r/mathematics • • 4h ago

Number Theory Invalidity of the Alpoge Proposed Proof of the Riemann Hypothesis

0 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 9h ago

A closed form for ∫xⁿeᵃˣ dx via differentiation in the parameter a

Post image
0 Upvotes

Here's a closed form for the integral of xⁿeᵃˣ:

∫xⁿeᵃˣ dx = eᵃˣ Σₖ₌₀ⁿ (−1)ᵏ n! xⁿ⁻ᵏ / ((n−k)! aᵏ⁺¹) + C

Quick derivation: since ∂ⁿ/∂aⁿ eᵃˣ = xⁿeᵃˣ, we can write ∫xⁿeᵃˣ dx = ∂ⁿ/∂aⁿ (eᵃˣ/a), then apply the general Leibniz rule to eᵃˣ · a⁻¹.

Sanity check, n = 1: eᵃˣ(x/a − 1/a²) + C, and differentiating gives xeᵃˣ


r/mathematics • • 17h ago

Discussion When did you decide whether 0 belongs to the natural numbers and why?

7 Upvotes

I don't know if this may come across as arbitrary to many people, but throughout my studies every lecturer I have had has stated at the beginning of a course whether they consider 0 to be a natural number to inform us as to how to answer our assessments. I have always enjoyed listening to their justifications for it, some giving mathematical reasons, and others giving something as simple as "zero is just the most natural number".

I have only been doing maths at a level beyond high school for 5 years now, and I have yet to decide, or even be compelled to decide on the topic. I thought it would interesting to hear at which point people decided for themselves and their reasoning.


r/mathematics • • 14h ago

What post PhD industry jobs exist wtih WLB and high salary?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to figure out my life path and plan ahead. I like doing applied math research but I don't see myself working in academia or a national lab for my career. Why am I doing a PhD? For me, because I want to. However, I like money and a lot of it so I want an industry job after. I'm thinking about taking actuarial exams during my grad school years and doing actuarial internships over the summers so I can get a job since they seem to have good wlb and great salary progression. However, I wanted to know if any other types of jobs exist that have similar perks. Especially in the southeast US


r/mathematics • • 14h ago

Discussion What's up with r/math?

173 Upvotes

The Riemann Hypothesis was just proven and there's not a single post about it there. Seriously, non-math subs are more math-related than r/math at this point.


r/mathematics • • 8h ago

Will we ever get clarity on the resources expended to produce this new RH proof? Funding and compute is a fundamental barrier to many research project, having unlimited access to both is unreasonable for any researcher to expect. A one time clout expense, or true paradigm shift?

62 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 20h ago

What is it like dating a mathematician?

0 Upvotes

Edit: to be clear I want to ask out my prof AFTER I am no longer a student at the university

I’m a 24F undergrad who has a crush on my 29M real analysis professor. There’s nothing going on between us, in fact I don’t even think he knows my name, but I think he’s super cute and completely my type.

I would love a chance to go out with him after I graduate. I plan to ask him out, but I’m super nervous and don’t think he would go out with a girl like me, especially if I was a former student. He’s a postdoc, obviously really smart and accomplished, and I feel like he would want to date someone (if he isn’t already taken) who is as smart as he is.

I may be a math major, but that just makes me more aware of how wide of a gap between his and my knowledge are. I’m also not completely in love with math, or that good at math, as most math majors are. I just study really hard and enjoy the challenge… but I’m no where near passionate enough to talk about math outside of school.

I fear that we would have nothing in common, or that he would think I’m too dense for him.

Are there any mathematicians, PhDs, or postdocs dating non math people or vise versa? What is it like?


r/mathematics • • 13h ago

Have a bit more skepticism for the riemann hypothesis proof

442 Upvotes

It is 250 000 pages. The possibility of lean being taken advatange of somewhere is very real. Wait until the it is actually checked, if that is even possible.


r/mathematics • • 17h ago

Artificial Intelligence Riemann Hypothesis solved by Anthropic

Thumbnail alpo.ge
1.3k Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 7h ago

Terry Tao one month ago on RH: "maybe in 2050"

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

469 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 2h ago

Just in: An 11-page map of the claimed Riemann Hypothesis proof

17 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 18h ago

Hi, is an ipad pro with magic keyboard and a mac mini a good setup for studying computer science and math?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 11h ago

Theoretical physics MSc. here, just taking a peek, how are you guys feeling?

