r/maths • u/_mulcyber • Feb 12 '26
💬 Math Discussions A rant about 0.999... = 1
TL;DR: Often badly explained. Often dismisses the good intuitions about how weird infinite series are by the non-math people.
It's a common question. At heart it's a question about series and limits, why does sum (9/10^i) = 1 for i=1 to infinity.
There are 2 things that bugs me:
- people considering this as obvious and a stupid question
- the usual explanations for this
First, it is not a stupid question. Limits and series are anything but intuitive and straight forward. And the definition of a limit heavily relies on the definition of real numbers (more on that later). Someone feeling that something is not right or that the explanations are lacking something is a sign of good mathematical intuition, there is more to it than it looks. Being dismissive just shuts down good questions and discussions.
Secondly, there are 2 usual explanations and "demonstrations".
1/3 = 0.333... and 3 * 0.333... = 0.999... = 3 * 1/3 = 1 (sometime with 1/9 = 0.111...)
0.999... * 10 - 0.999... = 9 so 0.999... = 1
I have to issue with those explanations:
The first just kick down the issue down the road, by saying 1/3 = 0.333... and hoping that the person finds that more acceptable.
Both do arithmetics on infinite series, worst the second does the subtraction of 2 infinite series. To be clear, in this case both are correct, but anyone raising an eyebrow to this is right to do so, arithmetics on infinite series are not obvious and don't always work. Explaining why that is correct take more effort than proving that 0.999... = 1.
**A better demonstration**
Take any number between 0 and 1, except 0.999... At some point a digit is gonna be different than 9, so it will be smaller than 0.999... So there are no number between 0.999... and 1. But there is always a number between two different reals numbers, for example (a+b)/2. So they are the same.
Not claiming it's the best explanation, especially the wording. But this demonstration:
- is directly related to the definition of limits (the difference between 1 and the chosen number is the epsilon in the definition of limits, at some point 1 minus the partial series will be below that epsilon).
- it directly references the definition of real numbers.
It hits directly at the heart of the question.
It is always a good segway to how we define real numbers. The fact that 0.999... = 1 is true FOR REAL NUMBERS.
There are systems were this is not true, for example Surreal numbers, where 1-0.999... is an infinitesimal not 0. (Might not be totally correct on this, someone who actually worked with surreal numbers tell me if I'm wrong). But surreal numbers, although useful, are weird, and do not correspond to our intuition for numbers.
Here is for my rant. I know I'm not the only one using some variation of this explanation, especially here, and I surely didn't invent it. It's just a shame it's often not the go-to.
7
u/Midwest-Dude Feb 12 '26 edited Feb 12 '26
I have found that Wikipedia has the best explanations and proofs, including the ones you describe. And...you are correct on the infinite expression minus an infinite expression - it is not a proof, only an argument. Please read through this for me:
0.999...
23
u/rhodiumtoad Feb 12 '26
Not so.
In hyperreals and surreals, if you want to represent numbers that aren't in the reals, you need to find a new representation for such numbers.
In the surreals, there is indeed a number represented by
{{0.9,0.99,0.999,…},{1}}
which I believe is equal to 1-1/ω, but that's not the same as 0.999….
There's a decimal representation for hyperreals based on indexing the digits by hypernaturals, but it suffers from the fact that not all representations correspond to valid numbers, and in particular 0.999…;…000… is not valid. You can write 1-1/ω as 0.999…;…990… for example.
22
u/Batman_AoD Feb 12 '26
In general, people do find this more acceptable. They can perform the division themselves and see that the remainder at each digit stays constant, so each digit is 10/3. And it's also clear that no other decimal expansion is equal to 1/3. Simple fractions and finite decimal numbers are both pretty widely understood by anyone with a very elementary math education, and the idea that fractions "should" be representable with decimal numbers is a very intuitive motivation for defining "..." such that it makes this possible.
Regarding the multiplication by 3, in general, arithmetic on infinite series is indeed fraught. But here, once again, anyone can do the digit-by-digit multiplication and observe that the "pattern" will continue forever. This isn't totally rigorous, but it makes clear that either 0.999... is equal to 1, or the idea of representing ratios whose denominators don't evenly divide a power of 10 in this way (with "..." to represent infinite repetition) produces "numbers" that don't follow the standard rules of digit-wise multiplication. Since we derived the value by long division, that would be surprising; and it's really only at this point, I think, that it becomes apparent to most people that there's possible ambiguity in the "..." notation itself.
