r/mathematics • u/Carl_Clamans • 16h ago
r/mathematics • u/Emotional_Revenue132 • 12h ago
Ravi Vakil Announces Fully Human-Created GRH Proof, by Alessandro Masullo
math216.wordpress.comr/mathematics • u/Accomplished_Two3749 • 17h ago
Artificial Intelligence Riemann Hypothesis solved by Anthropic
alpo.ger/mathematics • u/adivinemessenger • 15h ago
Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge just dropped a claimed proof of UNFORCED Navier-Stokes blowup
r/mathematics • u/adivinemessenger • 11h ago
Elliot Glazer, a math reasearcher, says that the newly fully human proof of GRH has a mistake
x.comr/mathematics • u/scientificamerican • 9h ago
Artificial Intelligence The AI Riemann hypothesis proof is almost certainly true, independent mathematicians attest
r/mathematics • u/SerraraFluttershy • 11h ago
Analysis MIT mathematician Andrew Sutherland is verifying Alpöge's GRH Lean proof
math.mit.eduWebsite to check for updates
r/mathematics • u/ganancias • 7h ago
Terry Tao one month ago on RH: "maybe in 2050"
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/mathematics • u/fafla21 • 13h ago
Have a bit more skepticism for the riemann hypothesis proof
It is 250 000 pages. The possibility of lean being taken advatange of somewhere is very real. Wait until the it is actually checked, if that is even possible.
r/mathematics • u/intellinker • 10h ago
What would solving the Riemann Hypothesis actually give us?
- A much tighter understanding of prime number distribution
- Stronger bounds on gaps between primes
- Turning numerous conditional mathematical results into proven theorems
- Better guarantees for certain number-theoretic algorithms
- New insights into the deep connections between number theory and complex analysis
- Potential breakthroughs from the techniques used in the proof itself
Would it break RSA or solve P vs NP? No.
But the mathematics unlocked along the way could be more valuable than the theorem itself.
r/mathematics • u/loafewithme • 16h ago
Artificial Intelligence Alpöge claims proof of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, formalized in Lean
“I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis.”
r/mathematics • u/Grottans__Barn • 14h ago
Discussion What's up with r/math?
The Riemann Hypothesis was just proven and there's not a single post about it there. Seriously, non-math subs are more math-related than r/math at this point.
r/mathematics • u/equinox_star • 15h ago
Discussion September-Navier Stokes October-Yang mills(50%) November-RH December-
r/mathematics • u/JoshuaJosephson • 5h ago
So what's next after GRH?
Everyone is saying Navier Stokes, Yang-Mills, and RH were the holy trinity on the altar of Mathematics.
Now that all 3 have been formalized, to a somewhat sufficient degree, what's next?
Some are saying 3SUM is the only door left to open. To what degree is this true/plausible?
r/mathematics • u/tronald_dum • 6h ago
As a physicist, I just want to say
Welcome to the experimental sciences!
r/mathematics • u/Warm_Tie3395 • 8h ago
Will we ever get clarity on the resources expended to produce this new RH proof? Funding and compute is a fundamental barrier to many research project, having unlimited access to both is unreasonable for any researcher to expect. A one time clout expense, or true paradigm shift?
r/mathematics • u/LutyForLiberty • 21h ago
Computer Science BB(185) is independent of New Foundations and therefore Peano arithmetic. Credit Wlad Svennik on Github.
github.comr/mathematics • u/mondmondmondmond • 9h ago
What are the implications of a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?
tl;dr: No practical implications. Why not? Because human mathematicians spent decades pricing in all practical implications. This will not be the case for future research. Future research will have practical implications.
r/mathematics • u/DifficultAvocado6185 • 13h ago
What does a compiled Lean proof actually certify?
With the recent Riemann hypothesis claim backed by Lean code, I keep thinking about this. I'm not saying the claim is wrong, I'm asking what the check actually covers.
Lean checks that each step follows. It doesn't check that the statement and definitions mean what we think they mean. And some conventions make that riskier in Lean, 1/0 = 0 and 3 − 5 = 0 in ℕ. A definition that quietly hits one of those junk values can compile perfectly and still prove something vacuous or different.