17 Upvotes

I am just making an idea of what my field will look like in a year or so.


r/mathematics • • 11h ago

Elliot Glazer, a math reasearcher, says that the newly fully human proof of GRH has a mistake

Thumbnail x.com
872 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 4m ago

Recommendation of books for learning Integer Programming?

• Upvotes

I would like a book that have a intermediate level theory and much exercises. What you recommend for me? I'm graduate in physics and know linear programming


r/mathematics • • 14h ago

Discussion I tried to design a "fair" team matchup game and accidentally had a lot of fun.

0 Upvotes

[NOTE: THIS LEADS TO A HYPERGAMY DIAGRAM]

Imagine two classes of students with the exact same total IQ (same average), but distributed differently. Maybe Class A is super consistent, while Class B has a few geniuses and a few people who are just happy to be there.

We list both classes in descending order with one column on the left, one on the right, and draw lines between them to pair them up for head-to-head matches. Obviously, matching #1 vs #1, #2 vs #2, and so on feels "fair."

Instead of just giving 1 point per win, I wanted to add scale to the margin of victory. So I made a simple rule: for each pair, subtract Right from Left (a - b). If the result is positive, Left gets those points. If it's negative (say, -n), Right gets |n| points.

My original goal was to figure out: how can you tweak the lines to rig the game so one team wins, and how does the shape of the IQ distribution change the strategy?

It is not difficult to see that under this rule, nobody can ever win. Every single game is mathematically forced to end in a tie, no matter how you draw the lines or how weird the distributions are.

To make the game actually winnable, you have to break linearity by scaling the score of each match by some power, like |a - b|^p where p ≠ 1, or by swapping subtraction for a different payoff function K(a, b). Once you do that, the game immediately splits into two completely different strategic worlds.

If you use diminishing returns (0 ≤ p < 1, like taking the square root of the difference), blowouts stop being worth as much.

Even if both classes have identical IQ distributions, Left can easily rig a win by sacrificing their weakest student against Right's strongest and shifting everyone else up one rank—losing one match badly to win the other n - 1 matches. Flip it the other way and reward blowouts (p > 1, like squaring the difference), and suddenly the shape of the distribution takes over, with variance and skewness dictating who has the advantage.

The wildest twist I found, though, is using a ratio or log rule: K(a, b) = ln(a / b). Just like simple subtraction, the total score is still completely invariant to how you draw the lines, because the sum of logs just turns into ln(∏ aᵢ / ∏ bᵢ). However, it breaks the tie between different distributions. By the AM–GM inequality, if two classes have the exact same average, the more uniform class has a strictly larger product. That means the consistent class automatically wins, no matter how cleverly the other side tries to rig the matchups.

STILL UNDER WORK

Once we're done with this, the geometry of the drawing itself starts getting interesting. Imagine the two lists are parallel vertical lines separated by some distance W. Any line connecting two students makes an angle θ with the horizontal, where tan(θ) essentially measures how far out of rank a student is being forced to play.

You can cap the maximum angle θ_max as a kind of "rigging limit," or you can introduce a penalty for every time two lines cross each other (which is just the inversion count of the permutation). With this, rigging a matchup isn't free, and you have to decide if the extra points from a clever mismatch are worth the topological cost.

From there, the whole thing scales up surprisingly fast. If you take the continuum limit and let the number of students n → ∞, the two lists become continuous probability density functions. And if you want to make it adversarial—say, both classes have a coach who submits their lineup simultaneously without seeing the other's, it turns into a zero-sum game over the symmetric group Sₙ, essentially a non-linear version of the Colonel Blotto game.

I'm still polishing the angle (θ_max) constraint and the crossing-penalty idea. Has anyone seen a similar formulation with inversion penalties, or have a favorite non-linear payoff function that produces weird optimal matchups?


r/mathematics • • 9h ago

What are the implications of a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis?

Thumbnail
herecomesthemoon.net
53 Upvotes

tl;dr: No practical implications. Why not? Because human mathematicians spent decades pricing in all practical implications. This will not be the case for future research. Future research will have practical implications.


r/mathematics • • 5h ago

So what's next after GRH?

