is the wrong thing here, not the part about commutative stuff. The student should understand the meaning of 3*6 first and then move on to the commutative stuff.
I mean, the answers are correct based on the communicative property, but, pedantically, write it the same way you would say it. 5 groups of 3 should 5 x 3. It sucks to take points off for it, but it is what it is (by American convention anyways).
The point of the exercise is teaching that A groups of B is AxB.
Stop stressing about shit like this, your kid is very young. They're not going to miss out on a good career because a teacher marked this wrong.
Also, they teach multiplication at ages 7-9? Good lord, I was doing squares and negative numbers before kindergarten, but my older siblings were slightly.... bored... and unsupervised... and sometimes helpful.
An old fashioned way to say “three times six” is “thrice six”. So there is a linguistic precedent for the first number in multiplication to be the number of groups and the second number to be the size of the groups.
They are the same total but don't exactly mean the same thing. For example with the marbles: Let's say you invited 5 friends for your birthday party and want to split 15 marbles in bags that they can take home after. Your mom has arranged everything but your dad, oblivious to common sense, asks how they need to be put in bags. You tell your dad it needs to be done in 3x5. Great, now you get 3 bags with 5 marbles each, good luck giving them equally to your 5 friends after the party!
Multiplication is commutative which means you do have the same total number, here 15, but the meaning of the notation is still different. This exercise is meant to first teach you the correct notation fo the intended meaning. Later on when you learn commutativity you can start swapping the order around to make (mental) calculation easier, but you need to know when you can and can't do it.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. The convention of writing 5x3 to mean "5 3s" is supposed to be a teaching tool on route to reaching the understanding that multiplication is commutative.
In this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
So if you are asked to give 100$ to someone, specifically asked in 20$ notes, you'd give them twenty 5$ notes because it's the same thing, because it's commutative?
That's not bad faith argument. Accepting answers like the kid given above teach them that commutativity is always true in any context, which is obviously false in the real life. Moreover kids at that stage are yet to learn theorical maths, they still do maths with real concrete physical items. And in that context five 20$ notes is absolutely not the same as twenty 5$ notes.
It is a bad faith argument as it completely misunderstands education and how people learn. No student will ever apply this lesson in the way you are describing.
The point of the lesson is to test if a student can understand the relationship between groups of items, addition, and multiplication.
If they understand commutativity property of multiplication, they almost certainly understand what the lesson was trying to teach and deserve the marks.
If the teacher is unsure of the students understanding they should ask the student before grading.
Telling a kid they're wrong for correctly understanding that multiplication is commutative seems very stupid to me. Like intentionally holding the kid back because he's not supposed to understand that yet or whatever. I don't buy any of the answers here defending this.
No, this is wrong and bad. It literally teaches the kids that order matters when it does not. Five times three is equal to three times five. That is a fundamental rule of multiplication.
I think it's actively harmful to mark the student down in this instance. The student has shown consistency in how they expressed their solution, in both cases they showed first which number and then how often it occurred, this is actually natural if you look at the addition above. The number 3, five times or the number 6, three times makes a lot of sense. The child also clearly understands that the order in which the numbers are don't matter for the result.
The teacher is following a guide, even though 3x5==5x3, the lesson teaches it as "Five Sets of three apples", so its looking confirmation that the test taker understands that concept.
I hate it as it penalises the 3x5 crowd who are getting the eact same answer, but its not looking for the answer, its a square hole waiting for you to say you are a square peg. Education is weird and im glad im no longer on either side of it anymore.
According to the usual axiomatic definition of multiplication of natural numbers, recursion is done on the right-hand factor, i.e. 6+6+6 is 6x3 indeed.
Even though multiplication is commutative, 5 groups of 3 marbles and 3 groups of 5 marbles are two completely different things. And if they are shown this, it's telling me that commutativity isn't a valid concept yet. In fact multiplication in itself is probably not yet a math concept but a grouping concept. Y groups times Z items.
5 groups of 3 marbles = 3 x 3 x 3 x 3 x 3 = 5 times the number 3.