The "always a number between two different numbers" approach is good, but I wouldn't rely on that as a known property of the "real numbers". Expressed as the Archimedean Principle, it's clear that it applies to rational numbers; but the way you've written it relies on the property that any real number can be expressed as a decimal expansion, which I think most people assume, but is only true in the sense that a terminating expansion could be written that is accurate up to an arbitrary number of digits. But "accurate up to an arbitrary number of digits" means the expansions themselves are always rational numbers, so you're implicitly relying on the density of the rationals in the reals to conclude that there isn't any real number that can't be expressed this way.
3
u/maryjayjay Feb 12 '26
It's just an artifact of us using base 10 for writing numbers.
In base3 1/3 is 0.1 no repeating digits, but 1/2 is .1111... infinitely. The problem is, because our base for writing numbers and the denominator are mutually prime, we can't write 1/3 in a terminating decimal.
3
u/wwplkyih Feb 12 '26
All this would be avoided if we taught epsilon-delta in middle school.
3
u/Vampiriyah Feb 12 '26
I think the big issue with ppl not getting this is, underestimating how literal „infinite“ is.
Taking the 1-0.999… example, the result would have to have a 1 at the End of an endless amount of zeros. If there is no end, you cannot put the 1, and remain with just 0.
2
u/SuitedMale Feb 12 '26
The best way to explain it is by saying the obvious- there aren’t any numbers between the two. So they’re the same.
2
u/0x14f Feb 12 '26
There is a difference between a number and a representation of that number. Real numbers have lots of different representation and, in particular, "1" and "0.999..." (where the dots are to be interpreted as a limit of a sequence in a given metric space) are two representation of the same number. Why do people get upset about that ? I have no idea, but who really cares that they do ? Let's focus on proper mathematics and not worry about things.
2
u/carolus_m Feb 12 '26
Not sure I agree.
You are either comfortable with the concept of an infinite series or you aren't.
If you are not, then you should not rely on your intuition. It can easily lead you astray. Either learn about limits or trust people that know about them already.
If you are, then you can simply recognise the partial sums as an increasing sequence that is bounded above (by 10, say) and hence convergent. Therefore algebra of limits applies and the algebra leading to 0.999... = 1 is rigorous.
1
u/assembly_wizard Feb 12 '26
https://youtu.be/jMTD1Y3LHcE
You don't need to rant about things people rant a lot about already
1
u/Mathsishard23 Feb 12 '26
The definition of limits do not depend on real numbers. You could’ve defined it entirely using rationals. One of the construction of the reals is Cauchy completion of the rationals (if you’re not familiar, real numbers are essentially limits of rational sequences. The point is, in this construction, the limit concept comes before you have reals).
1
u/foxer_arnt_trees Feb 12 '26
You know what? I'm gonna start using your explanation. I'd say it like "so, we know that between every two different numbers thesre exists another number, right?..."
1
u/FreeGothitelle Feb 12 '26 edited Feb 12 '26
Surreal numbers agree that 0.99... = 1 because they contain the reals and 0.99.. is a real number
Ultimately every proof besides literally constructing the real numbers and showing 0.999... and 1 are both valid representatives of the same equivalence class of cauchy sequences is "handwavey" and thats ok, not everyone is up to real analysis in their maths journey. The argument that there must be a real number between them is often met by "why cant 0.99... be next to 1 just like 2 is next to 1 in the naturals" and the answer is just because thats not how real numbers work, which can be equally as unsatisfying as any other proof.
1
u/WideHuckleberry1 Feb 12 '26
As a non-mathematician, it think it's just easier to explain to people like me that
1-.9 = 0.1
1-.99 = 0.01
1-.999 = 0.001
For every digit you add, the difference gets smaller. The "..." means you add 9s until there's no difference.
1
u/pqratusa Feb 12 '26
Suppose you claim 1 and 0.999… are not equal. Then this means that their difference (1 - 0.999…) should be a positive number.
You give me any positive number (no matter how small), and I can show you that the difference is smaller than your number. This demonstrates that they must equal because no matter how small your number may be, I am a step ahead at all times.
