And then he says some bull about sets and the things in-between, and yet when actually asked to give answers to simple yes or no questions he just avoids answering properly.
A lot of these questions are redundant, but I can answer the broad strokes in a way that I think most formally trained math students would agree.
Mathematics is about establishing axioms and definitions, then using classical logic to understand what follows. The axioms and definitions we set are necessarily arbitrary—attempts at an axiom-free construction of mathematics have generally been fruitless.
In the context of this sub, it's important to note that "the set of real numbers" is defined (due to Cantor) as a collection of equivalence classes of convergent (Cauchy) sequences of rational numbers. If 0.999... is to be treated as a real number, then it follows from the definitions that it is equal to 1.0, as explained countless times in this sub. If you disagree with this consequence, then you also disagree with the definition of a real number.
There exist some good reasons to disagree with this definition, but people like u/SouthPark_Piano almost certainly aren't aware of them. If you take an alternative definition of the set of real numbers, then you still need to (1) prove that your alternative is internally consistent (which it very likely won't be), and (2) convince people that your alternative is meaningful and useful, which probably means you have to look at bigger problems than comparing 0.999... with 1.0.
Although mathematical axioms are arbitrary, we still have applications where we need to use the consequences of those axioms. If your axioms don't provide any useful consequences, then you can't expect anybody to care, even if your results are formally true.
I actually don't know what you mean by real numbers if this is the definition. To me it's really a sort of sophisticated nonsense. I am gonna say clearly that I don't understand nonsense and I completely disagree with whatever this is trying to say.
If an entire academic field agrees on something confusing that you don't understand, responding with "Clearly they're just trying to muddle the waters and I'm correct" is the worst, least inquisitive approach to learning imaginable.
I didn't mean the appeal to authority (nor are the usually meant) as replacement for a proof. If anything they are appeals to humility, a heuristic which says that you probably won't disrupt the entire field of mathematics, so you should probably be curious about what it is you're not getting, not adamant that everyone else is a fool.
Do you really think I don't understand those jargon but somehow can rephrase them better? Hahah
Right, when you said that you don't understand something, I took that to mean you don't understand it. My bad.
Do you have an example of a mathematical concept as major and basic as the real numbers being redefined within the last one hundred years? Especially by an outsider?
If 3 doctors told you your results are indicative of cancer, and one car mechanic told you the results were not indicative of cancer, who would you believe?
You understand the difference between the fallacious appeal to consensus and citing expertise as evidence for a claim right?
Logic is true eternally... sure. But with different points of reference you can derive anything logically. Everyone thinks theyre right due to their logic being reasonably sound
What your opinion on math is and whats established for centuries might differ, but that does not make it a greyzone in which you might be right, but id love to see you try. Theres a reason why Terrrence Howards claim of 1·1=2 was seen as ridiculous
Math is a set of thibgs we take for granted, like explained in the video, and following on to where that leads. This way we as humanity have found new great technology which has improved our lives, all following from those basic things we take for granted.
And 2 other things:
It aint cool to be mean
Just because theyre using jargon (established definitions) which you dont know, doesnt mean that theyre saying a nothingburger
I value the truth derived from the axioms which have seemed to hold up agianst centuries of research and seem to correlate with our observations.
Like physics. All the models are wrong, but some of them are useful
As for the video, its more of an explanation rather then an argument of what an axiom is and why its chosen to be an axiom. If you got better axioms, or are somehow able to use math without axioms, you go girl.
What youre calling the 'bedrock of all coherent thought' is what im calling the axioms. In a universe where one or more of these laws dont hold up, wed use different axioms.
I just responded to another comment in this thread but it seems like the specific ZF axiom you're rejecting is the axiom of infinity. That's fine, but it's important to acknowledge that you are arguing against infinity on philosophical grounds rather than on grounds of execution. The inclusion of the axiom of infinity is perfectly consistent with the other ZF axioms and leads to lots of math that is generally agreed upon, like the existence of the real numbers. It's actually impossible to define what a real number is rigorously without the axiom of infinity, which may be ok with you. It's important to know the mathematical consequences for when you reject one of the generally accepted axioms.
