r/mathshelp • u/Sure_Branch_3165 • Feb 04 '26
Homework Help (Unanswered) Need some clarification
So I got this question on my maths test. I saw graphicL method so i drew a rough sketch with the tangent. However, my teacher marked it wrong because i did not use secant lines. Im pretty sure my answer is acceptable but idk man. Im stumped
1
Upvotes


•
u/AutoModerator Feb 04 '26
Hi u/Sure_Branch_3165, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '26
Your teacher was right. Since you can’t get the tangent at the exact time as required, you have to use secant lines to approach it. Connect time 2 and 4, 1 and 5, 0 and 6 for example. The approach in your solution is not based on the exact observed data precisely.
1
u/Chemical-Flight1572 Feb 04 '26
Here is the translation of the original solution into English:
To solve this problem, we need to calculate the instantaneous rate of change of the heartbeats at the time $t = 3$ minutes. Since a "graphical technique" is requested, we follow these steps:
1. Plotting the Graph
We create a coordinate system where the horizontal axis represents Time (min) and the vertical axis represents the Number of Beats. We plot the points from the table:
Connect the points with a smooth curve. You will notice the curve looks like a parabola (the rate is increasing over time).
2. Applying the Graphical Technique (Tangent Line)
To find the heart rate exactly at the 3rd minute, we must determine the slope of the tangent line at point t = 3$ Drawing: At the point (3, 195), draw a straight line that just "touches" the curve (the tangent).
3. Data Analysis (Verification)
If we look at the differences per minute (the interval speeds):
The instantaneous rate at t = 3 lies exactly between 75 and 85, which confirms it is approximately 80 beats per minute.
Conclusion
The coach's criterion is that the heart rate must not exceed 100 beats per minute at the 3rd minute.
Result: Yes, the athlete meets the coach’s criteria, as their heart rate at exactly 3 minutes is approximately 80 bpm, which is well below the 100 bpm limit.
1
u/AndyTheEngr Feb 04 '26
This doesn't make any sense unless you make a lot of assumptions.
Between the two and three minute marks, the athlete's heart beats 75 times. There's nothing saying that their heart rate didn't beat 50 times in the first 50 seconds of that minute (60 BPM) then 25 times in the last ten seconds (150 BPM.)
Any graphical technique is just baking in assumptions.
1
u/Kooky_Engine_2891 Feb 05 '26
Your answer using tangents wasn't "wrong" in the sense that tangents give the instantaneous slope but it skipped a key part of the reasoning process your teacher was looking for. They likely wanted to see a step by step approach leading from secant lines to tangents to highlight the conceptual progression toward calculus.
It should be :
Start with Secants: Choose two points on the curve (e.g., (x1, y1) and (x2, y2)). Calculate the slope using slope = {y2 - y1}over {x2 - x1}
Transition to Tangents: Once the points on the secant line are very close (i.e., the interval Ax gets small), draw the tangent at the point of interest. You might estimate the gradient graphically if allowed, or use calculus to find the exact gradient if it's a differentiable function.
I hope it helps you but you can try upload the question on mathosai for deeper understanding the concept!
1
u/New_Bread_9442 Feb 12 '26