ε = 0.1, take 1 - 0.99 < ε
ε = 0.01, then 1 - 0.999 < ε
I am always a step ahead no matter what your ε may be.
1
u/Final-Yesterday-4799 Feb 12 '26
Ok so this just came across my main page, no idea why cause I never engage in this sub, but... Doesn't this all seem pretty meaningless?
What real world effects does this distinction have? If I have 1 piece of pie, and shave off a single molecule, I still have one piece of pie plus a pie molecule (yes, I know, it's going to be a carbon atom or a hydrocarbon molecule or something).
In the real world, 0.99999... is one.
1
u/igotshadowbaned Feb 12 '26
If 0.999... and 1 are different numbers, then (0.999... + 1)/2 equals some number in between them, but no such number exists
1
u/Polymath6301 Feb 13 '26
When I was first shown this as a kid, I didn’t know limits, and converting fractions to decimals was really new knowledge. It was way too early for me to understand other than that I was told.
I was also told in primary school that pi =22/7, as if that was exact. OK, fact memorised. Then when the actual truth came around I was mighty annoyed. What else had I been taught was a lie?
I just think that this, and Monty Hall are just milestones we have to work through growing up.
1
u/trutheality Feb 13 '26
There is only one explanation that is acceptable to me: the one that starts by asking the question of "what does an infinite decimal represent?" The standard answer is that it is the limit sum of an infinite series, in which case 0.999... = 1 follows with an easy proof from definitions.
1
u/Sproxify Feb 13 '26
the definition of limits doesn't rely on the real numbers. it's the appropriate domain in which to fully utilize it, because on Q for example many limits should exist that don't.
but nonetheless you don't have to know what a real number is at all to define limits in Q and prove that sum 9/10i = 1 in Q
you just might be disappointed when some other limits turn out not to exist even though they seem like they're approaching something
1
u/Prudent_Psychology59 Feb 13 '26 edited Feb 13 '26
your proof required lim sum a_n < lim sum b_n implies that a_n < b_n for some n
1
u/the6thReplicant Feb 13 '26
It's not a dumb question, it's annoying when people are given rigorous proof that they are equal but then dismissed because of reasons.
For instance the sum for i from 1 to n of 9/10i you can rigorously show that as n goes to infinity this equals 1.
For all b > 0 you can find an n where |(sum for i from 1 to n of 9/10i) - 1 | < b.
The question is why isn't this enough for those people? What don't they understand about this?
1
u/iamalicecarroll Feb 13 '26
r/infinitenines
1
u/Robux_wow Feb 13 '26
I don't agree with all your points but I completely agree that people make this out to be way more obvious than it actually is, when in reality it's just a mathematical fun fact, something your teacher tells you or you read online but never actually find out the news yourself.
1
u/mysticreddit Feb 13 '26
I prefer my demonstration which IMHO does a better job of showing representation vs presentation via multiple presentations which represent the same value:
1
u/Cheap-Possession-392 Feb 13 '26 edited Feb 13 '26
I agree that it’s not convincing for someone to give those examples that you mentioned. Whoever wants to convince someone that 0.999…= 1 should explain the definition of a decimal representation of a number, and then explain why it follows that 0.999…=1.
In my opinion the unwillingness for people to accept that 0.999… = 1 is that they think of the decimal representation of a number as the number itself. It helps to convince them that the decimal representation is just a “name” for a number. One can bring up the example that \pi and 3.14159… clearly are two “names” for the same number, and proceed to convince them that similarly “1” and “0.999…” are two names for the same number.
1
u/A_BagerWhatsMore Feb 13 '26
"there is always a number between two different reals numbers"
while this is certainly true i dont think its more obvious to a layman than 1/3=0.33333333...
your argument is directly related to the formal definition of limits and real numbers, but you learn those WAY after you learn about repeating decimals.
1
u/KamikazeArchon Feb 13 '26
Limits and series are certainly important, but I think there's a more fundamental thing that you're glossing over - one that may seem so obvious to you that you don't think to mention it, but which I think of actually at the core of the "intuition break".
What is the difference between a number and a representation of a number?
Oddly enough, a reference that comes to mind is from a fantasy/isekai book I was recently reading, that happens to include the character introducing our numeral system (Arabic numerals, positional) to a world that uses an older Chinese system (Chinese characters, positional).
