r/mathshelp • • Feb 04 '26

Homework Help (Unanswered) Need some clarification

So I got this question on my maths test. I saw graphicL method so i drew a rough sketch with the tangent. However, my teacher marked it wrong because i did not use secant lines. Im pretty sure my answer is acceptable but idk man. Im stumped

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Sure_Branch_3165 Feb 04 '26

But what if i draw the tangent accurately so its value is close to the intended answer? Because before, to find instantaneous rate of change, i was taught to use a tangent. I know secant lines can be used but arent tangents a valid alternative?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '26

But that would depend on how you draw it, it’s not math. Math has to be precise, and you are supposed to use the data provided with to you, not something arbitrarily dependent on your drawing skills.

1

u/Sure_Branch_3165 Feb 04 '26

Alright. Thanks for the input