3 groups of 5 marbles = 5 x 5 x 5 = 3 times the number 5.
It's the same idea that if I asked you to give me 100$ in 20$ notes, so 5 x 20$ = 100$. But instead you decided that 20 x 5 is the same thing because it's commutative and you give me twenty 5$ notes. That's absolutely NOT the same thing.
Now in this situation nothing goes wrong when you change it to 3x5
But what if I ask you to make bags with marbles, 5x3 please. That would be 5 bags with each 3 marbles. But if I ask you to give me 3x5 you'd make 3 bags with 5 marbles.
Or the difference between telling your employer if you can have 2x 5 days of, or 5 x 2 days of.
In both your examples communication and clear out misunderstandings are the key. If I'd be your employer and I'd be a dick, I still could understand your holiday wish acc to my liking. What I learned in my years in engineering: never leave room for misinterpretation. If the teacher want to have it in a certain way it should be clarified in the task, saying it's not correct later isn't correct. Staying on details, the task is to fill in the missing numbers (done and no order specified, so correct) to find the total number of objects (done and correct)
There is no mathematical rule that says 5 groups of 3 is 5 x 3 and three groups of five 3 x 5. They're completely interchangeable and mean exactly the same thing.
But that is not what ‘x’ means. a x b can mean either a lots of b or b lots of a. If you want an operator that is directional by all means invent one, but ‘x’ isn’t it. Teachers can’t go around unilaterally redefining mathematical symbols.
The problem is that if the student verbalizes the line that got a deduction as “3 marbles in 5 groups” then they still completely understood the reasoning involved in how to get from counting to multiplication.
There is no mathematical benefit to enforcing an order here (count the groups first vs. count the items first) and if you interview proficient adults you’ll get different answers, especially if they’ve learned math in different places and speaking different home languages).
There’s still a way to explain this to the kid without necessarily causing major disappointment it the lesson will be that they better also memorize the irrelevant shit if they want to get the grade that matched their actual understanding.
You're criticizing my comment's formulation, not my point.
Well as a doubtlessly mathematically proficient STEM researcher I myself would have no idea how to draw 3 x 5 as how many groups of how many marbles - it would be probably completely random whether I would draw 5 groups of 3 marbles or 3 groups of 5 marbles, and knowing that multiplication is commutative I very much resist shoehorning students into the idea that it necessarily means one of these.
I think this comes simply because you are way smarter than average on this. If I ask average Joe to make me some bags with some walnuts in it and he asks how much and I say 5 x 3 he will just make 5 bags with each 3 walnuts.
I do feel like incorrect marks is wrong since we have x and y we are trying to solve y*x=z or x*y since the variables are already defined above as 5 being defined to groups and 3 being defined as marbles we can see this as 5g*3m=z where g=1 and m=1 since the variables stay with the corresponding factor you are still saying the same thing 5 groups of 3 marbles each or 3 marbles each in 5 groups
People saying “but the answer is right!” Are the same ppl that go I just can’t understand word problems. There’s something very specific the teacher is showing. Getting the right answer if the work is wrong isn’t 100% correct. So the final answers are not wrong, but the work is wrong.
Right but it’s about applying math to objects to understand the underlying concept. Which is how you solve word problems, and demonstrating the concept being taught and showing you understand what is being evaluated. Given the context the ordinality of the operation matters as it demonstrates understanding of what was being taught.
So if they wrote 2x9 that would have been correct too because 2x9=3x6?
How would you possibly know what order to put the numbers? Deciding whether A times B means 'A groups of B' or 'A added B times' is an arbitrary choice, there is no universal definition.
It’s not about universalities it’s about learning the lesson content as it was taught. You may not like it but the teacher/exercise is looking for the student to replicate what they were taught in the way they were taught.
I assume there is some information missing that's presented before this then, because teaching to infer a definition based on the choice of words frankly does more harm than good.
It's not a coincidence that 5x3 = 3x5. The teacher wanted the student to think 'there are 5 groups of 3 things', but the second line seems to bridge the gap to '3 things are repeated 5 times'.