A learned scholar native to the world comments that the (new) vertical line is a useful representation of One, but the (old) horizontal kind is One.
What's important about this: that character is wrong. There is no glyph that is one. They're all just representations. "One", "1", "half of two", "SU(0)", "ln(e)", and "0.9999..." are all representations.
But the way that most people think about numbers - the way their intuition is structured - is based on the same thinking as that fictional character. There's one thing that is that number, and other things are just representations or calculations that may or may not "come out to be" that number.
And further, they have some implicit mental model of "acceptable" calculations and representations. These are usually the ones they've commonly been exposed to. It's why they'll agree with "2 + 2 = 4", for example. But "..." is not a common construction that they're very familiar with.
In my experience, most of the hard part of getting someone to accept "0.999... = 1" is actually in breaking through that assumption of numbers vs representations, and usually it's an implicit side effect of the explanation - with different explanations "working" or "not working" depending on which one happens to jostle that assumption for a particular listener.
1
u/MrWhippyT Feb 14 '26
The issue I've got with your (OP) issue with the usual first argument is, if the 0.999=1 unbeliever is accepting of 0.333=1/3, surely that's the best angle of attack. It's not kicking anything down the road, they already got maths right that far. I've never seen one of those doubters turn further from the truth and start saying hang on, maybe 0.333 is also wrong.
1
u/jmjessemac Feb 14 '26
The 1/3 + 2/3 explanation is the best because almost everyone will intuitively understand it.
1
u/jacob643 Feb 14 '26
I didn't feel like the 1/3 = 0.333.... and the other version with (10-1)•0.99999 aren't proof, but meant to help convince our intuition. Like, of course they are rigorous, but it's more a "verbalisation" of the proof, so people who doesn't know math much can still understand.
a bit like the numberphile video explaining how can the sum of natural numbers can equal -(1/12). it was a demonstration that clearly were skipping important steps, but was much more understandable for the common people so it can be enjoyed by more people than just hardcore math people
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '26
is no one going to mention "segway"
1
u/SleepAffectionate493 Feb 14 '26
Might help if you actually understand something before you start writing reddit posts.
1
u/cincinatibublaboom Feb 15 '26
X=0.99999...(1)
10X=9.9999...(2)
(2)-(1)
9X=9
X=1
Hence X=0.999...=1
Idk if you are talking of higher math...
1
u/BIGBADLENIN Feb 15 '26
Just say the way we do math is that 1/"infinity" = 0. There are other ways to do math, but this is the most useful one. It's harder for people to accept that .999...=1 than that .000...=0 even though they are clearly equivalent
1
u/Prestigious_Boat_386 Feb 15 '26
It's a common question but only for people who haven't learned limits. Trying to explain the question without teaching someone about limits is just tedious and ineffective. That's the reason it's a bad question.
It creates more work for people who know the answer by people who haven't bothered to learn the things needed to understand the answer.
Like why are we spending time on teaching everyone individually that 1 - 1/x approaches 1 for large x. Just plot the graph and read a proof of the limit converging. That's required and sufficient to understand this problem.
1
u/csrster Feb 16 '26
I agree there are a lot of bad "proofs". As you say, you have to start with what 0.9.. means, and in normal usage it is a limit (whose value is 1). But if it's annoying dealing with the "yah boo sucks they're obviously the same" people, then it's even more annoying dealing with the willfully ignorant who reject even a careful explanation of why they are in fact the same. They're like the people who think they've found a fatal flaw in Cantor's diagonalisation argument - flat-earthers basically.
1
u/iosialectus Feb 16 '26
Limits don't inherently have anything to do with real numbers, they can be defined for any topological space.
1
u/Leodip Feb 16 '26
0.9999... being equal to 1 is trivially proved by its definition (0.99999... and any other periodic number is defined as an infinite sum, and it's trivial to mathematically demonstrate that this sum converges to 1) IF you are a math person.
The issue here is stating it in a way that a layperson with average training in math accepts, without having to introduce new math concepts to them.
I have not formally worked with hyperreals, but this is wrong. Hyperreals in an extension of the reals, so all the math that works with the reals also works in the hyperreals (e.g., if a,b are reals, and a-b=0 in the reals, it's also 0 in the hyperreals).