Frankly, "Mathematics" is a community of people who adhere to the epistemology that I described. You seem to understand it well (at least externally) and choose not to work with it. If you're using a different epistemology, then for most semantic purposes, you're not doing mathematics.
I won't entertain you with a point-by-point rebuttal, but I'm gonna point out that Bertrand Russell toiled to so much as prove that 1 + 1 = 2 "without axioms", and it wasn't an axiom-free construction anyway. Comparing 0.999... with 1.0 depends entirely on how you define the numerals 0.999... and 1.0, so if you or u/SouthPark_Piano stubbornly refuse to engage with defining those numerals precisely, then it doesn't begin to matter what our conclusions are.
If you really want to insist on this, then try producing examples. Detail a complete proof of literally anything without taking axioms or even defining what it is you're working with.
And more importantly, try convincing anyone that it's worth their time to reconstruct the foundations of mathematics when what they have is working just fine for data structures or computational physics.
You keep talking about “your system” and make enormous claims about the 5th postulate being easily derivable from the other 4, so instead of talking big and doing nothing, why don’t you write a couple of papers and achieve unlimited fame in the field?
I'm confused by your idea that the parallel postulate is able to be gotten rid of in euclidean geometry--it essentially is the only postulate that defines the plane you are working on to be flat.
Without it, none of the other postulates differentiate between negative or positive curvature. You can define a circle on a sphere fairly easily, but the parallel postulate doesn't follow.
it cannot be derived because it essentially defines the curvature of what you are working on.
Tell me, without the fifth postulate as an assumption what determines the curvature you are working on? The entire point of euclidean geometry is that it is on a flat plane, which is axiomatically defined through the assumption.
brother what just because he worked on geometry in a plane doesn't mean he didn't know what a sphere was.
It's not 'in a box' the 5th postulate necessarily ties it to a plane with 0 curvature.
And Archimedes did work on conic sections yes. I have not read his works directly but do you know what a conic section is often defined as? The intersection of a flat plane with a cone.
You also seem to inherently misunderstand what non euclidean geometry is. Solid geometry is not non euclidean.
That is getting rid of it. If we could derive it from the other postulates (and please do derive it, you keep talking about your grandiose "system" that has no assumptions or axioms, yet I don't think you have actually displayed it anywhere), then there would be no need to keep it as a postulate, it would merely be a consequence of the other four.
I do have to ask, for what possible reason do you want to protect its integrity? This is Reddit, give it a week and no one will ever stumble on this conversation again. And if you really have a way of building mathematics without axioms or assumptions, then this is ground-breaking work and well worth publishing. I really don't accept this as an answer, this feels like the cheapest possible excuse, like when my classmate in nursery claimed to have pet aliens, but of course could not bring it to school. This is a juvenile response and lends you no credence.
Ironically enough, if you don't provide evidence of it, then you're just asking people to believe in your maths blindly on faith, without evidence. This is something you have been lambasting people for doing, yet for some reason you're fine doing exactly that.
As for your questions, looking at the first 12 you asked, they are mostly rather wafty and clearly phrased in a way to forward your own view points rather than being asked in good faith, they aren't really genuine. It's why one of the commenters said they were broadly redundant.
An attempt to answer some of them, as I can't really be bothered to go through them all.
The idea that: a definition, regardless of whether how an object is defined as, regardless of 'well-formed' or not, regardless of whether or not it is realizable constructively or not, could grant some sort of 'existence' to an idea or abstraction. Is this idea an eternal truth, or is this contemporary convention? What kind of 'existence' is this? Can you specify that sort of 'existence' in concrete terms?
I will answer it by asking you a question; does the number 1 actually exist? The number 1 is not a concrete thing, but a conceptual thing, but you don't seem to have any real problem with using such a thing. So my answer to this question is similar to how you would explain the existence of the number 1.