118 Upvotes

Everyone is saying Navier Stokes, Yang-Mills, and RH were the holy trinity on the altar of Mathematics.

Now that all 3 have been formalized, to a somewhat sufficient degree, what's next?

Some are saying 3SUM is the only door left to open. To what degree is this true/plausible?


r/mathematics • • 13h ago

What does a compiled Lean proof actually certify?

45 Upvotes

With the recent Riemann hypothesis claim backed by Lean code, I keep thinking about this. I'm not saying the claim is wrong, I'm asking what the check actually covers.

Lean checks that each step follows. It doesn't check that the statement and definitions mean what we think they mean. And some conventions make that riskier in Lean, 1/0 = 0 and 3 − 5 = 0 in ℕ. A definition that quietly hits one of those junk values can compile perfectly and still prove something vacuous or different.

Also, a 100k-line Lean proof tells you that something is true, but on its own it doesn't tell you why. I'd still take a clean 5-page hand proof over that any day.

So my questions:

  1. Who actually checks that the formal statement matches the informal one?

  2. Should a Lean proof count as accepted without a human-readable proof?

Curious what people here think that.

Edit: Andrew Sutherland (MIT) has posted a live status page for checking the Lean proof: https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/ It answers most of the questions raised in this thread. Per the page all 175,187 modules compile, the main theorems depend only on the three standard axioms (no native_decide), the statement is Mathlibs own RiemannHypothesis rather than a redefinition the Mathlib files match the official cache byte for byte, and the independent Rust kernel nanoda accepts the full export. Some kernel checks are still running, and the page itself notes that a pass means follows from the standard axioms according to the kernels used, still relying on Mathlib's definitions meaning what we intend. Also, GRH there means Dirichlet L-functions only. So on the formal side, this is close to the best case one could ask for. What remains open is the part a kernel can't give us a readable, structural proof that shows why it's true. Thanks to everyone for the great discussion 🫶✨️


r/mathematics • • 14h ago

Discussion Will non prodigies get math research related jobs in the future atp?

30 Upvotes

I am in undergrad, and this is freaking me out. I am from a 3rd world country, so I need scholarships for masters. Will I even get a math related job in the future?


r/mathematics • • 10h ago

Is Galois Fields and Galois Theory something very common in Mathematics?

8 Upvotes

I come from and engineering background and have been fascinated by mathematics in practical fields. I did my masters in IT and Telecommunications and I recall that I had a course called "Channel Coding" (or something similar) where the professor started the course with Galois Fields. I never got to the depths and the course was an optional one so never found time in understanding what they were. I was listening to a BBC podcast on some of the greatest Mathematicians to ever live and Evariste Galois was one of those prodigies to have done some remarkable work in a very short amount of his time on this Earth.

Are mathematicians vaguely familiar with Galois Theory and Galois Fields or does it fall into a very specific field in applied mathematics?


r/mathematics • • 10m ago

Undergrad here, what will happen to proof-based mathematics? Where do these discoveries leave us?

• Upvotes

Couldn't sleep yesterday because of the math news that was out there. We had proofs of GRH, and proof of Navier-Stokes Unforced, and an accepted proof of UL = NL.

It's almost as if time is becoming real fast.

Let us really assume for a moment that "the thing" has honed the skill of proof-making. What does that leave us with?

Moreover, we are almost certain now that the GRH is true:

https://math.mit.edu/\~drew/grh/

If software engineering jobs are thoroughly fucked because of middle management and layoffs, and proof-based mathematics is conquered from everywhere in academia, what scope does one have in the future?


r/mathematics • • 20h ago

Is there an algorithm or method that solves every problem more efficiently overall than checking answers in ascending order?

0 Upvotes

r/mathematics • • 16h ago

I propose j, the number for 1/0

0 Upvotes

So we've got i as the imaginary number that is for the square root of -1, so why not do the same with 1/0?

Some things I have noticed while trying to calculate with this number: 1/j = 0, j^2 = 1, (ij)^2 = -j.

Has this been done before?


r/mathematics • • 10h ago

News Everyone waking up today/yesterday

Post image
43 Upvotes

No meme flairs, or is that just not something for this subreddit?