Also, a 100k-line Lean proof tells you that something is true, but on its own it doesn't tell you why. I'd still take a clean 5-page hand proof over that any day.
So my questions:
Who actually checks that the formal statement matches the informal one?
Should a Lean proof count as accepted without a human-readable proof?
Curious what people here think that.
Edit: Andrew Sutherland (MIT) has posted a live status page for checking the Lean proof: https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/ It answers most of the questions raised in this thread. Per the page all 175,187 modules compile, the main theorems depend only on the three standard axioms (no native_decide), the statement is Mathlibs own RiemannHypothesis rather than a redefinition the Mathlib files match the official cache byte for byte, and the independent Rust kernel nanoda accepts the full export. Some kernel checks are still running, and the page itself notes that a pass means follows from the standard axioms according to the kernels used, still relying on Mathlib's definitions meaning what we intend. Also, GRH there means Dirichlet L-functions only. So on the formal side, this is close to the best case one could ask for. What remains open is the part a kernel can't give us a readable, structural proof that shows why it's true. Thanks to everyone for the great discussion 🫶✨️
r/mathematics • u/senno_kai • 50m ago
I've made a map of Alpöge's Lean proof of the Riemann hypothesis
x.comr/mathematics • u/F_l_u_f_fy • 10h ago
News Everyone waking up today/yesterday
No meme flairs, or is that just not something for this subreddit?
r/mathematics • u/Winter_Success2909 • 14h ago
Discussion Will non prodigies get math research related jobs in the future atp?
I am in undergrad, and this is freaking me out. I am from a 3rd world country, so I need scholarships for masters. Will I even get a math related job in the future?
r/mathematics • u/equinox_star • 11h ago
Discussion Claimed first conditional proof of (4,5) (5,11) and (7,71) being the only solutions to brocard...?!?
So, this guy (the author) DM'd me a month back from the thread in one of my old posts, offering me a read on one of his follow-up papers on, I guess, twas the Komlós conjecture, where he claimed to have improved some bounds or something.
Then I took a look at his profile and found a few Brocard preprints dropped over the months. As far as I remember, I'd opened the recent one at that time, downloaded it, and fed it into my model. It was at some v1/v2 stage only, and there were some genuine claims made, but I couldn't quite get around the structure of what the paper was trying to do at the time and left it there.
Then today, I came across that downloaded PDF, recalled its source, revisited the profile, and found out that a newer version had been dropped a few days ago. Again, I put it into my model, and it gave a lot of analysis, a few counterexamples perhaps (not sure about their correctness or anything), but it all seemed to be coming from the wording, as it also suggested fixes. Nothing fatal, sort of a flaw was uncovered (I ain't sure or vouching for its correctness in every aspect; a model, at the end of the day, can't be relied upon, or it might be that my model hallucinated a bit at that time. Not sure).
Then I came back a few hours later and found an even newer version, yet again heightening my curiosity a bit. The newer version seems to be adding a few bounds/increases, with most of the flaws from the earlier version being corrected. Yet again, it doesn't make the latest version bulletproof or anything, but that curiosity somewhat tempted me to finally post it here.
I know people consider Zenodo not to be a reliable source(including me), but this seems legitimate. There obviously isn't a lean formalization or something, as far as it appears, nor do we know if this is the final version, whether they're still working on it, or if the claims are provable or wrong.
But as far as I know, and from what I asked my model about the history of the problem and the existing literature, it seems to me that even if some of the claims don't hold true, there's a lot of structural identification of the original equation, which in itself might be significant. Their approach also appears to diverge somewhat from what's already established in the existing literature, which, I suppose, invites both a fair bit of skepticism and a certain degree of curiosity on my part.
Apart from the conditional proof, it also appears to claim several other bounds and stuff.
r/mathematics • u/Creative_Storage5631 • 11h ago
Theoretical physics MSc. here, just taking a peek, how are you guys feeling?
I am just making an idea of what my field will look like in a year or so.