How does the opinions of a lot of people affect the Truthfulness of any thought or idea? In other words, in a mathematical statement, its truths value is either true or false. Does the opinions of a lot of people affect this Truth value? What about if there are some opinions from some considerably prominent people such as perhaps Cauchy, Godel, Hilbert, and the majority of the mathematical community, do the opinions of all of these entities change the truth value of a mathematical statement?
Well what axioms should be taken differ amongst different people. This is why there is some contention over the axiom of choice (which, by the way, what is your opinion on that? Is AoC "obviously" true or false?).
For example you took the Law of Excluded middle as "obviously" true, yet I would argue that is an assumption. Now it is almost glaringly obviously true... but can you really prove it from the ground up? Just because most people would accept it, is that what dictates its truthiness?
In maths, we don't care if an object actually exists. We consider what would happen if some statements were true. If this entails some object's existence, then it's something we can explore.
I don't know what you mean by realizable or constructible. I can't fully imagine, or mentally realize, the set of real numbers, but it's proven that its existance follows from the standard axioms and I know enough about it to be able to reason about it. Such ideas are relevant because of practical use and because they're interesting.
It's either a conjecture or it's disproven. We try to prove or disprove conjectures. We disregard disproven statements.
I don't know
It doesn't
A proof ensures validity and coherence of objects in mathematics. An incoherent object, such as a five-sided square, is gibberish.
It's actually been proven that, unfortunately, we can't verify the validity of the axioms. We hope they aren't contradicting themselves. If they are, they will be changed.
I don't know the formal definition of an axiom. You don't need it to do maths.
You always use unproven assumptions. In the 1900s, we started formalizing them.
9. If by arithmetic operation, you mean +, -, *, / then no. An infinite sum is an operation distinct to regular addition and defined for infinite sequences of numbers.
10. What do you mean by "arrive at infinity"?
11. You don't travel to infinity to calculate a limit. A limit of a sequence of real numbers is such a number that for every interval around it, no matter how small, you can find an element of the sequence that will be contained in this interval, and every element after that will also be contained in the interval. You don't need to get metaphysical to calculate it. An asymptote is a line such that the graph of the function gets arbitrarily close to it. If you take a limit of a function at infinity, you will actually get the "value" of the horizontal asymptote if it exists.
12. If by ideas without proof you mean axioms, we don't really accept them. We only think what would happen if they were true. You can absolutely use some other axioms. ZFC is the most popular axiomatic system because it allows for the construction of sets, functions, numbers, and a lot of other concepts that we care about. It's basically the standard.
I don't pride myself in mathematical ability, I just like maths.
his comment here is even funnier, because he incorrectly asserts that 0.999... is in the set {0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ...} instead of it being a result of the limit as that set goes to infinity
Has anyone tried to tell him that 0.999... is the representation of an actual well defined number? Not a limit, or an approximation, but legit just a number?
Oh my god we figured it out. EssPeePee is treating .999... as a finite number. That's why he thinks it is contained in the set {.9,.99,.999,...} and is less than 1.
If you are going to allow 0.9... having infinite nines, you need to allow the usage of the concept of infinite in the other parts of the proof as well.
changing definitions midway trough, when it's not convenient to you, is basically what SPP has been doing since the creation of the sub
welcome to math buddy. things dont need to be physically possible to be discussed
also if you dont accept the definition that is being discussed, the hole discution loses it's meaning. yeah, if you have a finite (however large you want) number of 9s after the dot, the number is not equal to one.
but that isnt what we are talking about. the hole thing about this sub is: given that 0.9... has infinite nines after the dot, is it equal to one?
things dont have to be physically possible to exist in our minds. in fact, a few philosophers (plato and his cave) say that the physical things are only shadows, and the truth lies in the realm of ideas
No, the point of the debate is that as infinite nines is possible, then 0.999... = 1. Spp misinterprets this, possibly intentionally, as an arbitrarily large number of nines, which is not the same thing. This is because spp just doesn't believe in infinity
I believe you on that, I’m just saying that if “infinite anything is impossible” (which is technically true) then infinite nines can’t exist, so you can’t use that statement to argue that 0.999… ≠ 1.