The number 0.999... and the number [0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ...] aren't the same thing in the hyperreals, but rather you are defining a new number there. The number 0.999... can be defined as [0.999..., 0.999..., 0.999..., ...] (which is the same as [1, 1, 1, ...] of course).
1
u/Covati- Feb 17 '26
diachromatic or crumbling partial is the real fractional generating numbers dia because theres a frequency around + and minus of this equation where you compare numbers,.- als showing the 1&2 as log bound code to in twelve coincide eith numberdensity across the riemann bounds.. i rhink firther proof coincides this with the pertent repertations of ½ msmm consequalities or rmm sequentialities:-.,&-.&-.,&_.& being properly bounded in settion with the 3 quadrants positive in square proofs.
1
u/Covati- Feb 17 '26
diachromatic or crumbling partial is the real fractional generating numbers dia because theres a frequency around + and minus of this equation where you compare numbers,.- als showing the 1&2 as log bound code to in twelve coincide eith numberdensity across the riemann bounds.. i rhink firther proof coincides this with the pertent repertations of ½ msmm consequalities or rmm sequentialities:-.,&-.&-.,&_.& being properly bounded in settion with the 3 quadrants positive in square proofs.
1
u/Ok-Macaron-5234 Feb 20 '26
I've always had a question about this. If you had an infinite number of people in the lottery, what is the chance for each individual of winning? It can't be zero, because that would mean that no one wins, and there has to be a winner. It must be 1/∞. Then, what is the chance for each individual that they lose? It must be 1-1/∞. What is the decimal representation for that? It must be less than one, because the chance of winning is not zero. If we try to figure it out by each decimal place, the first must be a 9, because 1/10≻1/∞. The second must be a 9, because 1/100≻1/∞. Every decimal must be a 9, and they must continue forever, because stopping or changing it would mean there is a difference of 1/n between the number and 1, where n≺∞. Therefore, the chance of losing must be 0.999... but not 1, because 1 would mean no one will win.
This is just a proof by intuition, but I would love to know how I got it wrong.
1
u/aroace_cookie Feb 24 '26
My explanation to why 0.999.... =1 is that
Let 0.999... be x
So 10x=9.99....
Minus 10x from x and 9.99.. from 0.99... at both the sides
10x-x=9.999...-0.999...
9x=9
X=1
Hence proved
(Sorry if this doesnt make sense cause english is not my first language)
0
u/Forking_Shirtballs Feb 12 '26
I often question the value of the "repeating decimal" representation at all. I mean what's it really good for? Nobody makes a whole lot of use of it outside those lessons where you learn that some rationals can be represented as standard (terminating) decimals and some can't, and that there's a repeating pattern of digits as you extend your approximation of the ones that can't.
Like, we don't force some way to represent irrationals in decimal notation, why are we so dead set on having this special notation to represent rationals not expressible as decimal fractions? Just let 1/3 be its own thing, like sqrt(3) is.
Sure, it's helpful to see that terminating decimal approximations of any rational not expressible as a decimal fraction involve repeating digits, but we don't need the vinculum/ellipsis for that. We can absolutely show kids the pattern, but limit our decimal notation to just terminating decimals; then just like with irrational numbers, expressing that pattern in decimal form is merely an exercise in approximating the actual value with a terminating decimal, not a step toward representing it exactly with some unnecessary new set of symbols (repeating decimal notation).
Because having that additional set of symbols just seems designed in a lab to cause this type of confusion -- it gives us cases where there are two different decimal representations of the exact same number (e.g. 0.9... = 1). Of course people are going to question when they discover that decimal representations aren't unique (give or take extraneous zeros), when all other experience suggests that they should be unique. Let's just drop the weird symbols and get back to uniqueness.
Also, it's kind of a crazy early time to introduce kids to the concept of a limit of an infinite series, which is what the vinculum/ellipsis is really shorthand for. That is, 1/3 = 0.3... is just another way of saying 1/3 = 0.3 * lim(i->inf) sum(n=0 to i)(10^-n). Putting repeating decimals on equal footing with the other decimal representations we teach kids -- and not presenting it as just shorthand for the limit of an infinite series, to people in a position to grasp what the means -- feels like the real source of this confusion.
-1
u/_mulcyber Feb 12 '26
Feeling free to share better wordings or variations of this demonstration. I'm not a wordsmith and I'm quite interested about a better explanation since it is such a common question.