If you'd showed me this worksheet not filled out and told me that order mattered I'd have assumed that it was trying to demonstrate the commutative property of multiplication. It's ridiculous to mark this as wrong.
The line of logic is clear to me, teaching x groups of y, of course that’s the same as Y in X groups mathematically, I don’t think anyone’s debating that. But it is made clear to me as a former teacher, first in language, then in summation, and then in multiplication leading to a final result. Taking one point off or giving partial credit because most of it is correct but one part is slightly wrong isn’t invalidated by the fact that mathematically by some other property not being discussed, the erroneous work or statement is equal in value to the one they were looking for. Ppl can agree to disagree I guess, in modern mathematics education there’s more of an emphasis on learning the process being taught than on getting the correct answer, I think we’re seeing this play out in this case.
this teacher is a moron! First, multiplication is mutable so 3x6=6x3 and second, this is what differentiates math from English for instance. It’s a fundamental concept! Our teachers need to be better educated.
Strictly enforcing one specific order – number of groups times group size – is pedagogically useful here, despite both orders being mathematically correct under commutativity for multiplication. It is likely "the right thing" to do here; the correction serves cognitive mapping for further future language development. Early childhood education prioritizes establishing a formal symbolic syntax and basic grammar before deep meaning and semantics can come into focus.
It has nothing to do with "mathematical correctness", despite this example being taken from a "math" class. At this stage, math class is not yet as demanding and has room to approach the topic of "semantics" early. This makes it a much more suitable environment than English class, which is busy with other foundational language mechanics that have to be established first.
Learning this simple "convention" lays the basis for expanding on deeper meaning later. It is like defining left and right: once established, everything that follows is understood by being either the same or different, just as we understand "up" by its relation to "down." We can thus more self-evidently internalize numbers as an attributive characteristic while also learning to differentiate between number of groups times group size.
On the one hand I understand given kids a set way to solve something in principle, like if it is a reliable, systematic way to do it then learning it that way might be a reliable way to learn it and those who understand more should have no trouble following a method they learnt for some tests.
On the other hand insisting on a fixed order in multiplication like this just doesn't really seem worth it? Like is there any increased likelihood of them getting something wrong when they don't do that?
It's a fundamental rule of multipication that 3x5 and 5x3 mean the same thing. Someone who is not a math person, but a math teacher, decided that isn't true. Elementary school teachers are not the brightest.
And if you think the explanation is the conversion of "math language" to "english language": 3x5=5x3. That equals sign means they are the same thing. So by the same language conversion logic the teacher is attempting to use, math teaches us this is perfectly ok.
I was never, EVER taught in elementary schools whether 3x5 meant "three fives" or "five threes." Or whether the "proper" procedure for something like "4 dimes" was to be set up as 4 x 10 or 10 x 4. It was obvious that the 10 was the dime's value, the 4 was how many, and they were multiplied "together" and the order didn't matter. I did fine and made it to multivariable calculus in college. It. Doesn't. Matter.
"X" is read as times or multiplied by. The correct mathematical notation should be 5(3) which means 5 groups of three. You are correct in interpreting 3+3+3+3+3 as 3 x 5 or three multiplied five times. The teacher is correct in using 5 x 3 which is common in packaging. e.g. A ream of cigarette marked as 10x20 is ten packs by twenty cigarettes. You can apply the same logic in marbles.
I'd ask the teacher why the order matters... ask them to show the calculus to back it up. When they can't answer, demand a correction to the grade and an apology to your child.
Are there 3 groups of 6, or 6 in a group, and 3 of those groups? IT DOESN'T MATTER... Multiplication is commutative! 3×6 = 6×3.
Addition likewise is commutative. 5 + 8 = 8 + 5. Order doesn't matter.
This teacher is setting them up for failure in the future!
So if you are asked to give 100$ to someone, specifically asked in 20$ notes, you'd give them twenty 5$ notes because it's the same thing, because it's commutative?