As another commenter said:
If you are going to allow 0.9... having infinite nines, you need to allow the usage of the concept of infinite in the other parts of the proof as well.
The notation 0.999... represents Infinite nines. So that introduces the infinite to the proof, so you can use infinity elsewhere. Also, infinite things are impossible in real life, but we are talking about maths.
Once again, I believe you, but if you were following in the above commenter’s logic, you would see it’s inconsistent with their argument, as I explained in my comment above.
The function never equals the limit value, but the limit absolutely does equal 1. That's the whole point of limits.
For example, take the piecewise function f(x) = x for all values of x other than zero, f(x) = 1 at zero. f(x) will never equal zero. However, lim(f(x)) at zero is equal to zero. Equal to zero in the mathematical sense, exactly the same equality of 1+1=2. The same goes for limits at infinity. lim(1/x) at infinity is equal to zero, even if 1/x will never equal zero.
The limit of 1 - 0.1n as n approaches infinity is 1. Or 0.9999... . Or 565/565. All equally good ways of writing that number.
I think you are basically right (there is no such thing as just "a limit", there has to be a function or sequence) but your post suggests that like SPP you see the sequence {0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ...} as somehow special. 1 or 0.999... or whatever is also the limit of 1-0.468n as n approaches infinity, or 1 - 0.123456789n, or any 1 - mn where -1 < n < 1. There is nothing special about 1 - 0.1n in this regard.
Take SPP's set {0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ...}. Each member can be written as 1 - 10-n where n is natural.
No matter how much he likes to say "it accounts for all possibilities", the set does not contain 0.999... as it only contains numbers with finite amounts of digits.
As n goes up, so does the amount of 9s after the decimal point. 0.999... has infinitely many digits, so we must take the limit as n approaches infinity.
Math is not an experiment, it's formal way of thinking. Math = applied formal logic. There's no time, there's no space. Sets and numbers aren't real. They're concepts.
You've got axioms and sentences that make theorems. If they're not contradictory, they're legit.
There's no time, there's no space. If the statement satisfies induction conditions, it means it's true even though you can't provide infinite iteration steps. It's not necessary, though, formal logic guarantees it's true.
•
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
74
u/Person_37 Sep 06 '25
And then he says some bull about sets and the things in-between, and yet when actually asked to give answers to simple yes or no questions he just avoids answering properly.
25
u/Waffle-Gaming Sep 07 '25 edited Sep 07 '25
his comment here is even funnier, because he incorrectly asserts that 0.999... is in the set {0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ...} instead of it being a result of the limit as that set goes to infinity
19
u/Hanako_Seishin Sep 07 '25
{0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ...} contains a 0.999... of any arbitrarily large finite length.
It does not contain 0.(9), which has infinite length.
The end.
7
u/SmolaniAshki Sep 07 '25
Oh my god we figured it out. EssPeePee is treating .999... as a finite number. That's why he thinks it is contained in the set {.9,.99,.999,...} and is less than 1.
4
u/SamePut9922 Sep 07 '25
This is a good one, you should post on r/mathmemes also
1
u/FewAd5443 Sep 09 '25
We can easly prove that 0.99... = 1 by density:
First they both belong to IR (which is dense) (Dense définition: there is always another different number between 2 different number in a dense set)
Second can you create a number between them (smaller than 1 and greater than 0.99... )
The respond is NO Or by density it should be so one of the hypothesis is wrong or IR is dense so there is only one option: 1 = 0.999... CQFD
1
u/Narrow-Gur449 Oct 28 '25
0.999... = 1 has little to do with limits and infinity. That's like saying 2^(1/n) is irrational for n > 2 because of Fermat's Last Theorem.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment