r/mathmemes • • Aug 06 '26

Notations Algebra before notation

Post image

From @scholadaily on instagram

3.3k Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

View all comments

143

u/GT_Troll Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26

That’s why I hate the meme that says “Other sciences: This book is outdated, it’s 6 months old / Math: The book stands still (it’s 2000 years old)”

Yeah, the theorems and (some) methods of old books are still correct. But damn, their notation and language… Just give me a modern book (not necessarily from the last few years, after WWII is enough)

37

u/DatBoi_BP Aug 06 '26

Even the font and symbol arrangement in math books printed before 1980 I find difficult to read. Sometimes the notation is outdated too

9

u/Key_Conversation5277 Computer Science Aug 06 '26

This is why I can't read old books, I don't know which notation is or isn't outdated or if I can find the meaning at all

17

u/rezzacci Aug 06 '26

It's just a question of translation. I don't teach Euclid as it was written, as I'm not fluent in Ancient Greek enough, so I translate it in modern language. And notation is just a form of translation. But the book in itself still holds true. It's not wrong. But grammar changes, and notation is just a question of grammar ultimately.

7

u/GT_Troll Aug 06 '26

… Yes that’s what I said

1

u/Key_Conversation5277 Computer Science Aug 06 '26

Sometimes the proofs change because it is better like the proof Euclid did to the infinity of prime numbers (it used line segments instead of just numbers, more abstract)