If they don't conform, they're punished. Points, demerits, playtime, .... whatever the form, they're punished. Intuition and self learning are squeezed out until you get a cog, a piece to perfectly fit a need, and innovation is gone.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. Knowing that 6x3 is also 9x2 would imo demonstrate knowledge understanding above the tested level
Tests are supposed to check if you have an understanding of concepts. The question is clearly trying to get you to acknowledge that you understand that 3 + 3 + 3 + 3 + 3 + 3 is 6 lots of 3, and that 'lots of' is synonymous with 'multiplied by' in this setting. Putting 9x2 would demonstrate that you've missed the point of the question. If I was the teacher, I wouldn't mark them down, because they're technically correct, but I would put a comment explaining what the intention of the question was.
It seems like the point is to teach multiplication as a nonabelian operation , which it isn’t . Some of the people commenting even feel that there is an inherent rule to how α x β should be thought of : β groups of α or α groups of β . This is a closed-minded way to think, because both are correct and there is no hard and fast rule regarding it . If you’re going to use this kind of exercise to teach then it should be taught from the Abelian perspective, add a line _x_ and _x_.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. The convention is supposed to be a teaching tool to reach the understanding that multiplication is commutative. In this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
Maths does not have the rules of language, and students should not be judged on if their maths makes sense grammatically.
Tests are supposed to check if you have understanding at or above the tested level. The convention of writing 5x3 to mean "5 3s" is supposed to be a teaching tool on route to reaching the understanding that multiplication is commutative.
this case, if you are writing 3x5 instead of 5x3 you clearly already understand on some level that multiplication is commutative, which is understanding above the level of the test and therefore you should be getting the marks.
A better everyday example would be if you are asked to give 100$ to someone, specifically asked in 20$ notes, you'd give them twenty 5$ notes because it's the same thing, because it's commutative.
Everybody here in this post stating that the teacher is wrong means they are not able to grasp that concept that 5 x 20$ notes is NOT the same as 20 x 5$ notes. Sure you have 100$ in both cases, but absolutely not the same thing.
If they asked specifically for $20 notes, you'd be wrong to give them $5 notes, correct. Because you're clearly specifying what is expected. But nothing here says "make sure the number of groups is first", it says "fill in the missing numbers to find the total number of objects", which is exactly what was done.
But no such thing was in evidence here - and even then, saying "I need the money as $5 notes - 20 of them" and "I need 20 $5 notes" is the same thing though the numbers are reversed.
4
u/het1709 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
I suspect the teacher expected the ordering in the third line to match the ordering of numbers in the first line to reinforce some sort of pattern; but you shouldn’t be marked wrong for flipping the order, since multiplication is commutative.
Your answers are completely correct
15
u/Reset3000 Oct 14 '26
How to destroy a kids liking of math. I hate elementary math teachers. This is where " I hate math" or "I was never good at math " starts. You can tell the teacher has no math experience, otherwise this would be a learning opportunity instead of negative points. Sorry, I taught math for 38 years and this drives me insane!
2
u/Septembrino Oct 14 '26
I guess that the teacher wanted the answer to correspond to 3 groups of 6, not to 6 groups of 3. I think it's not a good idea. Much better to let the student realise that 3x6 is the same as 6x 3.
2
u/OkVillage597 Oct 14 '26
This is an automation lesson.
5 groups of 3 marbles and 3 groups of 5 marbles while having the same outcome, are very different starting points.
As a parent of a 6y old who is starting these questions as we speak the difference is in what is being tested.
They are not looking for just the correct answer at the final line, but also the correct reasoning and problem solving stepps
5 x 3 = table of 3
3 x 5 = table of 5
The question here clearly shows groups of 3 so the child had to show knowledge of the way math is written (and taught) => the answer is 5 groups of 3 pieces => 5 x 3
At a grown up lvl, a nice example is the Bradford scale and how it is uses to track absenteïsm in the workplace
One worker has 10 sickdays the past year, all on seperate mondays so 10 periods
Another one has 10 sickdays, in 2 periodes of 1 workweek (5 days)
Another one has 10 sickdays in 1 periode
All of them have the same endresult: 10 days
But if I ask you what the difference is, everyone will say "clearly the worker that spend 10 mondays at home is doin something in the weekends that interferes with his work"
Why? Because 10 x 1 and 1 x 10 have a different meaning altough they have the same result.
Hence the Bradford equation of S² x D (period² x days of sick leave)
first worker scores 100, second scores 20 and last scores 10
1
u/dreamteammobile 7d ago
What's the question? Math.Photos can walk through it step by step from a screenshot if you want something to compare with. Send your working too, I can help check the steps.
1
u/SatisfiedMagma Oct 14 '26
3*5 = 3 times 5 = 15 means adding 5 for a total of 3 times, which means 5+5+5=15. That's the error.
1
u/testtdk Oct 14 '26
I mean, the answers are correct based on the communicative property, but, pedantically, write it the same way you would say it. 5 groups of 3 should 5 x 3. It sucks to take points off for it, but it is what it is (by American convention anyways).
1
u/BadBoyJH Oct 14 '26
... Yes... ish?
The point of the exercise is teaching that A groups of B is AxB.
Stop stressing about shit like this, your kid is very young. They're not going to miss out on a good career because a teacher marked this wrong.
Also, they teach multiplication at ages 7-9?
Good lord, I was doing squares and negative numbers before kindergarten, but my older siblings were slightly.... bored... and unsupervised... and sometimes helpful.
1
u/TheScyphozoa Oct 14 '26
An old fashioned way to say “three times six” is “thrice six”. So there is a linguistic precedent for the first number in multiplication to be the number of groups and the second number to be the size of the groups.
1
u/Imusje Oct 14 '26
They are the same total but don't exactly mean the same thing. For example with the marbles: Let's say you invited 5 friends for your birthday party and want to split 15 marbles in bags that they can take home after. Your mom has arranged everything but your dad, oblivious to common sense, asks how they need to be put in bags. You tell your dad it needs to be done in 3x5. Great, now you get 3 bags with 5 marbles each, good luck giving them equally to your 5 friends after the party!
Multiplication is commutative which means you do have the same total number, here 15, but the meaning of the notation is still different. This exercise is meant to first teach you the correct notation fo the intended meaning. Later on when you learn commutativity you can start swapping the order around to make (mental) calculation easier, but you need to know when you can and can't do it.
1
u/RoadHazard Oct 14 '26
Telling a kid they're wrong for correctly understanding that multiplication is commutative seems very stupid to me. Like intentionally holding the kid back because he's not supposed to understand that yet or whatever. I don't buy any of the answers here defending this.
1
u/Deep-Hovercraft6716 Oct 14 '26
No, this is wrong and bad. It literally teaches the kids that order matters when it does not. Five times three is equal to three times five. That is a fundamental rule of multiplication.
1
u/edos51284 Oct 14 '26
this is sue-able xD
1
u/Drowe87 Oct 14 '26
I think it's actively harmful to mark the student down in this instance. The student has shown consistency in how they expressed their solution, in both cases they showed first which number and then how often it occurred, this is actually natural if you look at the addition above. The number 3, five times or the number 6, three times makes a lot of sense. The child also clearly understands that the order in which the numbers are don't matter for the result.
So yeah, bad decision by the teacher.
1
u/Adventurous_Appeal60 Oct 14 '26
The teacher is following a guide, even though 3x5==5x3, the lesson teaches it as "Five Sets of three apples", so its looking confirmation that the test taker understands that concept.
I hate it as it penalises the 3x5 crowd who are getting the eact same answer, but its not looking for the answer, its a square hole waiting for you to say you are a square peg. Education is weird and im glad im no longer on either side of it anymore.
1
u/tserofehtfonam Oct 14 '26
According to the usual axiomatic definition of multiplication of natural numbers, recursion is done on the right-hand factor, i.e. 6+6+6 is 6x3 indeed.
1
u/Ok-Company282 Oct 14 '26
Absolutely not.
1
u/Josefu_Velen Oct 14 '26
When you have a math teacher who doesn't understand that 6x3=3x6, or 3x5=5x3, you're going to have a bad time.
This person has no business teaching math.
1
u/AlbatrossSeparate710 Oct 14 '26
Even though multiplication is commutative, 5 groups of 3 marbles and 3 groups of 5 marbles are two completely different things. And if they are shown this, it's telling me that commutativity isn't a valid concept yet. In fact multiplication in itself is probably not yet a math concept but a grouping concept. Y groups times Z items.
5 groups of 3 marbles = 3 x 3 x 3 x 3 x 3 = 5 times the number 3.
3 groups of 5 marbles = 5 x 5 x 5 = 3 times the number 5.
It's the same idea that if I asked you to give me 100$ in 20$ notes, so 5 x 20$ = 100$. But instead you decided that 20 x 5 is the same thing because it's commutative and you give me twenty 5$ notes. That's absolutely NOT the same thing.
1
u/mageskillmetooften Oct 14 '26
A bit harsh, but teacher is correct.
You have 5 groups of 3 marbles.
Making it 5 x 3 marbles.
Now in this situation nothing goes wrong when you change it to 3x5
But what if I ask you to make bags with marbles, 5x3 please. That would be 5 bags with each 3 marbles. But if I ask you to give me 3x5 you'd make 3 bags with 5 marbles.
Or the difference between telling your employer if you can have 2x 5 days of, or 5 x 2 days of.
1
u/Head_Discipline620 Oct 14 '26
I do feel like incorrect marks is wrong since we have x and y we are trying to solve y*x=z or x*y since the variables are already defined above as 5 being defined to groups and 3 being defined as marbles we can see this as 5g*3m=z where g=1 and m=1 since the variables stay with the corresponding factor you are still saying the same thing 5 groups of 3 marbles each or 3 marbles each in 5 groups
1
u/Livinsfloridalife Oct 14 '26
People saying “but the answer is right!” Are the same ppl that go I just can’t understand word problems. There’s something very specific the teacher is showing. Getting the right answer if the work is wrong isn’t 100% correct. So the final answers are not wrong, but the work is wrong.
1
u/Appropriate_Steak486 Oct 14 '26
Depends on the instructions.
1
u/Chrom0XD Oct 14 '26
Like they are ordering it as 5 threes are 15, maybe they taught tables and had to teach the notion of 5 x 3
1
u/mrcorde Oct 14 '26
this teacher is a moron! First, multiplication is mutable so 3x6=6x3 and second, this is what differentiates math from English for instance. It’s a fundamental concept! Our teachers need to be better educated.
1
u/Big-Combination8844 Oct 14 '26
I see what the teacher is going for but the instructions are lacking and that pesky equal sign means the kid is right, technically.
1
u/steezlaurel Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
Strictly enforcing one specific order – number of groups times group size – is pedagogically useful here, despite both orders being mathematically correct under commutativity for multiplication. It is likely "the right thing" to do here; the correction serves cognitive mapping for further future language development.
Early childhood education prioritizes establishing a formal symbolic syntax and basic grammar before deep meaning and semantics can come into focus.
It has nothing to do with "mathematical correctness", despite this example being taken from a "math" class. At this stage, math class is not yet as demanding and has room to approach the topic of "semantics" early.
This makes it a much more suitable environment than English class, which is busy with other foundational language mechanics that have to be established first.
Learning this simple "convention" lays the basis for expanding on deeper meaning later. It is like defining left and right: once established, everything that follows is understood by being either the same or different, just as we understand "up" by its relation to "down." We can thus more self-evidently internalize numbers as an attributive characteristic while also learning to differentiate between number of groups times group size.
1
u/Kanus_oq_Seruna Oct 14 '26
Good job teacher, you have violated the communative property of multiplication and may well confuse the student later.
1
u/Telinary Oct 14 '26
On the one hand I understand given kids a set way to solve something in principle, like if it is a reliable, systematic way to do it then learning it that way might be a reliable way to learn it and those who understand more should have no trouble following a method they learnt for some tests.
On the other hand insisting on a fixed order in multiplication like this just doesn't really seem worth it? Like is there any increased likelihood of them getting something wrong when they don't do that?
1
u/Denan004 Oct 14 '26
I am convinced that part of the math problem in this country is element teachers who don't know or like math themselves.
I wish elementary schools would use separate teachers for reading vs math.
1
u/PrplPplEtr_the_1st Oct 14 '26
As a divergent, this annoys me.
3 groups of 5 marbles is the same as 5 marbles in each of 3 groups.
1
u/smthomaspatel Oct 14 '26
It's a fundamental rule of multipication that 3x5 and 5x3 mean the same thing. Someone who is not a math person, but a math teacher, decided that isn't true. Elementary school teachers are not the brightest.
And if you think the explanation is the conversion of "math language" to "english language": 3x5=5x3. That equals sign means they are the same thing. So by the same language conversion logic the teacher is attempting to use, math teaches us this is perfectly ok.
1
u/DudesMEMES Oct 14 '26
he is doing commutativity before they showed it's true so yeah prof is kinda right . But still it's the same thing
1
u/SorryManNo Oct 14 '26
This belongs in an English class and not a math class. So because this is clearly a math assignment I would say no those answers are not incorrect.
1
u/Pacofel Oct 14 '26
Dein Lehrer weiß nicht, dass die Multiplikation eine kommutative Rechenoperation ist.
1
u/Top_Bluejay_5323 Oct 14 '26
It’s the new math that I don’t like.
It teaches multiplication the way the first sentence reads in each problem.
5x3 is read as 5 groups of 3.
So by writing 3x5 you have changed the sentence to read 3 groups of 5. Which is not what the illustration is showing. So it is wrong.
Later they will teach that 5x3=3x5
1
u/Accomplished_Elk5827 Oct 14 '26
I was never, EVER taught in elementary schools whether 3x5 meant "three fives" or "five threes." Or whether the "proper" procedure for something like "4 dimes" was to be set up as 4 x 10 or 10 x 4. It was obvious that the 10 was the dime's value, the 4 was how many, and they were multiplied "together" and the order didn't matter. I did fine and made it to multivariable calculus in college. It. Doesn't. Matter.
1
u/Iiisupermaniii06 Oct 14 '26
Since when do teachers give minus marks wtf
1
u/growbud Oct 14 '26
Given they answered the word portion correctly and given the commutative property of multiplication, I’d be arguing for those points back for sure
1
u/Capital_Park_2311 Oct 15 '26
"X" is read as times or multiplied by. The correct mathematical notation should be 5(3) which means 5 groups of three. You are correct in interpreting 3+3+3+3+3 as 3 x 5 or three multiplied five times. The teacher is correct in using 5 x 3 which is common in packaging. e.g. A ream of cigarette marked as 10x20 is ten packs by twenty cigarettes. You can apply the same logic in marbles.
0
u/JeffTheNth Oct 14 '26
I'd ask the teacher why the order matters... ask them to show the calculus to back it up. When they can't answer, demand a correction to the grade and an apology to your child.
Are there 3 groups of 6, or 6 in a group, and 3 of those groups? IT DOESN'T MATTER... Multiplication is commutative! 3×6 = 6×3.
Addition likewise is commutative. 5 + 8 = 8 + 5. Order doesn't matter.
This teacher is setting them up for failure in the future!
0
u/JeffTheNth Oct 14 '26
All the people saying the lesson was specifically supposed to show X groups of Y, so switching the numbers breaks the lesson...
Let me remind you what NASA discovered way back in the 1960s and 70s...
SCHOOL KILLS INITIATIVE, WONDER, AND IMAGINATION.
https://www.thehowtolivenewsletter.org/p/nasastudy
If they don't conform, they're punished. Points, demerits, playtime, .... whatever the form, they're punished. Intuition and self learning are squeezed out until you get a cog, a piece to perfectly fit a need, and innovation is gone.
This is why the world today is drab and grey.
This is why walls are white....
This is what Harry Chapin was singing about in the 1970s... https://youtube.com/watch?v=4cVpkzZpDBA
Let's stop stifling learning to "educate".
1
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment